Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Anna Maria Island (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Anna Maria Island (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

195 Views

I’ve been all over the world tasting some truly amazing pizzas. However, I was pleasantly surprised by the mix of traditional and unique pizzas to be found in Anna Maria Island. As an expert eater, I decided to take it upon myself to sample twelve of the best pizza places that the island had to offer.

The results were impressive and downright delicious. If you’re looking for a truly memorable pizza experience, read on and find out which restaurants made my list of the best Pizza places in Anna Maria Island!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Pizza Social

I stopped in to try their menu and I was impressed. From the moment I stepped in, the friendly staff made me feel welcome. It was a great atmosphere that made me want to stay longer and enjoy their delicious pizza.

The pizza was cooked to perfection with a crisp crust that was both light and crunchy. The toppings were fresh and incredibly savory. I opted for pepperoni, mushrooms, and red onion which balanced out perfectly for a flavor explosion in my mouth!

But the best part was that their pizza tasted just like it had been crafted with love (which I’m sure it had). It’s not often that you find a pizza place with such good quality ingredients and an amazing atmosphere to boot! All in all, Pizza Social is definitely worth trying if you’re ever on Anna Maria Island looking for some of the best pizza around.

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Bradenton!

#2 Vinny’s Italian Kitchen

I was so excited to try out this restaurant. I had heard that the vegetarian options were top-notch, and I was not disappointed. The veggie pizza was exceptionally good; it even made me question my carnivorous tendencies!

The dessert options at Vinny’s Italian Kitchen are absolutely insane. From traditional Italian pastries like tiramisu to unique creations like Nutella pizza, there is something for everyone. My tastebuds were in heaven!

The only downside of Vinny’s Italian Kitchen is that they don’t do delivery. For those seeking the best pizza on Anna Maria Island, though, a trip to Vinny’s will be worth the effort.

If you’re looking for delicious Neapolitan pizzas and some of the best desserts on Anna Maria Island, then make sure to check out Vinny’s Italian Kitchen — it’ll definitely be worth your while!

#3 The Feast Restaurant

From the moment I stepped in, I was welcomed with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff was incredibly friendly, which made the experience delightful!

The pizza here is simply divine – they use only the freshest ingredients, which makes each bite something to remember. Every variety I tried was out-of-this-world delicious; my favorite was definitely their pepperoni pizza, with plenty of flavorful cheese and crunchy pepperoni slices. The crust has that perfect combination of crispness and chewiness. It’s not too thick or too thin – it’s just right.

What makes this place truly stand out is their amazing selection of toppings. From spicy jalapeno peppers to succulent mushrooms, you’re guaranteed to find something to satisfy your cravings (or create your own custom combo).

Overall, The Feast Restaurant has certainly earned its spot as one of the best pizza places in Anna Maria Island. Whether you’re a local looking for an incredible slice or a traveler looking for an unforgettable dining experience, this is definitely the place for you!

#4 Danny’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and I knew I had come to the right place for a good pie. As soon as I sat down, I could tell that the staff takes pride in their craft – they had a passion for making great pizza!

I decided to try one of their specialties, the pepperoni pizza. The ingredients were fresh and flavorful. The crust was just the right thickness, lightly crusted with a nice chewiness. Each bite was loaded with melt-in-your-mouth cheese and spicy pepperoni. It was truly delicious!

I washed it all down with a cold beer and couldn’t help but feel satisfied. Danny’s Pizzeria definitely deserves its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Anna Maria Island. Whether you’re looking for something classic or something more creative, they’ve got it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 51 more pizza places in St Pete Beach!

#5 La Norma Italian Restaurant

Upon my first visit, I was taken aback by the freshness and quality of their ingredients. The pizza crust had just the right amount of chewiness and flavor, while their secret sauce hit all the right notes. Their topping selection is expansive and the combinations are almost limitless – my favorite is a combination of olives, pepperoni and feta cheese.

The staff at La Norma are incredibly friendly and attentive. I felt like I was part of the family with every visit! If you’re ever in Anna Maria Island, it’s certainly worth taking the trip over to La Norma for an unforgettable pizza experience.

Overall, I would rate La Norma Italian Restaurant 10/10 as far as best pizza in Anna Maria Island goes – highly recommended!

#6 Bella Mia Pizza & Italian Restaurant

The atmosphere of the restaurant is cozy and inviting, allowing you to take a break from exploring all the amazing sights on the island. The staff are friendly, attentive and always willing to accommodate my special requests.

On top of that, the pizza is simply out of this world! They use only freshly-made dough for each pizza and top them off with an incredibly delicious combination of fresh ingredients. Every time I come here I’m reminded why Bella Mia Pizza & Italian Restaurant is truly one of the best pizzerias on Anna Maria Island.

I’ve also had a chance to try some of their other Italian dishes and they’re equally flavorful and delightful. From the classic spaghetti and meatballs to the more adventurous four cheese ravioli – it’s all quite tasty!

All in all, when I’m looking for great pizza in Anna Maria Island, I can’t think of anywhere else I’d want to go than Bella Mia Pizza & Italian Restaurant. Definitely worth checking out!

#7 Nonna’s Pizza

The first time I entered Nonna’s, I was immediately impressed. The atmosphere was bustling and inviting, with a cozy Italian vibe that instantly made me feel at home.

The menu had an impressive selection of pizzas, ranging from classic favorites like pepperoni and cheese to adventurous toppings like bacon and caramelized onions.

I ended up ordering the Margherita pizza, done Neapolitan-style with fresh buffalo mozzarella, juicy tomatoes and fragrant basil leaves – it was one of the best I’ve ever tasted! The flavorful ingredients were perfectly balanced and cooked to perfection, making the pie both crunchy and soft in all the right places.

And that’s not all – Nonna’s Pizza also offers hearty Italian dishes like pasta primavera, chicken parmigiana and veal marsala – each one more delicious than the next!

All in all, I can confidently say Nonna’s Pizza is definitely worth trying if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Anna Maria Island.

If you’re willing to go an extra 18 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Pinellas Park!

#8 Domino’s Pizza

The atmosphere was inviting and the staff were pleasant and friendly. The pizza had a perfect combination of crunchy and chewy crust, with just the right amount of sauce, cheese and topping.

The service was fast and efficient – my pizza was ready in no time at all! I also enjoyed the selection of sides to accompany my meal – garlic bread, cheesesticks and coleslaw – delicious!

When it comes to value for money, Domino’s Pizza is unbeatable. The regular price is great, but they also offer some fantastic promotions that can make an already-tasty dinner even better – plus delivery options too!

All things considered, Domino’s Pizza is definitely the best pizza in Anna Maria Island! If you’re looking for an enjoyable dinner choice that won’t break the bank, this is a great option. Highly recommended!

#9 Pizzano’s Pizza

The pizza at Pizzano’s Pizza is truly a work of art. The crusts are thin and perfectly crispy, with just the right amount of doughiness and chew. The flavorful sauce is laden with herbs and spices, giving each pizza an incredibly rich flavor profile. The mozzarella cheeses used for topping are handmade and added in perfect proportions to give each slice a delightful combination of gooeyness and flavor.

The service at Pizzano’s Pizza is quite impressive too. I found the helpful staff friendly and inviting, always willing to provide assistance in selecting the perfect pizza. And they definitely knew their stuff – they were able to answer all my questions about ingredients, baking times, oven temperatures etc., with ease.

To sum up my experience at Pizzano’s Pizza – it was one that I won’t be forgetting anytime soon! This restaurant certainly lives up to its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Anna Maria Island!

#10 Oma’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant

I arrived at this quaint establishment to find it filled with the irresistible aroma of freshly-crafted pizza and Italian classics. I was immediately impressed by both the décor and hospitality of the restaurant staff.

The menu boasted an impressive variety of options, from classic favorites like Margherita and Pepperoni, to more adventurous options like Eggplant Parmesan or Fungi & Prosciutto. I decided to go with the latter, as I wanted to push my taste buds in a new direction.

To say that Oma’s Pizza is simply delicious would be an understatement. From the perfectly cooked crust to the generous toppings, this pizza was truly one for the ages. The sauce was flavorful yet not overpowering, and every bite left me wanting more. My dining companion enjoyed her Calzone equally as much!

On top of all of this, Oma’s also offers a wide selection of Italian delicacies—from lasagna to tiramisu—all made from the freshest ingredients available on Anna Maria Island. And if you choose to dine in rather than take away, you’ll get complimentary breadsticks!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Anna Maria Island—or simply some tasty Italian cuisine—then look no further than Oma’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant!

If you’re willing to go an extra 19 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Lakewood Ranch!

#11 Solorzanos Pizzeria Longboat Key

I was immediately impressed with their commitment to using only the freshest ingredients when making their pizzas. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, while the tomato sauce had just the right amount of sweetness. They use a variety of premium cheeses, including mozzarella, provolone and parmesan, all of which were melted to perfection.

As for toppings, they have an impressive selection that can satisfy any appetite. From classic favorites like pepperoni and sausage to more daring options like pineapple and mushrooms, Solorzanos Pizzeria Longboat Key has something for everyone.

The atmosphere at this pizzeria is charming and inviting. You can watch their skilled pizza makers prepare your meal from behind the counter or enjoy a peaceful outdoor seating area in the back.

If you are looking for some of the best pizza around Anna Maria Island, then look no further than Solorzanos Pizzeria Longboat Key! I would definitely recommend this place to anyone who enjoys great pizza with quality ingredients, friendly service and a nice dining experience – all at an affordable price!

#12 Solo’s Pizza

I had the pleasure of visiting Solo’s on a recent trip to the island. The atmosphere was laidback and inviting, and I immediately felt at home. The pizza was cooked to perfection, with a thin and crispy crust that was just the right amount of crunchy. On top were some of the freshest ingredients I’ve ever experienced in a pizza; from sweet tomatoes to tangy pepperoni, every bite was flavorful.

The customer service at Solo’s was excellent; everyone I interacted with was friendly and accommodating. As I enjoyed my meal, I could tell that they truly care about providing an enjoyable experience for their customers.

I can tell you from firsthand experience that this is some of the best pizza you’ll find in Anna Maria Island, so don’t miss out!