Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Boston Dave Portnoy (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Massachusetts

Best Pizza in Boston Dave Portnoy (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

1213 Views

After having sampled 12 different pizza places, I must say that Portnoy is a great spot for anyone looking for the best pizza in Boston. The sheer variety of options and freshness of ingredients are absolutely remarkable.

I have to give props to the folks at Portnoy who clearly know their stuff when it comes to making great pizzas. All the selections feature quality toppings and unique sauces that really set them apart from all others.

And, as an added bonus, prices remain right on track with what you’d expect for top-notch pizzas. With all these factors combined, Portnoy has emerged as my go-to spot for prime pizza in Boston!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Massachusetts

#1 FLORINA Pizzeria & Paninoteca

I went in expecting a good pizza experience, and boy did they deliver! The atmosphere was warm and inviting with a cozy Italian feel. Plus, the staff were friendly and knowledgeable about their menu – not to mention helpful when it came to recommending what I should order.

Now, onto the pizza! This is where FLORINA really stand out from the competition. Their pizzas are light and crispy with delicious toppings that weren’t overly salty or greasy – just the perfect mix of flavors. They also offer a great selection of traditional Italian dishes which I enjoyed very much as well.

Overall, FLORINA Pizzeria & Paninoteca should be on everyone’s list of top places to get pizza in Boston Dave Portnoy. From the friendly staff to the delicious food, this place is one of my new favorite spots for great-tasting pizza. Head over and check it out – your taste buds will thank you later!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 33 more pizza places in Boston!

#2 Regina Pizzeria

I went to the restaurant on a quiet Sunday night and was immediately impressed by its cozy, homey atmosphere. The staff were friendly, helpful and made me feel right at home. The pizza itself was delicious – perfectly cooked, perfectly seasoned and with just the right amount of cheese.

The standout item for me had to be their signature dish – the Regina Margherita Pizza. It’s a take on the classic Margherita featuring tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella and basil on a heavenly light and airy crust. Truly divine.

The rest of their menu is also fantastic – they’ve got everything from traditional Neapolitan pizzas to deep-dish Chicago-style pies that are all served up hot and fresh out of the wood fired ovens. They never skimped on ingredients – you can really taste the difference!

If I had to describe my experience in one word it would have to be amazing – truly one of the best pizza places in Boston Dave Portnoy!

#3 Picco

First of all, the presentation is on point! The pizza comes out looking beautiful and inviting. It’s like they took extra care to make sure that it looks as delicious as it tastes.

The crust is thin yet flavorful, with a perfect amount of chewiness. And the toppings are always fresh and flavorful, not too much and not too little. The combination of flavors and textures make a perfect harmony in each bite.

And the best part? You get generous portions for the price you pay. Which means you get full without feeling like you’ve been overcharged for your meal.

To top it off, the atmosphere at Picco is amazing! The staff are friendly and helpful, always willing to give advice about which pizzas and toppings to choose from. Plus, the place itself has a warm ambiance that makes it easy to hang out with friends after dinner.

So if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Boston Dave Portnoy, then head on over to Picco! I guarantee you won’t be disappointed.

#4 Ernesto’s Pizza

On my first visit to Ernesto’s, I was immediately captivated by the classic Italian decor and the aroma of perfectly cooked pizza emanating from the kitchen. After being seated, I indulged myself with a plate of freshly made appetizers and a glass of wine. The antipasti gave me a preview of what I would have for my main course: deliciousness.

For my pizza, I chose their signature ‘Ernesto’s Special’ – which features a rich tomato sauce and plenty of melted cheese and pepperoni. And yes, it did not disappoint! It was deliciously light with just the right amount of crunchy crust and gooey cheese. It was definitely one of the best pizzas I have ever had.

Overall, I’m amazed by how Ernesto has managed to recreate traditional Italian flavors in his pizzas, blending it with modern recipes to create something special, yet comforting at the same time. If you’re looking for some delicious pizza in Boston Dave Portney, look no further than Ernesto’s!

#5 Union Park Pizza

It’s easy to see why. The crust is freshly made every day, so it’s always light and fluffy with a slight hint of garlic. The toppings are generous, flavorful, and just the right mix of cheeses and spices. The pizzas at Union Park Pizza arrive at your table hot and ready to eat!

The atmosphere at Union Park Pizza is unlike any other pizza joint I’ve visited. Dimly lit with soothing music playing in the background, it’s the perfect spot for a night out with friends or a cozy date night.

I highly recommend trying one of their signature pies like the Italian Stallion or Chicago-Style Deep Dish if you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience. For something a little different, try their build-your-own option: choose from an array of fresh ingredients to create your own custom pizza masterpiece!

Union Park Pizza may have gotten its start as Boston Dave Portnoy’s favorite spot for great pizza, but now everyone can enjoy it! With delicious food, delightful atmosphere, and convenient locations throughout Boston (from Harvard Square to Brookline), there’s no excuse not to give Union Park Pizza a try!

#6 Podima Pizza

When you walk in the door of Podima, the first thing you’ll notice is the wonderful aroma of freshly baked pizza. The pizza is always cooked to perfection, with a perfectly crispy crust and thick sauce that’s not too sweet or tangy.

The toppings are always fresh and creative. They have some unique combinations that I’ve never seen before like their signature “Pesto Chicken,” which features basil pesto, spicy Italian chicken sausage, mozzarella, and Parmesan cheeses.

The staff at Podima take immense pride in their food. The waitstaff are friendly and helpful, and they’re more than willing to explain the menu offerings if you don’t understand them (it’s Italian-style for most items).
Create your own
If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Dave Portnoy’s Boston, then look no further than Podima Pizza! From their succulent crusts to inventive toppings, it’s clear why people keep coming back here time after time. Not only is the atmosphere inviting but so are the staff who go above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction. Whether you enjoy a veggie delight or meat lovers’ special – all of your cravings will be satisfied here! So come on down today and taste what everyone is talking about – Podima Pizza truly has some of the best pies around!

#7 Santarpio’s Pizza

The restaurant itself is a trip to the past, with its vintage decor and classic vibes. It’s no wonder why this place has been around since 1903!

The pizza is some of the best I’ve had anywhere in the world. The crust is perfectly thin and crisp, while the ingredient selection seems endless. Whether you’re looking for a classic Margherita or something more adventurous like their Prosciutto & Arugula pie, they have it all here.

I also tried a few of their appetizers and sides, which were all fantastic. From the slightly sweet garlic knots to the flavorful grilled calamari, they touched on all my taste buds’ pleasure points.

And last but not least, their service was top-notch; each server was friendly and attentive, taking the time to make sure all needs were met.

In my humble opinion, Santarpio’s Pizza is undoubtedly one of the best places for great pizza in Boston Dave Portnoy (or really anywhere!).

#8 Blaze Pizza

The crust is lightly charred and perfectly seasoned. The tomato sauce is wonderfully sweet, with just the right balance of acidity. And the toppings are fresh and flavorful.

The staff are friendly and accommodating, making sure that my pizza experience is top-notch. All in all, the atmosphere in Blaze Pizza can be described as the perfect combination of cozy and chic.

I’m often asked where I find the best pizza in Boston Dave Portnoy-it’s definitely Blaze Pizza! They have an incredible selection of signature creations or you can create your own masterpiece right at your table. Plus, they also offer a variety of sides like garlic knots and salads to round out your meal.

With its generous portion sizes and reasonable prices, Blaze Pizza is an easy choice for anyone looking for delicious pizza – whether they live in Boston Dave Portnoy or not! I couldn’t have asked for a better pizza experience; I highly recommend you give it a try!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in North Windham!

#9 Rina’s Pizzeria & Cafe

From the moment you walk in the door, you can immediately smell the deliciousness emanating from their brick-oven pizza. The cozy atmosphere of the restaurant is inviting and I couldn’t help but feel like I was at home when choosing from the many options on their menu.

I opted for a classic Margherita pizza – made with freshly picked tomatoes, basil, and mozzarella – and it did not disappoint! The crust was cooked to perfection, not too crunchy but just enough to make every bite enjoyable. The sauce was incredibly flavorful and not overly spicy or sweet. To top it off, the cheese melted in my mouth (literally!).

Overall, Rina’s Pizzeria & Cafe offers some of the best pizza in Boston Dave Portnoy. With great food and friendly service, what’s not to love? Highly recommend!

#10 Pastoral ARTisan Pizza + Kitchen + Bar

From the moment I stepped through their doors, I knew i was in for a treat. The cozy atmosphere and delicious smells made me feel right at home. The menu offers up a variety of artisan pizzas that are simply to die for.

The staff is friendly and attentive and make sure you get your order just the way you like it. I’m a fan of thin crust pizza so i opted for one of their signature creations: The Dave Portnoy. It was absolute perfection – crispy, cheesy and full of flavor! Every bite made me more satisfied than the last.

If you’re ever in Boston looking for some of the best pizza around, be sure you stop by Pastoral ARTisan Pizza + Kitchen + Bar! Trust me, it won’t disappoint!

#11 Papa’s Pizza Company

From the moment I walked in the door, it was clear that this place was serious about its pizza. The smell of wood-fired pizzas and freshly made dough hit me right away.

I decided to try the “Dave’s Special” which featured a variety of meats, cheeses and veggies. The crust was perfect – crispy yet chewy. The fresh mozzarella melted in my mouth and the sausage was flavorful and juicy.

The homemade sauce had subtle hints of garlic and oregano, which added to the flavor of the pizza as a whole. Everything tasted fresh and delicious!

To top off an already great experience, their staff was friendly and accommodating. They answered all my questions with a smile on their face!

Overall, I definitely recommend Papa’s Pizza Company for some of the best pizza in Boston Dave Portnoy!

#12 Pino’s Pizza

The atmosphere at Pino’s Pizza is amazing. They have a really cool, vintage Italian vibe that makes you feel like you’re in Little Italy! The staff are always so friendly and welcoming, and they make sure all of your food is cooked to perfection.

The pizza at Pino’s Pizza is truly the highlight of their establishment – it’s fantastic! All the ingredients are cooked to perfection; the crust is light and crispy, the sauce is flavorful, and the cheese melts in your mouth. It’s definitely some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!

If you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Boston Dave Portnoy, then I would highly recommend visiting Pino’s Pizza. You won’t be disappointed with their delicious food and warm hospitality!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Santarpio’s Pizza

It’s a small, rustic joint that oozes charm and character. As soon as you step inside, the scent of cheese and freshly baked dough wraps around you like a hungry boa constrictor. And let’s not forget the perks – they serve alcohol, and by alcohol, I mean all the delightful elixirs for your inner party animal. They even offer hard liquor, folks! So, if you’re yearning for a slice and a stiff drink, Santarpio’s has got you covered.

Now, onto the downsides. Brace yourself, my fellow pizza enthusiasts, because Santarpio’s does not accept reservations. Yes, you read that right. If you want to indulge in their delectable deep dish goodness, you have to be prepared to play the waiting game. But hey, consider it a lesson in patience and self-control, right?

But oh boy, is it worth the wait! Picture this: a thick, crispy crust that’s sturdy enough to support the hefty toppings without getting soggy. The cheese, oh the cheese! It stretches like a bungee cord, providing the perfect cheesy landing for your taste buds. And the toppings! They seem to have a magical way of transporting you to Italy with each bite. It’s like Mama Santarpio herself sprinkled some Italian magic on these pizzas.

So, my fellow foodies, whether you’re a tourist looking for a nice spot or a local in desperate need of a pizza fix, Santarpio’s Pizza is the place to be. Just don’t forget to wear your stretchy pants, because you’ll be leaving with a full belly and a heart filled with pizza love.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Regina Pizzeria

But first, let me start with the downsides. Regina Pizzeria, why, oh why, do you not accept reservations? I mean, isn’t it enough that we have to battle through hordes of hungry tourists to get a table? Now we have to stand there like vultures, waiting for someone to finish their last bite? But I digress.

Now, onto the benefits. Oh, thank the pizza gods for the fact that Regina Pizzeria serves alcohol. Nothing pairs better with a hot, cheesy slice of heaven than an ice-cold beer. And bonus points for having some vegetarian options! It’s nice to know that even us meat-eaters can bring our herbivorous friends along and not feel guilty about devouring an entire pie.

And speaking of guilt, Regina Pizzeria is a fantastic spot for tourists. Sure, it may be slightly overcrowded, but that’s part of its charm. You get to eat amazing pizza and people-watch at the same time. It’s like having dinner and a show! Plus, being surrounded by fellow pizza enthusiasts just adds to the whole experience. You can bond over your love of perfectly crisp crust, stretchy cheese, and tangy tomato sauce.

So, if you’re in the north end and craving the best thin crust pizza in town, make your way to Regina Pizzeria. Just be prepared to battle for a table and leave your reservation hopes at the door. But trust me, it’s worth every delicious bite.

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Pastoral ARTisan Pizza + Kitchen + Bar

Upon stepping into the restaurant, I was greeted by the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked dough and melted cheese. The ambiance of the place is like stepping into a rustic pizza paradise, with their signature wood-fired oven stealing the show. As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I couldn’t help but do a little dance of excitement.

But let’s get down to the important stuff: the pizza itself. The first bite sent me straight to pizza heaven. The perfectly thin and chewy crust with just the right amount of char had me swooning. The toppings were a delightful mix of flavors, from the classic margherita bursting with fresh basil and juicy tomatoes, to the adventurous prosciutto and arugula combo that left me craving for more.

But it’s not just the pizza that shines at Pastoral ARTisan Pizza + Kitchen + Bar, oh no. The kitchen + bar aspect adds a whole new dimension to the experience. I couldn’t resist trying some of their craft cocktails, and boy, did they hit the spot. The mixologists here are true artists, creating concoctions that perfectly complemented the pizzas.

As a seasoned pizza traveler, I can confidently say that Pastoral ARTisan Pizza + Kitchen + Bar is a true gem in the world of wood-fired pizza. The attention to detail and the passion for their craft shines through in every bite. So if you find yourself in Boston and craving a mouthwatering pizza experience, make your way to Pastoral and prepare for a pizza journey like no other.