Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Chatham MA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Massachusetts

Best Pizza in Chatham MA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

144 Views

I’ve tasted pizza all over the world, so I know that a good slice is hard to come by. But I was pleasantly surprised to find 12 different pizzerias in this small Massachusetts town.

Ready for a wild ride through the best pizza Chatham MA has to offer? Buckle up—it’s gonna be a cheesy, greasy adventure! With my experienced tongue and strategic stomach ready, I’m here to report on the best pizza favorites in Chatham.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Massachusetts

#1 Pizza Shark

From the moment I stepped through the front door and saw their giant shark mural, I knew I was in for a treat. Walking up to the counter, I immediately noticed the selection of delicious specialty pies on display.

The atmosphere was relaxed, yet friendly. The staff was so helpful and accommodating that I felt like part of the family by the time my order arrived.

It didn’t take long for me to dig in and sample their signature garlic-knot pizza – and wow, what an unbelievable flavor! It had a buttery garlic crust and a spicy cheese blend that melted in my mouth.

But what really sealed the deal for me was the homemade marinara dipping sauce they served with it. It had just enough tanginess to bring out all of the flavors on the crust and make it truly unforgettable.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Chatham MA – look no further than Pizza Shark! They’ve definitely earned my seal of approval!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 17 more pizza places in Dennis Port!

#2 Del Mar Bar & Bistro

I was skeptical at first; after all, there’s a lot of pizza out there. But when I walked in, I noticed the wonderful aroma of freshly-baked dough wafting through the air. My mouth instantly started to water!

The staff was friendly and accommodating, ready to answer my questions and give me recommendations. I ordered a classic Margherita pizza with fresh mozzarella and basil — it was divine! The sauce was thick and flavorful, and the crust had just the right amount of char. Plus, Chef Antonio’s cooking technique is top-notch — he really knows how to bring out the flavor in each topping.

To round off my visit, I gladly accepted their offer for dessert: Nutella pizza with fresh strawberries. It tasted like heaven! If you’re ever in Chatham MA looking for a unique treat, this is definitely worth trying.

It’s no wonder why Del Mar Bar & Bistro is one of the best pizza places in town! The food is delicious and the experience truly memorable. I’d rate it 10/10 and recommend it to anyone looking for great pizza in Chatham MA!

#3 Pleasant Lake Pizza Shark

I have to admit, I was skeptical at first when I heard about this place. But after one bite, I was hooked. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy on the edges and chewy in the middle. The sauce has a wonderful balance of sweet and savory flavors, while the cheese stayed perfectly melted throughout my entire pizza. They must be doing something right.

The staff at Pleasant Lake Pizza Shark were some of the friendliest folks I’ve met on my travels too! They were so accommodating – they went above and beyond to make sure everything was just right for me, from the moment I walked in until the last slice of pizza was devoured.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for a delicious pizza in Chatham MA, look no further than Pleasant Lake Pizza Shark! It’s definitely the best pizza in town, and it’s definitely worth a visit (or two)!

#4 Sweet Tomatoes Pizza

First off, the crust was incredibly delicious. It had a unique combination of crunchy yet chewy texture that made it stand out from the regular pizzas I’ve tried.

The toppings were also very flavorful and generous. Pepperoni, bacon, mushrooms, and onions were all present in balanced amounts. The sauce was also nicely spiced for a bit of an added kick!

The cheese was abundant but not overwhelming – it just added to the overall deliciousness. There’s no doubt that Sweet Tomatoes Pizza knows their way around cheese!

All in all, I would highly recommend Sweet Tomatoes Pizza if you’re looking for some great tasting pizza in Chatham MA – they have truly earned their title as having the best pizza in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Hyannis!

#5 Castaways

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Castaways and enjoying some of their delicious pizza. Everything from the crust to the toppings was perfect! The crust had that perfect crunch – not too hard, not too soft – just right! And the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

I particularly enjoyed the pepperoni pizza I ordered. The cheese melted just right and the pepperoni had a nice kick. Not to mention they offer a wide variety of toppings so everyone can find something they like.

One of the most impressive things about Castaways is their service. From the moment you walk in until you leave, everyone is friendly and helpful. They really do strive to make your experience as pleasant as possible!

All in all, I’d definitely recommend Castaways for anyone looking for the best pizza in Chatham MA. If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience, then this isn’t something you’ll want to miss!

#6 George’s Pizza House

My first bite of a slice when I first visited was simply heavenly. It had a perfect, crisp crust and the right amount of cheese and sauce. The flavor was unlike anything I’d ever tasted before! And that’s saying something since I’ve sampled pizza from all over the world.

The staff at George’s Pizza House were friendly and helpful – they made me feel like family. The prices were also reasonable, which is always a plus for a traveling food critic like me.

Overall, I would highly recommend George’s Pizza House to anyone looking for the best pizza in Chatham MA. It really is an experience that you don’t want to miss out on!

#7 Alecsies House of Pizza

The atmosphere was laid back and welcoming. I was immediately taken in by the inviting decor, which included a giant painting of everyone’s favorite Italian chef, Alec. He smiled down at me as I ordered my pizza margherita – it looked too good to resist!

The pizza itself was delicious. It tasted exactly like Italy: melty cheese paired with tangy tomato sauce and just the right amount of spices. The crust was perfectly cooked and had a nice crunch to it. Not only that, but it also wasn’t greasy or overly heavy like some other pizzas I’ve had.

Overall, I can safely say that Alecsies House of Pizza serves up some of the best pizza in Chatham MA! So if you’re ever in town looking for an amazing slice, don’t miss out on this spot!

If you’re willing to go an extra 15 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in South Yarmouth!

#8 Harwich Port House of Pizza

The atmosphere at Harwich Port House of Pizza was absolutely amazing – it had a great vibe and the staff were extremely friendly. Plus, the food was out of this world. I tasted some of the very best pizza I’ve ever had in my life, and that’s saying something!

The restaurant offers a wide variety of pizzas, from classic Italian to unique creations with all sorts of exotic toppings. I sampled several different pizzas and each one was delicious. The crust was perfect – golden and crispy on the outside but still light and fluffy on the inside. Plus, they use only the freshest ingredients for their toppings, so everything tastes just right.

I finished off the meal with an incredible dessert calzone stuffed with Nutella and jam, which sent me straight to seventh heaven!

Harwich Port House of Pizza serves up some truly remarkable pizza – if you’re ever in Chatham MA, make sure to drop by for a tasty slice or two! Hands down, this is definitely one of the best pizza places in town.

#9 Carmine’s

I had the pleasure of visiting Carmine’s recently and I must say that it was one of the most pleasant pizza experiences I’ve ever had. The service was great – they were friendly, quick, and really helpful in giving me advice on what to order.

The pizzas themselves were delicious; the crust was light and fluffy and the toppings tasty and plentiful! They offer a variety of toppings from classic pepperoni to more exotic choices like shrimp or artichoke hearts.

If you’re looking for a real treat after your pizza, then look no further than Carmine’s desserts. Whether you decide to get a classic cannoli, tiramisu, or something more unique like their Nutella-filled Calzones, you won’t be disappointed. It’s definitely worth saving some room for!

My only complaint is that they don’t offer delivery – so if you’re not able to visit the restaurant personally, then you’ll have to find another option for getting your hands on these delectable pies. Despite this minor downside however, Carmine’s is an excellent choice if you’re in Chatham MA looking for an awesome pizza experience.

#10 New England Pizza Chatham @ Knots Landing Bar & Grill

The atmosphere at this restaurant was unbeatable – from the warm and cozy seating area to the jukebox playing classic rock tunes in the background, I felt like I had been transported back in time. The staff were also incredibly friendly – they made me feel welcome from the moment I walked in.

But of course, the star of the show was the pizza. The crust was light and crispy, just how I like it. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and really added something special to each slice. It’s clear that New England Pizza takes their pizza seriously – they even make their own signature sauces!

I have to say that my experience at New England Pizza Chatham @ Knots Landing Bar & Grill was nothing short of amazing! Whether you’re looking for a casual evening out, a family meal or just an excellent slice of pizza – this is definitely the place to go!

If you’re willing to go an extra 16 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Hyannis!

#11 Upper Crust Pizza

The crust is the star of the show here – light, airy and flavorful with a hint of sweetness from the freshly rolled dough. The sauce is perfectly balanced – not too acidic or too sweet – and it’s topped off with a generous amount of melted cheese.

The toppings are also top-notch: mushrooms, onions, peppers – all fresh as can be and cooked to perfection. And don’t even get me started on their specialty pizzas! They have something for everyone: crazy combos like Greek olives and feta combined with spicy pepperoni, or just classic combinations like sausage and pepperoni.

The atmosphere is great, too – cozy and inviting enough to make you forget you’re in Chatham MA! You’ll find locals chatting away in the corner booths while chowing down on slices and sipping beer from mason jars at the bar.

All in all, Upper Crust Pizza is definitely one to check out if you’re looking for some of the best pizza around Chatham MA!

#12 Buca’s Tuscan Roadhouse

It’s no wonder that the locals love this restaurant so much – they get to enjoy a taste of Italy right here in their own backyard. The pizza is made with fresh ingredients, a perfect blend of cheeses, and cooked in the wood-fired oven to give it an amazing smoky flavor. The thin crust is just right – not too thin and not too thick.

What really makes Buca’s stand out is the atmosphere. I was welcomed with open arms as soon as I arrived and was even invited into the kitchen to watch the chefs at work. It felt like being part of the family! The ambiance is cozy and inviting, with just enough bright Italian colors to make you feel like you’re in a trattoria in Rome.

The service was impeccable too; attentive without being intrusive which is always a plus! As for the food, every pizza we tried on our visit was bursting full of flavor – from the classic Margherita pizza to their signature deep dish creation.

If you’re looking for great pizza in Chatham MA, look no further than Buca’s Tuscan Roadhouse! So when hunger strikes, make sure you take a trip down Tuscan Road – trust me; you won’t regret it!