Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Mechanicsburg PA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Pennsylvania

Best Pizza in Mechanicsburg PA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

274 Views

I’ve tasted pizza all around the world, from Venice to New York and everywhere in between, so don’t worry – I’m an expert on pizza! And I’m here to tell you where to find the best pizza in Mechanicsburg.

I toured 12 different restaurants in town and sampled some of their pies. Now, after careful consideration and a few full stomachs later, I’m ready to give you my opinion on who has the best slice in Mechanicsburg. So buckle up and get ready for some serious pizza talk!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania

#1 Amici Pizza

The crust was perfectly cooked and the toppings were fresh. The cheese was especially delicious—it seemed like it had been freshly grated just for me! The sauce was flavorful and balanced, not too sweet, not too salty.

I have to give Amici Pizza props for their amazing presentation. The pizza was served on a crisp wooden board with a dusting of herbs and spices that added an extra layer of flavor.

Plus, the atmosphere was totally chill. It felt like being in a cozy Italian pizzeria instead of just some generic chain restaurant.

Overall, I can honestly say that Amici Pizza has some of the best pizza in Mechanicsburg PA! If you haven’t tried it yet, I suggest you do ASAP!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Harrisburg!

#2 Giuseppe’s Pizza Cantina

My visit to this little cantina was an excellent experience. I was welcomed by the warm staff, who were all friendly and knowledgeable about their pizzas. The atmosphere in the restaurant is cozy yet lively, with a great selection of Italian wines and beers to round off an amazing meal.

As far as the pizza offerings go, Giuseppe’s can’t be beat. From thin crust to deep-dish and gluten-free options, they have it all! The classic margherita is always a great choice and their specialty pies like the truffle pizza or calzone are truly out of this world. When my kids visited, we were pleased to find that they had a kid’s menu that made them feel special.

One downside though is that Giuseppe’s does not offer delivery service – which would have been really convenient for me when I’m on the road! However, if you’re in town for some sightseeing or visiting family, it’s definitely worth a trip to get their delicious pies. Plus there are desserts like cannoli and gelato to make sure you get your sweet fix after dinner!

To sum it up, I’d definitely recommend giving Giuseppe’s Pizza Cantina a try – it’ll be one of the best pizza experiences you’ll ever have!

#3 Little Mario’s Pizza

The first thing that struck me about Little Mario’s Pizza was their wide variety of menu options. From classic margheritas to out-of-the-box creations like Bacon Mushroom Onion & Artichoke, there’s something for everyone. Not to mention the quality of the ingredients used. The dough is hand-made daily and the sauces they use are made with fresh tomatoes and herbs.

The service at Little Mario’s Pizza was also top notch. Despite being busy, they were still able to accommodate our large group quickly and efficiently. The wait staff was also very helpful in helping us choose pizza combinations that everyone would enjoy.

Overall, I’d have to say that Little Mario’s Pizza is the best pizza I’ve had in Mechanicsburg PA (which isn’t easy considering I’ve traveled the world tasting pizza!). My recommendation? Go check it out!

#4 Sal’s Pizza

The atmosphere at Sal’s is inviting, and the staff friendly and welcoming. As a pizza connoisseur, I was delighted to find that their menu boasts some of the most creative flavor combinations around, such as eggplant and pesto or bacon and potato.

I sampled just about everything on the menu and each slice was delicious. The crust was perfect; crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. The sauce was flavorful and had just the right amount of sweetness. The proportion of cheese to toppings was spot-on – never too much or too little!

Overall, Sal’s Pizza is definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in Mechanicsburg PA looking for a great pizza experience! I’m convinced it’s some of the best pizza in town!

#5 Pizzatown USA

I was pleasantly surprised by the friendly atmosphere and classic Italian style of the restaurant. The pizzas were cooked to perfection and topped with fresh ingredients. The crust was crispy, yet still fluffy inside – no soggy slices here!

The most impressive part about this place was the wide variety of toppings available. From traditional favorites like pepperoni and sausage, to more exotic selections such as pineapple and black olives, Pizzatown USA had something for everyone. My favorite combination? Prosciutto and goat cheese, of course!

I’d also like to mention that the prices at Pizzatown USA made my wallet very happy. All in all, I’d highly recommend this place for anyone who’s looking for great pizza without breaking their budget. Hands down, it’s the best pizza in Mechanicsburg PA!

#6 Alfredo Pizza & Italian Restaurant

I was immediately struck by the lively atmosphere in the restaurant. The staff were welcoming, and everything was clean and inviting.

Once I sat down at my table, I got to work sampling their signature pizzas. Though I’m not a vegetarian, it was great to see that Alfredo Pizza & Italian Restaurant also has some excellent veggie options on the menu for those looking for something lighter.

The pies were cooked to perfection. The crust was crisp yet chewy and the flavors of the toppings blended together nicely with the cheese and sauce. This was definitely some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!

And if you have room left over after your meal, they offer delicious desserts too! You can’t go wrong with their tiramisu – it’s out of this world!

Perhaps my only critique is that Alfredo Pizza & Italian Restaurant doesn’t deliver – but that’s really just an excuse for me to make another visit to their delicious restaurant soon!

#7 Vito’s Pizza

The pizza here is made with love, and you can really taste it. Every ingredient they use seems to be of the highest quality, and the flavors all come through in every bite. My favorite is the “Grandma Pie” – it’s a classic that never fails to satisfy.

The atmosphere at Vito’s Pizza is fun and inviting. The staff are friendly and always happy to help you pick out the perfect order for your needs. Plus, they have lots of additional offerings such as subs and appetizers if you want something other than pizza!

The best part about Vito’s Pizza is the price – it’s incredibly reasonable given the high quality of food they serve. So don’t hesitate to give them a try if you’re ever in Mechanicsburg PA looking for a great meal!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Carlisle!

#8 Aldo’s Pizza Town USA

The moment I stepped in, I was welcomed by a delicious mix of smells coming from the ovens. The place has a really cozy vibe with checkered tablecloths adorning the tables and an old-school jukebox playing classic hits.

I got their ‘Specialty’ pizza which had a delicious array of toppings like sausages, olives, mushrooms and peppers – it was definitely delectable! The crust was thin yet crunchy and had just the right amount of seasoning. Every bite tickled my taste buds and had me wanting more.

To top off the experience, Aldo’s also offers garlic knots as a side order which were fresh, fragrant and simply divine! I must say that if you’re looking for the best pizza in Mechanicsburg PA, Aldo’s Pizza Town USA is your go-to spot. Highly recommended!

#9 DaVinci Italian Eatery

I’ve been to Naples and New York looking for the perfect slice, and nothing compares to what I found here. DaVinci’s crust is made with a blend of perfectly cooked flour, salt and yeast – resulting in a flavorful and slightly chewy experience that leaves an impression of delight. The sauce is rich and flavorful, with tomatoes- which really bring out the Italian authenticity!

The toppings were equally delectable – especially the Italian sausage. And don’t even get me started on their cheese. It was so good it could make a lactose intolerant person need to take some Lactaid!

The atmosphere at DaVinci Italian Eatery was also conducive for having the perfect pizza-eating experience. The staff was friendly and hospitable, willing to answer any questions about the ingredients or specials of the day; and to top it off, the decor was laid back but had a distinctly Italian vibe, making you feel like you were dining overseas.

Overall, I can confidently say that DaVinci’s pizza is definitely some of the best pizza I have ever had in Mechanicsburg PA. If you’re ever looking for an authentic Italian pizza experience or just want to try something new, then DaVinci should definitely be your go-to spot!

#10 Amore Pizza Arcona

Upon walking through the door, I was met with an incredible aroma of freshly baked pizza and could hardly contain my excitement. I was immediately seated and given a menu that had some intriguing options. After much deliberation, I decided on the classic pepperoni because sometimes it’s best to keep it simple.

I eagerly awaited my pizza, and when it arrived at the table it did not disappoint! The crust had just the right amount of crunch while still being so flavorful that I couldn’t stop myself from taking another slice, even though I was already full. The sauce was simply divine and complimented the cheese and pepperonis perfectly.

When all was said and done I couldn’t resist taking home a few slices for later – which tasted just as delicious reheated! All in all, Amore Pizza Arcona is undoubtedly one of the top contenders for best pizza in Mechanicsburg PA.

#11 Nikoli’s Pizza and Catering

The first thing I noticed when walking into the restaurant was the warm, inviting atmosphere. You can tell that the owners and staff take great pride in their restaurant. The decor was something to behold, with classic Italian imagery adorning the walls.

The pizza itself was the real star of the show. I tried several different varieties and they were all incredibly delicious. The thin-crust pizza had just enough chew and flavor to make it a standout, while the deep-dish pizzas were packed full of traditional Italian toppings like sausage and mushrooms.

The service at Nikoli’s Pizza and Catering was also top-notch, as our server took time to explain each type of pizza and answered questions about ingredients without hesitation.

Overall, Nikoli’s Pizza and Catering is easily one of the best pizza places in Mechanicsburg PA! If you’re looking for delicious pizza at an affordable price, this is your spot!

#12 JoJo’s Pizza & Pasta Main Street

From the moment I stepped through the door, I knew this place was special. The aroma of pizza and pasta wafted through the air, and my mouth started watering. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting – complete with checkered tablecloths and a 1940s-style jukebox in the corner!

I decided to go big and ordered their signature large pie: the JoJo Supreme. It came overflowing with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, bell peppers, onions, mushrooms, garlic, black olives, and mozzarella cheese – all baked to perfection on a hand-tossed crust! Each bite was filled with luscious flavor – truly something I’ve never experienced before.

But that’s not all! To top it off, every plate comes with a side of their homemade marinara sauce that packs plenty of punch. A perfect accompaniment to my savory pizza!

To conclude JoJo’s Pizza & Pasta Main Street is definitely worth visiting if you’re in the Mechanicsburg PA area looking for some of the best pizzas around.