I’ve sampled pizzas from 12 places to determine which offers the tastiest pie. Get ready for a fun ride, because I’m about to reveal the best pizza in town!
No matter whether you prefer deep dish, thin crust, or even weird variations like jalapeno pineapple – I can tell you who has it covered. After all, taste is subjective – my mission is to sample as many slices as possible so everyone can find the perfect fit for their palette.
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York
#1 The Dough & Co. Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
From the moment I stepped in, I was struck by the warm and inviting atmosphere. The cozy dining area and upbeat music gave me a sense of comfort that you can only find at an Italian pizzeria.
The star of the show was surely their pizza! Their thin-crust pies are cooked to perfection with a crispy, crunchy crust and toppings that are full of flavor. Whether you’re a fan of classic pepperoni or more creative combinations like chicken parmesan, The Dough & Co. has something for everyone.
My favorite part was the addition of wood-fired ovens which gave the pizza an extra smoky taste that’s hard to come by. It takes real skill to pull off this feat without overcooking or burning the pies, and The Dough & Co. manages it flawlessly each time.
I could go on about how amazing the pizza is, but let’s not forget about their delicious calzones and strombolis! When I took a bite out of my pepperoni calzone I was overwhelmed by its deliciousness!
All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Huntington NY then look no further than The Dough & Co. Pizza!
If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in North Massapequa!
#2 La Nola
- No delivery
Being a serious pizza food critic, I can attest that La Nola’s pizza is top-notch. Not only is the dough perfectly crispy and flavorful, the sauce and toppings are always fresh and flavorful! Every time I’ve tried a new pizza at La Nola, it surpasses my expectations.
The ambience of La Nola adds to its charm. The decor is inviting and cozy; it’s like visiting your favorite Italian relative’s kitchen! It certainly adds to the enjoyment of eating their amazing pizza.
One downside for me when dining at La Nola is there isn’t delivery service. So if you’re looking for pizza delivery from this restaurant, unfortunately you’ll have to look elsewhere. But I think it’s worth going out of your way just to try the excellent pies made at La Nola!
#3 Catusco’s Pizza
The pizza at Catusco’s is truly a magnificent creation. The crust is thin, yet still retains its crunchy texture and the perfect-for-pizza sauces are plentiful with great flavor. The toppings are also fresh and of high quality, making each bite an explosion of flavor in your mouth!
But what sets Catusco’s Pizzas apart from other pizza eateries is the service. Not only does the staff go out of their way to make sure your order is perfect and accommodating to any dietary needs, but they also have an abundance of knowledge about particular types of pizzas. They even had tips on how to properly store different varieties and suggestions on which ones can be served together for a unique culinary experience!
The atmosphere at Catusco’s was also superb — it was lively, inviting and comfortably furnished. This place definitely provides a welcoming environment that makes it easy to relax and enjoy your meal.
In conclusion, I highly recommend trying out this dining experience. From the quality ingredients to the expert service, you won’t be disappointed by the best pizza in Huntington NY at Catusco’s Pizza!
#4 La Nonna’s
- Offers dessert
I had the pleasure of dining at this bustling pizza joint, and I must say that everything from the atmosphere to the mouthwatering pies was top notch. The walls were adorned with bright, vibrant photos of classic Italian dishes, and the tables were laid out in a cozy way that made me feel as if I was dining in an actual Italian kitchen. Being an avid foodie, I also appreciated the extensive selection of wines and beers that they offer.
As for the pizza itself — wow! It truly was something special. The crust was perfect — crunchy on the outside and softer toward the middle — and it held up to even my pickiest standards. And boy were those toppings flavorful! Generously layered pepperoni, spicy sausage, gooey cheese, and perfectly cooked mushrooms — just amazing! And to top it off, their house-made sauce added a flavor that carried into every bite.
I give La Nonna’s two big thumbs up for having some of the best pizza in Huntington NY! If you’re looking for a great slice of pie or a scrumptious Italian dinner, then La Nonna’s is definitely worth checking out!
#5 Di Raimo Pizzeria
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
- Serves alcohol
I’ll be honest, I wasn’t sure what to expect walking into this place. But the owners, Salvatore and his wife Josephine, made me feel right at home from the moment I stepped in. And it wasn’t just talk — they actually went out of their way to make sure my experience was one-of-a-kind.
The pizza itself was unbelievable! Packed with flavor and perfectly cooked crust, it was easily one of the best pies I’ve ever had. The secret? They use ingredients that are local and fresh – not frozen or canned like other places.
The atmosphere of Di Raimo Pizzeria is also great; it has an “old world” feel that gives you an authentic Italian experience. Every customer gets a smile from Salvatore and Josephine when they come in, which makes it even better.
From the delicious food to the friendly service, Di Raimo Pizzeria is definitely my favorite pizza place in Huntington NY! Highly recommend if you’re looking for some of the best pizza around!
#6 Rocco’s Pizza & Catering
- Offers dessert
The first thing I noticed as soon as I walked in the door was how inviting the atmosphere was – not to mention that amazing, delicious pizza aroma. The staff were all friendly and welcoming, which really set the tone for my experience.
Next, it was time to try some of the food! And wow, was I impressed. From their classic cheese pizza to more elaborate concoctions like their famous Buffalo Chicken Pinwheels, each dish was a real delight. All of their ingredients are fresh and quality-controlled, so everything is up to par with their high standards.
They also have an impressive selection of wines and beers to choose from that go great with every meal. Plus they offer catering services if you’re looking for something special for your next event or gathering.
Overall, Rocco’s Pizza & Catering has easily earned its reputation as the best pizza in Huntington NY! Their delicious pizzas and attentive service make it a must-try spot for anyone looking for excellent Italian cuisine.
#7 Mama Lucia’s Pizzeria
- Offers dessert
The first time I stepped foot in Mama Lucia’s Pizzeria, I was amazed. The atmosphere was welcoming and the staff was incredibly friendly. Not to mention the decor was absolutely stunning.
When ordering a pizza, you can expect to receive nothing short of perfection! Every pizza is made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. Whether you choose one of their specialty creations or build your own from the endless list of toppings, you can rest assured that your pizza will be delicious.
But don’t just take my word for it – their customers speak for themselves! Regulars rave about their favorite pies, like the Grandma Pie or the Bavarian Crust Pizza that’s topped with five different cheeses. If you’re looking for something a little more traditional, they also offer classic Margherita pizzas and authentic Neapolitan-style pies.
No matter what type of pizza you choose, Mama Lucia’s Pizzeria will not disappoint! In my opinion, they have some of the best pizza in Huntington NY and I definitely recommend trying them out when you’re in town.
If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Westbury!
#8 Little Vincent’s Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
The pizza here is completely unique, with a presentation that will amaze you. The thick crust has layers of melted cheese, sauce, and other delicious toppings that all melt together to create amazing flavors.
The service here was outstanding too. Every member of the staff was friendly and accommodating, making sure I had everything I needed. The dining area is cozy and intimate which made it perfect for a date night or a special family meal.
But let’s get down to what matters: the taste! Little Vincent’s Pizza truly delivers on its promise of having some of the best pizza in Huntington NY. With each bite I could tell that everything was fresh and flavorful – it was like no other pizzeria I’ve been to!
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Huntington NY, look no further than Little Vincent’s Pizza!
#9 Jonny D’s Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
When I walked in, I was immediately taken aback by the old-school, New York style pizzeria atmosphere. The walls were decorated with vintage posters from the 1950s and 60s, giving the place an authentic feel that I hadn’t found anywhere else.
The menu was a unique blend of classic Italian favorites like Margherita and Pepperoni, as well as signature creations such as the Big Ragu Pizza (topped with homemade meatballs, sausage and ricotta cheese). It was hard to decide which one to try first!
Eventually I landed on the Big Ragu Pizza and it didn’t disappoint. The crust was light and crispy while the toppings were generous yet flavorful. Every bite was heavenly! And if you’re wondering about portion size, rest assured that each pizza is large enough to feed 3-4 people – so come hungry!
All in all, Jonny D’s Pizza is definitely some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted in Huntington NY. Whether you choose a classic or something more creative, you’re sure to leave feeling satisfied. Highly recommend for anyone looking for an authentic slice of heaven!
#10 Campania Pizza & Pasta
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
From the moment I stepped foot in the door, I was transported to a little slice of Italian heaven. The aroma of freshly baked dough and tomatoes filled the air, and my mouth started to water.
The service was excellent; the waiter was friendly and knowledgeable about their menu options. I ended up ordering a classic margherita pizza and it did not disappoint! The cheese was melted perfectly on top of a thin, crispy crust. Every bite felt like a little piece of Italy in my mouth.
Not only does Campania Pizza & Pasta serve up some of the best pizza in Huntington NY, but they also offer delicious pasta dishes as well! My friends all enjoyed the ravioli carbonara that had just enough creaminess to it without being overly filling.
Overall, Campania Pizza & Pasta is definitely worth a visit if you’re in town looking for some good Italian food —you won’t be disappointed!
#11 Rosa’s Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
The crust is always light and airy, while the sauce has a depth of flavor that makes it unique. The toppings are always fresh, giving each pizza a delicious crunchiness.
And of course the cheese! Oh my goodness! I don’t know what kind of mozzarella they use, but it’s like nothing else I’ve ever tasted in all my travels. It melts perfectly, creating that perfect balance of gooey yet crispy texture.
The staff at Rosa’s Pizza also always make me feel welcomed and at home. Even though I’m a traveler, I’m always greeted with warm smiles and friendly jokes from everyone on the staff.
Wanting to try something different every time, I ask for recommendations from them and have never been disappointed so far!
All-in-all, if you’re looking for one of the best pizzas in Huntington NY, look no further than Rosa’s Pizza!
#12 Portofino
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
When I walked in, the staff immediately greeted me with a friendly hello and directed me to the best seat in the house. The atmosphere was inviting and the decor was spot on for a classic pizza place.
The food? Outstanding. Every bite in my mouth was pure pizzamore! From the classic Margherita to their unique offerings like their Bruschetta pizza, each one of them had its own uniqueness that made it stand out. The dough was lightly crispy, yet still soft in the middle. The toppings were generous and full of flavor.
My favorite part about this place was definitely the service. They were so attentive and accommodating, from grabbing extra napkins to making sure my soda glass was always refilled. It really made my experience here enjoyable.
All in all, Portofino is hands down the best pizza place in Huntington NY – I highly recommend it if you’re looking for some delicious pizza!
