Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Seaside FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Seaside FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

32 Views

I’m no amateur when it comes to pizza, having sampled pies from all over the world. So I was excited to see what doughy delights this corner of Florida had to offer.

My mission? To visit a dozen of the area’s top-rated pizza places and determine which one is the tastiest. And I’m up for the task! After all, who doesn’t love eating pizza? It’s warm, satisfying, and can make any day better. Plus, there was bound to be some humorous mishaps along my delicious journey–which is always part of the fun.

Ready or not pizzerias of Seaside FL, here I come!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Bruno’s Pizza

The atmosphere is the kind of place where the locals come to hang out – the kind of place I love to frequent when something feels like home. The servers are friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful when it comes to ordering.

Once we got our order in, it didn’t take any time at all for the pizza to arrive! And boy was it delicious! Thin crust with a perfect blend of cheeses and toppings that were cooked just right! Plus, their unique pizza sauces make every bite an experience.

Overall, Bruno’s Pizza is one of my favorite places for great pizza. It’s not pretentious or fussy – just good ol’ fashioned pizza done right. Highly recommended for anyone visiting Seaside FL looking for their next slice of cheesy goodness. Enjoy!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 17 more pizza places in Santa Rosa Beach!

#2 Fat Daddy’s Pizza – Santa Rosa Beach

The first thing that struck me about Fat Daddy’s Pizza was the delicious smell wafting out onto the street. I knew right then and there that this place had to be special. The atmosphere of the restaurant was inviting, with rustic decor, a cozy dining area, and a friendly staff.

The pizza selection at Fat Daddy’s was really impressive. They had some unusual options like their bruschetta-style flatbreads, as well as classic favorites like pepperoni and cheese. My personal favorite was their signature “Fat Daddy” pie, topped with house-made Italian sausage and sautéed red peppers. It was delicious!

But what really sets Fat Daddy’s apart is their commitment to quality ingredients – they only use the freshest mozzarella cheese and carefully select each topping for maximum flavor. Plus, the crust is perfectly thin yet crisp on the bottom – something you won’t find anywhere else in Seaside FL!

Overall, I give Fat Daddy’s Pizza – Santa Rosa Beach two enthusiastic thumbs up! If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Seaside FL, definitely give them a try – you won’t regret it!

#3 Pazzo Italiano Santa Rosa Beach

The selection of pizza is outstanding. From classic margheritas and pepperonis to unique creations like the zesty Meatball Bliss and the Cheesy Bacon Burger, there’s a perfect pizza here for everyone. The crust is delicious too – thin, crispy, and just the right amount of chewy.

What really makes Pazzo Italiano Santa Rosa Beach stand out though, is their attention to detail. Everything from the presentation to the flavors has been crafted with care, making it a truly unique experience each time I visit.

The staff is also top-notch. They’re incredibly friendly and attentive, always willing to help with ordering decisions and generally just make sure my experience was amazing.

All in all, Pazzo Italiano Santa Rosa Beach is definitely one of my top spots for pizza in Seaside FL!

#4 Bubba’s Pizza

The pizza is cooked to perfection with a thin, crispy crust. The homemade sauce has just the right amount of sweetness and spices. The toppings are so fresh and delicious, I could’ve sworn I was in Italy!

The staff at Bubba’s Pizza is also top-notch. Everyone from the counter attendants to the cooks were friendly and helpful in making sure my visit was memorable.

But what really sets Bubba’s Pizza apart is their unique approach to toppings. You can choose from traditional options like pepperoni or sausage, or you can get adventurous with specialties like artichoke hearts and goat cheese!

So if you’re ever in Seaside FL, make sure you stop by Bubba’s Pizza for some of the best pizza around!

#5 Angelina’s Pizzeria & Pasta

When I walked into Angelina’s, I was immediately hit with the smell of their famous brick oven pizza. It was enough to make my mouth water and I couldn’t wait to dig in!

The selection of pizzas at Angelina’s ranges from classic favorites like pepperoni and cheese, to more unique offerings like macaroni and cheese pizza. They also have great options for vegetarians and a kid-friendly menu.

But what’s really amazing about Angelina’s is that they serve alcohol, including hard liquor! I’m definitely not complaining about having a beer with my pizza. And if you’re feeling extra indulgent, you can finish your meal off with one of their homemade desserts.

One downside is they don’t offer delivery, so you’ll have to come into the restaurant to enjoy their delicious pizza pies. But considering its a nice tourist spot, that may not be too much of an inconvenience for some people.

Overall, it was an amazing experience at Angelina’s Pizzeria & Pasta! The food was fantastic and the atmosphere was fun and lively. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Seaside FL, then this place should definitely be on your list!

If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 15 more pizza places in Rosemary Beach!

#6 Lost Pizza Co.

I love the way that they combine traditional Italian ingredients with a more American style. They use fresh and flavorful toppings, and their cheesy crust is to die for! The combination is unlike anything I’ve ever tasted before.

The atmosphere at Lost Pizza Co. is worth mentioning as well – it’s cozy and inviting, making it the perfect spot to get together with friends or family for a delicious meal.

But let’s not forget about the pizza itself: it truly made my mouth water! The individual slices are just the right size and pack quite a flavor punch. I especially enjoyed the smoked ham and pineapple combo – it was perfectly sweet and salty.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Seaside FL, look no further than Lost Pizza Co. I’m absolutely sure you won’t be disappointed!

#7 Pizza by the Sea at WaterColor Crossings

The atmosphere was perfect for a tourist spot. They served alcohol, so I could unwind while eating delicious pizza! The kid’s menu was great too – they had plenty of options to keep even the pickiest eaters happy. Even though I’m not a vegetarian, there were some good vegetarian options on the menu as well.

I indulged in an amazing slice of their classic “Grandma Pie”, and it was amazing! To finish off our meal, they had a dessert menu with items like gelato and cannoli, which sounded too good to miss out on.

The only downside to Pizza by the Sea at WaterColor Crossings is that they don’t offer delivery, which would have been helpful if I didn’t want to make the trip out there.

Overall, Pizza by the Sea at WaterColor Crossings has some of the best pizza in Seaside FL and I highly recommend it for a visit or two!

#8 Brozinni’s Pizzeria

I visited Brozinni’s and was immediately impressed. The decor was the perfect combination of classy and hip, making me feel like I was part of something special.

The menu was extensive and had options for everyone. I went with the traditional pepperoni pizza, because let’s be honest—can you go wrong with that?

When my pizza arrived at the table it looked so good that I almost forgot to take a picture first! The crust was perfectly thin and crisp, no soggy slices here! The cheese was a generous layer and the sauce on top of it all added just the right amount of tangy flavor.

I even got to try a few other flavors from the pizzas around me, including Hawaiian and white mushroom. All were equally delicious!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in seaside FL, look no further than Brozinni’s Pizzeria. Their atmosphere is relaxed yet classy, their menu is expansive, and their pizzas are second to none! You won’t regret it!

#9 Bud & Alley’s Pizza Bar + Trattoria

From the first bite, I was impressed by the freshness of the ingredients. The crust was cooked just right and had an amazing flavor. The toppings were full of flavor and seasoned perfectly.

But that’s not all! This place has some great extra features that really made it stand out. It serves alcohol, including hard liquor if you want something a little stronger. They also have a kid’s menu which is a great option for families. There are also vegetarian options available, which is nice if you’re trying to cater to everyone’s tastes. And they even have dessert if you’ve got the room after all that pizza!

The only downside to this place is that they don’t do delivery – but when the food is this good, it’s worth a visit anyway. After all, Bud & Alley’s Pizza Bar + Trattoria is located in a beautiful spot and makes for a nice tourist destination as well!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Seaside FL, Bud & Alley’s Pizza Bar + Trattoria should definitely be your top pick!

If you’re willing to go an extra 15 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Panama City Beach!

#10 Grimaldi’s Pizzeria

I was astounded by the quality of their pies. The crust was perfectly crispy, the tomatoes were succulent and juicy, and the cheese was just melting in your mouth. I’m an adventurous pizza-eater, so I tried all sorts of toppings to see how they worked together. Every single combination was a winner!

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria has other great perks: they serve delicious drinks (including liquor!), have a kid’s menu, offer some vegetarian options, and serve up insanely good desserts. If you’re looking for a tourist spot that’s also great for watching sports or just hanging out with friends and family, Grimaldi’s is definitely a hit.

The only downside? They don’t deliver. You’ll have to go in-person to get your hands on this deliciousness! But trust me when I say it’s worth it – there really isn’t any better pizza in Seaside FL than Grimaldi’s Pizzeria.

#11 Pizza by the Sea at Gulf Place

From the moment I walked into this spot near the beach, I knew I was in for a treat. The casual atmosphere was inviting, and they have plenty of options for everyone from kids to vegetarians. Plus, if you’re looking to make a night of it, they have a great selection of beers and wines to go with your pizza!

The best part about Pizza by the Sea is their signature pizzas — no doubt some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. With options like smoked salmon caprese, pulled pork barbecue, and spicy arrabiata, there’s something for everyone. And if you’re looking for something sweet after your savory feast, they have delicious desserts like chocolate lava cake and strawberry cheesecake.

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery service — but that’s easily overlooked when you consider all the awesome features they do offer. So whether you’re looking for an enjoyable evening out or just want to grab some of the best pizza in Seaside FL, be sure to stop by Pizza by the Sea at Gulf Place!

#12 Ticheli’s Pizza

The atmosphere of Ticheli’s Pizza is relaxed and welcoming, with the smell of freshly baked pizza in the air. The staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating. I’m pretty sure they knew I was a food critic because they went above and beyond to make sure my experience was perfect.

Now onto the pizza: absolutely delicious! Their crust is light and fluffy, with a satisfying crunch, and the sauce is flavorful without being overpowering. But it’s their toppings that really stand out – so many options to choose from! They offer all sorts of unique combinations like barbeque chicken and goat cheese or prosciutto and olive oil. I ended up going with the classic pepperoni slice which frankly blew me away!

In conclusion, if you’re ever in Seaside FL looking for great pizza then look no further than Ticheli’s Pizza; you won’t be disappointed!