Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in St Augustine FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in St Augustine FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

127 Views

From the traditional to the inventive, I’ve tasted all types of pizza throughout my travels around the world. So it was with excitement that I accepted an invitation to visit St Augustine FL to sample and review 12 pizza places.

I’m sure this will be an experience like no other; ready for a delicious adventure? Let’s discover who makes the best pizza in St Augustine!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Old Town Pizza & Tavern

The first time I stepped foot in Old Town Pizza & Tavern, the aroma of delicious pizza from their brick oven hit me like a shock wave. I knew that I had to try their pizzas for myself.

When I finally got the chance to taste the pizza, my taste buds were immediately delighted! Their crust was perfectly thin and crispy, and loaded with garlic and herbs. The sauce was flavorful, not too sweet or acidic, but just right. And the cheese was gooey, stringy, and absolutely delicious!

But it wasn’t just the pizza that impressed me; the service at Old Town Pizza & Tavern was top-notch too! The wait staff was knowledgeable and friendly; they even suggested some delicious pairings with my pizza of choice.

If you’re in St Augustine FL and looking for an amazing pizza experience, look no further than Old Town Pizza & Tavern. In my opinion, they have some of the best pizza around – it’s truly a slice of heaven!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in St Augustine Beach!

#2 900º Pizza and Pasta

From the moment I walked in, I could tell that this place was special. The aroma of freshly baked dough and bubbling mozzarella filled the air and immediately made my mouth water.

When it came time to try the pizza, I wasn’t disappointed! The crust was perfectly crispy, yet still had a nice chewiness to it. The sauce was tangy and flavorful, and there were all sorts of delicious toppings from salami to fresh vegetables. Everything was cooked to perfection – not too crunchy, not too soft.

The side dishes at 900º Pizza and Pasta were also amazing! Their pasta dishes are rich with flavor and their salads are beautifully presented with fresh ingredients. Every bite was heavenly!

Overall, 900º Pizza and Pasta is without a doubt one of the best places for pizza in St Augustine FL. If you’re ever in town, don’t miss out on this culinary gem!

#3 Carmelo’s Pizzeria

The first thing that caught my attention about Carmelo’s was the smell of freshly baked dough wafting from the oven. The delicious scent alone put a smile on my face and had me eagerly anticipating what was to come.

When I dug into my first slice, I knew immediately why Carmelo’s has such a stellar reputation — the crust was light and fluffy, and the sauce was zesty without being overpowering. The cheese wasn’t greasy, either, which is a huge plus for discerning pizza fans like myself.

But the real clincher for me were the toppings! Everything from pepperoni to spinach to mushrooms was fresh and flavorful. It was clear that Carmelo’s puts in the extra effort to make sure each topping adds something special to their iconic pizza pies.

I have to say that after all my travels, I consider myself fortunate to have stumbled upon this little gem of a pizzeria in St Augustine FL. In my opinion, Carmelo’s Pizzeria is easily one of the best pizza places in town!

#4 St. Augie’s Pizza

The cheese was creamy and the sauce had just the right balance of tang and sweetness. The crust was thin and crispy, yet light enough to be foldable. I had the pleasure of trying a few toppings from their extensive options menu, and each one exceeded my expectations in flavor and texture combination.

The atmosphere at St. Augie’s is also top-notch. The walls are covered with unique murals that transport you back to Italy, while the staff is friendly, helpful, and accommodating.

If it’s pizza you’re after – look no further than St Augie’s! With their delicious pies and cheerful atmosphere, it’s sure to become your go-to spot for a night out or a casual slice on the go. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or wanting to take your time enjoying some quality Italian cuisine – check out St Augie’s Pizza for the best pizza in St Augustine FL!

#5 Pizzalley’s Chianti Room

As soon as I stepped inside, the atmosphere was inviting and pleasant. It’s located in a back alleyway near the old Spanish forts that line the city and reminded me of some of the classic pizzerias I’ve visited in Italy.

The menu was quite comprehensive, featuring all sorts of pizza creations such as Neapolitan-style pies, New York-style slices, pan pizzas, and even a few specialty dishes like lasagna. Each item was made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection – not too soft or crispy.

I especially liked their Chianti Room pizza – it had a delicious combination of roasted garlic, mushrooms, peppers and onions that blended perfectly with the tangy tomato sauce and melty mozzarella cheese. The crust was thin but just thick enough to hold up all the toppings without breaking apart. I would rate this pizza an A+!

To top off my experience at Pizzalley’s Chianti Room, I had one of their specialty Italian desserts – it was freshly baked cannoli filled with a sweet filling that was both creamy and crunchy at the same time. Absolutely delicious!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in St Augustine FL, look no further than Pizzalley’s Chianti Room! You won’t be disappointed!

#6 Real Peel Pizza

The atmosphere was inviting and comfortable, and the staff were all exceptionally helpful. What really won me over was the kid’s menu – it made me feel like I could bring my family along without having to worry about them not finding something to eat. The vegetarian options were also surprisingly good – it’s nice to find a pizza place that caters to everyone, regardless of dietary restrictions.

That being said, Real Peel Pizza has one major downside: there is no delivery option. For those who don’t enjoy dining out or don’t have a way of getting to Real Peel Pizza, this can be a major inconvenience.

I’d strongly recommend giving Real Peel Pizza a try – you won’t regret it! The quality of pizza here is top-notch and you’re sure to find something that hits the spot – even vegetarians can have their pick! Just remember, if you want it delivered, you’ll need to look elsewhere.

#7 Antonio’s New York Style Pizza

The pizzeria is owned by Antonio and his wife, who have placed an impressive emphasis on authenticity. As soon as you walk in, you’ll see it in the decor—complete with New York street signs, plastered pictures of Brooklyn Bridge and a New Yorker greeting you at the door!

When I took my seat, I was handed a big, thin-crusted pizza covered with pepperoni and mushrooms. The crust was spongy yet crisp–it was perfection! The sauce was a special blend of tomatoes, garlic and spices that melted in my mouth. The toppings were fresh and plentiful.

I think what really sets this place apart from other “New York style” restaurants is their adherence to original recipes from Pizza masters from NYC. Their recipe for dough was created specifically for this place which gives it that unmistakable flavor.

To top off my experience at Antonio’s New York Style Pizza: there incredible selection of beer and wine selections. From local craft brews to exotic Italian wines, they have something for everyone’s tastes!

All in all it was an amazing experience–the best pizza in St Augustine FL by far!

If you’re willing to go an extra 27 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Jacksonville Beach!

#8 Mellow Mushroom St. Augustine

The atmosphere in the restaurant is lively and inviting. Upon entering, you know you’re in for a special treat. The staff are incredibly friendly and welcoming, always ready to provide recommendations for the best pizza on the menu. And when it comes to the food itself, you can’t go wrong!

The pizzas are cooked perfectly and have a unique flavor that I haven’t had anywhere else. Whether it’s their signature Italian-style pies or something exotic like their Hawaiian Medley Pizza, each slice is truly delicious. The crusts are just right – light and crispy on the outside while still having a great chew inside. And of course, they’ve got all your favorite toppings like pepperoni, mushrooms, olives and more!

Overall, Mellow Mushroom St Augustine is an excellent choice if you’re looking for the best pizza in St Augustine FL! You won’t be sorry when dig into one of their incredible creations – I certainly wasn’t!

#9 Pizzalley’s on St. George

I was blown away by the quality of their pizzas. The thick, chewy crust and gooey cheese were some of the best I’ve ever tasted. And I can confidently say that the meticulously crafted sauces and toppings made each bite an absolute delight.

To top it all off, they have a great selection of specialty pizzas and unique flavor combinations including Thai curry, buffalo chicken, and a ‘veggie supreme deluxe.’ No matter your pizza preferences, you’re sure to find something to satisfy your taste buds here at Pizzalley’s. Plus, there’s always delicious beer on tap to accompany your meal!

The restaurant has a retro vibe with bright colors, vintage arcade games, and big leather chairs for relaxing in between slices. This makes for an extremely enjoyable experience whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout.

Overall, Pizzalley’s is easily one of the best pizza places in St Augustine FL – if not the best! Eating at Pizzalley’s is truly an unforgettable experience; each bite is filled with flavor that can’t be found anywhere else. So if you’re ever in town looking for a delicious slice – this should definitely be your first stop!

#10 Vinny’s Pizza

From the first bite, I could tell the pizza was made with only the freshest ingredients. The crust was thin and perfectly crisp. The sauce had a nice hint of garlic and herbs that added to its flavor without overpowering it. The cheese was gooey and flavorful, making each slice melt in my mouth.

The ingredients were top notch, but what really blew me away at Vinny’s Pizza was the service! The staff was so friendly and welcoming, it felt like we were part of their family. They talked us through all our options and gave us helpful suggestions based on our taste preferences. Plus, they even threw in free garlic knots with our order!

All in all, I think Vinny’s Pizza is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had – no matter where I’ve been around the world! If you’re looking for quality pizza in St Augustine FL, look no further than Vinny’s Pizza!

#11 Five Star Pizza

I had the pleasure of trying their signature pizza with a delicious blend of pepperoni, bacon, and three types of cheese. Its thin crust was perfectly cooked, giving it a crunchy yet chewable texture. The toppings were extremely fresh and flavorful.

The staff at Five Star Pizza were incredibly welcoming and accommodating when I mentioned I was a food critic. They even offered to let me sample some of their other pizzas, including classic margherita and white garlic pizzas. Each one was deliciously unique, and I could tell from the restaurant’s buzz that it was a popular local spot for pizza lovers.

The atmosphere was casual and fun as well, with a friendly staff happy to chat about everything under the sun between slices of pizza. When I asked them why their pizza is the best in St Augustine FL, they replied with one word: passion! Their talented chefs bring an infectious energy to each dish they prepare, making each slice unique and unforgettable.

If you’re ever in St Augustine FL searching for the best pizza around – look no further than Five Star Pizza!

#12 Anthony’s East Coast Pizza

This is no ordinary pizza joint. Here, you can find not only traditional Italian-style pizzas, but also a variety of creative specialty pies that incorporate ingredients from all over the world. For example, their “Tropical Temptation” pizza combines pineapple, bacon, and jalapenos for a unique flavor combination that I’ve never seen before at any other pizzeria.

The service here is friendly and fast; in the time it took me to order my pie, it was already coming out of the oven! And when they handed me my piping hot slice of perfection, I couldn’t help but be impressed with its size and taste. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy with just the right amount of charring around the edges. The cheese was gooey and creamy, while the toppings were freshly sliced and full of flavor.

At Anthony’s East Coast Pizza you’ll find not only amazing pizza but a vibrant atmosphere as well. From colorful murals on the walls to classic tunes playing in the background, this place creates a truly welcoming environment that makes you feel right at home.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in St Augustine FL, then look no further than Anthony’s East Coast Pizza!