Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Columbia SC (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in South Carolina

Best Pizza in Columbia SC (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

299 Views

Now, I’m not saying it’s the best pizza in the world–I mean, after all, I’ve had some amazing slices from Naples to Tokyo. But that doesn’t mean Columbia SC can’t still serve up a delicious slice.

I’ve visited 12 different pizza spots in Columbia SC and want to share my findings with you. From cheesy Margherita pies to creative toppings and gluten-free options, we’re going to find out where your next pizza craving should take you!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of South Carolina

#1 Blue Pizza SC

It’s rare to find a restaurant that has perfected such a simple dish, but Blue Pizza SC has done it! From the first bite I knew this was something special. The crust was perfectly crispy and had just the right amount of char. The tomato sauce was fresh and flavorful and the cheese was creamy and heavenly.

Of course, it wouldn’t be a local pizza joint without some unique toppings! Blue Pizza SC had some creative choices including bacon-wrapped shrimp and creamy garlic alfredo. They were both delicious!

I would definitely recommend dining at Blue Pizza SC if you’re in the area. You won’t be disappointed – this is truly some of the best pizza in Columbia SC!

If you’re willing to go an extra 16 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Lexington!

#2 Il Focolare Pizzeria

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, and the staff are friendly. They even offer alcoholic beverages, which I was pleasantly surprised by!

I tried their veggie pizza, which had a nice balance of veggies and cheese. It wasn’t your typical cheese-heavy option. There’s also some great dessert offerings for those with a sweet tooth.

What really got me excited about Il Focolare Pizzeria though was their commitment to quality ingredients. Their crust is made from the freshest dough, and they use only the best mozzarella and tomato sauce to top it off!

The only downside is that they don’t deliver; but that isn’t really an issue as they have plenty of seating to accommodate walk-in customers.

To sum it up, Il Focolare Pizzeria has got my vote for the best pizza in Columbia SC!

#3 MOD Pizza

The thing that stood out to me the most was their unusual toppings. I’m used to seeing pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms on pizzas all around the world, but MOD Pizza has an impressive list of unconventional ingredients like roasted garlic pesto, feta cheese, and truffle oil. It’s clear that they’re pushing the boundaries of what a pizza should be!

I also appreciate the fact that MOD Pizza lets you customize your own pizza with any topping you want for one set price. That means everyone can get exactly what they want without breaking the bank (or having leftovers!) It’s a great way to make sure everyone leaves happy.

The service at MOD Pizza was also top-notch. The employees were friendly and accommodating and were happy to answer my questions. Plus, their ordering system is really efficient – I was in and out in no time!

In summary, if you’re looking for a unique pizza experience with excellent customer service, then look no further than MOD Pizza. I can confidently say that it’s some of the best pizza in Columbia SC!

#4 Blaze Pizza

My first visit to Blaze Pizza was delightful. The decor was inviting and the staff were friendly. But most importantly, the pizza was delicious! Everything from the classic margherita pizza to more adventurous tomato, basil and gorgonzola creations were cooked to perfection.

The crusts were perfect; crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The toppings were always fresh, never over cooked and evenly distributed. The combination of flavors blended together for a truly sublime experience. Plus, I always appreciate restaurants that offer vegan options (Blaze Pizza did not disappoint).

I think my favorite feature of Blaze Pizza is their “Create Your Own” option where you can pick your own ingredients and watch them prepare your custom-made dish in an open-kitchen setting! It’s always entertaining, not to mention tasty.

In short, Blaze Pizza is definitely one of the best pizzerias in Columbia SC. If you ever find yourself hungry for delicious pizza with a homemade feel – this is the spot!

#5 Dano’s Pizza

The texture of the dough was incredible! It was perfectly proofed and had a great crunch when you bit into it. The sauce had the perfect balance of sweet and savory that made my taste buds sing. They didn’t skimp on the cheese either – it was melted to perfection and had a wonderful flavor.

My favorite part, though, was their topping selection. They always have something new and interesting on offer, which keeps me coming back time and time again! This time, I opted for their special: salami, garlic, and olives. It hit all the right notes and was so tasty I almost couldn’t get enough!

To top it off, the service at Dano’s Pizza is stellar. The owners are friendly, attentive, and always make sure your pizza experience is top-notch.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Columbia SC, head on over to Dano’s Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

#6 MOD Pizza

The pizza crust was perfectly thin and crispy, and the sauce was savory with just the right amount of herbs. The cheese was creamy and delicious, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

I’m especially impressed with the topping options at MOD Pizza – they had a huge selection from standard toppings like pepperoni to more exotic choices like vegan sausage. Whatever your tastes are, you’ll definitely find something to satisfy your cravings at MOD Pizza!

I have to say that all pizzas I tried were excellent in their own way – even the vegan ones! The staff is also friendly and knowledgeable about their menu, which really helps make ordering easier.

All in all, MOD Pizza is definitely one of the best places around for pizza – it’s definitely worth checking out in Columbia SC if you’re looking for a great pie!

#7 La Brascas Pizza

The pizza is cooked to perfection and the ingredients are fresh. The crust is always delightfully crispy, and the generous toppings – oh my! I could say that I’m in heaven when I taste it.

And if you do go, don’t forget to check out their wine and beer selection. They pair perfectly with their pizza. And of course, being the food connoisseur I am, I had to try some of their desserts. Let me just say that they are truly a sight to behold – delicious too!

My only gripe is that they don’t deliver – but no matter. A visit to La Brascas Pizza is worth it in more ways than one! What a great tourist spot and it’s conveniently located in town too!

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Columbia SC, then you need look no further than La Brascas Pizza. Highly recommended! Bon appetit!

#8 Pizza Palace

On my visit to Pizza Palace, I was impressed by the range of items they had to offer. From delectable Italian classics to more adventurous pies, the menu satisfied all my pizza-craving needs! Plus, they serve alcohol, so adults can enjoy their favorite beer while they chow down on a slice. For families with young ones, Pizza Palace also has a kid’s menu and desserts that are sure to please everyone.

Unfortunately there is one major downside – Pizza Palace does not have delivery service yet. If you’re looking for delicious pizza but don’t want to leave the house, you’ll have to find another option.

Overall, I think Pizza Palace is one of the best pizza restaurants in Columbia SC and definitely worth a visit! The atmosphere is relaxed, the prices are reasonable, and the pizza is heavenly!

If you’re willing to go an extra 64 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Rock Hill!

#9 Il Bucato

The restaurant is cozy, with just a few tables inside and one large communal table, where friends and family can come together to enjoy a slice. The staff are friendly and welcoming, always ready to answer questions about their delicious pizzas.

The star of the show at Il Bucato is without a doubt the pizza. It has a perfect thin crust that has just a hint of char from the wood-fired oven. Toppings are fresh and plentiful on every pie, with no two slices ever tasting the same. I’ve tried their classic cheese and pepperoni pies, plus some more unique flavors like truffle and gorgonzola, all of which were amazing!

I highly recommend Il Bucato for anyone looking for the best pizza in Columbia SC – you won’t be disappointed!

#10 Very’s Great Philly Food

When I arrived at the restaurant, I was immediately struck by the cozy atmosphere – almost like I had walked into someone’s living room! The staff were all friendly and made me feel right at home.

The pizza was delicious and cooked to perfection; it tasted just like the pizzas in Philadelphia! The crust was crispy and flavorful, while the toppings were fresh and flavorful. It didn’t take me long to polish off an entire large pizza!

I would definitely recommend Very’s Great Philly Food to anyone looking for the best pizza in Columbia SC. The food is top-notch, and you won’t be disappointed!

#11 Nick’s House of Pizza Restaurant

From the moment I stepped in, it was clear Nick’s House of Pizza Restaurant was a special place. From the vintage décor to the friendly staff, I could tell they valued the tradition of truly great pizza.

And did they deliver! Every bite of my pepperoni pizza had a delicate balance of flavor. The crust was perfectly chewy and the cheese had just enough saltiness to make every bite memorable—it really was something special.

The highlight of my meal was definitely the sauce. It had this combination of sweetness and tang that sent me into a food coma. This pizza really can compete with some of the best pies I’ve tasted in New York and Rome!

So if you’re looking for the best pizza in Columbia SC, look no further than Nick’s House Of Pizza Restaurant!

#12 Tazza Kitchen Trenholm Plaza

The pizzas are cooked to perfection – you can realy taste the freshness of the ingredients. Plus, they have a great selection of vegetarian options so everyone can enjoy their meal. And once your pizza is done, you can wash it down with some alcohol – they even carry hard liquor!

Speaking of desserts, Tazza Kitchen Trenholm Plaza has some insanely good treats – it’s something that really needs to be tried to be believed.

Unfortunately, they don’t offer delivery, but sometimes you just need that ‘dining in’ experience to appreciate the quality of the pizza and hospitality. So if you’re looking for one of the best pizza places in Columbia SC, look no further than Tazza Kitchen Trenholm Plaza!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Finding a good deep dish pizza outside of Chicago is like finding a unicorn at a grocery store. But lo and behold, Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom has managed to capture the essence of the Windy City in their cheesy, saucy creations right here in Columbia.

As I stepped into the restaurant, I was immediately greeted by the aroma of freshly baked dough and the lively atmosphere of people enjoying their pizza. The staff was friendly, eager to satisfy my pizza cravings, and even willing to engage in a deep philosophical discussion about the merits of cheese-stuffed crusts.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza itself. The deep dish crust was a masterpiece – thick, buttery, and flakey. It oozed with a perfect harmony of cheese, sauce, and toppings. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, causing my taste buds to break out in spontaneous applause. And let’s not forget about the generous amount of toppings – I had to take off my belt just to make room for all the deliciousness.

But it wasn’t just the pizza that impressed me. Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom also had an impressive selection of craft beers on tap. I decided to wash down my pizza with a local IPA that danced on my palate like a salsa dancer at a pizza-eating contest.

In conclusion, if you’re searching for the best deep dish pizza in Columbia, SC, head straight to Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom. Your taste buds will thank you, and your belt will forgive you…eventually.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Blaze Pizza

Walking into Blaze Pizza, I was immediately hit with the heavenly aroma of dough and cheese. The place had a lively, energetic vibe that made me want to do a little pizza dance. The best part? They serve alcohol! Nothing pairs better with a cheesy slice than a refreshing pint of beer.

As a vegetarian, I was thrilled to find that Blaze Pizza had several veggie options. I piled on all the veggies I could find, creating a colorful work of art on my pizza. And let me tell you, it tasted like a masterpiece! Each bite was bursting with flavors and textures that left me feeling like a pizza Picasso.

But wait, it gets better! Blaze Pizza also offers dessert. I indulged in their S’more Pie, which was a gooey, chocolatey delight that took me straight to dessert heaven. And I didn’t even need a reservation to enjoy all these tasty treats!

The only downside to Blaze Pizza is that they don’t accept reservations. So if you’re planning a big pizza party, you might have to leave your organizational skills at the door. But hey, isn’t spontaneity the spice of life? And in this case, the spice comes in the form of fresh, crispy thin crust pizza.

So if you find yourself in Columbia, SC, and you’re craving the best thin crust pizza in town, head on over to Blaze Pizza. They’ll make your taste buds dance, your stomach sing, and your pizza dreams come true.