Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Frederick MD (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Maryland

Best Pizza in Frederick MD (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

336 Views

Having been all over the world sampling exquisite pies, I’m always on the hunt for a pizza worthy of wearing my food critic hat. After testing out 12 pizza places in Frederick, I can confidently say that I have found some truly delicious contenders.

In this article, I’ll lay out all my findings and declare which places serve up the best pizzas Frederick MD has to offer. So stay tuned and get ready for some serious pizza discussions!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Maryland

#1 Rosati’s Pizza

It starts with their special sauce – it’s a blend of spices so unique and flavorful that I’m still puzzling over what exactly they put in there. They also top each pie-whether it be classic cheese, veggie, or one of the specialty pies-with fresh veggies, lots of gooey cheese, and just the right amount of meats and other toppings.

The crust is crunchy but not too burnt, which is something I haven’t seen too often outside Italy. The perfect ratio between dough and topping seems to come together like a symphony – it ain’t easy to do!

I’ve also sampled some of their specialty pizzas and surprisingly enough, they’re all really good! The Buffalo Chicken pizza was my favorite – covered with crispy fried chicken pieces, gooey blue cheese crumbles AND a drizzle of hot sauce – SO GOOD!

In terms of service, Rosati’s Pizza has been great every time I’ve come in. They always remember my order and make sure I get exactly what I’m looking for. All in all, it’s an amazing pizza experience that no one should miss out on. If you’re in Frederick MD and wanting the best pizza around then head over to Rosati’s Pizza – it truly has some of the best pie around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 18 miles, you can get to 21 more pizza places in Germantown!

#2 Bellisario’s Pizza

The first time I visited this place, I was absolutely blown away. The pizza had great flavor, the sauce was perfectly seasoned, and the crust was so light and fluffy. It really is hard to believe that such delicious pizza can be found in a small town like Frederick.

The staff at Bellisario’s are also top notch. They are friendly, helpful and seem to genuinely care about making sure their customers have a great experience. And how could I forget the decor? The restaurant looks like it should be in Italy with its warm tones, checkered tablecloths and Italian murals on the walls.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Frederick MD, Bellisario’s has got it going on!

#3 Pretzel & Pizza Creations

Every bite of their delicious creations was bursting with flavor and carefully made with the freshest toppings around. The dough was soft and chewy, but still had a nice crunch. The crust had a great buttery finish that melted in your mouth.

Their staff were friendly and attentive, always willing to answer any questions I had about the menu options. They even went above and beyond to accommodate my food allergies so I could enjoy their vegan-friendly pizzas.

The atmosphere was inviting and cozy, making me feel right at home. And the prices were very reasonable for the quality of ingredients they use.

If you’re ever in Frederick MD looking for some of the best pizza around, be sure to check out Pretzel & Pizza Creations! You won’t regret it!

#4 Pasquale’s Italian Pizza

I must admit that it took me a while to find out about Pasquale’s, but once I did, I was not disappointed. The facility itself is cozy and inviting, with the pizza oven sitting in the center of the restaurant.

The quality of their pizzas is what truly stands out. With a combination of Italian spices, fresh mozzarella cheese, and the perfect amount of sauce, you can expect something tasty each time you order. The crust is always cooked to perfection – golden-brown on the outside and soft on the inside.

Their menu also offers a variety of delicious speciality pizzas that are worth trying as well. They have an array of different toppings to choose from as well as unique sauces such as pesto or white garlic sauce.

All in all, Pasquale’s has some of the best pizza in Frederick MD and I would highly recommend them for any pizza lovers out there!

#5 Pistarro’s

I was able to try their pizzas along with some of their other great dishes, and the food was absolutely delicious. I especially loved their cheese bread – it’s one of those dishes that you will come back for time and time again.

Another great thing about Pistarro’s is that it serves alcohol (and hard liquor!), so if you’re looking for a place to grab dinner and drinks with friends, this is your spot. It also has a kid’s menu, which makes it perfect for families. As someone who sometimes likes to go meatless, I was pleased with their vegetarian options as well.

But one of the best things about Pistarro’s is its insanely good dessert! The tiramisu that I tried was amazing – definitely worth trying out if you get the chance.

Pistarro’s is also a great tourist spot – you can take in all the sights while enjoying one of their delicious pizzas. There is only one downside: they do not offer delivery, so you have to eat in or carry out.

In conclusion, if you’re searching for the best pizza in Frederick MD, look no further than Pistarro’s!

#6 Il Forno Pizzeria

When I first walked into the restaurant, I was immediately impressed with the open air kitchen and burning wood-fired oven. The aromas of oregano, garlic, and freshly-baked dough filled the air and made me even hungrier than I already was.

I tried several different pizzas on their menu, including the classic Margherita, a special mushroom pizza, and a pies topped with roasted veggies. Every single one was cooked to perfection in that blazing hot oven! The crusts were light and fluffy on the inside and had just enough crunch on the outside. The flavors were bold and balanced – none overpowered any of the others.

The staff at Il Forno Pizzeria were incredibly friendly as well. They always had huge smiles on their faces when I asked for help or advice about what to order.

Overall, I can honestly say that Il Forno Pizzeria has some of the best pizza in Frederick MD – even better than some of my other experiences around the world! If you’re ever in town craving some authentic Italian pizza, this is definitely your place.

#7 Ledo Pizza

I was delighted by the selection of liquor they had on offer, making it a great spot for adults to unwind after a long day. But my favorite part was their kid’s menu–perfect for families who don’t want to have to split up and eat at different places. Plus, vegetarian options? Ledo Pizza has you covered.

Speaking of good food, can we talk about the pizza? As an expert in pizza reviews I was surprised at how great it tasted! The crust was buttery and crunchy, with the perfect amount of cheese and sauce. It really hit the spot! If you’re looking for some delicious dessert, they have that too.

My only complaint is that they don’t offer delivery, so I had to brave Frederick’s traffic to get to Ledo Pizza myself. But it was definitely worth the wait! Overall I highly recommend this place – it may just be the best pizza in Frederick MD.

#8 Ledo Pizza

This restaurant has plenty to offer and it’s a great place to go for a tourist spot. I was impressed by their selection of alcoholic beverages which accompanied my delicious pizza perfectly. They also have a kid’s menu which is great for families, and they even have some vegetarian options.

The pizza was cooked to perfection with a nice crispy crust, flavorful toppings, and the perfect amount of cheese. And after such an amazing meal I got to top it off with dessert!

The biggest downside when it comes to Ledo Pizza is that they don’t offer delivery service. So if you’re looking for delivery you will have to look somewhere else. But, in my opinion, all the other benefits outweigh this tiny downside – it’s worth the trip! All in all, Ledo Pizza offers some of the best pizza around and I highly recommend trying this yummy spot out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 21 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Hagerstown!

#9 Capital Crave

My experience began with the drinks; they offer alcoholic and hard liquor beverages, and I thought that was a very nice touch.

The pizza was cooked perfectly, as it should be. Every bite was flavorful and delicious! What’s more is that their kid’s menu offers smaller options that kids will love.

After the pizza, they offer a variety of desserts to finish off your meal. All I can say is, wow!

Finally the atmosphere at Capital Crave was great for watching sports. So if you’re a sports fan, this is definitely the place to be!

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery, so you’ll have to come in person if you want to enjoy their amazing pizza.

Overall, I had a wonderful experience at Capital Crave and definitely recommend it for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Frederick MD!

#10 Coal Fire Pizza

The decor was simple, but the atmosphere was very inviting. The servers were friendly and attentive, and they really made the experience enjoyable.

When it came to the food, I was totally blown away. The crust on their pizzas is unbelievably thin and crispy – just how I like it! They offer a huge variety of toppings, so you can easily customize your pizza however you want. Every slice was loaded with flavor and you could really taste the freshness of each ingredient. Not only that, but their selection of appetizers and sides were also really tasty.

Overall, Coal Fire Pizza is one of the best pizza joints in Frederick MD and certainly worth checking out. Now if I could only find some pizza as good as this back home…

#11 Vocelli Pizza

I was instantly impressed by the wide selection of pizzas, ranging from classic cheese and pepperoni pies to more gourmet options like their pizza bianca with ricotta and spinach. The crusts are just the right thickness – not too thin, not too thick – and all the ingredients are always fresh.

Plus, the customer service is top-notch! The staff were friendly, knowledgeable about their products and helpful in suggesting what combinations would be best for any particular taste. With that kind of attention to detail, it’s no surprise why this place is consistently rated one of the best pizza places in Frederick MD.

The prices are also reasonable and they offer great deals that make it even easier to get your hands on a delicious meal. Whether you’re looking for slices to go or a full-on pie (or two!) I highly recommend Vocelli Pizza. It’s definitely earned its spot as one of the best pizza joints in town!

#12 Pizza Blitz

From the pizza crust to the toppings, they have it all. The perfectly crisp and fluffy crust made me swoon with delight, and the selection of toppings was incredible. I had a classic pepperoni pizza and I must say it was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. The sauce was flavorful and the cheese was just the right amount of greasy – what more could you ask for?

The seating area was bright and inviting, too. The tables were spacious and comfortable, making it easy to relax while enjoying a delicious pie. What’s more, the staff members were friendly, knowledgeable, and welcoming – you can tell they really care about their customers!

Overall, Pizza Blitz is an exemplary pizza joint that will not disappoint. If you’re in Frederick MD looking for great pizza, then look no further than Pizza Blitz!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Rosati’s Pizza

Now, before I dive into this cheesy review, let me just say that I was almost tempted to book a flight to Chicago after tasting Rosati’s deep dish. This pizza is so thick, I couldn’t help but wonder if it came with its own personal trainer. And let’s not forget about the cheese! The amount of melted mozzarella on top of that doughy goodness could rival a cheese fountain at a fancy wedding.

But what truly sets Rosati’s apart is the fact that they have some vegetarian options. As a traveling food critic, I often find myself stuck eating plain salads while my carnivorous compatriots feast on all sorts of meaty delights. But at Rosati’s, I was able to sink my teeth into a slice loaded with veggies that made me feel like I was eating a delicious garden.

And let’s not forget about dessert! Rosati’s offers a sweet ending to your pizza feast with their delectable dessert options. From gooey chocolate-filled calzones to rich tiramisu, they have something to satisfy any sweet tooth.

Now, I must admit that there is one downside to dining at Rosati’s – they don’t accept reservations. I mean, who are they, the pizza gods? I suppose I’ll just have to bring a book or form a queue with my fellow pizza enthusiasts as we wait anxiously for a table.

In conclusion, if you find yourself in Maryland and in dire need of some deep dish pizza, do yourself a favor and head over to Rosati’s. Just make sure you bring your appetite and perhaps a chair to sit on while waiting for a table. Trust me, it will be worth it!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Il Forno Pizzeria

Now, let me tell you about my experience. As a traveling food critic, I have visited countless pizza joints, but Il Forno Pizzeria stands out for a number of reasons. First and foremost, they serve alcohol, and not just your run-of-the-mill beer and wine. No, they have hard liquor too! So, if you want to pair your slice of cheesy goodness with a stiff drink, this is the place to be.

But don’t worry, my vegetarian amigos, they have some options for us too! The menu includes delicious veggie toppings and some tasty vegetarian specialty pizzas. Finally, a place that respects us and our herbivorous inclinations.

And let’s not forget about dessert. Because what’s a pizza feast without a sweet ending? Il Forno Pizzeria offers a delectable range of dessert options. One bite into their chocolate lava cake, and you’ll feel like you’ve died and gone to pizza heaven.

Now, Il Forno Pizzeria is not just an amazing place for pizza lovers; it’s also a great spot for tourists. Located in the heart of Frederick, it’s an ideal place to refuel after exploring the town. Plus, they have TVs, making it the perfect spot to catch a game while munching on their delicious slices.

However, there’s one downside: they do not accept reservations. So, if you’re planning to visit during peak hours, be prepared to wait. But trust me, it’s worth the wait. The thin, crispy crust coupled with the perfect balance of toppings and cheese will make you forget all about the wait.

In conclusion, Il Forno Pizzeria is a gem in the pizza landscape of Frederick. With its mouthwatering thin crust pizza, wide selection of drinks, vegetarian options, and tempting desserts, it’s a must-visit spot for any pizza aficionado. Just be sure to leave your reservation expectations at the door and prepare for a taste bud adventure like no