Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Hilton Head Island (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in South Carolina

Best Pizza in Hilton Head Island (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

497 Views

Let’s just say – I’m no stranger to a good slice. From Sicily to Sao Paulo, I’ve sampled pizza all over the globe. So when the time came to find the very best pizza in Hilton Head Island, I was more than up for the challenge.

I searched high and low in beautiful coastal town of Hilton Head Island and found twelve places that served up delicious pies. Come join me as I compare the flavors, scents and textures of each place, in search for the best pizza on this stunning island!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of South Carolina

#1 Dough Boys Pizza

It seems they use some kind of special magical dough recipe to get their crusts so light and fluffy. Every bite is a delicious experience – you can really taste the flavor that comes from their high-quality ingredients.

The toppings are fresh and flavorful, and the sauces are just out of this world! My favorite was their homemade marinara sauce, which had a great depth of flavor to it.

The staff at Dough Boys Pizza were also super friendly and helpful, which only added to my experience. They made sure I got everything I wanted in my pizza, even though I had quite a few requests!

Overall, if you’re ever looking for some of the best pizza in Hilton Head, look no further than Dough Boys Pizza. It’s definitely worth the stop!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Bluffton!

#2 Fat Baby’s Pizza & Subs

I was immediately impressed by the extensive menu, which had more than enough options for me to choose from. The various pizzas were all masterpieces in their own right and I could tell that real care and attention had gone into perfecting them.

My personal favorite was the “Sicilian Slice”, a thick-crusted delicacy that certainly tickled my taste buds. It was loaded with delicious vegetables and cheese, and I could tell it had been cooked to perfection. It’s definitely one of the best slices I’ve ever tasted!

On top of that, they have an impressive selection of subs and sandwiches on offer, all of which looked mouthwateringly good.

The atmosphere at Fat Baby’s Pizza & Subs was great too; it’s got a nice cozy vibe and the staff pay great attention to detail. This made getting my meal an enjoyable experience as well as eating it!

Overall, Fat Baby’s Pizza & Subs has certainly become my go-to spot for pizza in Hilton Head – if you’re looking for the best pizza around, this is the place for you.

#3 La pizzeria

Greeted by pleasant staff and a cozy atmosphere, I knew I was in for a treat. After taking a look at the menu I went for my classic pepperoni pie with extra cheese – boy was it delicious! The crust was thin, the sauce was well balanced, and the toppings were fresh and generous. Perfectly cooked to golden perfection in their wood-fired ovens, this pizza is number one!

What made La pizzeria even more amazing was the variety of options offered on their menu. From unusual flavor combinations like bacon and pineapple to simple pies like goats cheese and tomato basil – they have something for everyone’s taste buds.

To top it off, not only do they make delicious pizza but they also offer artisanal beers on tap as well as other Italian dishes like pasta and risotto. Even though La pizzeria may be located in Hilton Head, it certainly has some of the best pizza around!

#4 Local Pie Woodfired Pizza

The atmosphere was cozy, the staff was pleasant and helpful, and I was able to get a great seat right next to the enormous wood-burning oven. The smell of the fire-roasted pizzas was enough to draw me in!

The pizza itself was a work of art. It had all the right toppings, cooked perfectly. The crust had a nice charring that gave it a delicious smoky flavor. The taste was so amazing that I couldn’t help but take one more slice!

I would highly recommend Local Pie Woodfired Pizza to anyone looking for an authentic Italian pizza experience in Hilton Head. Between the great atmosphere, wonderful service, and delicious pizza, this place is definitely worth a visit!

#5 Giuseppi’s Pizza & Pasta House Shelter Cove

From the moment I stepped in the door, my senses were overwhelmed with the amazing smells coming from the kitchen. And then the pizza. Wow! The perfectly cooked crust and bubbly cheese explosion were enough to make me long for more!

But that’s not all – Giuseppi’s Pizza & Pasta House Shelter Cove isn’t just a place to get pizza. Their pasta dishes are mouth-watering, too! From classic spaghetti to vegan options, they have something for everyone on their menu.

What really sets Giuseppi’s Pizza & Pasta House Shelter Cove apart though is their friendly staff. From the warm smiles that greet you as soon as you arrive, to the speedy service and helpful recommendations, this place is a delight!

Plus, there’s no need to worry about time constraints when you come here, since their delivery service is lightning fast and always on time! So whether you’re in a hurry or looking for an evening filled with delicious food, Giuseppi’s Pizza & Pasta House Shelter Cove has you covered.

For me, Giuseppi’s Pizza & Pasta House Shelter Cove was an awesome experience that I would highly recommend – it’s definitely one of the best places for pizza in Hilton Head!

#6 TJ’s Take & Bake Pizza

The crust is light and flavorful, and every bite is filled with delightful flavors. The sauce has a lovely balance of sweet and spicy that makes my mouth water just thinking about it. I especially like their innovative toppings – the garlic parmesan wings are divine, and their unique smokey bacon pizza is to die for!

The service here is also top notch. The staff is friendly and attentive, ensuring that every visit here is an enjoyable one. And the atmosphere? Well, let’s just say it’s quite cozy and inviting.

Overall, TJ’s Take & Bake Pizza delivers a delicious pizza experience every time, leaving me wanting more. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Hilton Head, look no further than TJ’s!

#7 Club Seats Grille

The first thing that grabbed my attention when I arrived at the restaurant was the smell of fresh pizza dough in the oven. It immediately made my mouth water and I couldn’t wait to dig in!

The staff was incredibly friendly and professional, making sure we were taken care of and our orders were correct before leaving us to enjoy our meal.

I opted for an artisanal pizza and it certainly did not disappoint. Perfectly cooked thin-crust with a unique blend of cheese and spices, topped with fresh veggies – a true work of art!

The best part about Club Seats Grille is their commitment to using local ingredients, so you know you’re getting some high-quality produce. The portions are also really generous, so you definitely get your money’s worth.

Overall, if you’re looking for some great pizza in Hilton Head Island, Club Seats Grille is without a doubt your best bet!

If you’re willing to go an extra 19 miles, you can get to 19 more pizza places in Beaufort!

#8 Mangiamo’s Hilton Head Pizza Co

When I stepped into Mangiamo’s, I knew immediately that I was in the right place. The atmosphere is lively, and the staff is friendly and knowledgeable – they even gave me a few suggestions for the best pies before I could even ask!

After scanning their menu, I opted for one of their signature combo pies and it did not disappoint. The crust was thin and crispy yet still had enough surface area to hold all the delicious toppings. The sauce had just the right amount of spice, and my favorite combination of meats and veggies were cooked to perfection. Each bite was so delicious that I couldn’t help but keep coming back for more!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Hilton Head then Mangiamo’s is definitely your spot. From their mouthwatering ingredients to their attentive service, it’s no wonder why this pizza joint has been delighting customers since day one!

#9 Mellow Mushroom Hilton Head Island

The atmosphere of the restaurant is incredibly chill and relaxed. The interior is artfully decorated with bright colors and psychedelic prints, which made me feel like I was transported to the ’60s.

The menu has a variety of options that are sure to satisfy any pizza craving. I decided to try the Mighty Meaty Pizza, which was topped with pepperoni, sausage, beef, ham, applewood smoked bacon, and mozzarella. It was mouth-wateringly delicious! The crust was perfectly crispy while the toppings were juicy and flavorful.

When it comes down to it, Mellow Mushroom Hilton Head Island really delivers on tasty pizza! It is one of the best pizzerias I have encountered in my travels so far – hands down!

#10 Giuseppi’s Pizza

I was impressed from the moment I stepped through their doors. Not only was the atmosphere inviting and warm, but the staff was so friendly! I knew from the start that my experience at Giuseppi’s Pizza would be a delightful one.

The pizza itself was nothing less than outstanding. The dough was thin and crispy, with just the perfect amount of toppings that gave it a fresh flavor. The cheese melted in my mouth – it was so creamy and delicious! I can honestly say that this is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!

Their selection of sauces is top-notch, too – from traditional marinara to a variety of exotic flavors like chili oil and mango chutney, there’s something for every taste bud. They also offer other options like salads and calzones if you’re looking for something different.

If you’re ever in Hilton Head and looking for some fantastically crafted pizza – Giuseppi’s Pizza is your place! It has quickly become one of my favorite spots for great Italian cuisine. 5 stars all around!

#11 Bella Italia Pizza

I arrived at Bella Italia Pizza with high expectations and I was not let down. The charming, traditional atmosphere set the tone for a memorable experience. From the moment I entered the restaurant, I could smell the delicious aroma of fresh Italian cuisine wafting through the air.

The quality of their ingredients really sets them apart from other pizzerias in the area – it’s very clear that they are incredibly meticulous about what they serve to their customers. On top of that, they also offer some truly unique topping combinations on their pies, catering to all types of pizza-lovers out there.

I had a chance to try several different kinds of pizzas, including one of their signature pies – the Prosciutto Fretta pie – which was absolutely delicious! The crust was medium-thin and perfectly cooked, while the toppings were flavorful and perfectly balanced. It’s no wonder why this pizza won Bella Italia Pizza “best pizza in Hilton Head” award last year!

Overall, my experience at Bella Italia Pizza was remarkable and completely exceeded my expectations. They serve up some truly exceptional pizzas that are sure to make all pizza lovers happy! Highly recommend that you visit if you’re in the area looking for some great grub!

#12 Super Baked Pizza and Wings

The first thing I noticed when I stepped into the restaurant was how clean and welcoming it was. The staff was very friendly, and the décor created a great atmosphere for dining.

As for the food, the menu was surprisingly varied and creative. The pizzas are definitely some of the best I’ve ever had—especially their signature Super Baked pizza! It’s made with all sorts of wonderful ingredients like pepperoni, sausage, onions, peppers, mushrooms, and more.

But that’s not all they have to offer! They also have an incredible selection of wings that are always crispy and delicious. With flavors like garlic Parmesan and Honey BBQ, you won’t be disappointed.

For dessert, I highly suggest trying their s’more calzone—it’s something you won’t want to miss! All in all, Super Baked Pizza and Wings is definitely one of the best places to get pizza in Hilton Head!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Local Pie Woodfired Pizza

Let’s start with the benefits. First of all, this place serves alcohol, and not just any alcohol, they have hard liquor! So, you can wash down that delicious pizza with your favorite drink, and maybe even get a little tipsy while you’re at it. It’s a win-win situation!

For my vegetarian friends out there, fear not! Local Pie Woodfired Pizza has some tasty vegetarian options. You can enjoy your pizza guilt-free, knowing that no animals were harmed in the making of your delicious dinner.

Now, let’s talk about dessert. Oh boy, the desserts here are insanely good! I had the pleasure of trying their Nutella pizza, and let me tell you, it was like a slice of heaven in my mouth. I licked the plate clean, much to the embarrassment of my dining companions, but it was totally worth it.

Another great thing about this place is that it’s a nice tourist spot. So, if you’re looking to impress your out-of-town friends or have a little taste of the local flavor, Local Pie Woodfired Pizza is the place to go. Plus, they have TVs, so you can catch the latest game while enjoying your pizza and drinks. It’s like killing two birds with one stone!

Now, onto the downsides. The only downside I can think of is that they don’t accept reservations. So, you might have to wait a bit to get a table. But, trust me, it’s worth the wait. Just grab a drink, enjoy the atmosphere, and before you know it, you’ll be sinking your teeth into the most delectable thin crust pizza in hilton head.