Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Gulf Shores AL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Alabama

Best Pizza in Gulf Shores AL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

217 Views

I’ve visited 12 different pizza places in the area and am excited to share with you my top picks. If you’re looking for a good slice of cheesy goodness, then look no further.

From the traditional crusts and sauces to unique toppings like artichoke hearts and kale, I’ve experienced it all! It’s been a fun adventure trying out all these pizzas that Gulf Shores has to offer.

So if you’re ready for a fun, lighthearted exploration of the best pizza in Gulf Shores AL, let’s get started!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Alabama

#1 Crico’s Pizza & Subs

Upon entering the restaurant, I was instantly pleasingly surprised. The decor is warm and inviting and the staff were very friendly. I quickly realized why this place is so popular among the locals. After ordering my pizza, it arrived promptly – hot and bubbly.

The sauce at Crico’s Pizza & Subs was perfectly spiced, with just the right amount of sweetness to balance it all out. Topped with fresh mozzarella cheese and a nice sprinkle of herbs, this pizza was simply divine!

The crust was also surprisingly light and crunchy – an absolute delight for someone who has tried pizzas from so many different places around the world. It had great flavor without being overly greasy or heavy. An absolute must-have in my book!

Overall, I would highly recommend Crico’s Pizza & Subs to anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Gulf Shores AL. The staff are friendly and accommodating, while still ensuring that they make your pizza exactly to order. From their sauces to their crusts, you can be sure that your taste buds will thank you after indulging here!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Orange Beach!

#2 Surfside Pizza & Ice Cream

My first bite into a freshly prepared slice of Surfside’s signature crust gave me the same kind of feeling I get when I’m welcomed back home. The combination of their blend of spices and cheeses created an unforgettably delicious, yet unmistakably unique flavor.

Along with their amazing pizza, the atmosphere at Surfside is just as amazing. With its beach-side location, spectacular views, and outdoor seating area, it feels like you’re eating at your own private beach party. Plus, they always have delicious ice cream for dessert after such a great meal!

Overall, if you’re ever in Gulf Shores AL I would highly recommend checking out Surfside Pizza & Ice Cream for some of the best pizza around!

#3 The Brick Oven

The restaurant itself is small and unassuming, but the pizza here is nothing short of amazing. The crusts are thin yet perfectly crispy and crunchy, with just the right balance of toppings. The cheese is top-notch – perfectly melted and gooey. Every bite melts in your mouth and leaves you wanting more.

The atmosphere inside the restaurant is cozy and inviting; it almost feels like home! This makes it the perfect spot to grab a slice after a long day at work or when you need a break from your studies.

If you’re looking for an authentic Italian pizza experience, look no further than The Brick Oven! They have some of the best pizza in Gulf Shores AL, and I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a great slice!

#4 Mellow Mushroom Foley

The atmosphere at Mellow Mushroom Foley is perfect for a sophisticated food critic like me. From the modern interior to the friendly staff, it was an enjoyable experience.

The menu is full of delicious options and they have some unique specialty pizzas that you won’t find anywhere else. I tried the Funky Q Chicken pizza and it was delicious! They put just enough spice on it to make it flavorful without being overpowering.

The service was excellent as well. The waitstaff were friendly and attentive and made sure my drink stayed full throughout the meal. It’s nice to go somewhere where they take time to get to know their customers!

In conclusion, I highly recommend visiting Mellow Mushroom Foley if you’re looking for the best pizza in Gulf Shores AL. With a great atmosphere, delicious pies, and friendly service, it’s sure to become your favorite spot for pizza night!

#5 Tuscany Pizza and Grill

The service was friendly, and I appreciated their no-fuss attitude. They don’t take themselves too seriously, which is great when all you want to do is eat some good pizza.

The atmosphere was laid-back and inviting as well – it’s easy to imagine yourself settling in for a nice night with friends over some delicious pie.

As for the pizza itself? WOW! The thin crust was perfectly cooked, it had just the right amount of crunch and flavor – definitely not a soggy mess like I’ve found at other places. The toppings were fresh, plentiful, and full of flavor; from the classic pepperoni to the more unusual toppings like sautéed pineapple. Even better, they offer a host of vegetarian options so everyone can enjoy great pizza here!

All in all, Tuscany Pizza and Grill will undoubtedly have a piece of my heart for serving up some of the best pizza in Gulf Shores AL!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Foley!

#6 Vinny’s Pizzeria

I had the pleasure of visiting Vinny’s Pizzeria on my vacation to Alabama, and I’m so glad I did. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by a friendly staff who made me feel right at home.

The atmosphere of Vinny’s Pizzeria is warm and inviting and the decor is inviting – definitely makes you feel like you’ve stepped into an Italian family kitchen.

The menu has something for everyone – from veggie lovers to carnivores. They take great pride in their ingredients, sourcing everything locally and making sure it’s all fresh and delicious. But what really stands out at Vinny’s Pizzeria are their signature pizzas – they have perfected all of them!

The Sicilian is one of my favorites – it has just the right balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings (my favorite combination being pepperoni & jalapeños). It comes served on a crispy, flavorful crust that will make your mouth water just thinking about it!

And then there’s the Margherita pizza which is amazing with its sweet tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, basil leaves, and extra virgin olive oil.

Finally, don’t forget to try their Neapolitan pizza which has a thin crust and an array of delicious toppings that make each bite heavenly.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Gulf Shores AL then look no further than Vinny’s Pizzeria. Their unique specialty pizzas are a must-try – they’ll be sure to tantalize your taste buds!

#7 Papa Rocco’s

The atmosphere is great: it’s a nice tourist spot, the perfect place to watch sports, and it serves alcohol – even hard liquor! It also has a kid’s menu, so adults and children alike can enjoy their meal.

That said…it doesn’t deliver, which is slightly disappointing. But hey, if you don’t mind taking a short trip to get some of the best pizza in Gulf Shores AL, then there’s no need for delivery anyway!

All in all, Papa Rocco’s is an amazing restaurant with something for everyone. Whether you’re looking for a fun night out with friends or just want some good pizza while watching the game; this place really delivers. I highly recommend visiting on your next trip to Gulf Shores AL!

#8 Marco’s Pizza

Upon entering the restaurant, I was immediately greeted with a friendly smile and helpful staff. The atmosphere of the restaurant is incredibly inviting, with colorful art on the walls and family-style dining tables.

The pizza that I had at Marco’s Pizza was truly something special. It had a perfect thin crust that was crispy on the edges and still slightly chewy in the middle. The toppings were all fresh and flavorful, with plenty of generous amounts of cheese, vegetables, and meats. Every bite was delicious!

Overall, I am extremely pleased with my experience at Marco’s Pizza. They have some of the best pizza in Gulf Shores AL and it is definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in town. Highly recommended!

#9 Rotolo’s Pizzeria

Although the atmosphere isn’t quite as charming as the Italian pizzerias I’m used to, Rotolo’s more than makes up for it with its delicious pizzas. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, and the sauce has just enough sweetness to perfectly balance out the savory toppings. The ingredients are fresh and flavorful, and you can really taste the difference.

The service at Rotolo’s is friendly and helpful; everyone who works there seems truly passionate about their craft. They always take the time to talk to you about what kind of pizza you’d like and how they make it so delicious.

My favorite menu items are definitely their specialty creations such as their “Gulf Shores” pizza with shrimp and crab meat or their “Margherita” with roasted red peppers. Both of these pizzas pack a lot of flavor into one slice!

I would definitely recommend Rotolo’s Pizzeria for anyone looking for the best pizza in Gulf Shores AL! Try it for yourself – I promise you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 32 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Pensacola!

#10 Pizza Hut Express

I have to admit, it wasn’t exactly what I was expecting. Afterwards, I thought to myself, ‘Why didn’t I expect this?’ The pizza was absolutely delicious! The crust was just the right thickness and had a wonderful flavor. The toppings were fresh and tasty. And the sauce… wow, just wow. It added such great flavor that made me want more!

If you’re looking for a great tourist spot in Gulf Shores AL, Pizza Hut Express is definitely one to visit. Not only do they offer some of the best pizza in the area, but they also offer delicious desserts as well.

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery services at this location – which can be quite inconvenient if you are wanting pizza delivered directly to your door! However, the great taste of their pizza makes it worth the trip.

So if you’re ever in Gulf Shores AL, I highly recommend heading over to Pizza Hut Express for some of the best pizza in town!

#11 Pines Pizzeria

The staff at Pines Pizzeria were friendly and attentive, making sure my pizza experience was top-notch. The décor was surprisingly inviting too! It felt like a real Italian pizzeria!

The pizza itself was simply to die for. The crust was cooked to perfection with the perfect amount of chewiness and flavor. I tried their signature pies such as the Wild Mushroom and Tomato Basil, both of which were simply divine! Not to mention their wide selection of toppings from roasted garlic to fresh, succulent tomatoes.

I’m not one for dessert, but I decided to indulge in one of their homemade cannolis—it definitely did not disappoint. The pastry was light and flaky and the sweet ricotta cheese filling paired perfectly with the tart cherries on top.

Overall, Pines Pizzeria has earned its place as having some of the best pizza in Gulf Shores AL! If you’re looking for an authentic Italian dining experience or just a great slice of pizza—check them out!

#12 Janino’s Pizza

The pizza at Janino’s is delicious, with just the right amount of cheese and toppings to give you that home-cooked taste. The dough is always cooked to perfection, with a crispness on the outside and a softness on the inside. Not too crunchy, not too soggy – it’s just right. Plus, they put their own spin on some of the classic toppings like pepperoni or mushrooms so you won’t get bored with the same old flavors.

The service here is also great. The waitstaff are friendly and attentive, and always make sure your order is correct. They go out of their way to make sure everyone in your party has an enjoyable experience.

If you’re ever in Gulf Shores AL looking for some of the best pizza around, check out Janino’s Pizza! It’ll be one of the most delicious meals you’ve ever had!