Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Mckinney TX (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Texas

Best Pizza in Mckinney TX (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

158 Views

After having visited countless places all around the world in search of decent pizza, I’ve finally made my way to the suburbs of Texas. To save us all some time, I decided to put together a list of the 12 best pizza places in town – all tried and tested by yours truly!

Some of these were little gems that surprised me with their flavor, while others have been around long enough to become local favorites. All of them come highly recommended – so get your slice ready for a real treat and let’s take a look at the best pizza Mckinney TX has to offer.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Texas

#1 Zio Al’s pizza & pasta McKinney

The atmosphere in the restaurant was really fun and inviting. The staff were very friendly, and my pizza arrived quickly. I was instantly impressed by the aroma of the fresh ingredients when it arrived at my table.

Upon digging into my first slice, I could tell that this pizza was something special. The crust had a perfect consistency – not too tough or too soft – and the toppings were cooked to perfection. Each bite seemed more delicious than the last!

My mouth is watering just thinking about it. I think Zio Al’s has cracked the code on creating the most amazing pizza pie! If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Mckinney TX, this is definitely a must-try place. Trust me, you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Allen!

#2 Barro’s Pizza

I was immediately impressed with the atmosphere and décor of the restaurant. The walls were lined with Italian murals, while the tables were adorned with red-checkered table cloths and candlelight. The overall setting was one of great warmth and hospitality—perfect for a pizza parlor.

The menu was also quite impressive, featuring a wide variety of toppings and crusts to choose from. It’s no wonder that people come to Barro’s Pizza from all over town! I decided to go with their signature pepperoni pizza, which did not disappoint! The savory pepperonis had just the right amount of zesty spices, making it utterly irresistible.

The other items on the menu looked equally delicious, though I wanted to focus solely on their classic pies for this review. I ordered two pies, one for dine in and another to take home. Both were truly wonderful—the crust was thin yet delightfully crispy, while the sauce offered bursts of flavor in every bite.

From its welcoming atmosphere to its amazing pizzas, Barro’s Pizza has earned its spot as one of the best pizzerias in Mckinney TX! If you’re ever in town and looking for a delicious slice or two (or three!), you can’t go wrong with this place!

#3 Rosati’s Pizza

I was very impressed with the range of options at Rosati’s — from the classic pepperoni to the more creative combinations like BBQ chicken and bacon. No matter what kind of pizza you’re craving, they have something to satisfy all palates.

The ingredients used were top-notch: crispy crust, succulent tomatoes, freshly-grated cheese, and savory meats. All these flavors blended together perfectly to create delectable slices that made my mouth water. Even better, the prices were really reasonable considering the quality of ingredients and skillful preparation.

Additionally, the atmosphere in Rosati’s was great — it had a relaxed vibe that put me at ease immediately. The staff were friendly and helpful, and I could tell they genuinely enjoyed working there.

Overall, this has been one of the best pizza experiences I’ve ever had! If you’re ever in Mckinney TX looking for great pizza, Rosati’s is definitely worth a visit.

#4 Cadillac Pizza Pub

When I arrived, the first thing I noticed was the great atmosphere. It’s located in a nice tourist spot, making it perfect for visitors from out of town. It’s also a great place to watch sports or hang out with friends.

I was excited to find out they serve alcohol, and not just beer, but even hard liquor! That definitely made me smile. They also had a kid’s menu, which is helpful if you’re bringing your family along. There were vegetarian options as well, so everyone can enjoy the food here.

As soon as I ordered my pizza, I knew it was going to be amazing; it smelled like heaven! And after one bite, I knew why – it was the best pizza I’ve ever tasted! Sure there isn’t a delivery option available (which would have been nice), but that didn’t stop me from eating every last bit of my pizza. And when I was done dining in, their desserts sealed the deal – heavenly sweetness combined with savory dough…yes please!

If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience then Cadillac Pizza Pub is your spot! The atmosphere is inviting and full of life; the drinks are pouring non-stop; and their pizzas are simply divine. Get ready for your taste buds to be tickled in all the right ways.

#5 Shelby’s Pizza

The restaurant itself is quite cozy, but don’t let that fool you — the pizza is anything but. With a variety of options ,from classic pepperoni and cheese to more creative pies topped with sausage and veggies, Shelby’s Pizza has something for everyone!

The pizza dough was perfectly thin and crispy—just the way I like it! The sauce was flavorful and had the perfect balance of sweetness and acidity. The cheese was also very well-melted with plenty of flavor in every bite.

Overall, I have to say Shelby’s Pizza took my breath away. If you are looking for some truly unforgettable pizza in Mckinney TX, I highly recommend giving them a try! You won’t be disappointed.

#6 MOD Pizza

The atmosphere is relaxed, with a modern approach. The staff is friendly and helpful and the menu is large enough that you won’t be overwhelmed when trying to decide which pizza to order.

The best part, however, is their signature MOD Pizza. It’s truly like no other pizza I’ve ever tasted before! The dough is freshly made each day, the ingredients are top-notch quality, and the flavors blend together perfectly. Plus, you get as much or as little as you want for one low price! It’s incredible!

I must say that a visit to MOD Pizza was one of the highlights of my trip! If you’re in Mckinney TX, you must try this place out to see what all the hype is about. I guarantee you won’t be disappointed!

#7 Durkin’s Pizza

When I walked in, the delightful smell of dough and tomato sauce was unmistakable – a sign that I was in for a treat. I was seated immediately, as the friendly staff seemed to recognize me as a food critic. They brought out a piping hot pie topped with fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, and fragrant basil leaves; it was drool-worthy!

The pizza crust was crisp and chewy in all the right places, while the tomato sauce had an incredible depth of flavor. The cheese melted perfectly and each bite was loaded with savory flavor. The pepperoni provided an enjoyable kick and the fresh basil gave it that perfect finish.

Overall, Durkin’s Pizza is by far one of the best pizzerias I’ve come across. Their attention to detail in each element means that everyone can enjoy an exceptionally crafted pizza every time! If you’re ever looking for some of the best pizza in Mckinney TX, visit Durkin’s Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

#8 Cavalli Pizza Napoletana

The atmosphere is cozy yet modern, the service was friendly and prompt, and the food was absolutely delicious. From the classic Margherita pizza to the more exotic Prosciutto e Arugula topped with honey – this place is a must-try for anyone looking for a good slice.

The Margherita pizza had an amazingly thin crust that was topped with a generous helping of mozzarella cheese and fresh basil. The Prosciutto e Arugula also had a light and crispy crust but this time it was covered with prosciutto slices, arugula, and plenty of honey which gave it an interesting kick at the end.

I’d have to give Cavalli Pizza Napoletana 5 stars out of 5! It’s definitely some of the best pizza in Mckinney TX!

If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Plano!

#9 Sicily’s Pizza & Pasta

It’s honestly amazing! The pizza has the perfect texture and flavor. The crust is crispy yet chewy and the ingredients are top notch. The sauce is flavorful and you can taste the freshness of all the ingredients they use.

The atmosphere of Sicily’s Pizza & Pasta is also great. It feels cozy, inviting, and it’s a great place to bring your friends or family for a meal. They have a nice selection of beers on tap and the service is friendly.

Overall, I would definitely recommend Sicily’s Pizza & Pasta if you’re in Mckinney TX and looking for some of the best pizza around!

#10 Jim’s Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant is cozy and inviting. The staff is warm and friendly, and I felt right at home.

But most importantly, the pizza was simply delightful! It was hot, cheesy, and had a nice crispy crust. They use fresh ingredients that really make it stand out from other pizzerias in the area.

I tried several different slices from their menu, including a classic Margherita and a delicious Mediterranean speciality with olives and feta cheese. Each one was better than the last!

To top it all off, Jim’s Pizza also offers a great selection of craft beers to enjoy with your meal.

In conclusion, I can say without a doubt that Jim’s Pizza serves up some of the best pizza in Mckinney TX! Highly recommended!

#11 Palio’s Pizza Cafe

The moment I stepped into Palio’s Pizza Cafe, it felt like I was a part of the family. Everyone was welcoming, and I could tell that the staff truly cares about their customers. The atmosphere was inviting, and the decor was tasteful and fun.

The pizza at Palio’s Pizza Cafe is truly a one-of-a-kind experience. Their crust is light yet flavorful, and the toppings are fresh and delicious. I have never tasted a pizza quite like theirs! They have unique varieties like buffalo chicken and fire roasted veggie, making them perfect for even the pickiest eater. On top of that, they offer gluten free options as well!

Overall, my experience with Palio’s Pizza Cafe was outstanding. Not only was the food phenomenal, but service was also top notch. My waiter went above and beyond to make sure our meal went smoothly, creating an unforgettable dining experience.

If you’re in Mckinney looking for some mind-blowing pizza – head over to Palio’s Pizza Cafe! You won’t be disappointed!

#12 MOD Pizza

When I first walked in, I knew this place was special. The staff were incredibly friendly and helpful, and they really made me feel welcomed. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, so you can enjoy your meal in peace.

As for the pizza itself – delicious! The crust is crispy yet chewy and the sauce is perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness. On top of that, there’s an endless variety of toppings to choose from (including vegan options!), so you can customize your pizza however you like it.

The only thing that could make this place better would be if they had delivery – but then again, this is a restaurant that prides itself on quality so it makes sense why they don’t offer it!

All in all, MOD Pizza has made me a real believer in Mckinney’s pizza culture – hands down some of the best pizza I’ve ever had! Highly recommended for pizza lovers everywhere.

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Rosati’s Pizza

But before I dive into the deliciousness of their pies, I have to mention that Rosati’s is a gem for another reason—they serve alcohol! As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I’ve always believed that a good slice of pizza deserves a good glass of wine or craft beer to accompany it. Rosati’s understands this and caters to my boozy desires, making it an even more enjoyable experience.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show—the pizza. Oh my, where do I even begin? The deep dish pizza at Rosati’s is like a glorious tower of cheese and sauce, hiding beneath a thick, buttery crust. Each bite is a delightful explosion of flavors that transports me to a cheesy paradise. I have to say, their rendition of deep dish pizza is nothing short of magnificent.

But, as every pizza lover knows, no meal is complete without dessert. And Rosati’s doesn’t disappoint in this department either. Their dessert offerings are the perfect sweet ending to an already fantastic dining experience. From their decadent chocolate lava cake to their creamy tiramisu, each dessert is a masterpiece that’ll leave you craving more.

Now, I must warn you about one downside of Rosati’s—they don’t accept reservations. So, be prepared to either arrive early or embrace your inner patient foodie while waiting for a table. But let me tell you, the wait is absolutely worth it.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best deep dish pizza in mckinney tx, Rosati’s Pizza is the place to go. With their heavenly pizzas, intoxicating beverages, and mouthwatering desserts, you’ll leave with a full belly and a heart filled with cheesy joy.