Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Orange Beach AL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Alabama

Best Pizza in Orange Beach AL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

685 Views

I’m no stranger to delicious pizza — having tried it in nearly every corner of the world, I’d like to think of myself as a bit of an expert on the matter.

So when I heard about Orange Beach’s flourishing pizza scene, I had to check it out for myself. To be thorough, I made sure to visit and sample the fare of 12 different pizzerias in the area.

Now, after some extensive research (and an all-you-can-eat buffet or two), I’m prepared to share with you my findings on who makes the best pizza in Orange Beach AL. Get ready for a mouthwatering journey!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Alabama

#1 Pizza At The Pass

The pizza dough here is so airy and light that I could barely manage to pick it up without it falling apart in my hands. There’s an incredible selection of toppings, from classic staples like pepperoni and sausage to wilder options like shrimp and pineapple. Every single pizza I’ve tasted has been cooked to perfection, with a crisp crust and a combination of flavors that creates an intended symphony for the tastebuds.

The service here is also top notch – the staff always checks on me during the meal, ensuring I’m having a great experience. The atmosphere of the restaurant has this wonderful beach-inspired vibe, with plenty of natural light streaming in from the outdoor seating area.

Overall, Pizza At The Pass is a fantastic place for pizza lovers! With its unique flavor combinations and friendly staff, it truly deserves to be called the best pizza in Orange Beach AL!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 17 more pizza places in Gulf Shores!

#2 Crico’s Pizza & Subs

The moment I stepped foot in this charming little pizza shop, I could tell that I had stumbled upon something special. The aroma of the freshly-baked pizzas and sizzling subs filled the air with deliciousness.

I was promptly greeted by a friendly cashier who offered me a complimentary slice (which was pure bliss, by the way! ). After further exploration, I noticed several options on their menu such as calzones, gourmet subs, and even veggie pizzas.

When it came time to order up my own pizza creation, I went all out! From the meat lovers to the garlic mashed potato—the choices were endless! Each pie was cooked to perfection in their brick oven and each topping added a unique flavor to every bite. Even after trying them all, I can honestly say that Crico’s Pizza & Subs has got some of the best pies in Orange Beach AL!

If you ever find yourself craving for pizza in this neck of the woods be sure to check out Crico’s Pizza & Subs; you won’t regret it!

#3 Vinny’s Pizzeria

The cheesy slices are delicious, the crust is just right, and the toppings are second to none. I always order the Grandma Pie and it’s never a disappointment. The ingredients are fresh and well-balanced, creating a delicious masterpiece.

The atmosphere of this place is also amazing. The inside of Vinny’s Pizzeria looks like your favorite Italian eatery from the movies; quaint and welcoming with plenty of seating to accommodate large groups. The staff is friendly and helpful, ensuring that you get exactly what you want each time you visit.

It’s hard to find better pizza than this in Orange Beach AL, but I can confidently say that Vinny’s Pizzeria has some of the best pizza around. If you’re looking for an awesome pizza experience in Orange Beach AL, then Vinny’s Pizzeria is a must-visit!

#4 Surfside PIzza Orange Beach

The pizza itself was incredible. The crust was thin yet robust, the sauce was flavorful and seasoned perfectly, and the cheese was melted to perfection. It felt like I was eating a pizza that belonged in an Italian restaurant.

What really made it special, however, were the ingredients. They had an array of fresh vegetables, meats, and cheeses to choose from that gave each slice so much flavor. This wasn’t just any old pizza; it had layers upon layers of deliciousness!

The atmosphere at Surfside Pizza Orange Beach is also worth mentioning. The restaurant is small but cozy and welcoming. The staff was friendly and helpful when it came time to order. Everything felt warm and inviting, making it easy to relax after a long day of exploring Orange Beach AL.

All in all, I’d give Surfside Pizza Orange Beach an A+ for its authentic Italian-style pizza that’s sure to please even the most discerning palates! If you’re ever in the area looking for some quality pizza, this is definitely the spot!

#5 Tuscany Pizza and Grill

For starters, the atmosphere of the restaurant was incredibly inviting – it felt just like one of those rustic Italian restaurants you’d find in a Tuscany countryside village. The staff were very friendly and accommodating.

The pizza at Tuscany Pizza and Grill is made to perfection. Every bite had something new and exciting to offer. The thin crust was cooked to perfection and had just the right amount of crispness. Toppings are generous and flavorful – especially their signature topping combination, which includes roasted red peppers, pesto, feta cheese and Kalamata olives – yum!

And of course their homemade dough is delicious too. They have several unique flavors ranging from traditional cheese and tomato to something more exotic like barbeque chicken or even white clam pizza.

To top it all off (literally!), they offer an extensive selection of specialty pizzas that can be customized with your favorite toppings for a delicious meal.

If you’re ever in Orange Beach AL looking for some truly outstanding pizza, definitely make sure to check out Tuscany Pizza and Grill – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Foley!

#6 Rotolo’s Pizzeria

The owner, Jeff Rotolo, has created a true masterpiece here. The crust is perfectly thin and crisp with just the right amount of char. And the flavors! They really hit the spot – pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers; all topped off with a savory blend of cheese.

To make things even better, they have a great selection of craft beers to pair with your pie. My favorite was the IPA – a perfect complement to that heavenly sauce!

On top of all that, their customer service is second-to-none. From start to finish, my experience was extremely pleasant and efficient – they made sure all my questions were answered and I felt right at home!

All in all, Rotolo’s Pizzeria has earned its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Orange Beach AL. If you’re ever in town and looking for an out-of-this-world pizza experience – Rotolo’s is definitely the place for you!

#7 Island Time Daiquiris & Pizza at The Wharf

The restaurant offers a great variety of pizza, from classic margheritas to unique combinations like the Hawaiian Luau – which includes bacon, pineapple, and jalapeno! On top of that, they also offer something you won’t find in every pizza joint – hard liquor! From whiskey-forward concoctions to dark rum daiquiris, it has everything needed for an unforgettable night.

If you’re looking for a great spot to watch your favorite sports teams play, Island Time Daiquiris & Pizza is the place to be! With its gigantic flat-screen TVs and outdoor seating area, it’s the perfect place to grab some pizza and watch the game. It’s also situated in a prime tourist spot at The Wharf – so if you’re visiting Orange Beach AL, definitely swing by this place.

Unfortunately there’s no delivery service – but if you can get yourself there, you’ll be rewarded with some of the best pizza in Orange Beach AL!

#8 Papa Rocco’s

The atmosphere is perfect for a night out with friends or family – they have a full bar and serve hard liquor, plus a great kid’s menu. And you can’t beat the view – it’s a great tourist spot, with lots of people-watching potential. You can also catch the game while enjoying your pizza, whether it’s college football or basketball, or any other sport.

The pizzas themselves are simply delicious – an array of creative toppings piled onto perfectly cooked crust and finished off with tomato sauce that just won’t quit! It’s clear that this pizza joint takes their craft seriously.

Unfortunately, they don’t do delivery, so you’ll need to brave the Orange Beach streets to get your pizza if you don’t feel like dining in. But trust me when I say it’s worth it – Papa Rocco’s has some of the best pizza around!

#9 Marco’s Pizza

The moment I stepped into Marco’s Pizza, I was immediately smitten. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and the pizza counter offered an array of delicious pies, from classic margherita to creative combos.

When it came time to order, I decided to go with the house special—it didn’t disappoint! The perfect combination of pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, olives, and cheese were all cooked to perfection in a thin yet hearty crust. It was exactly how I like my pizza—well done yet still flavorful.

I also tried some of their other offerings like calzones, wings, and garlic bread. Everything tasted amazing! I especially enjoyed their special garlic sauce which wasn’t too overwhelming but had just enough zip to make it interesting.

Of course the service was equally impressive. Everyone who worked there was friendly and helpful; they always made sure I left feeling satisfied (which is not always easy to do).

All-in-all Marco’s Pizza is definitely one of the best pizzerias in Orange Beach AL! If you’re ever looking for great pizza in a pleasant atmosphere—this is your spot!

If you’re willing to go an extra 24 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Pensacola!

#10 Perdido Beach Pizza Company

At first glance, the place looks like a typical tourist spot – not much to write home about. But as soon as I took my first bite of their pizza, I knew I had stumbled upon a little slice of heaven. This was some of the best pizza I have ever tasted!

But it’s not just about the pizza. Perdido Beach Pizza Company really has something for everyone, with a kids’ menu and even dessert options to keep things interesting. The atmosphere is great too – relaxed enough that you can take your time savoring every bite without feeling rushed.

My only complaint? They don’t offer delivery service. That’s okay though – it’s worth the trip to Perdido Beach just to get a taste of their world-class pizza!

#11 Pizza Hut

The first thing that struck me when I walked in the door was the aroma. The smell of melting cheese and spices wafting through the air was irresistible. I knew right away that this place was going to be special.

The next thing I noticed was how friendly the staff were. From walking in the door to leaving with a takeout box of my favorite slices, they were always smiling and eager to help. They made sure my pizza was exactly what I wanted and hot out of the oven!

Then came the food! Oh, my goodness! The pizza crust was thin and crispy, just how I like it. Plus, it’s loaded with fresh toppings like pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, olives, and more. It’s so delicious – no wonder why it’s one of the best pizzas here in Orange Beach AL! One bite and I could tell it was made with love (and lots of cheese!).

Overall my visit to Pizza Hut left me wanting more – which is to say its one of the best spots for pizza around these parts. If you’re ever looking for great pizza in Orange Beach AL, then look no further than Pizza Hut – you won’t regret it!

#12 Sbarro

The first time I stepped into the Sbarro in Orange Beach, I knew immediately that this was going to be a pizza paradise. The smell of the freshly baked dough and cheeses filled the air like an Italian pizzeria. The restaurant itself is welcoming and inviting; it has a nice atmosphere, and you can tell that their staff takes pride in providing excellent service.

The menu is full of mouth-watering options from classic slices to stuffed crusts, with all the toppings and sauces to choose from! You can’t go wrong picking something off their menu.

When it came time to eat, I was blown away by how delicious the pizza was! The crust was perfectly crunchy yet light, not too thick or thin; every bite was loaded with flavor from fresh vegetables, meats, cheeses and seasonings. Each slice had just the right amount of cheese and sauce that perfectly complemented each other.

To top it all off, Sbarro has some great deals on drinks and sides. I got a special combo deal where I got two whole pizzas for one price – what a steal! Plus they also have generous portions at prices that won’t break your wallet.

To sum it up – Sbarro truly has some of the best pizza in Orange Beach AL! The pizza is outstanding and their prices are great; you can get an awesome meal without spending too much money. If you’re ever craving delicious pizza in Orange Beach AL – head over to Sbarro – you won’t be disappointed!