Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Newburgh NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Newburgh NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

120 Views

I’ve tasted pizza from 12 different places, and today I’m here to give you the lowdown on which ones made it into my list of the best.

And before you ask, yes, I’ve been all over the world tasting pizza – from Italy to Chicago and everywhere in between!

But there’s something special about Newburgh’s little slice of perfection that has kept me coming back.

So without further ado, let’s dive into the top 12 best pizzas in Newburgh NY.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Millz Wad Up Dough!

The decor of the place instantly put me in the mood for a grand feast. The bright red and neon green walls, combined with the classic brick ovens give it a real hip pizzeria feel. Plus, the music was a great touch – just loud enough to make you feel comfortable, but not too loud that it was intrusive.

I have to say, the pizza was absolutely delicious! The dough was perfectly cooked and had just the right amount of chewiness and flavor. The sauce was unbelievably savory and balanced out with some amazing herbs. Topped off with perfectly melted cheese, this pizza hit all the right notes.

Overall, I can confidently recommend Millz Wad Up Dough! as one of the very best pizza places in Newburgh NY. In my travels around the world, I’ve tasted many different types of pizzas and this ranks among my favorites. Go check it out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 11 more pizza places in Beacon!

#2 OCTY’S: Pizza, Tacos, Sandwiches.

The atmosphere of the restaurant is a fun and relaxed one. The staff are very friendly and helpful, which really adds to the experience.

These guys know how to make pizza – there’s no denying it. The combination of fresh ingredients, perfect cooking temperature, and precise baking times creates a crust that is both crispy on the outside yet still soft in the middle. The toppings are excellent too – from traditional pepperoni to mouth-watering combinations like pineapple and ham – each bite is an absolute delight!

But what really sets OCTY’S apart from other local pizza restaurants is their selection of tacos and sandwiches. From savory steak fajitas to classic BLT’s, these guys have something for everyone!

To top it all off, they never cut corners on quality or taste so you always get great value for your money.

In summary, OCTY’S: Pizza, Tacos, Sandwiches delivers some of the best pizza in Newburgh NY and should be your go-to spot for pizza night with friends and family!

#3 Stella’s Pizzeria

The crust was thin and perfectly baked, with just the right amount of chewiness. It was baked for just long enough to develop that nice crunchy texture. The sauce was also spot-on – flavorful, robust, and slightly sweet. Adding to this delicious combination of sauce and crust were generous amounts of cheese and premium toppings.

The service was outstanding! The staff at Stella’s were really friendly and attentive. They made sure I had everything I needed while dining in their restaurant.

In conclusion, Stella’s Pizzeria has some of the best pizza in Newburgh NY! The great tasting pizza combined with excellent customer service makes it a must try!

#4 Hudson Taco

The first thing I noticed was that the staff is incredibly friendly and accommodating. When I showed up, the pizzamaker greeted me with a smile and was genuinely interested in my pizza adventure. And then there’s the pizza itself – it truly is unique and delicious!

The crust is light and flavorful, made with a special blend of herbs and spices. The toppings are always fresh, never over or undercooked, giving every bite just the right amount of crunch. Plus, they have some really creative topping combinations – like their spicy BBQ chicken pizza!

It doesn’t stop there though – Hudson Taco also serves up some fantastic sides. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh-cut fries or crispy wings, they’ve got something to satisfy your cravings.

All in all, if you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience, Hudson Taco has certainly earned its reputation as having the best pizza in Newburgh NY!

#5 Cosimo’s

I’ve tried a variety of pizzas from all around the world, but I must say that nothing comes close to Cosimo’s signature Neapolitan-style pie. The crust was perfectly crisp and cooked in their wood-fired oven, and their sauce was full of flavor. Plus, the toppings were fresh and provide unique combinations that will take your taste buds for a ride!

The atmosphere at Cosimo’s is relaxed and cozy, so it’s a great spot for catching up with friends over pizza. The staff are all very friendly and helpful, which added to the overall experience.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Newburgh NY, look no further than Cosimo’s – you won’t be disappointed!

#6 Riverside Deli & Pizza

From the moment I stepped into the joint, I knew this place was something special. The décor is classic and inviting, with checkered tablecloths and vintage posters adorning the walls.

As for the pizza, I must say that it was beyond delicious. The crust is perfectly baked and has a light, slightly-crispy texture that melts in your mouth. Not to mention they use only the freshest ingredients so you’re sure to get an exquisite flavor experience every time you visit.

But what really sets Riverside Deli & Pizza apart is their friendly staff who truly make you feel at home no matter how busy they are. The counterperson not only offered me suggestions on which toppings to choose but also took time to chat about his favorite pizza places in the area.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Newburgh NY, then look no further than Riverside Deli & Pizza! From great atmosphere to tantalizing pies, it’s a truly wonderful spot for pizza lovers of all kinds. Highly recommended!

#7 Pizza Mia

When I stepped into the cozy little restaurant, I knew I was in for a good meal. The décor had a classic Italian vibe and the staff were genuinely friendly and enthusiastic about their food.

The menu boasted pizza options for all types of taste, from a traditional Margherita to a decadent meat-lovers special. But of course, I opted for the ‘Mia Special’ with prosciutto, buffalo mozzarella, mushrooms, olives and cherry tomatoes. Wow – it was an explosion of flavours in every bite!

The pizza also had great texture as well; the crust was perfectly cooked with just the right amount of crunch while still remaining soft and light. I could have eaten an entire pie on my own but luckily they served them up in individual portions.

I savoured every bite until my plate was clean! Pizza Mia is truly one of the best pizzerias in Newburgh NY and I’m so glad that I had the chance to enjoy it for myself. If you’re ever in town looking for a slice or two – be sure to give them a try!

If you’re willing to go an extra 15 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Poughkeepsie!

#8 Joe’s Pizza & Deli

I first tried the classic pepperoni pizza and it was absolutely delicious! The crust was light and crispy, but still had a nice chew to it. The cheese was melted perfectly and the pepperoni had just enough spice.

Next, I decided to try one of their specialty pies – the Italian Stallion. Wowza! This pizza definitely lived up to its name. Loaded with lots of Italian sausage, onions, green peppers, mushrooms and olives, it’s sure to satisfy all your cravings! The flavors came together so nicely and the crust held up well under all that toppings! Delicious!

To round out my meal I also tried their garlic breadsticks. They were warm and buttery with just the right amount of garlic flavor. I dipped them in their house made marinara sauce which was flavorful and full of herbs.

If you’re ever in Newburgh NY looking for an excellent slice of pizza or a full pie for takeout – look no further than Joe’s Pizza & Deli! In my opinion they serve some of the best pizza around – give them a try today!

#9 Eddie’s Gourmet Pizza

As soon as I stepped into the restaurant and saw the brick oven, I knew I was in for a treat. The crust was perfectly crisp on the bottom and had just the right amount of chewiness. The toppings were plentiful and extremely flavorful – from the classic pepperoni to their unique “Eddie’s Special” with homemade sausage and banana peppers.

The service was friendly, attentive, and lightning fast. No matter how busy they got, my order was ready in no time at all.

It gets even better: Eddie’s Gourmet Pizza also offers alcohol! Not only can you get a great bottle of wine or some craft beer to accompany your meal, but they even have a selection of craft cocktails for those special occasions.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Newburgh NY and an experience that is sure to leave you satisfied, head to Eddie’s Gourmet Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

#10 The Barile’s Planet Pizza

I went in expecting the usual, but I was pleasantly surprised. The crust was perfectly cooked and had that “just-right” crunchy texture. The sauce was made with fresh tomatoes and had just the right amount of zip to it. The cheese used was a blend of mozzarella and cheddar that complemented the other ingredients perfectly.

I’m also happy to report that the toppings were fresh, flavorful, and generous. I’m talking mouth-watering pepperoni, succulent sausage, vibrant bell peppers, mushrooms that were so meaty they almost qualified as a main course! All of this goodness piled high atop what could only be described as eternal comfort food – pizza!

The atmosphere was cozy and comfortable – perfect for a night out with friends or family. The staff were friendly and attentive – always willing to point me in the right direction if I couldn’t decide on which topping combination to go with.

But make no mistake – Barile’s Planet Pizza is all about the pizza. Simply put: it’s some of the best pizza in Newburgh NY!

#11 Youngest Brother Italian Restaurant

The restaurant itself deserves mention, as the atmosphere is vibrant and alive. From the red-checkered tablecloths to the romantic candlelit dinners, this establishment knows how to set an inviting dining scene.

As for the pizza, it definitely hits the spot! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, with just enough sauce and cheese to keep every bite delicious and enjoyable. The toppings were fresh and flavorful; there’s something here to please everyone’s palate.

As if that weren’t enough, they also offer some really unique topping combinations so your pizza can be one-of-a-kind. I tried their ‘Grandma Pie’ which had ricotta, black olives, pepperoni and garlic – it was amazing!

I’d say that Youngest Brother Italian Restaurant is definitely worth a try when looking for great pizzas in Newburgh NY. They have something for everyone, with generous portions and prices that won’t break your wallet. Surely one of the best places in town!

#12 Frank’s Pizza

It has the perfect crust – not too thin, not too thick – and a wonderful flavor. The sauce is just right, not too acidic, and the cheese is plentiful. It’s clear Frank knows his pies pretty well!

Toppings are also excellent at Frank’s – they’re plentiful, fresh and flavorful. They’ve got all the classics like pepperoni and mushroom, as well as some unique toppings that really make the pizza stand out!

And the service at Frank’s Pizza is top notch, with friendly staff who are more than happy to accommodate special requests. Plus, their prices are reasonable too – you get great value for your money.

So if you’re in Newburgh NY and looking for amazing pizza, I highly recommend checking out Frank’s Pizza. It definitely deserves to be recognized as one of the best pizza places around!