I recently visited 12 of the top pizza places in this Indiana city, determined to find the best. I’m happy to report that Elkhart is full of delicious pies! My criteria for judging included crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings.
My journey has been a real blast! The pizzas I sampled had some unique flavors and combinations. Whether it’s traditional pepperoni or something more exotic like pineapple and jalapeño, there are plenty of options to satisfy your taste buds.
So join me as I share my thoughts on the best pizza in Elkhart – it’s time for some serious taste testing!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Indiana
#1 Freshieez
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
From the moment I walked in, I knew this was going to be a special experience. The smell of freshly baked pizza filled the air and it was almost enough to make my mouth water.
The staff greeted me with a smile and the friendly atmosphere put me at ease immediately. The decor was inviting and the vibe in the restaurant made me feel right at home.
As for the pizza itself, I was blown away! Every slice was cooked to perfection – crispy on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside. Every ingredient was fresh, flavorful and cooked just right. I especially loved their signature sauce – it was tangy, savory, and had a hint of sweetness that just made everything come together perfectly.
In conclusion, Freshieez has easily earned its place as one of Elkhart’s best pizza restaurant! If you’re looking for a great meal in an inviting atmosphere, look no further than Freshieez!
If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Mishawaka!
#2 Vesuvio Pizza
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
Upon entering the shop, I was taken aback by the wonderful aroma of freshly baked pizza. The smell was heavenly and it only got better when I tasted the pizza. The crust was thin and delicious, and the toppings were perfectly cooked. Every bite was incredibly flavorful – it really hit the spot!
The staff at Vesuvio Pizza went above and beyond to make sure my experience was great. They were very courteous, friendly, and accommodating. Plus, they weren’t afraid to throw in a free slice or two for good measure!
All in all, Vesuvio Pizza is easily one of the best pizzerias I’ve ever visited around Elkhart – if not anywhere! Its delicious pies make for a truly unforgettable experience. So if you’re ever craving great pizza, be sure to check out Vesuvio Pizza – you won’t regret it!
#3 Milano’s Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
- Has a kid’s menu
The dough was cooked to perfection, with a crispy bottom and fluffy center. The toppings were generous and flavorful, and you can tell they use high quality ingredients just by looking at them!
The cheese was absolutely amazing as well. It had a great balance of melted gooeyness and stringy cheesy goodness.
I could have eaten an entire pizza in one sitting since it tasted so good. The sauce was delicious too – the perfect blend of spices that really made the flavors pop.
Overall, I’m so glad I finally found a place in Elkhart that makes incredible pizza. Milano’s Pizza is definitely the best pizza in town!
#4 Enzo Pizza
The atmosphere at this place is definitely unique – it has a very fun and quirky vibe that instantly puts you in a good mood. The staff are incredibly friendly – they go out of their way to make sure your visit is enjoyable!
The pizza itself is absolutely delicious! The dough is made with the freshest ingredients and it’s perfectly cooked every single time. They have an amazing selection of toppings too, so you can customize your meal to suit your taste buds.
I’ve been coming here for years and I’ve never had anything but the best. No matter which topping combination I try, it always tastes like the best pizza ever!
If you’re looking for some seriously authentic Italian pizza in Elkhart, Enzo Pizza is definitely the place to go! I can’t recommend this restaurant enough – it’s clearly one of the best pizzerias around.
#5 Antonio’s Italian Restaurant
- Has insanely good dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- No delivery
The restaurant itself is a great tourist spot – the atmosphere is cozy, and you can even get your drink on with alcohol (and hard liquor!) served here. Plus, there’s something for everyone with a kid’s menu, vegetarian options, and some insanely good dessert.
Of course, no pizza place would be complete without its signature dish: pizza! The pizza at Antonio’s doesn’t disappoint – it has just the right amount of crunch and flavor that leaves your mouth watering. It must be true what they say – you won’t find better pizza in Elkhart!
Unfortunately, the only downside to Antonio’s Italian Restaurant is that they don’t offer delivery. But trust me: visiting this amazing place makes it worth the trip!
#6 Luigi’s Pizza
The restaurant itself is nothing fancy, but that doesn’t matter once you taste the pizza. The crust is light, with a hint of crispness on the edges. It’s made with the perfect combination of flavors and texture to make it absolutely delicious!
The sauce is flavorful and robust, yet subtle enough to not overpower the toppings. And speaking of toppings – they were fresh, plentiful and cooked to perfection. Every bite was filled with flavor and satisfaction.
My personal favorite pizza at Luigi’s is the “Italian Special” – featuring pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and onions. The combination of these ingredients made for a truly unique flavor experience that will have me coming back soon!
I’ve been lucky enough to eat wonderful pizza all over the world, but Luigi’s Pizza has some of the best I’ve tasted in Elkhart. If you’re ever in town looking for great pizza – look no further than Luigi’s Pizza!
#7 Volcano Pizza / Easy Shopping Place
I can’t say enough about the amazing selection of toppings at Volcano Pizza / Easy Shopping Place. From your traditional pepperoni and sausage to more exotic toppings such as anchovies and pickles, they have something to suit everyone’s tastes.
But of course, it’s not just the toppings that make Volcano Pizza / Easy Shopping Place so great! Their signature dough is what really sets them apart from other pizza places. It has a perfect balance of crunchiness and chewiness that makes every bite a delight.
I also have to mention their friendly staff. Everyone is always smiling and willing to help you choose the perfect pizza for your taste buds.
In conclusion, whether you are looking for a casual dinner out or an elevated dining experience, Volcano Pizza / Easy Shopping Place most definitely should be your destination. It truly is the best pizza in Elkhart!
#8 Bruno’s Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
I’m not just saying that because the owner, Bruno, is a good guy either (he totally is). I’m saying that because their pizza is truly one of a kind. The crust is so fluffy and light, it’s like a cloud pie. It’s cooked perfectly in the brick oven – just enough crunch to make your jaw work for every bite.
And then there’s the sauce – oh boy! Every time I go there I can taste the difference between what they use and other pizzerias. The tomatoes are always deliciously fresh and vibrant, never canned or processed like you get at other places. Plus, the combination of herbs mixed with garlic and oregano makes my mouth sing a happy song each time!
And don’t even get me started on the cheese! That special blend of Mozzarella and Parmesan cheese melted throughout makes for an experience you won’t forget soon. Every melt is thick yet creamy and has that perfect balance between being sharp without being too intense. One bite will have you hooked from then on out!
So if you’re ever in Elkhart looking for some of the best pizza around, look no further than Bruno’s Pizza. The heavenly crust mixed with flavorful herbs, unbeatable sauce & amazing cheese will quickly have you realizing why this place has earned its title as having some of the best pizza in Elkhart!
If you’re willing to go an extra 16 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in South Bend!
#9 Volcano Pizza / Concord Commons
The atmosphere was great. The place was bustling with activity and the staff were warm and welcoming. I especially loved their ‘Volcano Challenge’ – can you finish a large pizza in under 15 minutes?
The pizza itself was incredible – the crust was thin but still crunchy, the cheese could only be described as ‘oozing’. The toppings – from sweet pineapple to savory pepperoni – were all incredibly balanced and flavorful.
To top it off, the prices were very reasonable. A large for two people (or one very hungry person with a hollow leg!) is under $20.
In short, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Elkhart, Volcano Pizza / Concord Commons is definitely worth checking out!
#10 Boomerelli’s Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
I was amazed at the quality of the pizza here. The crust was perfectly cooked, with a light crunch and golden-brown edges. The sauce is a flavorful blend of spices that will tantalize your taste buds. And don’t get me started on the cheese – it melts in your mouth like no other!
I also had the pleasure of trying some of their speciality pizzas. Each one was unique and bursting with flavor. There’s something for everyone at Boomerelli’s, whether you’re looking for something classic or more exotic.
The staff at Boomerelli’s are also top notch, always friendly and helpful in recommending different options so you can find something to fit your craving.
All in all, I would highly recommend Boomerelli’s Pizza to anyone looking for the best pizza in Elkhart!
#11 MOD Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
- Serves alcohol
- Has some vegetarian options
I recently had the pleasure of visiting this restaurant and, let me tell you, it was a truly unique experience! The atmosphere of the place is warm and inviting and the staff was incredibly friendly.
The menu here is like nothing else I’ve seen before. They offer individual-sized pizzas that you get to customize with as many toppings as you want – perfect for someone like me who can never decide on just one topping!
When it comes to taste, MOD Pizza really knocks it out of the park. The ingredients are all fresh and delicious! The crust is thin and crispy, and their signature sauce is full of flavor.
It’s no surprise why MOD Pizza has become such a local favorite in Elkhart. If you’re ever in town or passing through, make sure to stop by for some of the best pizza around!
#12 Big City Pizza
I walked into the restaurant on a Saturday night, and it was already bustling with people. I could tell that this was going to be good. I ordered a pepperoni pizza, and the thin crust stayed perfectly crisp and flavorful as it cooked. The cheese had a great flavor, too.
When my pizza came out of the oven, there were no disappointments here—the presentation was beautiful! The topping portion was over-the-top generous and as I took my first bite, the flavor exploded in my mouth. That melted cheese flooded every crevice of the pizza along with powerful seasonings that will linger for days in memory.
With Big City Pizza you don’t just get great pizza—you get a whole show! There’s music playing in the background and friendly staff that will make you feel right at home. Plus, they offer an extensive array of toppings so you can really customize your pizza to your own tastes!
In short, Big City Pizza is hands down one of the best pizzerias I’ve ever had the pleasure of enjoying in Elkhart or anywhere else for that matter. If you haven’t tried it yet, do yourself a favor and head over soon!
