Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Idaho Falls (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Idaho

Best Pizza in Idaho Falls (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

262 Views

The best part? With only 12 pizza places to review in the area, I’m sure that I’ve got a solid handle on the local offerings.

I’m not saying I know everything about what makes the perfect pizza (come on, that’s impossible!), but after all my travels and tastings throughout the world, I can confidently say that Idaho Falls has some really great restaurants serving up their pies. So come along as I review some of the best pizza spots in town and give you my honest opinion of each one.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Idaho

#1 Pie Hole Idaho Falls | Pizza by the slice

The decor is simple, but inviting. The staff are friendly and welcoming, making me feel right at home. But, of course, the most important part was the food.

The pizza itself was delicious! The crust was crispy and flavorful, and the toppings were cooked to perfection. I’d even go so far as to say it was some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted!

In addition to pizza by the slice, Pie Hole Idaho Falls also offers a variety of other menu items like subs, salads and wings. Everything tasted wonderfully fresh and flavorful – definitely worth a try!

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Idaho Falls then you absolutely have to check out Pie Hole Idaho Falls | Pizza by the slice. You won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 47 miles, you can get to 14 more pizza places in Pocatello!

#2 Uncle Benny’s Pizza

You can find Uncle Benny’s in a nondescript strip mall on Main Street. Upon entering, I could tell that this restaurant was special. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, and the staff was friendly and welcoming.

The menu at Uncle Benny’s is impressively large. They have all your classic pizza favorites like pepperoni, cheese, and Hawaiian, but they also offer unique creations like their Gourmet BBQ Chicken pizza. Those with a heartier appetite can even order one of their specialty pizzas like the Supreme Deluxe or Meat Lover’s.

I decided to try out the Supreme Deluxe for myself and it did not disappoint – it was delicious! The crust had just the right amount of crispiness, and each topping complemented the other perfectly. Every bite of my meal was heavenly! Even better, each slice of pizza was surprisingly affordable – I have definitely found a new go-to spot when I’m hankering for the best pizza in Idaho Falls!

If you’re ever in town looking for an amazing pizza experience, be sure to give Uncle Benny’s Pizza a visit!

#3 MOD Pizza

When I walked through their doors, I was instantly in pizza heaven. The restaurant smelled of freshly baked dough and Wisconsin mozzarella cheese. The colorful chalk board menu excited me – so many options! Who knew that something as simple as a pizza could have an endless selection of ingredients to choose from?

After ordering the classic pepperoni and Italian sausage combo, I was ready to start my review. The first bite blew me away! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, the sauce was flavorful and fresh, the cheese melted into a perfect blanket atop the thin layer of meats. MOD Pizza definitely knows how to make some amazing pies – it’s no wonder why it has become so popular in Idaho Falls!

Overall, my experience at MOD Pizza put it on my list for one of the best pizzas in Idaho Falls. But don’t take my word for it – go check them out for yourself!

#4 Lucy’s New York Style Pizza

The first thing that stands out about the restaurant is the charming atmosphere. As soon as you walk in, the staff greet you with smiles and pleasantries. The decor is what you would expect from an old-school Italian pizzeria – red tablecloths, brick walls, and checkered floor tiles.

The pizza is where Lucy’s really shines! The hand-tossed crust is perfectly thin and crunchy with just the right amount of chewiness. Toppings are generously applied and cover every inch of the pizza – it’s like a culinary masterpiece! I’m especially a fan of their signature sausage topping – full of flavor with just a hint of spice!

But perhaps most importantly (at least for me) is that they offer gluten-free options! After years of eating traditional (glutenous) pizza, it was such a treat to be able to enjoy something without having to worry about an allergic reaction.

Bottom line, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Idaho Falls, head on over to Lucy’s New York Style Pizza for an unforgettable experience!

#5 Papa Tom’s Pizza

The first thing that struck me upon arriving at Papa Tom’s Pizza was its inviting atmosphere. Food-lovers of all ages were gathered around the main counter, eagerly awaiting a slice of their favorite pizza. It felt like a neighborhood joint – the kind you’d expect to find in New York City or some other major metropolitan area.

I decided to try the ‘Tommy’s Special’ and it certainly lived up to the hype! The crust was perfectly cooked – not too crispy and not too soft – and the cheese was just cheesy enough. But it was the combination of flavors that really made this pizza stand out – from the tomatoes to the pepperoni, everything came together perfectly.

The service at Papa Tom’s Pizza is also worth noting here. From start to finish, every employee I encountered was friendly and helpful, ensuring my experience there was enjoyable. To top it all off, they even offered an unbeatable deal – buy one pizza get one free!

In conclusion, I can safely say that Papa Tom’s Pizza offers some of the best pizza in Idaho Falls. With its mouthwatering pies and friendly staff, it’s definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in town!

#6 Lucy’s New York Style Pizza

The pizza here is made with traditional New York style ingredients, and you can really taste it in the flavor. The cheese has a nice mild flavor that isn’t too overpowering, and the sauce has just enough tanginess to make it truly outstanding.

The crust is definitely the star of this meal, though. It’s crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside with just the right amount of crunch. It’s definitely not your typical floppy pizza fare!

I also had some of their delicious garlic-knot appetizers which were cooked to perfection and had a great mix of flavors – I especially liked the buttery freshness of them.

Overall, if you’re looking for a great pizza in Idaho Falls, then Lucy’s New York Style Pizza is definitely where you want to go! The food was top notch and I would highly recommend it!

#7 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The first thing that impressed me was the wide range of options they had. From classic favorites like pepperoni and cheese to something more unique like their signature “Deluxe” with its combination of sausage, mushrooms, olives, and green peppers, there’s something for everyone here.

The next thing that immediately caught my eye was the quality of ingredients. They use only the freshest produce and meats, meaning you’re getting top-notch quality each time you order.

When it comes time to bake your pizza, Papa Murphy’s has made it easy by including an oven-ready baking pan with each order. All you have to do is pop it in the oven according to the included instructions, wait 15 minutes or so, and you’ll have a hot, delicious pizza ready to enjoy!

I also found their staff to be super helpful and friendly – always giving great advice on which combinations work best together as well as pointing out any special deals that might be running at the time. I even managed to walk away with a free soda just for being a loyal customer!

So overall I’d say if you’re looking for some killer pizza in Idaho Falls then Papa Murphy’s is definitely worth checking out – especially when it comes to those late night cravings!

If you’re willing to go an extra 58 miles, you can get to 8 more pizza places in Jackson!

#8 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

Walking into the restaurant, I was overwhelmed by the aroma of freshly made dough and baking cheese. The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful; they even asked me customize my order to ensure I got the best possible pizza!

When it was time to actually bake the pizza, I was relieved that they had provided easy-to-follow instructions. No chef skills needed here – a beginner can pull off an amazing masterpiece! The crust was light and crispy, holding up a pillowy layer of cheese that melted in my mouth. They also have an excellent selection of meats, veggies and other toppings, so you can make your own signature pizza if you want.

Overall, I highly recommend Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza for anyone looking for the best pizza in Idaho Falls. Delicious, convenient and affordable – what else could one ask for?

#9 Homestead Pizza & Bowling

When I first walked in, I was instantly charmed by the cozy atmosphere. The pizza chef behind the counter was busy making pizzas for customers, and it smelled amazing. After finally getting to order, I got the classic cheese pizza – nothing like a classic to test a restaurant’s mettle!

The cheese pizza that arrived was remarkable – it had just the right amount of crunch to the crust, and each bite was deliciously cheesy. I found myself wanting more after every bite!

Then there were the extras. The staff here go out of their way to make sure you’re accommodated. They gave me extra dipping sauces on the side while they refilled my drinks without me having to ask. It’s clear they go above and beyond for their customers here.

If you’re ever in Idaho Falls and looking for some of the best pizza around, then Homestead Pizza & Bowling is your place!

#10 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

From the second I stepped foot inside this inviting restaurant, the smell of delicious ingredients immediately filled the air. The delightful aroma combined with the cheerful and helpful staff made me feel right at home.

I was quickly presented with an impressive selection of pizzas to choose from, including their signature “Create Your Own” pizza where you can pick and choose your favorite toppings. Let me tell you, I’ve tried a lot of different styles of pizza in my travels, and Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza really stood out!

The thin crust was perfectly cooked and loaded with all sorts of amazing flavors. In fact, every single bite was so flavorful that it felt like I was eating a slice of heaven! And that sauce? It was simply divine!

To top it off (pun intended!), the prices were incredibly reasonable for such high-quality pizza. So if you’re ever in Idaho Falls and looking for some great pizza, be sure to check out Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza – it’ll definitely be worth your while!

#11 Blaze Pizza

I mean, this place had some real pizzazz. No pun intended. The decor was stylish and inviting–just like the staff. They were so friendly and helpful during my visit. I knew I was in the right place the second I stepped through the door!

But what really made me fall in love with Blaze Pizza were their pizzas! Wow! They were unique and delicious, with fresh ingredients and flavorful sauces. The crusts were light and fluffy, just like I like them. And don’t even get me started on the toppings! From classic favorites to creative combinations, there was something for everyone here.

Overall, Blaze Pizza definitely deserves its title as the best pizza joint in Idaho Falls. It’s a great spot for sharing a meal with friends or enjoying a solo slice or two! So if you’re ever in town, make sure to check them out–you won’t regret it!

#12 Pizza Pie Cafe

I’d like to start off by saying the pizza was FANTASTIC. It’s obvious that the chefs at Pizza Pie Cafe know what they are doing, because every slice of the pizza I had was cooked to perfection. The flavor combination of salty and sweet melted in my mouth. And then there’s the fresh dough—mmmm! It was light and airy, yet sturdy enough to hold up whatever toppings you wanted on it.

Aside from supplying some of the best pizza in Idaho Falls, Pizza Pie Cafe also has a great atmosphere. From its quaint outdoor seating area with twinkly lights to its cozy interior seating area, this restaurant makes you feel right at home. Plus, their staff are really friendly and helpful; they made sure I left with a full stomach (and many compliments!).

If you’re looking for delicious pizza and an enjoyable dining experience, look no further than Pizza Pie Cafe! It’s definitely earned a spot in my top five favorite pizza restaurants in all of Idaho Falls.