Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in The Outer Banks (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in North Carolina

Best Pizza in The Outer Banks (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

383 Views

I’ve traveled all over the world, tasting pizza from places near and far – Rome, Naples, New York City. But I was pleasantly surprised to find a number of great options in the Outer Banks too.

I’m here to give you the scoop on the best pizzas this area has to offer – from 12 different restaurants! So get ready for plenty of cheesy goodness – let’s dive in and see which pizzas come out on top.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of North Carolina

#1 Gingerbread House Bakery

My most recent visit there was an enjoyable experience from the second I stepped in the door. From the cozy atmosphere to the delicious aromas, it was impossible not to enjoy my time there.

The pizza itself was simply amazing! The crust was just right – not too thick and not too thin. Plus, the toppings were cooked perfectly. It’s clear to see that a lot of care went into making each pie.

In addition to having some of the best pizza around, Gingerbread House Bakery also has insanely good desserts! They have all kinds of treats – from cheesecakes to pies and cinnamon rolls – that will leave you craving for more.

On top of everything else, Gingerbread House Bakery is also a great tourist spot. It may be slightly off-the-beaten path but its worth the trip if you are looking for a nice place to relax and enjoy some food with friends or family.

The only downside about Gingerbread House Bakery is that they don’t offer delivery service. But even this small drawback can’t take away from how delicious their food is!

If you’re ever in Outer Banks and looking for great pizza, then your search should end at Gingerbread House Bakery! Not only do they have some of the best pizza around but they also have some seriously scrumptious desserts and an inviting atmosphere as well.

If you’re willing to go an extra 48 miles, you can get to 14 more pizza places in Nags Head!

#2 MADISONS PIZZA

The atmosphere is incredibly inviting and tourist-friendly, with lots of local art on the walls. And I can verify that the pizza itself is outstanding – there’s a reason why it was the talk of the town! The crust is perfectly crisp and the flavors amazing.

However, you’ll have to come in person to enjoy it, asMadisons Pizza doesn’t offer delivery. It’s worth it though – it’s an experience like no other. You won’t be disappointed!

I always joke that for anyone looking for the best pizza in Outer Banks, MADISONS PIZZA should be your first stop – you won’t want to go anywhere else after trying their delicious pies. Highly recommended!

#3 Pizza Stop

The atmosphere of the restaurant was inviting, with a warm andfriendly staff. The décor was rustic, with a cosy ambience thatwas perfect for dining in.

The menu was expansive, offering plenty of optionsfor the pizza-lover. On my visit, I went for their specialty dish: “Best Pizza in Outer Banks”. It didn’t disappoint! The crust was perfectly crispy, but still had an airy texture that melted in my mouth. The toppings were juicy and flavorful – a far cry from the bland offerings I’ve found elsewhere.

I also tried some of their side dishes and was very pleased with what they had to offer. The garlic knots were soft and delicious, while the mozzarella sticks oozed cheese when bitten into.

All in all, Pizza Stop is an excellent spot to get your pizza fix; they deliver on taste and presentation every time!

#4 Gidget’s Pizza & Pasta

I was pleasantly surprised to learn that this spot serves alcoholic beverages, has a kid’s menu, and even offers vegetarian options. I mean – you can’t beat that! And if all of that isn’t enough, they even have desserts.

If there were any downsides to Gidget’s Pizza & Pasta, it would be that they don’t offer delivery, which means you’ll have to dine-in or drive-thru. But who needs delivery when you can go to one of the most popular tourist spots to enjoy some delicious pizza?

Overall, I’d say my experience at Gidget’s Pizza & Pasta was great. The food was excellent and the atmosphere was inviting and lively. If you’re ever looking for the best pizza in Outer Banks, then look no further than Gidget’s Pizza & Pasta!

#5 Lisa’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere was quaint and inviting, and the staff were both friendly and accommodating. We started our meal with some of Lisa’s special garlic knots, which were simply to die for – the garlicky-doughy perfection was mouthwateringly delicious!

For the main course, we picked a ‘Build Your Own’ pizza. The quality of the toppings was top notch, from the fresh basil to the succulent pepperoni. We added a few extra ingredients too: jalapenos for heat, artichokes for crunch and mushrooms for that wonderful earthy taste.

The pizza was cooked to perfection in their brick oven, creating a wonderfully crisp base layered with melted cheese and fragrant toppings. It tasted even better than it looked! My dining companion couldn’t stop raving about it – they are definitely going to be returning again soon!

If you’re looking for delicious pizza in Outer Banks then look no further than Lisa’s Pizzeria! Try their garlic knots – you won’t regret it.

#6 Nags Head Pizza Company

My very first bite of their pizza was perfection. The cheese was gooey and flavorful, the crust was crisp and golden brown, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

The atmosphere of Nags Head Pizza Company is cozy and welcoming. The waitstaff treats you like family and serves up steaming hot slices of pizza with a smile. The restaurant itself is clean, inviting, and rustic- yet modern.

And if you’re looking for something sweet to top off your meal, I highly recommend one of their homemade gelato or cannoli! They’re both simply divine.

Overall, Nags Head Pizza Company is an outstanding spot for a casual lunch or dinner with friends and family. Their pizza is delicious, the atmosphere inviting, and the service outstanding. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Outer Banks then look no further – Nags Head Pizza Company has got you covered!

#7 Slice Pizzeria

I was immediately impressed by the atmosphere at Slice. It’s a quaint little place with an inviting vibe, and I could tell the staff takes pride in their restaurant.

The highlight of my visit, of course, was the pizza. The thin crust had a wonderfully crisp texture that balanced well with the gooey cheese. Toppings were generous and flavorful, as if they were carefully chosen to complement each other perfectly.

As if that wasn’t enough, they also have some of the best deals I’ve seen in Outer Banks. You can get unlimited toppings for a very reasonable price, meaning you can create the perfect pizza every time.

Overall, Slice Pizzeria is a great spot to get amazing pizza in Outer Banks! Next time you’re in town, make sure you stop by and give them a try!

If you’re willing to go an extra 51 miles, you can get to 14 more pizza places in Kill Devil Hills!

#8 Sal’s New York Pizza

From the first bite, I could tell Sal’s pizza was something special. The crust was light and airy, with just the right amount of crunchiness. The sauce was sweet with a hint of oregano, and the cheese was melted to perfection.

The toppings were incredibly fresh! They had a variety of meats like sausage, pepperoni and bacon, as well as plenty of veggies like mushrooms, peppers and onions. Every topping was cooked to perfection, leaving me asking for more!

My favorite part about Sal’s New York Pizza is the atmosphere. It has a classic Italian restaurant vibe that makes you feel like you’re eating in someone’s home. From the checkered tablecloths to the Italian decor on the walls, everything adds to create a cozy ambiance.

All in all, if you’re looking for some delicious pizza in Outer Banks, then look no further than Sal’s New York Pizza! With its fresh ingredients and charming atmosphere, it will be sure to satisfy even the toughest food critic.

#9 Southern Shores Pizza & Deli

When I first walked into the restaurant, I knew I was in for an amazing experience. The warm atmosphere and wonderful aromas made me instantly feel at home.

The menu is filled with delicious options, but it’s the pizza that stands out above all else. Every single one of their pies is loaded with toppings and cooked to perfection! From classic pepperoni to unique creations like Bacon & BBQ Chicken Pizza, there’s something for everyone here. And believe me – they don’t skimp on the cheese!

The staff here are friendly, knowledgeable, and ready to make your meal as enjoyable as possible. I was served quickly and had a great conversation with the owner about his favorite pizzas. He even gave me some free samples of their amazing cinnamon sticks!

All in all, Southern Shores Pizza & Deli offers some of the best pizza in The Outer Banks. If you’re ever in town and craving a delicious pie, be sure to check them out – you won’t be disappointed!

#10 Nino’s Pizza

From the moment I stepped into Nino’s Pizza, I knew that I had come to the right place. Not only did it smell like delicious pizza, but the atmosphere was inviting and cheerful. The walls were adorned with pictures of previous customers who had enjoyed their pizza and the staff was friendly and ready to assist.

The menu offered a wide range of different pizzas, all freshly made and cooked to perfection. From classic cheese and pepperoni to more inventive creations like bacon and eggplant, there was something for everyone! After much deliberation, I decided on the ‘Cheesy Caprese’ – boy oh boy am I glad I chose that one! It was honestly one of the most delicious pizzas I have ever tasted – lightly crisp dough topped with creamy mozzarella cheese, sweet tomato sauce, basil pesto and succulent slices of fresh tomato.

But what really sets Nino’s Pizza apart from its competitors is its commitment to quality ingredients. In fact, they pride themselves on using only locally sourced produce in every one of their dishes! Not only does this ensure you get the freshest ingredients possible with each bite, but it also helps support local farmers too!

In conclusion, Nino’s Pizza is hands down the best pizza joint in Outer Banks. Whether you are looking for a quick slice or looking to enjoy a whole pie with friends and family, Nino’s Pizza has got you covered – deliciously!

#11 Angelo’s Pizza

I’m not exaggerating! I’ve visited some of the most renowned pizza places around the world, and nothing comes close to Angelo’s Pizza when it comes to delivering an exceptional pizza experience.

The first time I walked in, I was immediately impressed by the welcoming atmosphere. The staff were friendly and courteous, and even offered me a complimentary sample before I ordered. Talk about good hospitality!

When my order came out, my taste buds were immediately in heaven. The crust had just the right amount of crispiness to it and the toppings were cooked perfectly. Not too greasy or dry – just absolutely spot on!

The highlight of my visit was watching one of the pizza chefs prepare my dinner right in front of me. He created my masterpiece with such skill and finesse, it almost felt like a piece of art!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some truly amazing pizza then Angelos is hands-down your best bet in Outer Banks. If you want to enjoy some great hospitality alongside delicious food then this is definitely the place for you – no doubt about it!

#12 Dare Devil’s Pizzeria

From their paper-thin crusts to their generous toppings, every bite of their pizza had me wanting more. I’m no stranger to pizza places, but Dare Devil’s Pizzeria definitely stands out.

What struck me the most about Dare Devil’s Pizzeria was its range of options and atmosphere. With a kid’s menu, a great selection of beer and hard liquor, and lots of TVs for sports fans to enjoy the game, it truly has something for everyone. It was also quite obvious that Dare Devil’s Pizzeria is something of a tourist spot – you can tell by all the pictures on the wall!

To top off my unforgettable experience at Dare Devil’s Pizzeria, I tried one of their desserts as well. Needless to say, it was delicious! The only downside I can think of is that they don’t offer delivery services – so you’ll have to drop in or else order out.

Still, even without delivery service, I’d highly recommend Dare Devil’s Pizzeria for anyone looking for some delicious pizza in Outer Banks – it just might be the best around!