Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Pensacola Beach (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Pensacola Beach (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

156 Views

My mission was to find the best pizza in the area, so I traveled and tasted twelve pies from various places. Along the way, I encountered some unexpected surprises, and I’m eager to share my reviews with you!

I’ll tell you about every place’s pizzas – from the atmosphere of the restaurant, to the ingredients used in each pie – all while maintaining a humorous and lighthearted tone. So kick back, prepare your appetite and let’s dig into the best pizza options in Pensacola Beach!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 New Yorker Deli & Pizzeria

The first thing I noticed when walking in the door was the smell of freshly baked pizza. The restaurant had an inviting atmosphere and the staff were very friendly and helpful.

The pizzas are made with fresh ingredients that really hit the spot. The crispy crust was perfectly cooked, while my favorite topping combination–pepperoni, onions, and olives–was flavorful without being too overwhelming.

I also tried their specialty sandwiches and I must say they did not disappoint! They have a wide variety of choices including Italian subs, Philly cheesesteaks, and more.

Overall, I highly recommend New Yorker Deli & Pizzeria to anyone looking for some delicious pizza in Pensacola Beach. It’s definitely one of the best around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Pensacola!

#2 Santino’s Pizza & Grinders

The atmosphere at Santino’s could only be described as inviting and comfortable. The walls are decorated with pictures of happy customers enjoying their meal, which only adds to the overall welcoming feeling.

The pizza itself is amazing! The crust is so perfectly crisp that it almost melts in your mouth. I highly recommend the classic cheese and pepperoni; the combination of the two flavors is magical! The toppings are generous and fresh, and they always arrive hot and ready to eat.

Plus, the staff at Santino’s is great! They’re friendly and accommodating, making sure every customer has an enjoyable experience. They even have a selection of beers available if you want to wash down your pizza with an ice-cold beverage.

So if you’re looking for a great place to get some delicious pizza then look no further than Santino’s Pizza & Grinders – it really does have some of the best pizza in Pensacola Beach!

#3 O’Zone Pizza Pub

I was pleasantly surprised to find that O’Zone Pizza Pub offers a variety of options for adults and kids alike. Not only can adults enjoy their favorite adult beverage while eating some delicious pizza, but they also offer hard liquor, so you can spice up your pizza night!

For those who don’t eat meat, there are some good vegetarian options on the menu. It’s always nice when restaurants offer choices beyond plain cheese or pepperoni pizzas. And don’t forget dessert! They have some mouth-watering desserts that pair perfectly with a cold beer or glass of wine.

My only complaint is that they do not offer delivery, which would make it even easier to enjoy their delicious food.

Overall though, I highly recommend O’Zone Pizza Pub if you’re looking for the best pizza in Pensacola Beach. The atmosphere is great and the drinks pair nicely with their wide selection of pizzas. Plus it’s a great spot for tourists looking to have a night out without having to travel too far!

#4 East Hill Pizza

I stopped in recently to sample their pies, and I was not disappointed. The crust was delightfully crunchy and the sauce tasted like it had been cooked up with a little help from the Italian gods. The cheese was gooey and flavorful, and the toppings were a perfect complement to the rest of the dish.

The atmosphere at East Hill Pizza is nothing short of magical. With its rustic wooden décor, cozy booths, and vibrant live music, you can’t help but feel like you’ve stepped back in time. The staff was friendly and really went out of their way to make sure my experience was top-notch.

Overall, East Hill Pizza is definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in Pensacola Beach looking for great pizza. Not only is it some of the best pizza I’ve ever had, but it’s also an amazing atmosphere!

#5 Cafe Bistro

The first thing that hits you when you walk in the door is the wonderful smells of fresh-baked dough, savory tomatoes, and melting cheese. The restaurant has a cozy atmosphere with plenty of seating to accommodate groups of any size.

When it comes to their pizza, they have a wide range of flavors and toppings to choose from. My favorite is their signature pie: a thin-crust white pie topped with ricotta, roasted tomatoes and mushrooms. It’s like a flavor explosion in your mouth!

The service at Cafe Bistro is also top-notch. Our waitress was attentive, friendly, and helpful with suggestions on what kind of pizza to try. She even asked if I wanted extra napkins!

All in all, Cafe Bistro has some of the best pizza in Pensacola Beach – especially for those looking for an unforgettable pie experience. Try it out for yourself and you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 25 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Orange Beach!

#6 Marco’s Pizza

My search for the perfect pizza began when I decided to make it my mission to find the best slices of pizza I could. When I arrived at Marco’s Pizza in Pensacola Beach, I knew I had found the right place. The smell of fresh dough and melted cheese wafted through the air like a dream.

The service was friendly and helpful – they served me up with a piping hot pie of pepperoni, sausage, olives and more. Each slice was cooked perfectly, with just the right amount of crunchy crust and flavorful toppings. Even after eating multiple slices, I still felt light as a feather!

If you’re looking for a great pizza experience that’s out of this world, Marco’s Pizza is definitely worth a try. It’s got a nostalgic atmosphere and amazing pizzas that bring me back to Italy every time. Do yourself a favor and check it out – you won’t regret it!

#7 Rotolo’s Pizzeria

When I first walked into the restaurant, I was struck by its charming atmosphere. The staff were friendly and inviting, giving me a real sense of comfort. The decor was well done and there were plenty of tables to sit at which made eating with family or friends enjoyable.

The pizza itself was amazing! They have an extensive menu with many different toppings from around the world including Italian classics like pepperoni, Italian sausage, and olives. Their crust is light and airy with just the right amount of crunch. The sauce was savory and flavorful without being overbearing – perfect for a traditional pizza experience.

I also tried one of their specialty pizzas which had a delicious combination of ham, mushrooms, peppers, onions, and garlic. It was cooked to perfection – perfectly crispy on the outside while still being soft and gooey in the middle.

For dessert I enjoyed a generous helping of tiramisu which rounded out my meal perfectly!

Overall Rotolo’s Pizzeria deserves 5 stars for its excellent food and friendly service! In my opinion it’s easily the best pizza in Pensacola Beach!

#8 Graffiti Pizza

The atmosphere is perfect for tourists, especially sports fans. The food menu is loaded with several delicious options, including vegetarian options – and they even serve alcohol, including hard liquor.

Speaking of their pizza, let me tell you this – their crusts are so thick and chewy that I had to use a knife and fork to eat them. Plus, their toppings were just so flavorful that I couldn’t help but keep eating slice after slice. It’s definitely one of my top choices when it comes to the best pizza in Pensacola Beach.

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery. But if you’re looking for a great restaurant experience, then Graffiti Pizza should be your go-to spot!

#9 Georgio’s Pizza

The atmosphere at Georgio’s is definitely inviting. It’s a great spot for tourists and locals alike. From the moment you enter, you can smell the delicious aroma of freshly-made pizza. The decor is warm and inviting, and the seating areas give it a cozy family-friendly vibe.

The quality of their pizza is definitely something to write home about. I’ve tried them all, from the classic Margherita to the more adventurous Hawaiian; they were all cooked perfectly and tasted delicious! They also have an extensive selection of alcoholic beverages, so you can really make your pizza experience extra special. And if you’ve got kids in tow, they even have a kid’s menu!

However, one downside is that Georgio’s doesn’t offer delivery, so you’ll have to dine in or take out instead. But don’t let that put you off; they also serve desserts such as brownies and ice cream sundaes – perfect for enjoying after a long day exploring the beach!

Overall, I’d highly recommend Georgio’s Pizza for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Pensacola Beach. With its friendly staff, tasty drinks and amazing menu, it won’t disappoint!

If you’re willing to go an extra 25 miles, you can get to 10 more pizza places in Navarre!

#10 Sal’s Pizzeria & Grill

I’d been hearing the buzz around town, so when I finally decided to take the plunge and try Sal’s, I was expecting to be blown away. It didn’t disappoint! The pizza was cooked to perfection – a light golden hue on top with soft and chewy dough underneath.

The toppings were also top-notch. They had every topping you could imagine, from pepperoni to pineapple. The sauce was made with fresh tomatoes and herbs that gave it an amazing flavor. It wasn’t too salty or too sweet – just plain delicious.

The service at Sal’s Pizza & Grill was excellent too. Our server was friendly, attentive and helpful in guiding us through their menu options. And the prices were very reasonable – my party of four had a great meal for less than $30!

Overall, I can confidently say that Sal’s Pizzeria & Grill is one of the best pizza establishments in Pensacola Beach. If you’re looking for an authentic Italian pie experience, this is definitely the place for you!

#11 Domino’s Pizza

I know I’m a bit biased being from the area, but I can honestly say that Domino’s Pizza has some of the best pizza around. The dough is light and fluffy with just the right amount of crunchiness when you bite into it. The toppings are always fresh and flavorful, and the sauce is always delicious. On top of that, the service at Domino’s Pizza is always friendly and attentive.

Overall, this is definitely one of my favorite places for pizza in Pensacola Beach. Whether you’re looking for a quick slice on the go, an entire pie for friends or family, or even a delivery to satisfy your late-night cravings – Domino’s Pizza has you covered! If you’re ever in town, do yourself a favor and try out their pizza — it really is some of the best around!

#12 Pizzaluté

When I first stepped foot in Pizzaluté, it felt like a warm, inviting place. I particularly enjoyed the atmosphere with its sporty decor and TVs playing the latest games around the room. And there’s plenty of seating both indoors and outdoors for those who like to watch sports while munching on some delicious pizza.

The menu offers several vegetarian options for those so inclined – something that’s rare in this part of Florida. But even if you’re not a veggie lover, you’ll still find plenty of classic pizzas that are sure to satisfy. With toppings such as basil pesto, shrimp, prosciutto or goat cheese, they definitely have something for everyone! And as an extra perk, they also serve beer and wine too.

One small downside though is that they don’t deliver…but really how much of a sacrifice it is when your taste buds will be reaping all the benefits?! After my visit to Pizzaluté, I can say with certainty that it’s one of the best pizza spots around Pensacola Beach — if not THE best!