Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in St Augustine Beach (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in St Augustine Beach (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

125 Views

I’m no stranger to pizza, having sampled pies all over the world. But could there be real contenders in this sleepy Florida beach town? With a flight booked and a food critic’s enthusiasm, I set off to review 12 of the best pizza places in St Augustine Beach!

My mission? To find out what makes each restaurant stand out and decide who offers the very best pizza in St Augustine Beach. Get ready for an epic journey filled with delicious pies, hilarious anecdotes, and maybe even a few surprises along the way.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Real Peel Pizza

First, the atmosphere was astounding. The restaurant was so inviting with its cheerful décor and warm ambience. It looked like an Italian bistro but with a modern twist. Plus, there’s a special kids’ menu for those families with young children!

I got to sample all the top picks on the menu and each dish had unique flavors that I’ve never experienced before. They even have several vegetarian options which were incredibly delicious!

By far, my favorite topping was the Italian sausage and capers combination – it was out of this world! The crispy crust had just enough crunch and yet still gave way to each mouthful of gooey cheese and flavorful toppings. It’s no wonder they boast some of the best pizza in St Augustine Beach!

The only downside I found is that Real Peel Pizza doesn’t offer delivery. That said, considering how phenomenal their pizzas are, I’m more than happy to make the trip for some truly remarkable pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in St. Augustine!

#2 Violas

I’m not exaggerating either – the taste was like nothing I’d ever experienced before. From the thin crust to the amazing array of toppings, everything at Violas was top-notch. Plus, they were even able to accommodate my vegetarian friends with some great options!

But it wasn’t just the pizza that impressed me – their selection of alcohol and hard liquor made for a great spot to watch sports, or just meet up with old buddies and catch up. And if you’ve got kids with you, they even offer a kid’s menu so everyone can be happy.

Lastly, and perhaps my favorite part of Violas: The dessert! From crepes to ice cream sundaes, I swear that each and every one was insanely good – an absolute must-try for any foodie looking for a fantastic dinner experience.

The only downside is that there’s no delivery option. But hey, that gives you an excuse to come visit St Augustine Beach and experience the deliciousness of Violas in person! Trust me when I say it’s worth it – this place truly serves up some of the best pizza in St Augustine Beach!

#3 Carmelo’s Pizzeria

The owners, the Melinos, are great hosts and they know how to make a fantastic pie. The ingredients are always fresh, and their dough is made with love. I had their classic cheese pizza with green peppers and mushrooms, and it was out of this world!

The atmosphere in the restaurant was cheerful and inviting. It was very cozy, and the staff were friendly and attentive.

One thing that really stood out to me about Carmelo’s Pizzeria was their commitment to sustainability. All of the ingredients used in their recipes come from local farmers who practice responsible farming methods. This kind of care for the environment definitely adds to the quality of the food here!

In conclusion, Carmelo’s Pizzeria is my top pick for best pizza in St Augustine Beach. Not only does it have consistently delicious food, but its emphasis on sustainability makes it even more special!

#4 St. Augie’s Pizza

The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with no shortage of friendly staff members. The restaurant had an air of authenticity about it, aided by the mouth-watering aroma wafting out from the ovens.

My eyes lit up as soon as I saw the menu. Before I could even decide what to order, my server came over with a plate of garlic knots – which were nothing short of divine! They set the standard for the rest of my experience there: delicious!

For my main course, I opted for a thick crust pizza loaded with pepperoni, mushrooms, and olives. It arrived quickly – still hot from the oven and oozing cheese. The pizza was cooked perfectly; crispy on the outside but soft on the inside. My taste buds rejoiced at every bite!

To top off my meal, I tried their signature tiramisu cake – a slice of heaven if ever there was one! It was creamy without being too sweet and provided a decadent finish to an already amazing meal.

All in all, St Augie’s Pizza lived up to its reputation: completely worth it and absolutely delicious! Any pizza-lover looking for great food in St Augustine should definitely give this place a try – you won’t be disappointed!

#5 Pizzalley’s Chianti Room

The atmosphere is as inviting and cozy as a quilt-covered sofa on an Italian beach. The staff is friendly, efficient and passionate about their pizza.

When it comes to the pizza, Pizzalley’s Chianti Room doesn’t disappoint. The thin crust is perfectly crisped in the oven and has just the right amount of gooey cheese on top. The variety of toppings are plentiful, but my favorite has to be their signature Pepperoni Supreme – it’s like they’ve managed to capture all the flavor in one slice!

Aside from their amazing pizza, Pizzalley’s Chianti Room also offers other classic Italian dishes like lasagna and calzone that have been carefully crafted with fresh ingredients and authentic recipes.

It’s no wonder why Pizzalley’s Chianti Room is considered some of the best pizza in St Augustine Beach. If you’re ever in town for a visit, be sure to stop by this amazing restaurant and treat yourself to some truly delicious food!

#6 Antonio’s New York Style Pizza

I had the delightful pleasure of trying their classic Margherita pizza, and it was one of the best I’ve ever had. The crust was perfectly thin, light, and crispy; the tomatoes were sweet and deliciously juicy; and the cheese was creamy yet slightly tart. It was an absolute delight!

For my next slice I decided to try something a little more unique: Antonio’s signature creation — The Big Apple. This pizza is a combination of traditional Italian flavors with a hint of Manhattan flair.

The Big Apple consists of a generous helping of mozzarella cheese, sliced prosciutto, fresh basil leaves, and a dollop of ricotta cheese with freshly ground pepper on top. With each bite my taste buds were able to experience something new and exciting while still retaining all the flavor they love from regular pizza.

In conclusion, Antonio’s New York Style Pizza is definitely the best pizza in St Augustine Beach! Not only are their pizzas delicious but you can tell that every pie is made with an incredible amount of care, attention to detail, and passion for perfection — like every good Italian chef should demonstrate! Trust me when I say that you won’t be disappointed when you visit Antonio’s — it will be love at first bite!

If you’re willing to go an extra 27 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Palm Coast!

#7 Anthony’s East Coast Pizza

When I arrived for a late-night snack, the restaurant was bustling with locals enjoying the delicious pies. The pizza was cooked to perfection, with a perfectly crisp crust and just the right amount of gooey cheese. The toppings were flavorful and plentiful – from classic pepperoni to creative combinations like macaroni and cheese.

I also had a chance to speak with some of the staff about the pizzas. They told me about how they use fresh ingredients each day and how they make sure their recipes are top notch. This dedication to quality really shines through in the food!

As far as atmosphere goes, Anthony’s East Coast Pizza has it all – cozy chairs, lively music blasting out of speakers, friendly staff… this place is truly an ode to classic Italian pizzerias!

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in St Augustine Beach, then Anthony’s East Coast Pizza is THE spot! From their delicious pies to their cozy atmosphere, it’s hard to find fault with this restaurant. Go check it out for yourself and see why I’m raving about it so much!

#8 Romano’s On The Beach

The restaurant has a cozy, beachfront atmosphere and the staff were very friendly. The pizza itself was delicious – the crust was light and airy, the sauces were flavorful, and the toppings were fresh.

The highlight of my experience at Romano’s On The Beach had to be the dessert pizza. What could have been a simple topping of Nutella and strawberries was elevated by their unique twist: chorizo! It was sweet and savory all at once, creating a flavor combination that I’ve never experienced before.

Overall, I highly recommend checking out Romano’s On The Beach if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in St Augustine Beach. Trust me, it won’t disappoint!

#9 Mellow Mushroom St. Augustine

I don’t think I’ve ever seen a pizza place with such creativity and variety. From their Classic Kosmic Karma to the Magic Mushroom, I was blown away by the flavor combinations Mellow Mushroom was able to achieve. They have unique options like the Avocado White Pie and Pesto Primo Grindadio that are so delicious they will have me coming back again and again.

The service at Mellow Mushroom St. Augustine is outstanding too! The waitstaff is always friendly and helpful in making sure you get exactly what you want from your pizza experience.

Plus, the atmosphere of the restaurant adds to its charm. There’s always great music playing, plenty of seating for groups of all sizes, and it’s clean throughout!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in St Augustine Beach then look no further than Mellow Mushroom St. Augustine – you won’t be disappointed!

#10 Tony’s Pizza New York Style

The pizza is absolutely delicious and it definitely has that New York style taste. The tomato sauce is just perfect- not too tart and not too sweet. The crust is crunchy and the toppings are cooked to perfection.

What really sets Tony’s Pizza apart from the rest is their unique selection of toppings. From their classic pepperoni, to their gourmet spinach, artichoke, and feta combo, you won’t find anything like it in all of St Augustine Beach!

Their service is outstanding too – always friendly and attentive. They’ll make sure your order is delivered hot and on time, every time!

Overall, I wholeheartedly recommend Tony’s Pizza New York Style for anyone looking for the best pizza in St Augustine Beach. Don’t take my word for it- try it out for yourself and see what you think!

#11 Vinny’s Pizza

I stopped in for lunch one day, and couldn’t believe how good the pizza was! Everything from the dough to the sauce was perfection. The cheese melted in my mouth like snowflakes on a winter night and the toppings were cooked just right.

The atmosphere was great too – cozy yet lively, with a bustling crowd of locals that seemed like they’d grown up together. Plus, the service was wonderful – friendly and attentive.

My favorite part of the experience was being able to try so many different types of pizzas. From classic pepperoni and mushroom to something more daring like eggplant and spinach, there’s something for everyone at Vinny’s Pizza!

All in all, I definitely rate this place as one of the best in St Augustine Beach. If you’re looking for amazing pizza that will make your taste buds sing, you won’t be disappointed at Vinny’s Pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 29 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Jacksonville Beach!

#12 Pizzalley’s on St. George

I’ve tasted pizza in some of the most exotic places, and I can honestly say that Pizzalley’s has outdone them all. The dough was crispy and flavorful, just the way it should be. The sauce was sweet and tangy, with a hint of garlic, which complemented the flavor of the dough perfectly. The toppings were fresh and generous – not skimpy at all! The cheese was stringy yet creamy – a real feat for any pizzeria!

The atmosphere at Pizzalley’s is also great – it’s a laid back place with a really nice staff that always greeted us with friendly smiles. Plus, they offer outdoor seating on their patio so you can enjoy your meal while taking in the stunning views of St Augustine Beach.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in St Augustine Beach, look no further than Pizzalley’s! I can honestly say that their pies are some of the best I’ve come across on my travels around the world.