Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Tinley Park (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Illinois

Best Pizza in Tinley Park (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

104 Views

After trekking around the world sampling different kinds of pizza, I decided it was time to take a trip down south and check out what Tinley Park had to offer. After visiting 12 pizza places I think I’ve come across some mouth-watering gems that are sure to tantalize your taste buds!

My journey wasn’t just about finding amazing pizza though – it was an adventure in trying out unique flavors from all types of pizzerias throughout Tinley Park. Along the way, my taste buds encountered everything from classic Neapolitan-style pies to more experimental offerings with inventive topping combinations.

So join me on this journey as I present my top picks for the best pizza in Tinley Park. Bon appetite!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Illinois

#1 Village Pizza

The moment I stepped through the double doors into this cozy restaurant, I knew it was going to be a memorable experience. The staff warmly welcomed me and the overwhelming smell of cheese and tomato sauce filled my senses with delight.

As I looked around the restaurant, it was easy to see why this joint has such a strong reputation; everything from the freshly painted walls to the brightly lit selection board made me feel right at home.

I decided to go with the classic Village Pizza pie, which is loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers and onions. After one bite, I realized why people come back again and again; this pizza had all the elements of a great pizza – crispy crust that wasn’t too thick or too thin and an incredible combination of flavors that left my taste buds in complete bliss.

The service at Village Pizza was top-notch; they were quick to get my order out and even when things got busy, they never lost their smiling attitude. In addition to amazing pizza, they offer some unique side dishes such as garlic knots, chicken wings and mozzarella sticks – all of which are delicious!

If you’re ever feeling a bit peckish in Tinley Park – look no further than Village Pizza; it’s definitely one of the best spots for great tasting pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Orland Park!

#2 Jet’s Pizza

Upon arriving, I was greeted by the friendly staff who were eager to tell me about the restaurant. The atmosphere is casual and inviting – it feels like everyone in Tinley Park knows each other!

The pizza itself is nothing short of amazing. They offer a wide variety of pizzas, from classic cheese and pepperoni to specialty versions topped with everything from jalapeños to feta cheese. The crust is baked perfectly – not too thick and not too thin – for the perfect balance of crunch and chewiness. The sauce is robust and flavorful without being overwhelming, and the toppings are always fresh!

I think it’s safe to say that Jet’s Pizza has earned its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Tinley Park! So if you’re ever in the area, stop by Jet’s Pizza for some delicious-tasting pizza. I guarantee you won’t be disappointed!

#3 Ed & Joe’s Restaurant & Pizzeria

I was absolutely blown away by the flavor and quality of their pizzas. The crust was flavorful and slightly crisp, and the toppings were fresh, juicy, and delicious. I tried the house special which had pepperoni, sausage, onions, peppers and mushrooms – it was an immediate hit! The service was friendly and prompt; my pizza was cooked to perfection in just a few minutes. They also have a wide selection of other Italian-style dishes such as calzones, stromboli and lasagna.

The atmosphere at Ed & Joe’s is cozy but still bustling with activity. There’s plenty of seating so you don’t have to worry about waiting for your turn. The decor is classic pizza joint style – checkered tablecloths, red-and-white walls, colorful posters on the wall – but with modern touches that make it feel fresh and inviting.

Overall I’d give Ed & Joe’s Restaurant & Pizzeria five stars for producing some of the best pizza in Tinley Park! Highly recommended if you’re looking for great Italian food (not to mention a great time)!

#4 Nancy’s Pizza

I was eagerly anticipating a good meal when I pulled into the parking lot – and boy was I not disappointed! The restaurant itself has a quaint, charming atmosphere with its rustic wood furnishings and cozy vibes.

The staff at Nancy’s were incredibly friendly and helpful from start to finish. From the moment I walked in, they made me feel welcome and their enthusiasm for pizza was contagious.

As for the food, it truly exceeded my expectations! Their thin-crust pizzas are cooked to perfection in a blazing-hot oven that yields delicious crispy results. My favorite pizza of all had to be the classic Margherita – it clearly showed off their skill with simple ingredients like sauce, cheese, and basil.

The best part of my visit to Nancy’s Pizza certainly had to be dessert! Their creamy cannoli was one of the lightest and most flavorful treats I’ve had in years. It was an absolutely heavenly end to my dining experience there.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Tinley Park (which you are!), then Nancy’s Pizza is definitely your go-to spot! Delicious food, warm hospitality, and great value make this place a must-visit for any pizza connoisseur like myself.

#5 Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere of the restaurant is excellent. The chic yet cozy vibe makes you feel like you’re in a family-owned pizzeria while they offer the same quality of a big restaurant chain.

As for the pizza itself, you can taste that they take great pride in making each pie. Every slice was cooked to perfection and filled with so many layers of flavor! The buttery crust, gooey cheese, and flavorful sausage all made for an amazing pizza experience. I don’t think I’ve ever had better pizza than this before!

All around, Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria did not disappoint! They have definitely earned their title as having the best pizza in Tinley Park – I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for an out of this world pizza experience!

#6 Blaze Pizza

From the moment I walked into Blaze Pizza, I was absolutely delighted by the atmosphere and decor. The restaurant is sleek and modern, with an open fire oven at the center of the space that mesmerizes you with its beauty.

The staff were also extremely friendly and gave me a warm welcome when I arrived. That kind of hospitality really made a difference in my decision to give Blaze Pizza a chance.

Speaking of chancing, it’s safe to say that I made the right decision! Not only did they have fantastic pizza options on their menu, but they also gave me the chance to customize my own creation from their wide selection of toppings and sauces. From pepperoni to black olives and everything in between, Blaze Pizza had it all!

But what about taste? Well, let’s just say it exceeded my expectations! The crust was cooked perfectly and each topping was fresh and flavorful. Even better, everything about the pizza was evenly distributed – no one piece had too much or too little of anything!

Overall, I’m convinced that Blaze Pizza is not only one of the best pizza restaurants in Tinley Park, but also one of the best pizzerias in the world! Highly recommend this place for your next delicious dining experience.

#7 Cuzin’s Tavern, Gaming & Pizza Tinley Park

On my first visit, I was amazed to find a small but inviting atmosphere filled with gaming tables and TVs tuned to sports. The staff was friendly and eager to show me their best dishes. And that’s when I got the pizza. Wow! The crust had a nice crunch, the cheese was flavorful and melted perfectly, and the toppings were fresh.

After indulging in the delicious pizza at Cuzin’s Tavern, Gaming & Pizza Tinley Park, I walked out convinced that this place serves some of the best pizza in Tinley Park! It’s definitely worth a visit for both gamers and foodies alike!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Oak Lawn!

#8 Nancy’s Pizzeria

The crust was perfectly crisp, the sauce was flavorful and the cheese was the right mix of creamy and ooey-gooey. The toppings were fresh and plentiful — I had pepperoni, sausage and jalapeño, but there are so many to choose from!

The atmosphere at Nancy’s is great too. It has a cozy and inviting vibe; old-fashioned Italian charm combined with modern-day comfort. There’s also a full bar where you can enjoy some beer or wine while you wait for your pizza to arrive — that’s an extra bonus!

I must say, I am very impressed by Nancy’s Pizzeria. I know it won’t be long before it becomes the talk of the town in Tinley Park as one of the best pizza places around!

#9 Aurelio’s Pizza Tinley Park

The crust is nice and thick, perfect for folding over and eating with one hand. It’s also got a delicious crunch that’ll have you dreaming of pizza all night long.

The sauce at Aurelio’s Pizza Tinley Park is surprisingly flavorful for a small town restaurant – it has both a spicy kick and a sweetness that compliments each slice perfectly. Plus, there are plenty of topping options to choose from, making the pizza even more unique!

But what really makes Aurelio’s Pizza Tinley Park stand out from other pizzerias is the level of care put into each slice. Even though I’m just a food critic, I could tell that the ingredients were fresh and that the staff took great pride in every pie they made. That commitment to quality shines through when you take a bite!

In conclusion, if you’re in Tinley Park looking for some truly delicious pizza, then Aurelio’s Pizza Tinley Park is your place to go!

#10 Arrenello’s Pizza

I was immediately blown away by the atmosphere of the restaurant. It was inviting and unpretentious, yet modern and stylish – a great balance I like to see in a pizza joint. Plus, with its location in the heart of downtown, Arrenello’s Pizza is convenient for all those looking for an enjoyable night out!

The service was also great – friendly staff that took care to understand my preferences and help me select the perfect pizza combination. The staff were also incredibly knowledgeable about pizzas from all over the world.

And then there was the pizza. Wow! If you want some seriously delicious pizza that captures traditional flavors with a modern twist, then this is the place to go. The crusts were perfectly cooked but moderate in thickness while still leaving room for creativity in topping options. I ordered a classic pepperoni pizza with their famous garlic buttercream sauce on top and it did not disappoint! Every bite had me wanting more.

Overall, Arrenello’s Pizza has quickly become one of my favorite spots in Tinley Park and I can confidently say that it has some of the best pizza around – hands down!

#11 Fratello’s Deli & Cafe

The atmosphere was warm and cozy, making it perfect for a dinner date or a family gathering. The staff was friendly and they went out of their way to make sure my experience was top-notch.

As for the pizza, it was nothing short of amazing. The dough was cooked to perfection with an airy yet chewy texture that melted in my mouth. The sauce had just the right amount of acidity that I look for in a good pizza, and the toppings were flavorful but not overpowering.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Tinley Park, make sure to check out Fratello’s Deli & Cafe!

#12 Little Joe’s Pizza

I’m not just saying this because I’m a food critic either–the pizza here is truly something special. The crust is perfectly thin, and the sauces are unbelievably savory. You can really tell that they use only the freshest ingredients in all of their pies.

The cheese selection at Little Joe’s Pizza is great too! Mozzarella, cheddar, feta, and more — you name it, they’ve got it. It’s also worth noting that their pepperoni has a unique spice to it that really stands out from the crowd.

If you’re feeling adventurous, I’d definitely recommend getting one of their specialty pizzas! They have some truly unique combinations that will leave your taste buds tantalized. Whether you’re looking for something sweet or savory, there’s sure to be something on the menu to satisfy your cravings.

Little Joe’s Pizza is quite simply the best pizza in Tinley Park. The prices are fair, the atmosphere cozy and inviting, and the quality of ingredients top-notch. If you’re ever in town and looking for a slice of authentic Chicago-style pizza, look no further than Little Joe’s Pizza!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria

When I first walked into Lou Malnati’s, I was greeted by a friendly staff who seemed genuinely excited to serve me their mouthwatering masterpiece. As I sat down, I couldn’t help but notice the aroma of melted cheese and freshly baked dough filling the air. My taste buds were already doing a happy dance in anticipation.

I decided to order their classic deep dish pizza, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint. The crust was thick, buttery, and had just the right amount of crunch. It was like biting into a cloud made of bread. The cheese was ridiculously gooey and stretched out in the most satisfying way. I could have played a game of cheese tug of war with it!

The sauce was perfectly tangy, with just the right amount of seasoning. And let’s not forget about the toppings! The pepperoni slices were so beautifully spaced out, it was like they were doing a synchronized swimming routine. Each bite was an explosion of flavor and joy.

As I devoured slice after slice, I couldn’t help but be grateful for this pizza revelation. Lou Malnati’s has truly nailed the art of deep dish pizza. It’s a harmonious symphony of dough, cheese, and sauce that is sure to please even the most discerning pizza connoisseur.

So if you find yourself in Tinley Park, don’t miss the chance to experience the glory that is Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria. Trust me, your taste buds will be forever grateful, and your waistline, well, that’s a small price to pay for pizza perfection!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria

Stepping into Lou Malnati’s, I felt like I had entered a secret pizza society where only the finest dough-spinning wizards gather. The aroma of freshly baked crust wafted through the air, enticing me to abandon all hope of a healthy meal and embrace my inner pizza monster.

Now, let’s talk about their thin crust. It’s so thin, you could use it as a frisbee to challenge your friends to an unconventional game. But don’t waste it like that, people! It’s meant to be savored, not thrown around like a flying disk from the ’90s.

The first bite was like a flavor explosion—a jubilee of tangy tomato sauce, melty cheese, and a symphony of toppings that made my taste buds do a little happy dance. It was a harmonious combination of crunch and chew that left me pleasantly surprised.

And can we talk about their toppings? They’ve got it all, from classic pepperoni to exotic combinations that would make even the most seasoned pizza connoisseur raise an eyebrow. I tried their Chicago Fire pizza, topped with spicy sausage, jalapenos, and a fiery red sauce that left my tongue begging for mercy. It was like a rollercoaster ride for my taste buds, in the best possible way.

So if you’re in Tinley Park and craving a thin crust pizza that will transport you to pizza nirvana, look no further than Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria. Your taste buds will thank you, and your waistline might slightly resent you, but who cares? Life’s too short to count calories when there’s pizza this good.