Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Avalon NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Avalon NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

124 Views

I’ve tasted pizza from around the world, but I’m confident that Avalon has some of the best options. I recently spent time in the area sampling slices from twelve different places, and my taste buds were absolutely delighted.

Join me as I share with you my experiences eating some of the best pizzas Avalon NJ has to offer. I promise to keep it lighthearted and humorous as I rate each one!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Zio Niccolo Pizza

The flavor was like a torrent of joy that rushed over my taste buds! I ordered the ‘Grande Speciale’ and the toppings were piled high with generous dollops of sausage, peppers, mushrooms and extra cheese – pure deliciousness.

The crust was light and fluffy yet crisp, cooked to perfection. The cheese was gooey and melted in my mouth instantly. Every bite oozed flavor – it’s no wonder why this is one of the most talked about pizzerias in Avalon NJ!

The atmosphere was a trip down nostalgia lane with classic Italian music playing in the background. The staff were friendly and accommodating even though I came in late.

If you’re ever looking for a little slice of Italy in Avalon, NJ then look no further than Zio Niccolo Pizza. Trust me when I say you won’t be disappointed – their pizza is truly the best pizza in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Wildwood!

#2 Seven Mile Pies

The crust here is light and crispy, just the way I like it. The fresh tomatoes, garlic and herbs make the perfect tomato sauce to top it off. The cheese is sharp and flavorful – never too greasy or overbearing. Each bite was a delight!

I especially enjoyed their roasted vegetable special: tender eggplant, peppers and onions in an olive oil garlic sauce that was out of this world. It may have been one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

Their service was friendly and attentive, too. They even helped me pick out a bottle of wine to pair with my meal – something I appreciated very much.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Avalon NJ, look no further than Seven Mile Pies!

#3 Berardi Brothers Pizza

I arrived at the restaurant and was immediately greeted by a friendly, smiling face. The decor was charmingly rustic and cozy, which made me feel right at home. After ordering my favorite pizza – their classic pepperoni with extra cheese – I quickly became aware that this pie isn’t your typical slice! From the moment I took my first bite, I knew it was out of this world.

The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside yet fluffy on the inside – and it simply melted in my mouth. The tomatoes were ripe, flavorful, and juicy while the cheese was gooey and freshly grated. And the pepperoni? Well let’s just say it completed what can only be described as an edible masterpiece.

If you’re ever in Avalon NJ looking for an amazing slice of pizza then make sure to stop by Berardi Brothers Pizza for some of the best pizza around!

#4 Nemo’s Pizza Of Stone Harbor

I was thoroughly impressed with the quality of the pizza here. The crust was perfectly crisp and the toppings were truly delicious. The sauce had just the right amount of flavor, not too acidic or salty.

The atmosphere of the restaurant is also great for a pizza joint. It’s bright yet cozy, which made me very relaxed as I savored my pie. Plus, they have an overall family-friendly atmosphere that can’t be matched by other restaurants in Avalon NJ!

Nemo’s Pizza Of Stone Harbor has some of the most creative topping combinations I’ve seen anywhere in my travels – whether it’s their amazing smoked salmon & mango topping or their classic pepperoni special sauce, you’re sure to find something that’ll tantalize your taste buds.

All in all, Nemo’s Pizza Of Stone Harbor is definitely one of the best pizzeria in Avalon NJ! Whether you live nearby or are visiting from out-of-town, you won’t be disappointed with your meal here!

#5 Claudio’s Pizza Kitchen

The first thing that struck me when I walked in was the cozy and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant had a nice warm vibe and the staff were very friendly and helpful.

The pizza itself is something to write home about! Their classic Italian-style pizzas are made with fresh ingredients, giving it an incredibly flavorful taste. The crust is perfectly crisp without being too hard and the toppings are always cooked to perfection.

I also recommend trying their specialty pies, like the “Tuscan” or the “Roman” – they’re absolutely delicious! And if you’re looking for something a bit more adventurous, they have some delicious gourmet pizzas that will please any palate.

And of course no visit to Claudio’s Pizza Kitchen would be complete without trying one of their amazing desserts – their tiramisu is simply out of this world!

All in all, Claudio’s Pizza Kitchen is definitely one of the best pizza places in Avalon NJ! Highly recommended!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Wildwood Crest!

#6 Pizza in Cape May – Pizza Heaven

The atmosphere is perfect – dimly lit, cozy and inviting. The pizza itself is heavenly! The crust is thin and crunchy, the sauce is flavorful and savory, the toppings are fresh and abundant. And of course, they have a great selection of craft beers which are a perfect accompaniment to any pizza.

The service here is top-notch as well. The staff are friendly and helpful – they seem to really care about making sure you get exactly what you want.

Overall I highly recommend Pizza in Cape May – Pizza Heaven for anyone looking for the best pizza in Avalon NJ! It’s certainly worth a visit if you’re ever in town.

#7 Domino’s Pizza

The pizza is consistently good and always arrives on time. I’ve been to their place a few times now and they never disappoint. The crust is perfectly golden brown and crispy, while the cheese is plentiful and delicious. The sauce has the perfect amount of tanginess and sweetness—it’s truly a flavor explosion in your mouth.

The toppings are always fresh and varied. From bacon, to mushrooms, to pepperoni, you can find all your favorite toppings at Domino’s Pizza. My personal favorite is their supreme pizza with double cheese – it’s simply divine!

If you’re in Avalon NJ looking for great pizza, Domino’s Pizza should be your top choice. They truly serve some of the best pizza in Avalon NJ that you can find!

#8 Fratelli’s Wood-Fired Pizzeria – Sea Isle City

The pizza here is almost as delicious as the views of the ocean! When you first enter, you are greeted by the smell of wood-fired ovens. The atmosphere is warm and inviting – perfect for a date night or family get together.

The pizzas here have been cooked to perfection, with a crispy crust that is just the right amount of charred. And, boy, does Fratelli’s know how to stuff their pies! Each delicious bite filled with amazing toppings that perfectly compliment each other. I especially recommend trying the pepperoni pizza – it’s sheer deliciousness!

To top it all off, their service was also outstanding. Our server was friendly and attentive, making sure we were having a great experience while at Fratelli’s.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Avalon NJ, look no further than Fratelli’s Wood-Fired Pizzeria – Sea Isle City! Trust me – you won’t be disappointed!

#9 Uncle Oogie’s Pizzeria & Specialty Sandwiches

The atmosphere is great, and the family-run pizzeria has a cozy, inviting vibe. The staff are friendly and welcoming and truly make you feel at home.

But of course, the thing that really matters is the pizza! Uncle Oogie’s knows what they’re doing when it comes to pizza. The crust is thin and crisp, just the way I like it. They also have a great selection of toppings and sauces to choose from. For me, their specialty pies are where it’s at—the Alfredo Garlic with fresh basil, mushrooms, onion and roasted red peppers was particularly delicious!

I also sampled some of their sandwiches while I was there and they were equally as good as their pizzas. Their Philly cheesesteak sandwich cooked to perfection with oozy cheese melted over top was definitely one of my favorites.

In conclusion, I can confidently say that Uncle Oogie’s offers some of the best pizza in Avalon NJ (and beyond!). Whether you’re looking for a cozy spot to enjoy a classic pie or want to try something new, this place won’t let you down!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Ocean City!

#10 Stone Harbor Pizza Pub

The atmosphere was perfect for a food critic like me – cozy and inviting, with the smell of cheese and freshly made dough. The waitstaff was friendly and accommodating, and made sure I had plenty of napkins and drinks throughout the evening.

As for the pizza, it was incredible! The crust was crunchy yet still light and fluffy, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. My particular favorite was their classic Margherita pizza – it had tomatoes that tasted like they came straight off the vine paired with just enough mozzarella to make it cheesy but not too heavy.

I also sampled some of their other dishes, all of which were divine. Whether you’re looking for a quick slice or an entire meal, Stone Harbor Pizza Pub is your go-to spot for great pizza in Avalon NJ!

#11 Circle Pizza

The first thing that impressed me when I arrived at Circle Pizza was the atmosphere. It’s both cozy and inviting, with nice seating and a warm fireplace. The second thing that I noticed were the wonderful aromas of freshly made pizza in the air. It was enough to make my mouth water!

When it came time to order, I had a hard time deciding because there were so many great options. After much deliberation, I decided on a classic cheese pizza with pepperoni and onions. And boy, was I glad I did! The pizza was delicious – the crust was crispy and thick, while the toppings were fresh and flavorful. Even though I’m only visiting Avalon NJ for a short time, it won’t be complete unless I come back to Circle Pizza again!

In summary, Circle Pizza is definitely one of the best places to get a great slice of pizza in Avalon NJ. The atmosphere is welcoming, the pizzas are delicious; what more could you ask for? Highly recommended!

#12 Ristorante Luciano

The pizzas here are all cooked to perfect perfection. The ingredients are top-notch, the sauce is flavorful and the crust is just crunchy enough — they know how to make a great pizza.

Even better than the pizza itself is Ristorante Luciano’s dessert menu. If you come here, you definitely need to leave some room for dessert because they have some insanely good sweet treats!

Now, if there was one downside to this place, it’s that they don’t offer delivery. So if you’re having a pizza night at home, you’ll probably need plan ahead and pick up a pizza from Ristorante Luciano before hand.

All in all, I highly recommend Ristorante Luciano for anyone looking for the best pizza in Avalon NJ!