Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Findlay OH (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Ohio

Best Pizza in Findlay OH (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

127 Views

I’m pleased to share my review of the top twelve pizza places, which I carefully critiqued after traversing around the city in search of a cheesy slice. From traditional Italian delights to unique takes on classic recipes, there’s something tasty for everyone.

I’ll be your guide through the pros and cons of each place – bringing you all my cheesy, saucy knowledge! I promise not to take myself too seriously and to deliver an entertaining and informative review with a humorous, lighthearted tone. So let’s get started!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Ohio

#1 Dougie John’s Pizza LLC – FINDLAY

My first bite of Dougie John’s pizza was a revelation. On the outside, it looks like your average small-town pizza joint. But the instant I took a bite, I knew something special was going on here. The crust was perfectly chewy and had just the right amount of char. And the sauce! Oh my goodness – it had just enough sweetness and tantalizing flavor that one could easily mistake it for homemade.

On top of all this were generous amounts of cheese and pepperoni with a hint of Italian herbs. All in all, it’s no wonder why this place has become known as the best pizza in Findlay OH!

If you’re in Findlay OH and looking for some top-notch pizza, Dougie John’s Pizza LLC – FINDLAY is your go-to spot! Not only have they perfected their delicious pies, but their friendly atmosphere ensures an enjoyable visit every time. Plus, they even have outdoor seating if you want to take advantage of those summer days while enjoying the best pizza around. So don’t miss out – head over to Dougie John’s Pizza LLC – FINDLAY today and get ready to be amazed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 23 miles, you can get to 13 more pizza places in Bowling Green!

#2 Jac & Do’s Pizza

The moment I stepped in the door, I knew I was in for a treat. The ambiance is fantastic, with classic Italian decor surrounding the restaurant and a staff that looks like they actually enjoy working there.

As for the food, it’s incredible! The pizza crust is crispy but still has plenty of flavor. Plus, the toppings are fresh and delicious. This place also offers some unique topping combinations that you won’t find at just any old pizzeria – definitely something worth trying out!

I also love how Jac & Do’s Pizza encourages us to get creative and make our own pizza masterpiece. You can pick any combination of toppings you want, which makes for an entertaining dinner experience.

To sum it all up: if you’re looking for the best pizza in Findlay OH, then look no further than Jac & Do’s Pizza! It doesn’t get much better than this!

#3 Joey Fratello’s Pizzeria

When I first stepped into the restaurant, I was taken aback by the wafting aroma of garlic, herbs and freshly baked dough. The place oozes old-world Italian charm with its red-and-white checkered tablecloths and brass accents.

The pizza itself is really something special. They use only the finest ingredients to achieve a perfect texture and balance of flavors—the crust is thick and crunchy, the sauce is tangy and slightly sweet, and the cheese is abundant but not overwhelming. All in all, it’s an incredibly delicious experience.

But what really sets Joey Fratello’s apart from other pizzerias is their innovative toppings. Whether it’s duck sausage or goat cheese, they always find a way to create unique combinations that make each slice a culinary delight.

In short, if you want some of the best pizza in Findlay OH, go to Joey Fratello’s Pizzeria—I guarantee you won’t be disappointed!

#4 Pieology Pizzeria Findlay/Independent Square

I had the pleasure of tasting their creations and found them to be utterly divine. From the fresh, hand-tossed crusts down to their unique and flavorful toppings, I can confidently say that this is some of the best pizza I’ve ever eaten!

The atmosphere at Pieology Pizzeria is also top-notch. The decor is warm and inviting, and it’s clear that the staff really care about providing an enjoyable experience for all their customers.

No matter what type of pizza you’re in the mood for, Pieology Pizzeria has something to offer everyone. Whether you choose one of their signature pies or create your own custom masterpiece, you can be sure that it will be cooked to perfection!

If you’re ever looking for the best pizza in Findlay OH, I highly recommend checking out Pieology Pizzeria!

#5 Rossilli’s Restaurant

I recently visited and was stunned by their variety of options – from vegetarian to meat, and even the hard liquor they offer! My friends and I settled with a delicious pepperoni pizza, which tasted like it had been cooked straight from Italy.

The atmosphere at Rossilli’s was also impressive. Not only was it a great spot for tourists, but the restaurant itself looked quite cozy with its casual setting. We felt like we could spend all night there chatting with friends over drinks and relaxing music.

Unfortunately, Rossilli’s doesn’t deliver, so you’ll have to head down in person if you want to enjoy the amazing food. But boy is it worth it! On top of their amazing pizzas they also have some insanely good desserts. Every single one of my friends had a fantastic time and were raving over how good everything was!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Findlay OH, Rossilli’s Restaurant is definitely the place to go! I highly recommend it as a must-see on your list of stops while touring Ohio!

#6 Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill

The first sign that I was in for a treat was the aroma of freshly baked pizza dough wafting the moment I stepped through their door. Talk about mouth-watering! The interior of the restaurant had a cozy, inviting atmosphere and you could tell that it’s a place where people come to enjoy great food, chat with friends and family, and just relax.

The pies here range from classic pepperoni to more creative concoctions like buffalo chicken or Mediterranean veggie – so there really is something for everyone. The slices were thin yet hearty and flavorful – truly some of the best pizza that I’ve ever tasted. Each slice was smothered in melted cheese goodness that left me wanting more – definitely worth every penny.

The service here was also outstanding – they could not have been more friendly or attentive. Everyone seemed to be enjoying themselves and celebrating good times which made this already enjoyable experience even better.

In conclusion, Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill is unquestionably one of Findlay’s best pizza joints – even by this world traveler’s standards! I highly recommend giving them a try if you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience.

#7 Campus Pollyeyes

The first time I visited Campus Pollyeyes, I was totally blown away. The pizza is simply sublime. The crust is thin and crispy, the cheese is perfectly melted and the toppings are always fresh and delicious. Every bite is a party in your mouth!

I especially love their signature creation, the “Sloppy Joe” pizza: a nice blend of ground beef, tomatoes, onions and green peppers—all topped with mozzarella cheese. It’s one of my favorite pizzas anywhere.

The atmosphere at Campus Pollyeyes is also great. There’s always something fun going on in the restaurant; they seem to know just how to keep people entertained while they’re enjoying their meal. And if you get bored of pizza, you can always order up some fresh wings or a big plate of nachos.

All in all, this place gets my highest recommendation. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Findlay OH, head over to Campus Pollyeyes—you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 33 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Lima!

#8 Heavenly Pizza Findlay

I was completely floored when I first tasted the pizza here; it was unlike anything I’ve had before. The crust was crispy, yet still fluffy and light. The toppings were fresh and perfectly balanced with each other. It’s definitely a pizza that stands out from the rest.

The service at Heavenly Pizza Findlay is also top-notch! They are always friendly and make sure that your order is correct the first time. Plus, if you’re looking for a great deal they have daily specials that will keep you coming back for more.

If you’re in Findlay OH, do yourself a favor and try Heavenly Pizza Findlay–you won’t regret it! I can confidently say that this is the best pizza in Findlay OH hands down!

#9 Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders

The atmosphere was a great start to the evening. The owner, who goes by the name Alfredo, was friendly and welcoming from the moment I stepped in the door. Music played in the background as we talked about what kind of pizza I should try. I decided to go with one of their classic pizzas—the Bellacino’s Special, which had pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, and onions on it.

The pizza was cooked to perfection! The crust was delightfully crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. The toppings were fresh and flavorful. Everything tasted like it had been made especially for me! And since they offer a wide variety of sauces and seasonings that you can add to your pizza at no extra cost, I was able to customize my meal just right!

My experience at Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders wasn’t just an enjoyable culinary experience; Alfredo made sure it was also a fun evening out. He interacted with everyone in the restaurant with clear enthusiasm and positive energy. It felt like being invited into his home.

Overall, my trip to Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders definitely proved why it is acclaimed as having the best pizza in Findlay OH!

#10 Domino’s Pizza

The first thing I noticed upon arriving was how friendly and helpful the staff were. When I asked for their best pizza, they quickly directed me to the new “Pepperoni Lover’s Pizza”. And boy let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The crust was absolutely perfect, with a crispy exterior and a soft and chewy center. The pepperoni had just the right amount of spice and the cheese was melted to perfection.

In addition to great pizza, Domino’s also offers delicious sides like garlic breadsticks and cheesy bread. The garlic breadsticks are definitely worth trying – they have just the right amount of garlicky flavor. And don’t worry if you’re on a budget – Domino’s also offers an extensive menu of lunch deals that won’t break your bank!

Overall, I’m rating Domino’s Pizza 5/5 stars. For the best pizza in Findlay OH, look no further than Domino’s Pizza. You won’t be disappointed!

#11 Sbarro

I was blown away by the variety of toppings and their creative combinations! From the classic pepperoni to alfredo with grilled chicken, there’s something for everyone. The flavors are all balanced perfectly, and the crust is just right – crunchy on the outside but light and fluffy on the inside.

The service at Sbarro is top-notch as well. The staff are so friendly, always willing to answer questions or make suggestions. They even gave me a little pizza sampler to help me decide which one I wanted!

Overall, I can confidently say that Sbarro has some of the best pizza in Findlay OH. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a full-course meal, I definitely recommend stopping by this place!

#12 Jac & Do’s Pizza East

From the moment I stepped through the door, I was impressed. The atmosphere was inviting and the decor immediately set the stage for a perfect pizza experience. Even if I hadn’t been on a mission to try out the best pizza around, this place would have won my heart at first sight!

The menu selection did not disappoint either. With traditional Italian favorites as well as some unique choices, there truly is something for everyone’s palate. And then there’s the pizza itself – oh my! When it arrived, I couldn’t believe my eyes (or nose). The aroma wafting from the delicious slices beckoned to me and upon tasting, my taste buds sang in unison of its perfection.

For me, Jac & Do’s Pizza East was an unforgettable experience – and one that I’d highly recommend to anyone who loves great pizza like myself! Yes indeed this place has easily earned its place as one of Findlay OH’s finest pizza establishments. So go ahead and treat yourself – you won’t regret it!