From chunky, cheesy slices to a Chicago-style thin crust, I’ve tried them all. No short cuts were taken – I visited all twelve pizza places in the town to discover which ones are worth writing home about.
Don’t worry, I’m no hard grader! My reviews will be lighthearted and humorous – I want you to enjoy these pies as much as I did. Come with me on this pizza-filled journey through Fond Du Lac and let’s find out together which slice comes out on top!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Wisconsin
#1 JJ.s
- Nice tourist spot
The pizza is cooked to perfection with a thin, crispy crust and just the right amount of homemade tomato sauce. The toppings are always fresh, and there is plenty to choose from. Whether you like an all-meat pizza or something a little more vegetable-oriented, JJ.s has it all.
The service at JJ.’s is also top-notch – friendly, efficient, and always willing to go above and beyond for the customers. The atmosphere of the restaurant is great too – it’s modern and comfortable with plenty of seating and TVs playing sports games.
Overall, my experience at JJ.’s was one of the best pizza experiences I’ve had in Fond Du Lac. It’s definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for some really good pizza!
If you’re willing to go an extra 19 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Oshkosh!
#2 Advice By the Slice LLC
- No delivery
The friendly staff at Advice By the Slice LLC greeted me with open arms when I entered the restaurant. I was immediately drawn to the aroma of freshly baked dough and herbs. The atmosphere of the place was warm, inviting, and relaxed.
I quickly ordered a classic cheese pizza with extra tomatoes, olives, and mushrooms. When it arrived at my table I knew this was going to be something special – it almost looked too good to eat! But that didn’t stop me from devouring every single piece on my plate! The pizza had a light and fluffy crust, while being perfectly crisp around the edges. The vegetables were fresh and plentiful and added great flavor to every bite.
The only drawback to Advice By the Slice LLC is that they don’t offer delivery service – but trust me when I say it’s worth making a trip out there for this incredible pizza experience! So if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Fond Du Lac, look no further than Advice By the Slice LLC – a truly unforgettable experience!
#3 Eaton’s Fresh Pizza – Park Avenue
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- No delivery
The restaurant itself is warm and welcoming – a great place to spend a relaxing evening. The staff was friendly and their pizza knowledge was impressive.
One of the great things about Eaton’s is that it offers a kid’s menu. This makes dining out worry-free for families with young children. There’s also a few vegetarian options for those who don’t eat meat, which is always nice to have.
Although I enjoyed my experience at Eaton’s, there is one downside: they don’t offer delivery service. For those who are too busy or exhausted to go out, this can be an inconvenience.
Overall, I would highly recommend Eaton’s Fresh Pizza – Park Avenue as the best pizza in Fond Du Lac! Great food, friendly atmosphere, and affordable prices make it the perfect place to dine in or take out your favorite pie.
#4 Eaton’s Fresh Pizza – Hickory Street
- No delivery
This restaurant really knows how to make a pizza! The dough is always fresh and perfectly cooked, the flavors of their sauces are incredible, and their wide selection of toppings ensures that I’m never bored. Plus, it’s great for large groups since they offer personal pizzas as well as larger ones.
The only downside of Eaton’s Fresh Pizza – Hickory Street is that there is no delivery option. It would be nice to have the option to get my favorite pizza delivered right to my door! But, despite this minor inconvenience, the deliciousness of the pizza more than makes up for it.
All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Fond Du Lac, look no further than Eaton’s Fresh Pizza – Hickory Street! I guarantee it won’t disappoint.
#5 Toppers Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
The dough is expertly crafted and has the perfect amount of crunch. The sauce is bright and flavorful without being too overpowering. The toppings are always fresh, from classic pepperoni to loaded veggie specialties.
The staff are really friendly and accommodating, which adds to the overall experience you get at Toppers. I’m a bit of a picky eater when it comes to pizza, and they always manage to make me something special that fits my needs perfectly.
The atmosphere at Toppers is cozy and casual, making it a great spot for friends or family. The prices are reasonable too — definitely worth it given how delicious the pizza is!
All in all, Toppers Pizza consistently produces some of the best pizza in Fond Du Lac. It’s an absolute must-visit spot if you’re ever in town!
#6 Ala Roma Pizzeria & Pub
- Great place to watch sports
- Nice tourist spot
- Serves alcohol
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has insanely good dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
I walked in expecting the typical gas station pizza and was delighted to see something completely different. The restaurant had a cozy, intimate atmosphere that made me want to stay all day. They offer a variety of artisan pizzas with top-notch ingredients like fresh mozzarella and locally sourced sausage.
When my pizza arrived, I was blown away by how delicious it was! The thin crust was perfectly cooked and full of flavor. Toppings were generous but not overwhelmed and the cheese blended seamlessly with the other flavors.
The service was also great – friendly staff and attentive waiters eager to please their guests. Plus, they have an impressive selection of craft beers and wines to pair with your meal for an unforgettable experience.
So, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Fond Du Lac, Ala Roma Pizzeria & Pub is definitely worth checking out!
If you’re willing to go an extra 32 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Appleton!
#7 Joe’s Fox Hut
- Great place to watch sports
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
The atmosphere is cozy, yet modern with a mix of exposed brick and blonde wood furniture that sets the perfect tone to enjoy their delectable dishes. Plus, I’m always down for a place that plays classic rock – it just felt like home!
I had the pleasure of trying multiple types of pizzas from Joe’s Fox Hut and can confidently say that their crust is what dreams are made of; thin and light, but still crunchy enough to hold everything together without getting soggy. And the flavor! Definitely one of my top picks when it comes to pizza – so good you won’t want to share!
But let’s not forget about their other toppings. The Italian sausage was cooked perfectly and the mozzarella was melted to cheesy perfection. Even their veggies were as fresh as they come – nothing canned here! All in all, it was an impeccable pizza experience and definitely best pizza in Fond Du Lac.
If you haven’t been to Joe’s Fox Hut, do yourself a favor and head over there right away – you won’t regret it!
#8 Jet’s Pizza
I’m usually a critic when it comes to pizza, but Jet’s Pizza exceeded my expectations. They offer the traditional pizzas you know and love, as well as some unique and delicious creations.
One of my favorite orders was the Jet’s Turbodog – a pizza topped with hot dogs and then baked to perfection. It was an interesting mix of flavors that I just couldn’t get enough of!
The crusts are always cooked perfectly crisp throughout every bite. The staff is super friendly and accommodating which makes the experience even better. The prices are reasonable too – something that’s hard to say about many other places in town.
Overall, Jet’s Pizza is definitely the best pizza in Fond Du Lac and worth checking out if you’re ever in town looking for great pizza!
#9 Sal’s Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
On my first visit to Sal’s, I wasn’t sure what to expect. I’m a bit of a pizza snob, and I was hesitant that a restaurant in such a small town could offer top-notch pizza. Boy, was I wrong!
When we walked in, we were greeted with friendly smiles, and the atmosphere was inviting. We were seated immediately and handed menus that had every kind of pizza imaginable (it took us forever to decide what to order). After finally making our decision, our deliciousness arrived mere minutes later.
The crust was perfect – both light and crunchy – and the sauce had just the right amount of tanginess. All the ingredients on top were fresh and flavorful – from anchovies to artichokes – Sal’s really has something for everyone!
To top it all off, the price is very affordable for such good pizza. So after eating my way around the world, I can honestly say that Sal’s Pizza is some of the best pizza in Fond Du Lac! If you’re ever in town, don’t miss out on this delicious experience.
#10 Gino’s Italian Restaurant
- Has insanely good dessert
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- No delivery
I was invited to sample the food at Gino’s and I was very impressed with what I found. The pizza dough is handmade, resulting in an incredibly flavorful crust that hardly needs any sauce. And speaking of sauces—the selection is amazing! From the classic marinara to the alfredo, there’s something for everyone!
Another great thing about Gino’s is that it serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)—which makes it a great spot for grownups to relax after dinner, too. Not to mention, they have a great kid’s menu with yummy options like cheese pizza or mac and cheese.
But my favorite part of all was the dessert menu. Wow – talk about insanely good! They had just about every dessert you can think of—from cheesecakes to cannolis and everything in between. Yum!
Now, I should note that Gino’s has no delivery option, so if you want their delicious food, you’ll have to come into the restaurant. But don’t worry–Gino’s Italian Restaurant is an awesome tourist spot too with its warm atmosphere and friendly staff – so a visit might just be worth your while!
#11 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
I’m always a bit skeptical when it comes to pizza from chain restaurants, but Papa Murphy’s proved me wrong. The quality of the dough was exceptional, and their unique approach of having customers take home the uncooked pizzas to bake them later actually made for some of the freshest, most flavorful pies I’ve ever had!
The toppings were all fantastic too! I tried several different combinations, including sausage and pepperoni, veggies and cheese, and Hawaiian. Each one was cooked to perfection in my oven at home – making me feel like I had a professional chef in my kitchen!
I also have to compliment Papa Murphy’s on their prices. For the quality of pizza they offer, the price is hard to beat. Plus they often have great deals going on so you can save even more money.
In short, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Fond Du Lac then head on over to Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza. You won’t be disappointed!
If you’re willing to go an extra 37 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Sheboygan!
#12 Bob’s Pizza
The crust was nice and crispy without being tough or dense. The sauce had great flavor with some subtle spice that really made the pizza stand out. The cheese was plenty and melted perfectly.
The selection of toppings was also impressive! Given my travels, I know how hard it is to please everyone, and Bob’s Pizza nailed it – pepperoni, olives, mushrooms, sausages…you name it!
I’ve got to say that the pies they served were quite big as well! Usually when I travel for pizza I don’t get to bring any home with me – not this time around. I’ve got leftovers in my fridge that will keep me eating good tonight.
All in all, Bob’s Pizza is definitely the best pizza spot in Fond Du Lac and worth checking out if you’re ever in town!
