Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Hagerstown MD (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Maryland

Best Pizza in Hagerstown MD (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

319 Views

I’m always on the hunt for the best pie out there and have tasted a dozen of Hagerstown’s top pizza places. I’m looking for two essential things – a delicious crust and incredible flavor. With all that experience, I think I’m qualified to give you an update on the best pizza in town!
Humor plays an important role as I try to navigate through every restaurant’s menu trying to decide if it’s worth a try; this article will be no exception! So join me on this pizza journey that may lead us to some interesting and delicious finds. Ready? Let’s go!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Maryland

#1 Castello’s Pizzeria & Tex Mex

The crust was perfectly crisp and light, just the way I like it. The toppings were flavorful, with a delicious blend of cheeses and other ingredients that left me wanting more! Even the sauce was spot on – not too spicy but not too bland either.

I also tried their combination Tex-Mex pizzas, which were surprisingly delicious. The combination of flavors meshed together perfectly! It was definitely something different from what I’ve had before.

The service was friendly and helpful as well. Our waiter was quick to answer questions and help us decide on our order.

All in all, I was thoroughly impressed with Castello’s Pizzeria & Tex Mex and will definitely be back soon to sample more of their fantastic pizzas! This is the best pizza in Hagerstown MD – don’t miss out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 21 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Frederick!

#2 American Pie Pizzeria

First of all, the crust is second-to-none. It’s perfectly thin and crunchy and it has just the right amount of chewiness. Plus, it never seems to get soggy even when reheated. And the toppings are all top-notch. All of their pizzas come with premium ingredients like fresh tomatoes, tangy peppers, zesty onions and real mozzarella cheese.

The atmosphere is also great – it’s a cozy little spot that always seems to be filled with happy customers chatting over slices of pizza while they wait for their pies. The prices are also very reasonable – you can get two large pizzas for around $20!

All in all, American Pie Pizzeria is definitely one of the best places to get pizza in Hagerstown MD! If you’re looking for an authentic experience with amazing pizza, this place should be at the top of your list.

#3 Dolce – Eastern European Restaurant & Pizza

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting. The staff was extremely friendly and helpful in helping us pick out a delicious pizza. The decor had a European flair that gave the restaurant charm and character.

The menu was extensive, featuring all sorts of unique Eastern European inspired pizzas. We decided to order the Polish Sausage and Kielbasa pie, which had an amazing combination of flavors. The crust was thin and crispy, yet still had a great chewiness to it. The toppings were perfectly cooked and flavorful without being too greasy or salty.

Overall, Dolce – Eastern European Restaurant & Pizza served up some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted! It definitely stands above the rest when it comes to pizza in Hagerstown MD, so if you’re looking for a good slice then this is the place to go!

#4 Little Alex’s Pizzeria

On my first visit to this restaurant, I noticed that they have a wide range of toppings – from classic pepperoni to eggplant parmesan. The pizza itself was delicious, with the perfect balance of sweet tomato sauce and savory cheese. The crust was delightfully thin and crispy, and the chicken wings were spicy and flavorful.

The staff at Little Alex’s Pizzeria were very friendly and attentive. From the welcoming smile when I walked in until the time I left, they made me feel like I belonged there.

Overall, this place is definitely worth visiting if you’re ever in Hagerstown MD looking for great pizza. I’d recommend it to anyone looking for an enjoyable dining experience and some of the best pizza around!

#5 La Trattoria Pizzeria

To start, the atmosphere at La Trattoria Pizzeria is unlike anything I’ve ever experienced. The ambiance is cozy and inviting, yet chic and modern – perfect for a night out with family or friends.

When it comes to the pizza, let me just say this – it’s some of the best pizzas I’ve had in my life! The crust is perfectly cooked and crunchy, but also chewy at the same time. The sauce is savory and flavorful with just the right amount of sweetness, while the cheese melts in your mouth like a dream. The toppings are fresh and flavorful too, ranging from pepperoni to mushrooms to even vegan options!

On top of that, they offer great deals on their pizzas. Whether you’re looking to feed a large group or just want one pie for yourself – their prices won’t break your wallet either way.

Overall, La Trattoria Pizzeria offers some of the best pizza in Hagerstown MD – so if you’re ever in town be sure to give this place a try!

#6 Rocky’s New York Pizza

The presentation was beautiful – the thin crust was golden brown, and the cheese was melted perfectly. The sausage and pepperoni were specifically cut by hand to create an even distribution of flavor throughout each bite. And that sauce! It was a perfectly balanced blend of sweetness, acidity, and spice.

I also tried some unique pizzas such as the smoked Gouda & bacon white pizza. The creamy Gouda combined with thick slices of smoky bacon created a memorable flavor experience.

From the friendly staff, to the warm and inviting atmosphere, Rocky’s New York Pizza is more than just a great place for pizza – it’s a destination for anyone who loves food. I will definitely be back again soon!

#7 Dino’s Pizza

The thin crust was perfection, with a delightful crunch and lots of flavor. The sauce was just the right amount of tang, and the cheese was perfect for my taste.

My favorite part? The toppings! Everything from classic pepperoni to the special ‘Dino’s Special’ topping had a unique and flavorful twist. I especially enjoyed the mushrooms – they were fresh and had just the right amount of buttery goodness.

Service was friendly, efficient, and quick – exactly what I wanted after all that traveling around! Also, Dino’s offers delivery options so you can enjoy their delicious slices straight to your door!

If you’re looking for great pizza in Hagerstown MD, look no further than Dino’s Pizza! It easily earns my two thumbs up as the best pizza in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 29 miles, you can get to 11 more pizza places in Gettysburg!

#8 Pretzel and Pizza Creations

From the moment I stepped foot into this restaurant, I could tell I was in for a treat. The aroma of freshly baked pizza dough wafted through the air, giving me a strong sense of nostalgia as I remembered all the great pizzas I have had around the world.

As much as I love to travel and taste different kinds of pizza, one thing that remained constant was my love for Pretzel and Pizza Creations’ pizza. From their hand-tossed crusts made from pretzel dough to their generous topping portions, it’s hard not to fall in love with their traditional recipes.

Not only does Pretzel and Pizza Creations nail it with every slice, but they also use fresh ingredients that really take it up a notch. There are so many unique flavor combinations on offer like Black Bean & Cheese Crumble or Chicken & BBQ Pulled Pork; you simply can’t go wrong!

All in all, Pretzel and Pizza Creations has some of the best pizza in Hagerstown MD. Whether you’re looking for something classic or something new and exciting, you won’t be disappointed!

#9 Cafe Del Sol

I had their classic Margherita pizza, made with vine-ripened tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and basil – it was delicious! The thin crust was perfectly crisp on the outside, yet soft and chewy on the inside. And the fresh ingredients added an amazing burst of flavor.

The atmosphere at Cafe Del Sol was also outstanding, with its warm and inviting decor. The staff were super friendly and accommodating – they even let me take my slice to go!

Overall, I highly recommend Cafe Del Sol if you’re looking for great pizza in Hagerstown MD. Trust me, it’s worth the visit!

#10 Rocky’s New York Pizza

The atmosphere is cozy, the staff are friendly, and the pizza is divine. You can tell they take pride in creating something special here – their crust is made using signature ingredients, giving it a unique flavor that’s hard to match. The selection of toppings is vast, making it possible to craft your own masterpiece or choose one of their signature pies.

Speaking of signature pies, I have to give Rocky’s an A+ for taste and presentation! Whether you’re craving a classic cheese or a more creative specialty slice, you won’t be disappointed. I’m still dreaming about their pepperoni and sausage pizza – it was so good I could barely take my eyes off of it long enough to try anything else!

If you’re ever around Hagerstown MD looking for delicious pizza (or just great food in general), do yourself a favor and check out Rocky’s New York Pizza. It truly is the best pizza experience in town!

#11 Ledo Pizza

The atmosphere is nice and cozy, making it the perfect tourist spot for visitors. They offer a full bar and even a kid’s menu for the little ones. For those looking for lighter fare, there are vegetarian options available.

The pizza was delicious! The crusts were nicely cooked with just the right amount of crunch. The toppings were fresh and flavorful – I’m still drooling thinking about it.

Perhaps the only downside to this fine establishment is that there is no delivery service; however, once you try their delicious pies, you won’t want to wait around for them to arrive at your door anyway!

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Hagerstown MD, do yourself a favor and check out Ledo Pizza — you won’t regret it! And if you’ve got a sweet tooth like me, don’t forget to sample one of their tantalizing desserts after your meal. Bon Apetit!

#12 Cafe Italia Restaurant & Pizzeria

From the moment I stepped foot in this family-run restaurant, I was welcomed with an atmosphere that said, “We take our pizza seriously here.” From the wood-fired brick oven to the stainless steel pizza paddles, it’s clear that Cafe Italia knows what they’re doing.

The pizza at Cafe Italia is truly special. The crust is thin and flavorful, the sauce has just the right amount of spice, and each topping is fresh and bursting with flavor. My favorite creation is the ‘The Hagerstown Special’ – a delicious combination of sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and black olives – but really any combination of toppings would taste great.

Cafe Italia also offers a variety of other Italian dishes like lasagna and spaghetti if you’re looking for something different. Service is friendly but efficient so your food arrives quickly and hot from the oven.

All in all, if you’re looking for great pizza in Hagerstown MD then Cafe Italia Restaurant & Pizzeria should be your first stop. They serve up some seriously delicious pies that are sure to hit the spot every time!