To save you the trouble of searching for the best pizza in town, I’ve done all the hard work for you. After tasting 12 different pizzas from various places around Kill Devil Hills, I’m confident I can tell you where to go if you want the best slice around. My journey had its highs and lows – some pies were downright terrible while others were so good they made me feel like a millionaire!
You’ll have to read on to find out why one pizza place stole my heart (hint: it wasn’t just because of their delicious sauce). Get ready for an entertaining and educational journey into pizza-land – trust me, you won’t be disappointed!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of North Carolina
#1 MADISONS PIZZA
- Nice tourist spot
- No delivery
The atmosphere is great – perfect for tourists to get a taste of the local flavor. The pizza is delicious – nice and cheesy with a crispy crust that never feels doughy or soggy. Plus, the menu offers a wide variety of toppings so there’s something for everyone to enjoy.
The only downside is that there’s no delivery service; you have to go in and pick up your pizza if you’d like to take it to-go.
All things considered, MADISONS PIZZA has some of the best pizza in Kill Devil Hills! If you’re ever in the area, I highly recommend you giving it a try!
If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 14 more pizza places in Nags Head!
#2 Pizza Stop
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
When I arrived, I was struck by the establishment’s mouth-watering aromas – my palate hadn’t tasted anything like it! Inside, the decor and atmosphere were inviting. The staff were friendly and welcoming, which only added to the experience.
The pizza was divine! From the perfectly crunchy crust to the generous topping selection, I couldn’t find a fault with it. It was heavenly – not just for Kill Devil Hills standards but the whole world!
I highly recommend Pizza Stop to anyone who is looking for top-notch pizza in this area. Not only will you get great service and fantastic food, but you’ll also have a chuckle as well! I can guarantee that you won’t be disappointed; if anything, you’ll become a regular here like me.
#3 Slice Pizzeria
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Serves alcohol
- Nice tourist spot
As soon as I stepped in the restaurant, I felt a sense of excitement. The atmosphere was lively and inviting. I could feel the anticipation of what was on the menu.
The pizza dough was cooked to perfection! It had a crunchy outside with a soft and doughy center. The sauce was flavorful and the toppings were fresh. The combination of flavors melted together perfectly… it’s almost like they made the pizza just for me!
The staff at Slice Pizzeria were friendly, helpful and courteous; they made sure my experience was enjoyable from start to finish.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Kill Devil Hills, Slice Pizzeria is definitely worth checking out!
#4 Sal’s New York Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
- Serves alcohol
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
On my visit, I was warmly greeted by the friendly staff and immediately taken with the rustic yet cozy atmosphere. It’s your classic brick oven pizza place but with a modern twist.
The menu is filled with all sorts of options for those inclined to experiment, but the star of the show is the classic New York Style Pizza. The sauce was rich and flavorful, while the crust was just thin enough without being overly crunchy. Topping wise, you can choose from a variety of traditional toppings plus some surprises like bacon bits! It really hit all the right notes and I quickly wolfed down my slice in record time.
No review would be complete without talking about the service, so let me just say that Sal’s has some of the best hospitality around. They clearly care about each and every customer who walks through their doors and go out of their way to make sure they have a fantastic experience.
Overall, my experience at Sal’s New York Pizza was top notch. I highly recommend it for anyone who wants to indulge in some truly delicious pizza!
If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 14 more pizza places in Kitty Hawk!
#5 Nags Head Pizza Company
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
The atmosphere here is unique – it’s like stepping into a time machine and being teleported back to the seventies. The walls are decorated with vintage posters and other memorabilia, giving the place a retro vibe.
The service was top-notch as well – the staff was friendly, helpful and attentive without being overbearing. They know their pizzas inside out and gave us lots of helpful advice on what to order.
Now onto the pizza! I have to say, Nags Head Pizza Company really blew me away – this is hands down the best pizza I’ve had in Kill Devil Hills! The crust was perfectly cooked, with just enough chewiness, and the toppings were fresh and flavourful. Delicious!
I’d definitely recommend Nags Head Pizza Company for anyone looking for an authentic Italian-style pizza experience – you won’t be disappointed!
#6 Southern Shores Pizza & Deli
- Nice tourist spot
- Serves alcohol
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
This place definitely lives up to its name. Upon entering, I was quickly transported to the southern shores with its coastal-inspired decor. It was the perfect setting for my pizza tasting.
The menu has something for everyone, but I chose the classic Margherita and it did not disappoint! The crust was crispy yet light and flavorful and the toppings were generous and delicious. Everything about it was spot on – from the ingredients to the baking technique.
Besides great pizza, Southern Shores Pizza & Deli also offers an extensive array of deli sandwiches made with fresh local ingredients. From Italian Subs to Mexican-style tacos, there’s something for everyone here!
Overall, I highly recommend Southern Shores Pizza & Deli! It’s clear that they take great pride in making their pizzas with love and attention to detail. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Kill Devil Hills, look no further!
#7 Max’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
- Serves alcohol
- Has a kid’s menu
On my visit to Max’s, I was thoroughly impressed by their wide selection of pizza toppings – everything from sausage to mushrooms and olives to pineapple! The crust was perfectly crunchy and the cheese was flawlessly melted.
But what really stood out for me at Max’s was their incredible house-made sauce. It had just the right balance of sweetness and heat, and it made all the difference in the taste of their pizzas.
I also loved how they bake each pizza in a wood-fired oven, which gives them an authentic Italian flavor that you can’t find just anywhere. Plus, they offer all sorts of unique combinations like their signature “Tropical Gourmet,” with kiwi, mangoes, white onion, and jalapeño peppers!
All in all, my experience at Max’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria was beyond satisfactory. Without a doubt, they have some of the best pizza in Kill Devil Hills!
If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 19 more pizza places in Duck!
#8 Dare Devil’s Pizzeria
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Great place to watch sports
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- No delivery
When you step foot in Dare Devil’s Pizzeria, it feels more like a party than a pizzeria. They offer a full bar and specialize in hard liquor – so get ready to have some fun! Plus, their kid’s menu is sure to please any young one so it’s a great spot for the entire family.
And of course, no visit would be complete without dessert. Their selection of pies and cakes is top-notch, with something tasty to satisfy everyone’s palate. It’s also a nice touristy spot, offering great views of the Kill Devil Hills area.
For those sports fans out there, this is the place to watch your favorite teams – Dare Devil’s Pizzeria has huge TVs everywhere so you can make sure you don’t miss a moment of the action!
The only downside I could find was that they don’t offer delivery – although for pizza this delicious, I might just have to make the trip every time I’m craving it! All in all, if you’re looking for some tasty pizza (and an awesome time!), definitely check out Dare Devil’s Pizzeria. It really is one of the best places for pizza in Kill Devil Hills!
#9 COSMO’S PIZZERIA
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
- No delivery
The atmosphere was great – I could tell from the moment I walked in that this place is a tourist hot spot. Plus, it’s a bonus that you can get some beer or wine with your pizza if you’d like! But more importantly, the food lives up to its reputation. They offer both classic and creative pizzas, as well as some vegetarian options for my herbivorous friends.
It’s too bad they don’t have delivery, because then I would get actual rest while still satisfying my pizza cravings. Fortunately, they do offer delicious desserts to top off the meal. You won’t be disappointed!
All in all, COSMO’S PIZZERIA is a must-try if you’re visiting Kill Devil Hills and looking for the best pizza around. Highly recommended!
#10 Vinny’s Pizza Joint
My first bite into a slice of their pepperoni pizza had me hooked. The sauce was perfectly balanced with a hint of garlic and the cheese was just the right amount of gooey. I also love the way Vinny’s takes traditional ingredients of a classic margherita pizza but steps it up with unique toppings like olives, mushrooms, and onions.
The atmosphere in Vinny’s Pizza Joint is truly something special. It’s like stepping into an Italian pizzeria from the 1950s! From its checkered tablecloths to its old-timey jukebox, every detail transports you straight to Italy.
And if you’re looking for something to wash down your delicious pizza, Vinny’s has a wide selection of craft beers and local wines that pair perfectly with their dishes.
I definitely recommend giving Vinny’s Pizza Joint a visit if you’re ever in Kill Devil Hills. I taste-tested lots of pizzas around town and this one comes out on top – hands down the best pizza in Kill Devil Hills!
If you’re willing to go an extra 30 miles, you can get to 14 more pizza places in Corolla!
#11 Pizzazz Pizza of Nags Head
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
The pizza is out of this world. The flavors are bold and unique – from the classic Margherita to the more adventurous Pesto & Bacon. The thin crust and just the right amount of fresh, crunchy vegetables makes you think you’ve died and gone to Italy!
When I visited, I was struck with how friendly the staff were. They seemed to take great pride in their work and it really showed in the quality of the food they served. They were quick to serve up my pizza and even remembered my name when I came back a few days later!
The atmosphere was also top-notch. It’s well-lit with plenty of seating to accommodate parties both small and large. Plus, they offer some interesting arcade games that add a fun touch for families or groups looking for something more than just delicious pizza.
In conclusion, if you’re looking for some awesome pizza on your next trip to Kill Devil Hills, Pizzazz Pizza of Nags Head is definitely worth a visit! It’s got an amazing selection of delicious pizzas, friendly staff, and a great atmosphere – everything you’d expect from the best pizza joint in Kill Devil Hills!
#12 Domino’s Pizza
The cheese pizza I got was great, with perfect amounts of both cheese and sauce. The crust had that nice crunch to it that captures the classic pizza experience. To top it off, the pepperoni slices made for a very flavorful combination.
The service at Domino’s Pizza is top notch too! Everyone seemed helpful and friendly, which definitely adds to the overall experience.
I’ve had a lot of pizza in my travels, but none can compare to the amazing slice I got at Domino’s Pizza. It really is some of the best pizza in Kill Devil Hills!
