Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Laguna Niguel (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in California

Best Pizza in Laguna Niguel (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

208 Views

I did some heavy research and personally sampled twelve of the best pizza places in the area to bring you, my dear readers, an opinionated yet light-hearted review of the best pies Laguna Niguel has to offer. My stomach didn’t thank me for it, but my taste buds certainly did! Let’s dig right in and get cheesy.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of California

#1 Brooklyn City Pizzeria & Market

I was initially impressed by the ambiance of the restaurant. I felt like I had been transported to a pizzeria in Brooklyn itself, from the décor to the engaging staff. It was clear that the owners were proud of their establishment and it gave off a welcoming vibe.

Once I had settled into my seat, I noticed that the menu was extensive and filled with local favorites as well as some unique dishes. After ordering my food, I couldn’t help but admire how quickly it came out. The pizzas were cooked to perfection and served hot with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The slices themselves were flavorful and crispy on the outside while still remaining chewy on the inside—it definitely lived up to Brooklyn City Pizzeria’s reputation of crafting delicious pizza!

To top it all off, they also have an incredible selection of craft beers if you’re looking for something more than just pizza. All in all, this place is definitely one of my go-to spots when it comes to finding the best pizza in Laguna Niguel!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Mission Viejo!

#2 B+C Pizza

My first bite was pure heaven. The dough was perfectly thin, yet still had great texture. The smile was savory with just the right amount of spice and cheese. I’ve never had a better pizza in my life!

The service was top-notch as well. Everyone I interacted with at B+C Pizza was friendly and attentive. They went above and beyond to make sure my experience was perfect, which made it even more enjoyable.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Laguna Niguel, look no further than B+C Pizza! Their pizzas are out of this world and their friendly staff will help make your experience one to remember. Highly recommend!

#3 Sal’s Pizzeria

The first thing that struck me about Sal’s Pizzeria is the cozy atmosphere. It’s a great place to just relax, chat with friends, and share some delicious pizza. The staff make it an even more inviting place to be – they couldn’t be friendlier!

And the star of the show is definitely the pizza! The crust is just the right thickness and has a delicious, herby flavor. The toppings are fresh and flavorful, and you can never go wrong with their cheese – it’s always incredibly rich and creamy.

My favorite dish at Sal’s Pizzeria has to be their pepperoni pizza. It’s absolutely loaded with juicy pepperoni slices and enough cheese to make your mouth water just looking at it!

Overall I’ve got nothing but good things to say about Sal’s Pizzeria. They’ve earned a spot in my list for some of the best pizza experience in Laguna Niguel! If you’re ever in Laguna Niguel, be sure to check out Sal’s for an unforgettable pizza experience!

#4 Terra Mia Pizzeria

Upon arrival, I was welcomed by an upbeat and friendly staff that immediately made me feel at home. The menu had a wide variety of options from classic pepperoni to unique BBQ Chicken pizzas. They even had vegan options, which isn’t always easy to find in pizza places!

The atmosphere of the restaurant was great for families, friends and couples alike. It wasn’t overly stuffy or too casual – it was just right for a fun night out with great company.

The best part about Terra Mia Pizzeria is obviously the food! The pizza crusts were so flavorful, light and fluffy and cooked perfectly. The toppings were fresh and generous; there was no scrimping here! Each bite felt like I was getting an explosion of flavors in my mouth. They even added freshly grated parmesan cheese as a finishing touch.

I’m glad I decided to venture out and try Terra Mia Pizzeria because it’s definitely one of the best pizzas in Laguna Niguel! If you’re looking for delicious pizza, friendly service, and a great atmosphere then this is the place to go!

#5 NEApolitan Pizzeria & Birreria

The atmosphere is great – I love the vibe and energy. The staff is friendly and accommodating. Plus, it’s a great tourist spot!

The menu has something for everyone – vegetarians rejoice in the options that are available, while the kids can choose from a variety of delicious items specifically made just for them.

Oh, and don’t forget the alcohol! It’s always nice to wash down some good pizza with your favorite beverage.

But wait – what really sets this place apart is its insane dessert selection! It’s so hard to make a decision; everything looks amazing (and tastes even better).

My only gripe is that there isn’t delivery… but that aside, NEApolitan Pizzeria & Birreria still deserves five stars from me! If you’re looking for the best pizza in Laguna Niguel, look no further – this place truly stands out from the rest.

#6 Slice Of The Pie Pizza

The pizza has a perfectly crafted crust that is delightfully crunchy and thick. It’s not too greasy, either— just the right amount of oil to give you that delicious taste.

The toppings are generous, varied, and fresh. I recommend getting the Cheese Supreme. It comes with generous portions of mozzarella, cheddar, Parmesan, and ricotta cheese! The combination of these creamy cheeses makes this pizza an absolute delight.

Their customer service was quick and friendly as well. Everyone there was super accommodating to my dietary restrictions when I asked them to hold off on some ingredients.

Overall, I would highly recommend Slice Of The Pie Pizza if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Laguna Niguel! Trust me— it’s worth every penny!

#7 NEW YORK PIZZERIA

I was skeptical at first, as I’ve had many disappointing experiences with pizzerias that claim to serve authentic New York style pizza. However, NEW YORK PIZZERIA proved me wrong!

The crust was perfectly cooked and full of flavor. The cheese was deliciously gooey, melted just right. And the toppings? Delicious! From the classic pepperoni to the more adventurous toppings like mushrooms and pineapple- it all tasted great.

I highly recommend this place for anyone looking for a great slice of New York-style pizza in Laguna Niguel. I guarantee you won’t be disappointed. Trust me- after having sampled pizza from all over the world, I know good pizza when I taste it!

#8 Tony Pepperoni Pizzeria

Every time I walk in, the first thing that hits me is the aroma of freshly cooked pizzas. It’s like entering my own little paradise! The toppings are all so fresh and flavorful and the dough perfectly cooked to give it that perfect crunch.

The staff at Tony Pepperoni Pizzeria are always super friendly and go out of their way to make sure each customer has a great experience. They have a great selection of traditional Italian pizzas but also experiment with fusion flavors and recipes, which makes it extra exciting. Who doesn’t love having new options to try?

I’ve tried a few of their signature dishes and every one has been amazing. The Tony Special – a delicious combination of pepperoni, sausage, olives, mushrooms and onions – was particularly tasty!

Overall, I highly recommend Tony Pepperoni Pizzeria for anyone looking for some seriously good pizza in Laguna Niguel. Their service is top-notch and their food definitely lives up to expectations. If you’re ever near this part of town, do yourself a favor: find your way over to Tony Pepperoni Pizzeria for some truly delicious pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Laguna Beach!

#9 Peppino’s Pizzeria

I’m sure glad I decided to check it out, because their pies are full of flavor. The crust is thin, but sturdy enough to stand up to their delicious sauces and plentiful toppings. I had a slice with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms and onions – it was absolutely divine!

The staff at Peppino’s was incredibly friendly. They took extra care to make sure my pizza was cooked just right. It arrived hot and fresh every time! Plus, they have a great selection of craft beers to go along with your meal.

All in all, it was an excellent experience. Peppino’s Pizzeria definitely deserves its spot as the best pizza in Laguna Niguel. If you’re ever in the area and craving some great-tasting pizza, this is definitely the place for you!

#10 The Pizza Store

As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by the warm, inviting atmosphere and the smell of freshly baked pizza. The staff was very friendly and accommodating, which made me feel right at home.

I decided to go with their signature Margherita pizza, topped with tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, basil, and a drizzle of olive oil. The result was nothing short of amazing! The crust had a perfect blend of crunchy edges and pillowy softness that melted in my mouth. The toppings were fresh and flavorful- truly some of the best I’ve ever had!

I also tried their garlic knot appetizer which was a wonderful addition to my meal. Not only were the knots light and fluffy but they also had just the right amount of garlic flavor without being overpowering.

Overall, I give The Pizza Store an A+ for their delicious pizza selections and welcoming atmosphere! If you’re in Laguna Niguel looking for great pizza, this is definitely your spot!

#11 Santora’s Pizza Subs & Wings

I’ve been all over the map in search of a truly excellent pizza, but Santora’s always leaves me wanting to come back for more. Their crust is perfect every time; thin, crisp and delightfully chewy. The sauces they use are unbelievably flavorful and deliver a delightful punch of flavor with each bite. Topping options are plentiful; veggie lovers can rejoice as there are plenty of healthy choices while meat lovers will be delighted by the variety of options like sausage and pepperoni.

When you walk in you’re greeted with an irresistible aroma that will make your mouth water before you even reach the counter! We sit down to enjoy our delicious slices and marvel at how quickly the restaurant fills up (seriously, don’t wait too long!). The atmosphere is friendly and relaxing, making it great for groups or just grabbing a quick slice on your own.

Overall, Santora’s Pizza Subs & Wings has earned my vote for the best pizza in Laguna Niguel. If you have yet to give them a try, I strongly suggest that you do so – you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Ball Park Pizza

The atmosphere is casual and inviting, which makes it a great spot to meet up with friends. As soon as I stepped in, I was welcomed with a warm and friendly smile by the staff.

The best thing about Ball Park Pizza is its delicious pizza! They have a large selection of pizzas to choose from, ranging from traditional favorites like Margherita and pepperoni to more unique flavors like pesto and artichoke. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, and every bite has just the right amount of cheese and sauce.

As if that wasn’t enough, they also serve other tasty Italian dishes such as pasta dishes, calzones, garlic bread, and salads. On top of that, their prices are very reasonable making it an economical choice for pizza night!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Laguna Niguel then look no further than Ball Park Pizza! Their delicious pies will definitely satisfy your craving for pizza!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Slice Of The Pie Pizza

Let me start by saying that they don’t mess around when it comes to their thin crust. It’s like biting into a cloud that’s been lightly dusted with pizza-flavored fairy dust. It’s so thin, you might confuse it for a cracker, but don’t be fooled because this cracker packs a punch of flavor. Their secret sauce is like the Picasso of pizza sauces – a perfect balance of tangy, sweet, and just a hint of garlic.

Now, let’s talk toppings. As a vegetarian, I was thrilled to see that they have plenty of options for me. From the classic margherita with fresh basil and mozzarella to the roasted vegetable medley, these toppings are as vibrant as a rainbow after a pizza-induced food coma. And don’t even get me started on their dessert pizza. Nutella and banana on a crispy, golden crust? Yes, please!

But here’s the catch – Slice Of The Pie Pizza doesn’t accept reservations. So, if you plan on dining at their establishment, be prepared to wait. However, fear not! They serve alcohol, so you can drown your wait-time sorrows with a delicious cocktail. Just make sure to pace yourself, or you might end up stumbling into the kitchen demanding more pizza like a pizza-loving pirate.

So, for the best thin crust pizza in laguna niguel, head to Slice Of The Pie Pizza. Your taste buds will thank you and your waistline may even forgive you. Bon appétit, my fellow pizza aficionados!