Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Seaside Heights (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Seaside Heights (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

176 Views

I’ve been all over the world trying some of the best pizzas out there and, while Seaside Heights isn’t Italy, it still has a lot to offer. After eating my way through 12 pizza places in the area, I’m ready to share with you my picks for the best of the best.

Here’s a hint: expect some tasty surprises! Join me as we explore what this beach town has to offer when it comes to delicious pies. There will be mouth-watering details, maybe some amusing stories, and certainly plenty of cheesy goodness along the way!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Johnny G’s Pizza Factory

I’m always on the look-out for top notch pizza joints, and I must say that Johnny G’s did not disappoint! The first thing I noticed was the atmosphere. With its colorful decor and friendly staff, it’s no wonder why this place is a tourist spot.

The pizza at Johnny G’s Pizza Factory was the star of the show. The thin crust and various topping choices gave me so much to explore. Whether it was their simple cheese creation or something more complex, like their Italian Sausage & Ricotta recipe, each individual slice was delicious.

The only downside of Johnny G’s Pizza Factory is that there is no delivery option available – so if you’re craving some delicious pizza from here you’ll have to visit in person. But that being said, it’s well worth the trip just for a taste! All humor aside, I definitely recommend this place as one of the best spots for pizza in Seaside Heights.

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Brick Township!

#2 Jerry’s Pizza & Subs

I had the privilege to visit this delightful establishment and try their signature pie. It was crusty yet fluffy, the pepperoni was juicy and abundant, and the cheese was perfectly melted – everything a pizza-lover could ever hope for!

The atmosphere wasn’t too shabby either. It felt like an old-school Italian joint with its red checkered tablecloths, classic tunes playing in the background, and a friendly staff that made me feel right at home.

Their subs are worth a mention too; they come loaded with all sorts of tasty toppings and condiments – my favorite being their hot BBQ chicken sub.

Overall, if you’re ever looking for great pizza or subs in Seaside Heights, you can’t go wrong with Jerry’s Pizza & Subs – I highly recommend it!

#3 Maruca’s® Tomato Pies (Maruca’s® Pizza)

I’ve tasted the pies in Italy and the United States, but I never expected to find anything that could compare with Maruca’s®.

When I arrived at their bright and inviting restaurant, I was immediately blown away by their thin-crust pies. Not too thick, not too thin — just perfect! The tomato sauce was cooked perfectly with a tantalizing blend of herbs and spices. The mozzarella cheese was melted to perfection with just the right amount of gooeyness. And finally, the toppings were fresh and delicious.

I have to say that Maruca’s® truly does have some of the best pizza in Seaside Heights — or any other place for that matter! Trust me, this place is well worth a visit!

#4 The Sawmill

The pizza here was nothing short of a masterpiece. The crust was perfectly cooked and incredibly flavorful. The sauce had some nice heat to it, while the cheese was gooey and delicious. As for the toppings – they were top notch and really made the pizza shine.

From my experience, their signature dish is a must try – the “Sawmill Supreme”, which layers pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers and olives for some unique flavor combinations that can’t be beaten. I took this one for a spin and I’m still thinking about it days later!

I’d also like to mention the great service we experienced at The Sawmill; the staff are knowledgeable and friendly, taking extra care with each order and making sure we had all we needed throughout our meal. This makes it even easier to enjoy their food!

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Seaside Heights look no further than The Sawmill – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Toms River!

#5 Mia’s Pizza & Cafe

When I first walked into Mia’s, I was greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff were friendly and welcoming, and the decor was classic Italian with bright colors and pictures of Italy adorning the walls.

The pizza itself was simply amazing – the crust was thin and crispy, while the toppings were fresh and flavorful. The sauce had just the right amount of kick to it but still had a nice balance of sweet and savory flavors. And can we talk about the cheese? It was bubbly, melted to perfection and oh so gooey!

It’s no wonder Mia’s Pizza & Cafe is one of the best places for pizza in Seaside Heights – they really know their stuff! With its cozy atmosphere, delicious food, and great service, this spot is definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in town.

#6 Three Brothers from Italy

My experience started with the delicious, wood-fired crust. It was light and crunchy – perfect for a thin-crust pizza! The sauce was savory and they weren’t stingy with it, which made each bite so flavorful. Speaking of bites, the toppings were definitely generous – pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers – all the classics. And let me tell you… the cheese! The cheese was gooey and oozing out of each slice. You could tell it was of high quality; it wasn’t greasy at all but melted like a dream.

The overall atmosphere in Three Brothers from Italy is great too! Very cozy decor with a lot of Italian charm that adds to the great flavors in their pizza. Plus their staff are very friendly and attentive making sure each customer has an awesome experience at their establishment.

If you’re ever in Seaside Heights looking for some amazing pizza, look no further than Three Brothers from Italy! Trust me when I say this place serves up some of the best pizza around.

#7 Lenny’s Pizza & Italian Grill

First of all, the atmosphere is fantastic. It feels like you’re walking into a classic Italian restaurant, with warm colors and rustic furniture. Everyone who works there is very friendly, and they remember my order every time I come in (a testament to how delicious the food is!).

But let’s talk about the pizza – it’s outstanding! The crust is light and crispy on the outside yet still has a hint of chewiness. And the sauce…well, let’s just say it’s not for those faint of heart! It has a nice kick that leaves an unforgettable impression. Plus, their topping options are out of this world! From classic pepperoni to spicy jalapeños, there’s something to satisfy everyone’s taste buds.

To sum up my experience at Lenny’s Pizza & Italian Grill, it can only be described as truly authentic and definitely one of the best pizzas in Seaside Heights!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Toms River!

#8 Naples Pizza & Restaurant

I arrived at this quaint little spot, which is tucked away on a quiet street, and I was immediately taken in by the cozy atmosphere. Inside, the restaurant was adorned with classic Italian decor and even had a traditional wood burning oven.

When it came time to order, I was extremely impressed with their menu. They had all of your favorites from classic pizzas to Sicilian-style pies and more! On top of that, they offered a wide array of toppings so that you can really customize your pizza just how you like it.

When my food arrived at the table, I could tell that it was made with love. The crust was perfectly cooked and had a nice crunch to it. It was also covered with quality cheese and tasty toppings that were made from fresh ingredients.

After one bite into this delicious pizza, I knew why people said Naples Pizza & Restaurant had some of the best pizza in Seaside Heights! Everything came together beautifully and I couldn’t have asked for a better dining experience. If you’re ever in town, make sure to check them out – you won’t be disappointed!

#9 Nino’s Pizzeria & Bistro 812

The first thing I noticed when walking into the establishment was the welcoming aroma of dough and cheese. The restaurant had a cozy atmosphere that made me feel right at home.

I decided to try a classic pepperoni pie, and I’m glad I did. The pizza was cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of cheese and crunchy crust. It definitely satisfied my craving for a slice!

I also tried some of their specialty dishes, such as the Mediterranean Pizza with feta cheese and black olives, as well as their BBQ Chicken Pizza topped with smoked Gouda cheese and onions. Both were delicious!

If you’re looking for great pizza in Seaside Heights, Nino’s Pizzeria & Bistro 812 is definitely worth checking out! With delicious food served up in an inviting atmosphere, it’s no wonder why this place earned the title of best pizza in town.

#10 Shore Slice Pizza & Grill

The first thing that struck me was the inviting aroma of Italian spices and freshly baked pizza. My mouth watered in anticipation as I stepped inside.

The welcoming decor and careful attention to detail immediately made me feel at home. The staff were friendly and eager to answer any questions I had about the restaurant or the menu.

The selection on offer was varied and interesting, with offerings like a seafood pizza, Thai-style chicken curry, and many more I wanted to try.

I decided on the classic margherita pizza for my meal, which came out piping hot with a thin, crispy crust. It was simply divine! The combination of flavors from the tomatoes, basil, mozzarella cheese and garlic oil was truly incredible. The crust was perfectly cooked and had a delightful crunch in every bite.

Overall, Shore Slice Pizza & Grill definitely lives up to its reputation as some of the best pizza in Seaside Heights – if not all of New Jersey! If you’re ever in town looking for delicious pizza with an Italian twist, this is definitely a must-try spot!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Point Pleasant!

#11 Little Mia’s Pizza – Seaside Heights

The first time I visited Little Mia’s Pizza – Seaside Heights, I was instantly entranced by the mouthwatering smells wafting through the air. From the fresh herbs and fragrant cheeses to the perfectly prepared sauce, this place had all of my taste buds singing. The pizza itself was amazing – golden brown, bubbly crust with a perfectly chewy texture and crispy edges that yielded to a delightfully soft bite.

Topped with an assortment of savory vegetables, zesty meats, and mouth-watering cheeses, this pizza truly embodied perfection. Each flavor note blended seamlessly with the others to create an unforgettable experience in every slice. And when I say unforgettable – I mean it! I have yet to find a pizza elsewhere that can compare to Little Mia’s Pizza – Seaside Heights!

To sum up my experience at Little Mia’s Pizza – Seaside Heights: simply put, it has some of the best pizza in Seaside Heights!

#12 Little Mia’s Pizza – Lavallette

On my visit to Little Mia’s, I was amazed at the deliciousness of the pizza. The crust had just the right amount of crunchiness and saltiness. The sauce was sweet and flavorful, complementing the toppings perfectly—I opted for pepperoni, mushrooms, and olives.

The service was also top-notch; our waiter was so friendly and attentive it felt like we were regulars. He even brought us an extra order of breadsticks when we asked!

Overall, my experience at Little Mia’s Pizza – Lavallette left me feeling satisfied (and full!) Best pizza in Seaside Heights? I think so!