Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Bar Harbor ME (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Maine

Best Pizza in Bar Harbor ME (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

303 Views

After tasting my way through 10 pizza places, I can honestly say that the best pizza here rivals spots I’ve visited all over the world.

I’m going to take you with me on a taste-testing journey and share with you my top picks for the best pizza in Bar Harbor ME.

You may be surprised by some of my choices, as lighthearted humor will be injected into each review. So, gather around the table and let’s dig in!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Maine

#1 West Eden Pizza

The atmosphere at West Eden Pizza is very inviting and it’s a great spot for tourists to check out. On top of that, the pizza here is delicious. It’s not exactly New York-style thin crust but it’s close and I always find myself going for a second slice.

I was especially impressed with the vegetarian options; there are some unique combinations that I haven’t seen anywhere else! And if you’re feeling adventurous, you can always create your own specialty pizza.

Speaking of specialty dishes, they also offer dessert pizzas! Again, these are creative combinations like s’mores and strawberry topping that add something special to the dining experience at West Eden Pizza.

Unfortunately, it doesn’t seem like they offer delivery which is disappointing but makes sense since this isn’t exactly the kind of place where people typically order take out (at least while on vacation). Still, I would recommend any curious foodie in the area to swing by and try their pies. After all, not many places can say they serve up some of the best pizza in Bar Harbor ME!

If you’re willing to go an extra 35 miles, you can get to 21 more pizza places in Bangor!

#2 Sweet Pea’s Cafe

I was blown away by the atmosphere of the cafe– it’s cozy and inviting, with brick walls and dim lighting. The service was top-notch, too– our waiters were friendly and attentive.

The menu offers a variety of pizzas, with something to please everyone. From vegetarian options to adventurous toppings like feta cheese and pineapple, there’s something here for every taste! I’d recommend trying the Mediterranean pizza– it was absolutely delicious! They also serve beer and hard liquor if you want to enjoy a cold beverage with your meal.

And if you have room for dessert, there are several sweet treats to choose from that will complete your meal.

The only downside is that Sweet Pea’s Cafe does not offer delivery– so you have to come in and enjoy the atmosphere in person before you can get your hands on their great pizza!

So if you’re in Bar Harbor ME and looking for great pizza, be sure to check out Sweet Pea’s Cafe – I guarantee you won’t be disappointed!

#3 Reel Pizza Cinerama

As soon as I walked in the door, I knew this was going to be a great experience. The restaurant smelled like a classic pizza joint, with garlic and oregano wafting through the air. The atmosphere is friendly and casual, but still cozy and inviting.

The menu here is outstanding, with ample options for everyone. Whether you’re vegan or gluten-free, there’s something delicious to try! But what really blew me away was the classic cheese pizza – made with high-quality ingredients and cooked to perfection. The dough was light and fluffy and the cheese was gooey and flavorful. It was definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted!

In addition to their amazing pizza, Reel Pizza Cinerama also has a full bar that offers some delicious cocktails to wash down dinner. And don’t forget about their selection of desserts – from gelato to cannoli, there’s something for everyone!

Overall, Reel Pizza Cinerama is definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Bar Harbor ME!

If you’re willing to go an extra 108 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Portland!

#4 Aloha – Poke Bowl Restaurant

The first thing that struck me when I walked into the restaurant was the decor. The bright colors, Hawaiian-inspired artwork and bamboo accents transport you to an island paradise. I took a seat at one of the outdoor tables and my mouth started watering in anticipation of what was to come.

The menu is filled with exotic pizzas like Pineapple Bacon Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza and even Hawaiian Seafood Pizza! Needless to say, I had plenty of choices to choose from.

I opted for the Hawaiian Seafood Pizza and it did not disappoint! The blend of sweet pineapple chunks, savory bacon bits and fresh seafood made for a delicious combination that would get even the pickiest of eaters asking for seconds (and thirds). It was like a flavor explosion in my mouth!

But wait – there’s more! The service here is second-to-none. The friendly staff greeted me with warm smiles, polite conversation, and quick service that made my dining experience truly special.

Bottom line, Aloha – Poke Bowl Restaurant at Bar Harbor ME has some of the best pizza around. If you’re ever in this neck of the woods, make sure to check them out!

#5 Rosalie’s Pizza

What makes this particular pizzeria stand out is that they offer a kid’s menu, which can be helpful when traveling with a family.

The flavors were simply delicious – the sauce was perfectly seasoned and the crust was so light and airy it seemed to melt in my mouth. I could tell they used only the freshest ingredients, especially the cheese! Not many places can get that just right.

My only complaint about Rosalie’s is that they don’t offer delivery service.. But let me tell you – it’s definitely worth a trip to their location and picking up your own pizza. You won’t regret it! If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Bar Harbor ME, Rosalie’s Pizza is a must try!

If you’re willing to go an extra 122 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in Old Orchard Beach!

#6 Geddy’s

As soon as I stepped in, I was impressed. First, they have a great selection of beers, wines, and hard liquor – perfect for a night out while enjoying some delicious pizza. And there’s even an entire kid’s menu so you can bring the whole family and enjoy Geddy’s amazing pies!

And not just pies featuring pepperoni and sausage either; Geddy’s offers some vegetarian options too! If a pizza isn’t your thing, don’t worry, Geddy’s also serves dessert like brownies and cannoli.

The only downside to Geddy’s is that they don’t offer delivery service. That said, it’s worth the trip over to experience some of the best pizza in Bar Harbor ME! Plus, every game day Geddy’s is the place to watch your favorite team. You’ll enjoy an atmosphere with lots of laughs and good times while you chow down on their delicious food.

If you’re looking for the best pizza around Bar Harbor ME then you’ve got to check out Geddy’s!

#7 Pat’s Pizza

As soon as I walked in the door I was taken aback by the wonderful smell of dough, cheese and sauce coming from the kitchen. The restaurant itself was cozy and inviting with a welcoming atmosphere.

The pizza selection at Pat’s Pizza is excellent – they offer a wide range of specialty pizzas with unique toppings, as well as traditional styles. My personal favorite is the Skinny Margherita – it’s thin crust, light sauce and flavorful toppings make for a perfect combination.

The service at Pat’s Pizza is top-notch as well. The waitstaff are friendly and knowledgeable about their menu, allowing me to ask questions and customize my order to my liking. And speaking of customization – their gluten-free crusts are some of the best I’ve tasted!

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Bar Harbor ME, look no further than Pat’s Pizza. They have something for everyone – from classic favorites to creative specialty combinations – all made with quality ingredients and served with a smile!

If you’re willing to go an extra 135 miles, you can get to 13 more pizza places in Wells!

#8 pepper’s pizza

The restaurant has a cozy atmosphere and the staff is incredibly friendly, making sure every customer leaves with a smile on their face. In terms of the food, the quality is unbeatable! They’ve managed to perfect the crust by getting it just crispy enough, while still having it be soft enough to retain some of its chewiness. The toppings are always fresh, and they have some creative combinations that will give any pizza lover a reason to come back for more.

Despite all these amazing qualities, there is one downside – no delivery. So if you want to try out pepper’s pizza for yourself, you’ll have to make your way down to Bar Harbor ME in person. However, I can guarantee that it will be worth your time!

All in all, if you’re ever in Bar Harbor looking for pizza, there’s no better place than pepper’s pizza – hands down the best around!

#9 La Bella Vita

I was initially hesitant to try a small town joint, but all my doubts quickly faded once I stepped inside. Not only did they have an extensive drinks menu that included cocktails and hard liquor, but the atmosphere was really inviting and comfortable. Best of all, they offered a kid’s menu for families who like to enjoy some pizza together.

As for the pizza itself, it was incredible! They had vegetarian options which was great for those who don’t eat meat and each slice tasted like it came from a professional Italian chef in Naples. Honestly, it put some Italian restaurants I’ve visited in Rome to shame.

To top of this amazing experience, I got to try their desserts which were amazing! Seriously, best dessert I’ve ever had in any pizzeria anywhere on earth.

My only complaint would be that they do not offer delivery which is unfortunate since it can be quite a long drive back to Bar Harbor when you live elsewhere.
But if you’re looking for the best pizza in Bar Harbor ME then La Bella Vita is definitely worth checking out!

#10 Mama Dimatteo’s

The atmosphere is great – you can sit outside and enjoy the sunshine while enjoying your meal. The inside of the restaurant is nicely decorated and has a nice, cozy feel to it. And bonus: they serve both beer and hard liquor! What more could a pizza-loving traveler ask for?

But their pizza is what really sets Mama Dimatteo’s apart. From the hand-tossed crust to the generous toppings, their pies are simply delicious. And the dessert? Insanely good!

Unfortunately, they don’t offer delivery service (which might be a dealbreaker for some people), but that just gives you an excuse to make a trip out of it. It’s definitely worth checking out if you’re in Bar Harbor ME – you won’t regret it!