Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Princeton NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Princeton NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

172 Views

Having searched all over the world for the best pizza, I’m here to share my findings with you. After tasting a total of twelve pizzas from Princeton, I’m confident that I’ve found the best that this city has to offer.

I’m ready to tell you which establishments have got it right and which ones dropped the ball when it comes to giving you a delicious slice of pie. With a lighthearted and humorous take on the pizzerias in Princeton, follow me as I take you on a journey to find the best pizza in town!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Saturn Pizza Princeton

The space-themed decor, with its countdown clock to the next launch and spacey soundtrack, instantly transported me to a different galaxy. But it was the pizza that really made this place stand out.

The crust was perfectly crispy, while the garlic and olive oil base made each bite more flavorful than the last. The combination of fresh mozzarella, spicy pepperoni, and fresh basil – as if picked right from the garden – made for an unforgettable taste experience.

The flavors were so unique that I had to try slice after slice! The sauce was also incredible – rich, tomato-y goodness spiced just right with fragrant herbs.

And if you’re in the mood for something out of this world (literally!), Saturn Pizza Princeton has some interesting toppings like gorgonzola cheese, artichokes, and even sun-dried tomatoes.

From start to finish, I’d rate my experience at Saturn Pizza Princeton a 10 on a 10-point scale. In my books it’s definitely one of the best pizza places in Princeton – perfect for grabbing a delicious slice after a long day exploring outer space!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Elizabeth!

#2 Genteel’s Brick Oven Pizza & Ristorante

The atmosphere and decor were both beyond charming, the staff was friendly and courteous, and the food was outstanding. The pizza itself had everything I love in a great slice: the crust was perfectly thin yet crunchy, the sauce was flavorful without being overbearing, and the toppings were all fresh and flavorful.

But what really set Genteel’s apart from other pizza places was its creativity. From their signature deep dish with mozzarella and ricotta to their gourmet vegan pizza with roasted vegetables and vegan cheese, they managed to put a unique twist on each slice they made.

Overall, I can confidently say that Genteel’s Brick Oven Pizza & Ristorante is one of the best places for pizza in Princeton. From their unique creations and flavors to their fantastic atmosphere, you won’t be disappointed!

#3 Tino’s Artisan Pizza Co.

I first stepped into the cozy little shop, expecting a traditional pizza joint with just average pies. Boy was I wrong! The menu featured an eclectic mix of gourmet pizzas that made my mouth water. From the classic Margherita to the more creative creations like “The Adams” – which is topped with pesto, garlic, mushrooms, and mozzarella- I knew I had found something special.

The pizzas were cooked to perfection. Crispy, yet chewy crusts gave way to melt-in-your-mouth cheese and toppings. The flavors came together in an explosion that is not often found outside of Italy itself!

The service was also outstanding; friendly and helpful staff made sure all of our questions were answered quickly. Plus they even threw in a side dish of garlic bread for good measure!

In conclusion, if you are ever in Princeton and looking for amazing pizza, be sure to give Tino’s Artisan Pizza Co. a try! You won’t be disappointed – it truly is the best pizza in Princeton!

#4 Beniamino’s Cucina & Pizza

When I first stepped in the door of Beniamino’s, I knew I had found something special. The staff was welcoming and friendly, and the atmosphere felt just like home. The decor was cozy and inviting, and the smell of fresh pizza filled the room.

I was able to sample a few different pizzas, so I could get a better feel of what they had to offer. To start off my tasting experience, I tried their classic Margherita pizza. It was a combination of sweet tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella cheese, and fragrant basil that created an amazing flavor. They also offered several unique gourmet pies that included things like fig jam, honey goat cheese and truffle oil; each one was more delicious than the next!

The thing that really impressed me about Beniamino’s is that they use only the freshest ingredients available; everything is made from scratch with love by their talented chefs. And above all else, their thin crusts are always cooked to perfection – not too crispy but still firm enough to hold up to any toppings!

If you’re looking for best pizza in Princeton (or beyond!), look no further than Beniamino’s Cucina & Pizza. From traditional slices to creative topping combinations, you’ll be sure to find something you’ll love here!

#5 Pizza Den

The first thing I noticed when I arrived here was the pleasant atmosphere. It was cozy and inviting, not to mention the smell of freshly cooked pizza in the air. I could barely contain my excitement!

The menu offered a wide selection of pizzas, from classic Italian style to gourmet concoctions with interesting ingredients. After much deliberation, I decided on the Roman-style pizza with sausage and mushrooms. Let me tell you – it was delicious! The sausage was juicy and flavorful, the mushrooms were cooked perfectly, and the crust was thin yet chewy – exactly how a Roman-style pizza should be.

The service at Pizza Den is also top-notch. My server was friendly and attentive, making sure that I got everything I needed throughout my meal.

All in all, Pizza Den is a great spot to grab some of the best pizza in Princeton. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, the menu has something for everyone, and the food is simply exquisite! Highly recommended!

#6 Alfonso’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

Just stepping foot into the restaurant, I knew I was in for a treat. The atmosphere was homey and inviting, with fresh Italian music playing in the background and the smell of pizza filling the air.

Their selection of pizzas is impressive. From classic cheese to more creative options like white pizza with Alfredo sauce, there’s something for everyone. My personal favorite is the Sicilian-style deep dish pizza – it’s packed with flavor and has just the right amount of crunch from the crust. It’s honestly one of my favorite pizzas anywhere!

The service at Alfonso’s is also top-notch – always courteous and helpful. Plus, they offer delivery if you want to enjoy their delicious pizzas in your own home.

If you’re looking for some amazing pizza that tastes like it came straight from Italy, Alfonso’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is definitely worth a try – it may just be the best pizza in Princeton!

#7 Conte’s Pizza

I’ve been to a lot of places in search of the perfect slice, but none compare to Conte’s. From the minute you walk in you can feel the cozy atmosphere as an old Italian family runs it, and smell that classic wood burning oven.

Their pizzas are made with fresh ingredients, making every bite an explosion of flavor. The cheese is gooey and melty and the crust is so light and crispy, it just melts in your mouth! The slices themselves are huge too – I’m pretty sure one piece could feed two people.

The prices are surprisingly affordable for all the fantastic food they offer – it’s amazing what they can do with just a few dollars! Of course, if you’re feeling especially fancy there’s plenty of specialty pies on the menu that offer up unique combinations like quattro formaggi or pesto basilico. Yum!

All in all, Conte’s Pizza is hands down some of the best pizza in Princeton. If you have yet to experience their delicious pies, then head over there soon – I promise you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Trenton!

#8 Nomad Pizza

I’ve been to the most exotic cities around the world, seeking out the most authentic pizza I could find. But after sampling Nomad Pizza’s offerings, I quickly realized that their pizza was up there with the best of them.

From their traditional Italian style pies to their specialty creations like the Pesto Pollo, Nomad Pizza has something for everyone. The crust is crunchy and well-cooked, while still managing to hold all of its delicious toppings together. The sauce is flavorful and just the right amount of tangy-sweet; it ties everything together perfectly. And then there are the cheeses they use! So many varieties and combinations – each offering a unique flavor experience that enhances whatever type of pizza you decide to try.

The service at Nomad Pizza is wonderful too. Their staff is friendly and attentive, ensuring that your visit is an enjoyable one. To top it off, they offer some great specials on particular days or times so you can stretch your dollar as far as possible when dining out with family or friends.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Princeton, look no further than Nomad Pizza!

#9 Jules Thin Crust Princeton

I recently had the pleasure of visiting this restaurant and it was an absolute delight. The atmosphere is cozy, with a nice brick oven in the corner and inviting décor. The staff were friendly, knowledgeable, and eager to make sure I had a great experience.

As far as the food goes, I can honestly say that Jules Thin Crust Princeton serves some of the most delicious pizza I’ve ever had! The crust was thin but light and crispy, just how I like it. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, ranging from classic pepperoni to more inventive creations like zucchini with feta cheese.

All-in-all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Princeton then look no further than Jules Thin Crust Princeton. From its friendly staff to its amazing menu selection and pizza that can’t be beat – it’s definitely worth trying out!

#10 Aljons Pizza & Restaurant -West Windsor

I must have tried every kind of pizza imaginable, from the classic Italian Margherita to the gourmet Hawaiian. But at Aljons, I got what I consider to be the perfect slice – thin, chewy crust topped with a combination of savory tomatoes, onions and mushrooms that had just enough cheese and the perfect amount of garlic. The flavors truly melded together for an unforgettable bite!

The restaurant is small but cozy with a charming decor. The atmosphere was relaxed and friendly, making it a great destination for a casual evening out. The staff were also very accommodating and helpful in helping us choose the right toppings.

But what really made me come back to Aljons time after time was their commitment to ensuring that each customer experiences the best pizza possible. That’s why they only use fresh ingredients and employ experienced chefs who bring out all of the nuanced flavors in each pizza.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Princeton then look no further than Aljons Pizza & Restaurant -West Windsor. You won’t find better quality food or more welcoming hospitality anywhere else in town!

#11 Proof

From the first bite of their signature “Princeton Pie,” I was blown away! The thin crust had the perfect amount of crunch and was smothered in a flavorful tomato sauce, savory cheese, and toppings that were fresh and delicious.

The atmosphere could not have been more perfect either; the restaurant was cozy with friendly staff members who went above and beyond to make sure I had an amazing experience.

I tried a few other pies on the menu and they were all equally as fantastic! They offer a wide selection of creative topping combinations that never fail to impress.

If you’re ever in Princeton looking for great pizza, look no further than Proof. You won’t be disappointed!

#12 D’Angelo Italian Market

The pastry-like crust was so light and fluffy that it melted in my mouth. It was lightly seasoned with garlic, oregano, and basil for a burst of flavor. The sauce was fresh and flavorful, with just the right amount of tomato flavor. The cheese was gooey and stringy, and complemented the other toppings perfectly.

I tried the supreme pizza which had pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and black olives. With its perfect ratio of toppings to dough this pizza had an optimal chewiness that took me back to my days in Italy!

I also tried a calzone filled with pepperoni and mozzarella cheese. It was baked to perfection inside the flaky crust; not too crunchy on the outside but still nice and tender on the inside!

Overall I would highly recommend D’Angelo Italian Market if you’re searching for some delicious pizza! Their pies are definitely some of the best in Princeton.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Jules Thin Crust Princeton

First of all, let’s talk about their vegetarian options. As a food critic, I try to accommodate all diets. And Jules Thin Crust Princeton certainly delivered on that front! They have a wide range of veggie toppings that will make any herbivore’s taste buds dance with joy. From fresh spinach and roasted red peppers to caramelized onions and artichoke hearts, I was in vegetarian pizza heaven!

Now, onto one of my favorite parts – dessert! Yes, you heard it right. Jules Thin Crust Princeton offers delicious desserts to end your meal on a sweet note. Their Nutella pizza is a dream come true for chocolate lovers like myself. It’s basically a thin crust pizza covered in a generous amount of gooey Nutella. Just thinking about it makes my mouth water!

And let’s not forget about its location. Situated in the heart of Princeton, this restaurant is a nice tourist spot. So, after fueling up on mouthwatering pizza, you can take a stroll around the charming town, burn off those pizza calories, and soak in the local atmosphere.

Now, I do have one bone to pick – Jules Thin Crust Princeton doesn’t accept reservations! So, be prepared to wait for a bit during busy times. But trust me, the wait is worth it. The delicious thin crust pizza and the friendly staff make up for this small inconvenience.

In conclusion, I highly recommend Jules Thin Crust Princeton for the best thin crust pizza in central nj. With its vegetarian options, irresistible desserts, and prime tourist spot, it’s a pizza lover’s dream come true. Just make sure to arrive early or be ready to wait for your slice of cheesy heaven!