Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Aspen (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Colorado

Best Pizza in Aspen (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

261 Views

In my opinion, it’s time to settle the debate of who makes the best pizza in this Colorado resort town. After visiting twelve different places, tasting more than thirty pizzas, and asking locals for their opinions, I’m ready to share what I found.

I’ve always had a healthy appreciation for good food, but after this experience I’m starting to see why Aspen is becoming a culinary mecca. As confectionery as the landscape is around here, the pizza offerings are just as mouth-watering! Let’s get started on finding your new favorite slice together; come along with me on this journey of deliciousness and enlightening pies.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Colorado

#1 Highlands Alehouse

My adventure began with the crust. It was the perfect combination of crunchy and chewy, almost like eating a cloud. If I were being honest, that alone would’ve been enough to make me give Highlands Alehouse five stars.

But it didn’t stop there. The sauce – a homemade blend of tomatoes and herbs – gave an extra layer of flavor that was out of this world. And the cheese? Forget about it! Flawlessly melted into the pizza, it provided just the right amount of creamy goodness. Aesthetically, this pie could’ve graced the pages of any gourmet magazine!

The toppings? Beyond delicious! Fresh vegetables, savory meats, and even some creative additions I hadn’t seen before added to an already-impressive palette of flavors. Not too heavy or greasy either – dried oregano sprinkled on top was a nice touch for texture contrast as well.

In short: Highlands Alehouse has earned my seal of approval for not just offering one of the best pizzas in Aspen, but one of the best pizzas I’ve had anywhere in my travels!

If you’re willing to go an extra 35 miles, you can get to 9 more pizza places in Glenwood Springs!

#2 New York Pizza Aspen

The first thing that stands out about NYPAspen is the atmosphere. It’s cozy, inviting, and makes you feel like you’re part of the family – which I definitely appreciate.

The pizzas are New York style and are cooked to perfection. The crust has a nice crispness and crunch to it, and the sauce is made from fresh tomatoes. The cheese was nicely melted and had that stringy, gooey consistency I crave in a pizza!

I tried one of their classic pies, topped with pepperoni, mushrooms, olives and bell peppers – it was delicious! There’s no doubt in my mind that NYPAspen make some of the best pizza in Aspen.

And if you’re not feeling pizza, they have an awesome selection of subs and salads too! All around great place to get a bite to eat!

#3 Aspen Tap / Aspen Brewing Co

The atmosphere of the restaurant gives you a great vibe, especially if you’re in the mood for watching some sports. And it doesn’t hurt that they accommodate the beer and hard liquor drinkers in addition to serving up amazing pizza! Plus, if you’re looking for some vegetarian options, they have those too.

They really took things up a notch when it comes to their dessert offerings – so if you wanna save a little room for something sweet after that delectable pizza, Aspen Tap / Aspen Brewing Co has got you covered!

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery services – but let’s be honest: their perfect pizzas are definitely worth visiting in person anyway.

In conclusion, Aspen Tap / Aspen Brewing Co really lives up to its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Aspen. It’s a great tourist spot and an even better place to watch sports while enjoying some delicious pizza with a cold beer or cocktail. Highly recommended!

#4 Aspen Pie Shop

The restaurant is cozy and inviting and the staff was incredibly friendly. The pizza dough was perfectly cooked with just the right amount of crispiness and the toppings were surprisingly fresh. I had the classic Margherita style pizza and it was delicious!

The best part about Aspen Pie Shop is that they don’t skimp on the cheese. They use a combination of mozzarella, parmesan, and asiago cheeses which makes for an incredibly rich flavor.

I’ve definitely found my new favorite pizza spot in Aspen! This place will be my go-to whenever I’m in town and looking for great pizza. Highly recommended!

If you’re willing to go an extra 41 miles, you can get to 10 more pizza places in Vail!

#5 Pastore’s Taste of Philly

I had heard so many great things about Pastore’s that I just had to check it out. When I arrived, the first thing that caught my eye was the huge oven in the corner. It was bursting with glowing embers and smelled absolutely heavenly.

The menu selection was impressive – they have traditional Philly-style pizzas as well as some more unique toppings. I eventually decided on a sausage and mushroom pizza; it came out steaming hot and goodness, was it good! The crust was perfectly crispy yet fluffy, and the toppings were generous and flavorful.

The service here is also top-notch. Everyone from the waitstaff to the kitchen staff did an excellent job of making sure my meal experience was perfect. My water glass was never empty, my plate cleanly cleared, and my questions expertly answered.

If you’re in Aspen looking for some of the best pizza around, don’t miss Pastore’s Taste of Philly!

#6 Francescas Pasta Market & Empanadas

The pizza dough is light and fluffy, and almost melts in your mouth. The toppings are nothing short of outrageous – they offer some of the most creative combinations I’ve seen. From Sriracha-glazed chicken to roasted mushroom medleys to shrimp scampi, the options are truly limitless.

I have to admit that I was a bit concerned about their empanadas at first – after all, I’m here for pizza! – but it turns out that these delicious pastries actually enhance myexperience here. Anytime I can find a place where I can enjoy both pizza and empanadas together, I’m always happy!

Of course, the service is top-notch as well. The waitstaff is knowledgeable and helpful; whether you’re ordering for delivery or eating in, you’re sure to receive great care every time. That just adds to the overall experience at Francescas Pasta Market & Empanadas.

Bottom line: if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Aspen, this is definitely the place to go! Between the amazing pizza (and empanadas!), friendly staff, and great atmosphere, Francescas Pasta Market & Empanadas will surely become your favorite spot.

#7 Ellina

The restaurant itself is a great spot for tourists, and the atmosphere is inviting and fun. The staff are friendly, helpful and attentive, which always adds to the experience.

The menu offers a good selection of pizza options, and there’s even a few vegetarian ones too! This was especially welcome since I’m not much of a meat eater. The crust was thin and crispy as it should be. The cheese was abundant and melted perfectly, and the tomato sauce had lots of flavor with just enough spice.

But what really impressed me was the beverage selection. Not only do they have sodas and juices, but they also serve beer AND hard liquor! How could you not love that?! Plus their house-made desserts were insanely good! No other place I’ve visited has come close to Ellina’s fantastic recipes.

The only downside I can think of is that they don’t offer delivery services. But honestly, when your food is this good, you don’t mind driving a few miles for it! All in all, Ellina has earned my highest praise – it truly does serve up some of the best pizza in Aspen!

If you’re willing to go an extra 48 miles, you can get to 11 more pizza places in Breckenridge!

#8 The Wild Fig

From the moment I stepped inside, it was obvious that this was a cool spot. It serves alcohol not only in beer and wine form, but also hard liquor! They have some vegetarian options, which is definitely a plus for me. But the real eye-catcher was their dessert menu – insanely good!

I can honestly say that The Wild Fig has some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. With its perfectly kneaded dough and flavorful toppings, the pizza here is a must-try. Even if you are visiting Aspen as a tourist, take some time out to try The Wild Fig’s pizza – you won’t regret it!

The only downside to The Wild Fig is that they don’t offer delivery services. Other than this minor detail, I’d recommend giving this place a visit – you won’t be disappointed!

#9 Casa D’ Angelo Ristorante

The first thing that caught my eye was that they serve alcohol and hard liquor. I don’t know about you but for me, nothing goes better with a good slice of pizza than an ice cold beer!

The pizzas themselves are sensational. They have all the standards you’d expect plus a few unique takes on classics. The crust is thin and crispy, just the way I like it. And the toppings are always fresh and flavorful.

But what really sets Casa D’ Angelo apart is their dessert offerings. From decadent tiramisu to silky smooth gelato, they have something to tantalize everyone’s taste buds. It’s such a nice surprise after every meal there!

One of the downsides is that they don’t offer delivery – You’ll have to visit in person or get them to cater your event if you want their delicious pies. But that inconvenience is more than worth it in order enjoy Casa D’ Angelo’s pizza at its best! All in all, this place is definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in Aspen looking for the best pizza around!

#10 Acquolina

When I first walked into Acquolina, I knew this place was special. The décor is classic Italian and the smells of delicious pizza fill the air. I ordered a simple Margherita pizza and it didn’t disappoint. Every bite was like a little burst of flavor. It was made with fresh ingredients and had just the right amount of cheese, sauce, and crust.

The service at Acquolina was great too. Everyone seemed genuinely interested in making sure my experience was perfect. On top of that, they have a large selection of wines to pair with your meal if you want to make things extra special!

All in all, this is easily one of the best pizzerias I’ve ever been to! If you’re looking for amazing pizza in Aspen, then look no further than Acquolina!

If you’re willing to go an extra 54 miles, you can get to 13 more pizza places in Dillon!

#11 Campo De Fiori

The atmosphere is inviting, relaxed and friendly. From the moment you step into the door, you can smell the aroma of delicious pizza being made in their wood-fired oven. The warm, inviting colors make it feel like a home away from home.

The pizza itself? Absolutely amazing! The dough is light yet crisp and the toppings are fresh and flavorful. I especially enjoyed the Bianca pie – a classic combination of creamy ricotta, mozzarella and pecorino cheeses. The crust was golden brown and had just enough char to give it an added crunch. Delicious!

And no visit would be complete without trying one of their signature cocktails. The White Sangria was fruity, refreshing and quenched my thirst perfectly.

Overall, Campo De Fiori is a great spot for an enjoyable evening with friends or family gathering around a wood-fired pizza experience that can’t be matched anywhere else in Aspen. In my opinion, Campo De Fiori serves up some of the best pizza in Aspen – if not the world!

#12 Casa Tua

I was immediately impressed by the wide selection of alcohol at this restaurant, including hard liquor, so you can get a real Italian-style pizza experience! The pizza itself is as close to perfection as you can get: that perfect combination of crispy crust with all the right flavors.

And when I think about dessert… wow! Even after eating so much pizza, I couldn’t help but have a few slices of their insanely good desserts. It’s hard not to indulge in them – they’re simply irresistible!

The only downside? Unfortunately, there isn’t any delivery service available here. But if you’re ever in Aspen, Casa Tua is worth a visit – it’s become something of a tourist spot now! All in all, it’s perhaps the best place for pizza in Aspen.