The promise of Grove City’s small town charm was hard to resist, so with high expectations and a trusty guidebook in hand, I visited the top 12 pizza places.
My mission? To evaluate every slice on quality, texture, ingredients, and crust thickness (among other things). It was going to be an interesting journey—and one I was up for taking!
What I discovered in Grove City OH surprised me! From artisanal pizzas to the classic cheese and pepperonis—the variety of options was impressive. You’ll never go hungry if you’re looking for the best pizza around!
So grab a slice and get ready to embark on a tasty adventure as I determine which place takes the title of “Best Pizza in Grove City OH”.
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Ohio
#1 Zamarelli’s Pizza Palace
The moment I stepped into Zamarelli’s Pizza Palace, it was clear that something special was happening here. The atmosphere is inviting and cozy, with a great selection of classic Italian decor. Plus, the staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming – they made me feel like part of the family!
The menu at Zamarelli’s Pizza Palace has something for everyone. Their classic pizza toppings are second-to-none, from pepperoni to mushrooms to anchovies. They also have an impressive array of specialty pizzas, like the Italian Cowboy (with sausage and bacon), which really blew me away.
But let’s not forget the pizza itself. The crust is thin but still substantial enough to hold all of their delicious ingredients without getting soggy. And then there’s the sauce – it’s perfectly balanced between sweet and savory, with just the right amount of heat. Plus, each piece comes out piping hot and loaded with cheese that just melts in your mouth!
All in all, Zamarelli’s Pizza Palace serves some of the best pizza I’ve ever had in Ohio – or anywhere else for that matter! If you’re looking for a memorable meal that won’t break your wallet, then this is definitely the place for you!
If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Hilliard!
#2 Tammy’s Pizza – Broadway Town Center
- Offers dessert
From the moment I walked in, I was impressed. The restaurant itself was quaint and inviting, with bright pops of colour from the walls and decorations. There was a friendly atmosphere that made me feel immediately welcome.
When I got to the counter, I had a chat with Tammy who runs the place. She was really helpful and went out of her way to make sure I had a great experience. She even recommended some of their specialty pies which were simply delicious!
I opted for one of Tammy’s homemade pizzas – pepperoni with extra cheese -and it certainly didn’t disappoint! The crust was light yet crispy, while the toppings were plentiful and perfectly cooked. It was easily one of the best pizzas I’ve ever eaten!
To top it all off, Tammy’s Pizza – Broadway Town Center offers an incredibly reasonable price point for such high-quality pizza. In short, this is definitely my go-to spot for great pizza in Grove City OH.
#3 Flyers Pizza Grove City South/Commercial Point
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
I have to say, the pizza here was absolutely delicious! The crust was light yet crunchy and baked perfectly, while the sauce had a wonderful tomato flavor that was nicely balanced. To top it off, the cheese melted like a dream, making every bite just as good as the last.
The menu offered a wide variety of pizzas so there is something for everyone. Plus, they even offer some unique options like their signature hot wing pizza with buffalo sauce and blue cheese – which was really tasty!
And let’s not forget about the friendly service. They were always quick to seat us and attentive whenever we needed something. Even when I asked them how their pizzas were made, they were more than happy to explain every step in detail.
Overall, my experience at Flyers Pizza Grove City South/Commercial Point was great and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for the best pizza in Grove City OH!
#4 Cattleman’s Pizza
As soon as I stepped foot inside this quaint Italian restaurant, I knew that I had stumbled onto an incredible pizza experience. The cozy atmosphere only added to the anticipation of what I was about to eat.
The menu is vast and offers a variety of choices from traditional classic pies like the “New York Classic” and “California Supreme”, to their signature pies such as the “Cattleman’s Special” and their famous deep-dish. No matter which pizza you choose, you know you’re in for a treat.
When my pizza arrived, it was clear why Cattleman’s Pizza is rumored to have some of the best pizza in Grove City OH. The large slice was served on a thin, crispy crust that held up perfectly after my first bite – no soggy mess here! Toppings were abundant and varied, each bringing something special to the flavor party. In fact, this might be the most flavorful pizza I’ve ever had!
To top it off (pun intended), the friendly staff at Cattleman’s Pizza really went above and beyond to make sure that my dining experience was perfect. Every single person was incredibly knowledgeable about their menu and did an amazing job of recommending other dishes for me to try out.
If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Grove City OH, look no further than Cattleman’s Pizza!
#5 Zanzis Pizza Grove City
The pizza was cooked to perfection, with the perfect amount of cheese and just the right mix of spices. The crust had a delicious crunch that I hadn’t experienced before in my travels. The sauce was flavorful and delicate, not too overpowering.
The atmosphere at Zanzis Pizza Grove City was fantastic. From the inviting décor to the friendly staff, it felt like home away from home. The waitstaff was knowledgeable about their menu and gave great recommendations for new dishes to try.
I would highly recommend Zanzis Pizza Grove City for anyone looking for an enjoyable pizza experience that won’t break the bank. They offer high quality pies at reasonable prices, plus a variety of specialty items such as calzones, stromboli, and garlic knots.
Overall, my experience at Zanzis Pizza Grove City can only be described as extraordinary! Best pizza in Grove City OH? I think so!
#6 Jet’s Pizza
I was really impressed with the service and friendly attitude of the staff – they made me feel right at home. The pizza was top notch – it had a perfect combination of crunchy, chewy crust, savory sauce, and gooey cheese. I especially enjoyed the variety of toppings they offer – so much more than your standard pepperoni or sausage!
Speaking of toppings, I have to give credit where it’s due for Jet’s unique 8-Corner Pizzas. It’s like having two pizzas in one! And no matter how many toppings you add, it still comes out perfectly cooked every time.
Finally, I have to mention the prices – unbelievably affordable for the quality you get. You get great food for a great value! Overall, I highly recommend Jet’s Pizza – it’s definitely earned my stamp of approval as one of the best pizzas in Grove City OH!
If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Columbus!
#7 Fazoli’s
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
After sampling the delicious fare at this quaint Italian eatery, I was in Heaven. The homemade dough and sauce were the perfect combination to create a pizza that was perfectly cooked with bubbling cheese and perfectly crispy crust.
The toppings were also top-notch, from classic pepperoni to create a traditional favorite, to simple veggies for those trying something more healthful. Whatever your preference, Fazoli’s has it!
But it doesn’t end there. Fazoli’s offers other Italian dishes like calzones and lasagna that are equally as tasty and delicious as the pizza. Plus they have great sides like garlic breadsticks, salads, and desserts that make this restaurant worth visiting time and again.
For those looking for the best pizza in Grove City OH (and beyond!), this is definitely the place to go! The food is fresh and flavorful yet still reasonably priced – an unbeatable combination if you ask me!
#8 Marco’s Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
The atmosphere is inviting, the staff is incredibly friendly, and the prices are quite reasonable. Not to mention they serve up some of the freshest, most delicious pizza I’ve ever tasted!
Their specialty pies are truly something special – each topping was fresh and flavorful. The crust was perfectly baked, not too crispy and not too doughy, just right. And let’s not forget about their signature sauces – a blend of herbs and spices that set this pizza apart from any other place I’ve visited.
If you’re looking for a great slice of pizza in Grove City OH, Marco’s Pizza is definitely worth checking out. Trust me, after all my travels, I know good pizza when I taste it!
#9 Pizza Cottage
- Serves alcohol
- Great place to watch sports
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
From the moment I stepped in the door, I knew this place was different. The inviting atmosphere and reasonable prices made me feel right at home.
The menu was expansive, with all kinds of delicious options, including specialty pizzas like prosciutto and fig, veggie deluxe and artichoke pesto. My personal favorite is the classic pepperoni pizza — oh man it was the best! I can’t put into words how good it was. The perfect blend of fresh ingredients combined with just the right amount of cheese and saucy goodness — mmmmmm!
Service was top-notch as well — friendly staff that were always willing to answer questions about the menu or offer suggestions for a great pizza combination. Prices were also incredibly reasonable, making it an affordable option for a family dinner or gathering with friends.
In short, Pizza Cottage is my go-to spot for the best pizza in Grove City OH. If you’re ever in town looking for a delicious slice of pie, head there first!
#10 Tammy’s Pizza – Hoover at Rt-665
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
The first thing that caught my eye as I walked into the restaurant was the wood-fired oven. It’s a sight to behold, and it certainly reeled me in! All of the pizzas cooked in this oven are bursting with flavor and have an unbeatable crispness that can’t be replicated anywhere else.
I had the pleasure of trying the margarita pizza, loaded with tomatoes, cheese, herbs, and olive oil. Let me tell you – it was simply divine! The crust was perfectly thin and crunchy, while still having a hint of chewiness to it. The flavors were absolutely spot on – each component blended together perfectly for a delightful experience.
On top of that, Tammy’s Pizza has some really excellent sides too! Their garlic knots were so fragrant and flavorful – I ate them all up in no time at all! And their signature wings were such a hit – they’re definitely worth ordering too!
To sum up my experience at Tammy’s Pizza: if you’re looking for some delicious pizza made with quality ingredients in Grove City OH, look no further than Tammy’s Pizza – Hoover at Rt-665! From the incredible wood-fired oven pizzas to the tasty garlic knots and wings, this place is guaranteed to have something for everyone!
#11 Flyers Pizza Grove City North
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
There’s something about the tasty sauce and the perfectly cooked crust that makes this pizza stand out from all the others. The cheese is top-notch and there’s a huge selection of toppings to choose from. Whether I’m craving classic pepperoni or something more adventurous, like anchovies, Flyers Pizza Grove City North always has something for me.
The atmosphere at Flyers Pizza Grove City North is also top-notch. The staff always has a smile on their face and they’re friendly, helpful, and attentive – they really make you feel welcome! I love how they play some great music while you wait for your order – it really adds to the experience.
To top it all off, the service is fast and efficient – my food was ready in no time at all! With its great pizza, friendly staff and delicious atmosphere, I can confidently say that Flyers Pizza Grove City North is the best pizza in Grove City OH!
If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Columbus!
#12 Grandstand Pizza Shop
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
I admit, I was a bit skeptical at first. After all, what could this pizza place in the heart of Ohio have that can beat out pizzas from New York or Rome? But as soon as I took the first bite, my skepticism disappeared.
The crust was perfectly cooked to perfection and had just the right crunch to it. The cheese was delectably creamy and complemented the toppings perfectly. Speaking of toppings – the combination was spot on! Every bite had an ideal balance of flavor and texture, making for an amazing culinary experience.
The atmosphere in Grandstand Pizza Shop is great too! The staff is very friendly and accommodating, ensuring that each customer’s needs are met. Plus, the shop has a cozy ambiance that can help make your dinner even more enjoyable.
At the end of the day, I’m willing to declare Grandstand Pizza Shop as having some of the best pizza in Grove City OH! If you love good pizza (and who doesn’t?), you owe it to yourself to visit here and see why I found it so delicious!
