I have a wealth of pizza experience from all around the world, and I was excited to see what Hamilton had to offer! I recently spent some time in the area exploring the delectable options here. After taste-testing twelve different pizza places, I’m ready to share my results: the best pizza in Hamilton NJ!
In this article, you’ll find out what makes each of these pizzas so unique. Get ready for a lot of cheesy goodness and fun stories as I take you on a delicious journey through Hamilton’s pizza scene. So heat up some slices and let’s get started!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey
#1 Pi Pita & Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
The atmosphere was inviting and relaxing – perfect for families and friends. The staff was friendly and helpful, but the best part of my experience was definitely the pizza.
Their menu offers a variety of traditional pizzas as well as their specialty pies, like “The Pita Pizza”. This one had a delicious pita-style crust that was surprisingly light and crunchy. For the toppings, I went with the classic cheese pizza (because sometimes simple is better). Every bite was divine!
In conclusion, Pi Pita & Pizza is indeed one of the best pizza places in Hamilton NJ! I’d highly recommend it to anyone looking for an excellent slice.
If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Trenton!
#2 Marcello’s Pizza-Grill
From walking in and catching a whiff of the delicious smell of freshly baked pizza, to hearing the bubbling cheese on top of the pies, I could already tell that I would be in for a treat!
The service was great as well. All the employees were friendly and welcoming, and they seemed to really care about making sure I had a great experience. Plus, they had a wide selection of toppings which allowed me to get creative with my choice of pizzas.
What made Marcello’s stand out from all the other pizza places was the quality of their ingredients. The crust was crispy yet fluffy, and the sauce was rich and flavorful without being too heavy. The cheese was melted to perfection, creating an irresistible texture. And don’t even get me started on their unique toppings–I’m telling you now that these are some serious game-changers! Each topping added its own special flavor that enhanced my overall dining experience.
In conclusion, Marcello’s Pizza-Grill is hands-down one of the best places for pizza in Hamilton NJ and it certainly deserves all five stars!
#3 Mamma Maria’s’ pizza restaurant
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has insanely good dessert
On my recent trip to the area, I had heard from a few locals that Mamma Maria’s’ pizza was something special – and one taste proved it! From the wood-fired oven to hand-tossed dough from their own bakery – this is serious pizza.
The toppings are first rate as well. The pepperoni and sausage were especially noteworthy; they gave each slice a delicious, smoky flavor. The veggie options too were very fresh and tasty. Add to that amazing fresh tomato sauce and you have a winning combination.
What really clinched it for me, however, was the atmosphere at Mamma Maria’s’. It’s cozy yet dynamic, with candles flickering on the walls and people chatting animatedly while enjoying their own slices of pizza.
If you’re ever in Hamilton NJ looking for great pizza, I highly recommend stopping by Mamma Maria’s’. Their commitment to quality ingredients combined with their friendly vibe makes it one of the best places in town!
#4 Jeppy’s Gourmet Pizza Shop #2
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
My first slice was a classic Margherita. It had a slightly charred crust with a nice chewiness. The tomato sauce was flavorful and the mozzarella cheese melted perfectly over the top of it. Each bite was a delight!
Next, I tried their signature mushroom pizza. Wow! The combination of mushrooms, garlic, olive oil, and Parmesan cheese was incredible! The earthy flavors came through in each bite and made my mouth water for more.
Finally, I tried the prosciutto pizza with arugula—a flavor combination I’ve never had before at any other pizzeria! The sweetness of the prosciutto balanced out the bitterness of the arugula nicely, creating an incredibly delicious pizza.
Overall, Jeppy’s Gourmet Pizza Shop #2 is where you want to go if you’re looking for great pizza in Hamilton NJ. They have something to satisfy everyone’s taste buds! Don’t forget to order some garlic knots or wings on the side; they’re just as good as the pizza itself!
#5 Nino’s Pizzarama
- Nice tourist spot
The atmosphere at Nino’s is right up my alley. With a dimly lit room, red checkered table cloths and the sound of Frank Sinatra playing in the background, it makes for an enjoyable dining experience that rivals any pizzeria in the world.
The food itself is even better than the atmosphere! I started with the garlic knots which were always a hit – they were crispy on the outside while still being warm and fluffy on the inside. The sauce was perfectly seasoned and made me feel like I was in Italy.
For my main course, I ordered a large margherita pizza with extra cheese. Let me tell you – it was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! The dough was light, fluffy and perfectly cooked, with just the right amount of charring on the crust. The sauce had a perfect balance of sweet and savory flavors that went perfectly with all of the fresh mozzarella and basil leaves scattered across the pie.
All in all, this place really does serve up some of the best pizza in Hamilton NJ – and dare I say, anywhere else! If you’re ever looking for an amazing slice (or three), do yourself a favor and swing by Nino’s Pizzarama!
#6 Mario’s Pizza
- Offers dessert
The first thing that struck me when I went to Mario’s Pizza was the atmosphere. It was a lively and vibrant place, and you could tell everyone there was having a good time. Plus, it had a great smell – like tomato, garlic, and oregano.
I sampled many of their pizzas, from classic cheese pizzas to more complex creations like margherita pizza with mushrooms and peppers. Every bite was delicious! The crust had just the right amount of crunch, the sauce was flavorful without being too overpowering, and the cheese was perfectly melted. The toppings were fresh and well- balanced making each slice an artful masterpiece.
But what really sets Mario’s Pizza apart is their genuine hospitality. From the moment I walked in until my last bite of pizza, I felt like family. The waitstaff was friendly and attentive, always making sure my dining experience was top notch.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Hamilton NJ, look no further than Mario’s Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!
#7 Villaggio Iccara
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has insanely good dessert
Upon arriving at the restaurant, I was shocked to find out that Villaggio Iccara is a family-run business that’s been around for over 20 years! It’s heartwarming to see such a long-standing legacy still serving up amazing pizza.
The pizza itself is something else. The crust is cooked just right – nice and crispy on the edges so it doesn’t get soggy from the toppings. The tomato sauce packs a punch with its bold flavor, which goes well with the generous amounts of cheese and toppings. And finally, every pie here comes with lots of garlic knots – you’ll need to breath mints afterwards but it’ll be worth it!
When all is said and done, Villaggio Iccara has some of the best pizza in Hamilton NJ, hands down! They’ve more than earned their spot as one of my top picks for the best pies in town.
#8 Villa María Restaurant
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
I have to admit, I was a bit skeptical at first. After all, it’s a small restaurant located in the middle of nowhere. But boy oh boy, was I wrong!
Villa María Restaurant serves up some of the most delicious pies I’ve ever tasted. The crust is so flavourful and light – as if it was handmade in Italy that very day! The toppings are amazing too – fresh vegetables, juicy meats and tangy cheeses make every single bite an explosion of flavour.
But what really sets this place apart from the competition is their service. From the moment you step foot inside the restaurant, you are treated like royalty. All of the staff take the time to talk to you and explain each pizza they serve. It almost made me feel like family!
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Hamilton NJ, look no further than Villa María Restaurant!
If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Trenton!
#9 Corleone’s Old Fashion Tomato Pie & Pizza
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
Whenever I’m in town, I always make it a point to stop in for one of their signature pies. They have all sorts of options, from classic pepperoni and cheese to more gourmet toppings like artichoke hearts and goat cheese. No matter what kind I get, the homemade tomato sauce is always spot on—it has just the right amount of sweetness that really makes the pizza sing.
The crust is also crucial, and Corleone’s never disappoints; it’s a thin-crust, crispy affair that puts most other pizza places to shame with its light yet flavorful crunch. And the generous helping of cheese does not overwhelm but rather complements the flavors of each topping perfectly.
To top it all off, Corleone’s has a great atmosphere—the staff are incredibly friendly and helpful with menu choices, and they have an extensive selection of craft beers as well as traditional Italian wines to choose from.
In short, if you’re ever in Hamilton NJ and craving some delicious pizza, then there’s no better place than Corleone’s Old Fashion Tomato Pie & Pizza. It may be hard to find a better pie anywhere else!
#10 Anthony’s Pizza Palace
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
The place has a great atmosphere, and the staff are incredibly friendly and attentive. The dough was light and fluffy, the sauce had just the right amount of sweetness, and each topping was carefully chosen to give maximum flavor.
As for the toppings, they have an extensive variety that will make you feel like a kid in a candy store! From pepperoni to pineapple, you’ll find everything your heart desires at Anthony’s Pizza Palace.
My favorite pizza is their “exotic” pie – with feta cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, artichoke hearts, olives and onions – it’s truly a one-of-a-kind taste sensation!
I’m not sure if I have ever experienced such satisfaction from eating pizza before but let me tell you – this is possibly the best pizza in Hamilton NJ! If you’re ever in town, you must try Anthony’s Pizza Palace at least once.
#11 Vincent’s Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
I was first struck by the inviting atmosphere when I walked in. The staff was friendly and welcoming, and the decor had a classic Italian-style pizzeria feel to it. And then there were the pizzas – oh my! The crusts were thin and crispy, with just the right amount of char on them. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, with a perfect balance of sweet and savory. It was truly a pizza-lovers dream!
As if that wasn’t enough, Vincent’s also offers an impressive selection of toppings, sauces, and cheeses. From pepperoni to jalapenos to vegan cheese, you can find whatever topping your heart desires. Plus, they offer specialty pizzas like Buffalo Chicken and Bacon Mac & Cheese that are sure to please even the pickiest eaters.
The bottom line? If you’re looking for the best pizza in Hamilton NJ, look no further than Vincent’s Pizza! Don’t miss out on this delicious slice of heaven!
#12 Mannino’s 3
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has insanely good dessert
It’s the kind of place where you can smell the deliciousness when you walk in. Everyone is always friendly and welcoming, making me feel right at home.
The pizza crust here is beyond perfection. It’s crispy on the outside and oh-so soft on the inside. The freshly-made sauce has a wonderful balance of sweet and savory flavors, which makes it a mouthwatering experience. And, the cheese – ah, they don’t skimp! Each slice contains loads of cheese that melts in your mouth with every bite.
I dare say that Mannino’s 3 may even have better pizza than some of my favorite spots in Rome! They definitely set the bar for great pizza in Hamilton NJ. I can’t wait to come back for more!
