Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Kansas City MO (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Missouri

Best Pizza in Kansas City MO (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

189 Views

I’ve traveled all over the world tasting pizza, and I must say that KC doesn’t disappoint. With over 12 different places to try, I’m excited to share my findings with you.

I’m a big fan of cheesy slices and unique flavors, so I decided to check out what Kansas City had in store. Was it worth it? Absolutely! From mom-and-pop shops to top-notch eateries, KC definitely has some of the best pizza around.

With a humorous and lighthearted attitude towards discovery, let’s get ready to take a journey through Kansas City’s finest pizzerias and find out which one reigns supreme!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Missouri

#1 Martin City Pizza And Taproom

The atmosphere at Martin City Pizza And Taproom is great – the staff are welcoming, always willing to offer advice on which pizzas to try and talk about their own personal favorites. There’s also a great selection of craft beers and ciders, making it the perfect place to take your friends for an evening out.

As far as the pizza itself goes, I have to say that Martin City Pizza And Taproom just knocked it out of the park! The quality of their ingredients is top notch and you can tell that they take pride in everything that comes out of their kitchen. The crusts are light and fluffy, yet still nice and crispy once cooked. The sauce is full of flavor with a little kick of spice that really adds to the overall flavor profile. Finally, the toppings are so fresh, you can almost taste the farm-to-table attitude behind every slice.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Kansas City MO, then look no further than Martin City Pizza And Taproom! Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite alone or hanging out with friends while enjoying some delicious craft beer, Martin City Pizza And Taproom definitely hits all the right notes!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Overland Park!

#2 Southside Mafia Pizzeria

The atmosphere at Southside Mafia Pizzeria was excellent! The rustic decor and industrial-chic vibe made it feel like I was really part of the ‘mafia’. The staff was friendly, knowledgeable and always welcoming.

The pizza itself was like a piece of art. Each slice looked like it had been carefully crafted with love and care. But don’t let the presentation fool you – there’s real flavor behind it too! The crust was perfectly crisp while still remaining light and airy. Topping combinations were unique but incredibly delicious, from the classic cheese to their signature Bacon Supreme – this is some good stuff!

Overall, I would highly recommend Southside Mafia Pizzeria for anyone looking for the best pizza in Kansas City MO! With great atmosphere, friendly staff and some seriously delicious pizza – you’d be hard pressed to find better. So grab your gang (legal or otherwise) and head on down to Southside Mafia Pizzeria – it won’t disappoint!

#3 Providence Pizza Westport

When I walked in, I felt overwhelmed by the aroma of fresh-baked pizza in the air. The decor was inviting and cozy, creating a relaxing atmosphere perfect for enjoying a delicious meal.

As soon as I sat down and ordered my pizza, I knew this place was special. The pizza was cooked to perfection with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Plus, it had an amazing crunchy crust that made it stand out amongst other pizzas. And trust me, I’ve tasted A LOT of pizza on my travels!

The staff were incredibly friendly and helpful, making sure we were comfortable throughout our entire visit. They were also very knowledgeable about their menu options – something that you don’t always find in other establishments.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some great pizza here in Kansas City MO then look no further than Providence Pizza Westport! With it’s tasty options and friendly service, you won’t be disappointed!

#4 Leo’s Pizza

The thing that really sets them apart is the fresh ingredients. Unlike other pizza places, they only use top quality ingredients in their pies, giving you a fantastic flavor. The crust is the perfect combination of crunchy and chewy, with a hint of sweetness from the Italian olive oil used to bake it.

The toppings are also something special – from the classic pepperoni and sausage to their unique creations like artichoke hearts and sundried tomatoes. No matter what combination of toppings you choose, you won’t be disappointed.

And let’s not forget about the sauce – it’s tangy and flavorful, without being overpoweringly spicy. It complements all the flavors perfectly!

Overall, Leo’s Pizza is my favorite pizza spot in Kansas City MO. If you’re looking for delicious pizza with top-notch ingredients served up by friendly staff, then this is definitely your place!

#5 Buffalo State Pizza Co. & Bar

The atmosphere was warm and welcoming, with a family-friendly vibe. I ordered the “Signature Pizza,” and it truly lived up to its name. The spices were just right and the crust was perfectly cooked. The toppings were fresh and flavorful—definitely some of the best I’ve ever tasted!

The staff at Buffalo State Pizza Co. & Bar were super friendly and accommodating as well. They made sure my slice was cooked to perfection, without me having to ask them twice!

I have to say, this visit has been one of my most enjoyable pizza experiences ever—really top notch! If you’re looking for the best pizza in Kansas City MO, look no further than Buffalo State Pizza Co. & Bar! You won’t be disappointed.

#6 Milwaukee Delicatessen Company

The ambiance is second to none with a friendly and welcoming staff and classic decor. The menu gives you lots to choose from, including some really unique topping combinations.

And the pizza? Well, let me tell you – it’s out of this world! Each slice is cooked to perfection with a nice crunch on the crust and tons of flavor. The sauces are also amazing and they have one that pairs perfectly with each type of pizza.

My favorite thing about Milwaukee Delicatessen Company? Their commitment to quality ingredients. They source all their produce locally, so you know it’s fresh! Plus, they use premium cheeses for their slices that just can’t be beat.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Kansas City MO, there’s no doubt that Milwaukee Delicatessen Company should be your first stop!

#7 Nicky’s Pizza

The first thing I noticed at Nicky’s was their unique atmosphere. As soon as I walked in the door, I was welcomed by friendly staff, and the room smelled like a delicious blend of spices and cheese. Plus, everyone in the restaurant seemed to be having a great time!

Next, it was time for the pizza. The crust was perfectly thin and had just the right amount of crunch on the outside and chewiness on the inside. The sauce had a slight sweetness that paired well with the array of toppings—my favorite being the homemade sausage. Each slice was loaded with flavor that made my taste buds dance!

It’s safe to say that I will definitely be back to try more of Nicky’s delicious slices! In my opinion, they provide some of the best pizza in Kansas City MO. If you haven’t stopped by yet, do yourself a favor and drop by soon—you won’t regret it!

#8 Pizza Tascio NKC

The first thing I noticed was the adorable little storefront with a blue and white striped awning. It made me feel like I was in an Italian pizzeria! But the pizza itself is what really won me over. The cheese had a great flavor, with just the right amount of creamy and tangy notes, and the crust was perfectly cooked — not too thick, not too thin.

The toppings were also top-notch. Whether it was pepperoni, bacon, onions or mushrooms, everything tasted fresh and delicious. And if you’re looking for something extra special to try out, they also have some unique specialty pizzas that are definitely worth trying.

Overall, I’d give Pizza Tascio NKC a hearty 5/5 stars! If you’re looking for great pizza in Kansas City MO, this is definitely your go-to spot!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Olathe!

#9 Pizza Shuttle

The smell of freshly baked pizza greeted me when I walked into Pizza Shuttle, and the friendly staff made me feel welcome. The tasty dough and flavorful toppings won me over right away. The thin, crispy crust was just perfect for my taste buds – not too thin and not too thick. And each slice was perfectly cheesy with just the right amount of sauce.

The atmosphere at Pizza Shuttle is second to none. From the retro-style dining area with lots of seating to the gaming area with vintage pinball machines, there’s something for everyone here. The staff was very knowledgeable in recommending the best options and they were able to accommodate my dietary needs without any hassle at all.

If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Kansas City MO, look no further than Pizza Shuttle – it truly is some of the best pizza around!

#10 Bella Napoli

The atmosphere of this restaurant is both inviting and cozy. From the moment I arrived, I was greeted warmly by the staff and immediately felt right at home.

My friend and I were seated quickly, which gave us ample time to peruse the menu. There was a wide variety of pizzas, ranging from classic margheritas to creative gourmet creations that showcase their use of fresh ingredients. As expected, I had to try them all – but luckily my friend was more than happy to help me out!

We started off with some classic margherita pizza and an order of garlic breadsticks. The crust was thin but perfectly cooked, which is a must for any good pizza in my book. You can really taste the love that goes into each pie here.

Next up was the Sicilian pizza with sausage and peppers – an absolute classic! The spicy Italian flavor combination had me hooked from first bite to last. Another highlight of our experience at Bella Napoli was their house-made Italian ice cream; it’s like nothing else you’ll find elsewhere!

Overall, Bella Napoli definitely lives up to its reputation as one of Kansas City MO’s best pizza places – don’t take my word for it though – come try it for yourself!

#11 Haha’s Pizza Hub

My experience there was a sheer delight! From the moment I stepped through the doors, I was welcomed by the friendly staff. They directed me to a seat and gave me their menus with a wide variety of delicious pizza options.

I opted for The Firecracker, which came from Haha’s signature “Air-Baked™” cooking style. This unique method of baking creates an incredibly light yet crunchy crust with a rich flavor that really brings out the toppings. The blend of zesty pepperoni and spicy jalapenos on top was unlike anything I’d ever tried before, and it left my taste buds dancing!

Not only is their pizza top-notch, but they also serve up some pretty delicious sides as well. Their garlic bread sticks covered in melted cheese were virtually irresistible!

In short, it’s clear that Haha’s Pizza Hub knows how to do pizza right. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Kansas City MO, look no further than this place!

#12 Pizza 51

I’ve never been so impressed with a pizza restaurant, especially one in the Midwest. The atmosphere of the restaurant is great- it’s lively yet comfortable. The service was fantastic, and the staff were very friendly and knowledgeable about their food.

The pizza itself was what I came for though, and boy did it not disappoint! It was freshly baked in their wood burning oven, with an amazing crispy crust that had just the right amount of char. The pizza was topped with quality ingredients like vine-ripened tomatoes and fresh mozzarella – they definitely weren’t skimping on any flavors here! The flavors were robust yet balanced, and I could tell that the chefs had put a lot of care into crafting each pie.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza around Kansas City MO, look no further than Pizza 51 – you won’t be disappointed!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Walking into Old Chicago, I felt a rush of excitement that can only be compared to winning the lottery or finding your long-lost sock. The aroma of freshly baked pizza dough filled the air, beckoning me to dive right in. I sat down, ready to embark on a culinary adventure.

As I took my first bite, my taste buds did a happy dance, high-fiving each other and congratulating me on the excellent choice. The crust was crispy and golden, like a sun-tanned surfer riding a wave of flavor. Each layer of cheese had been carefully crafted, making it melt in my mouth like a celebrity in front of the cameras.

The toppings were a symphony of flavors that harmonized perfectly with the cheesy canvas. From the classic pepperoni to the exotic pineapple, every bite was like a surprise party in my mouth. And let’s not forget about the sauce! It was tangy and robust, like a superhero saving the day from blandness.

The atmosphere at Old Chicago was as lively as a game of musical chairs, with friendly staff who were as happy as a dog with two tails. They made sure my pizza experience was top-notch and even recommended some delicious craft beers to pair with my meal.

Overall, Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom is a pizza paradise in Kansas City. So if you’re in the mood for the best deep dish pizza in town, look no further. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you, and you’ll leave with a bigger smile than a clown at a birthday party.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Il Lazzarone Pizza

Let me start by saying that their decision to serve alcohol (and hard liquor, no less!) is an absolute stroke of genius. What better way to wash down a delicious slice of pizza than with a cold, refreshing beer or a cheeky cocktail? They really understand the needs of their customers.

Now I know what you’re thinking, But Edward, I’m a vegetarian! Well, fear not my herbivorous friends, because Il Lazzarone Pizza has got your back. They offer some delicious vegetarian options that will have you forgetting about meat altogether. Their veggie toppings are so fresh and flavorful, it’s like a party in your mouth!

But wait, there’s more! Il Lazzarone Pizza also offers dessert. That’s right, you can indulge in a sweet treat after devouring their incredible pizza. Trust me, you won’t want to skip out on this part of the experience.

Now, I have to mention one downside, and that is the lack of delivery service. But hey, if you’re in the mood for the best thin crust pizza in kansas city, isn’t it worth the effort to make the trip to Il Lazzarone Pizza? Think of it as a mini adventure in search of pizza perfection.

All in all, if you’re a pizza lover like me, Il Lazzarone Pizza is a must-visit. From their delectable thin crust to their fantastic drink selection, it’s a tourist spot that will leave you feeling satisfied and entertained.