Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in The Poconos (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Pennsylvania

Best Pizza in The Poconos (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

243 Views

In the last few months, I’ve sunk my teeth into twelve different pizza places in The Poconos to find out which one makes the best pie. This was no easy feat! I have traveled around the world and tasted all kinds of pizza – so you know this review is serious business.

But don’t worry – I’m keeping it lighthearted. This isn’t fancy food critique; it’s an honest opinion from a passionate foodie who loves delicious pizza! Keep reading to find out which place serves the best pie in The Poconos.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania

#1 Bennys

I’d heard a lot of buzz about Bennys, so I was eager to check it out. When I arrived, I was immediately blown away by the warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff were friendly and helpful, asking questions about what type of pizza I wanted and making sure that my order was perfect.

The food itself was nothing short of incredible. The pizza crust was perfectly crisp, with an ideal ratio of sauce to cheese. Plus, the toppings were top-notch: sausage, pepperoni, olives, and more! The combination of flavors made this one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

On top of all that, they have a great selection of beers on tap that pairs perfectly with pizza. From local microbrews to national favorites; they have something for everyone.

To sum it all up, if you’re in The Poconos and looking for some delicious pizza (plus some really great beer!), then Bennys is the place for you!

If you’re willing to go an extra 23 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Easton!

#2 Brothers Pizzeria

The restaurant itself isn’t anything fancy, but it definitely has character and a unique charm. The staff is friendly and always greet customers with a warm smile.

The pizza is where Brothers most shines though! They are dedicated to providing the best pizzas around using only the freshest ingredients. Every pizza is hand crafted with love, care and attention to detail that you won’t find in any other restaurant.

The mixtures of toppings they have on their menu are truly something special – from classic pepperoni and cheese to more exotic combinations of flavors like pineapple, artichoke hearts, and capicola. Whatever you choose, you’ll be sure to be satisfied!

I can confidently say that I’ve yet to find another pizza place with such great tasting pizza in The Poconos! Brothers Pizzeria definitely earns its title as the best pizza around!

#3 Aj pizza and Parm House

The restaurant itself has a cozy atmosphere that puts you right at home. Service was friendly and attentive, not to mention very fast.

Now, let’s talk pizza. They serve up some delicious pies here with simple yet flavorful toppings. The crust is nice and thin with a nicely golden brown top. Every bite had the perfect balance of sauce, cheese and topping.

My favorite thing about Aj pizza and Parm House is their speciality Parm House Pizza! It comes with garlic buttery crust topped with a creamy ricotta cheese base, fresh mozzarella and tomatoes, then sprinkled with fresh basil leaves for an added kick of flavor. Delicious!

Overall, my experience at Aj pizza and Parm House was nothing short of amazing. Their pizzas are top notch and the service was great! If you’re ever in The Poconos looking for authentic Italian pizza, this is definitely the place to go!

#4 Pocono Pizza & Eatery

The quality of the ingredients was obvious right away. The steak pizza I ordered had juicy, flavorful steak that was cooked to perfection. And the classic cheese pizza? To die for. Even though the sauce was fresh and tomato-y, it wasn’t too acidic or sweet. It tasted like a dream!

But what really stood out to me were some of the unique toppings that you won’t find anywhere else. The Mexican Pizza had simple but delicious chili con carne on it, as well as chunks of real jalapenos for a nice kick.

My favorite part about my experience at Pocono Pizza & Eatery might have been the atmosphere. It’s a cozy, family-owned spot with friendly staff who really care about creating something special for their customers. They even carried some vegan options on their menu!

All in all, Pocono Pizza & Eatery is definitely one of the best pizza spots in The Poconos – and I would know!

#5 Mamma Maria’s

I stopped by recently and I was blown away by the atmosphere, the fresh ingredients, and of course, the delicious pizza.

Even as a seasoned food critic that’s tried some of the best pizza around the world, Mamma Maria’s truly stands out. From their crust to cheese ratio to their selection of toppings, each slice was truly something special.

I even chatted with Mama Maria herself who told me her family recipe has been passed down for generations! She also shared some insight in how she uses local Poconos ingredients to make each pizza one-of-a-kind.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in The Poconos, look no further than Mamma Maria’s!

#6 Dominic’s Pizza

I indulged in one of their locally famous pies and it was absolutely incredible. The crust was light and fluffy with the perfect amount of crunch, and their signature sauce was full of flavor. To top it off, they used only the freshest ingredients to make some truly delicious toppings.

The atmosphere of Dominic’s Pizza was relaxed and inviting, with a casual environment that made it easy to enjoy my pizza experience. The staff were also incredibly friendly which added to the charm.

This place definitely deserves an A+ for pizza! Anyone looking for some of the best pizza in the Poconos should definitely give Dominic’s Pizza a try!

#7 Mamma Lucia’s Pizzeria at Sorrenti Family Estate

The pizzeria is a cozy spot with warm, inviting decor and friendly staff who make you feel like part of the family. They serve up some awesome Italian recipes that never fail to tantalize my taste buds. Plus there’s a variety of vegetarian options, so everyone can enjoy their meals here!

But what I think really sets Mamma Lucia’s apart is the selection of delicious alcoholic beverages. Whether you want a beer or glass of wine, they have something to fit every mood. And believe me, no pizza experience is complete without the perfect pairing!

Of course, if you save room, then there are also plenty of scrumptious dessert choices. From cannolis to baked ziti – not to mention the made-from-scratch gelato – your sweet tooth will thank you for choosing Mamma Lucia’s Pizzeria at Sorrenti Family Estate.

The only downside I can think of is that they don’t offer delivery (but c’mon – it’s worth it to visit in person!). When all is said and done, this restaurant deserves all its accolades for serving up some seriously good pizza in The Poconos. Trust me: if you’re looking for the best pizza around, this is definitely it!

#8 Pizzaro’s

The atmosphere alone will make a lasting impression. You’re greeted with the smell of freshly baked pizza dough, and the cheerful staff made the experience even better.

I can’t say enough about the quality of their ingredients. The sauce was cooked just right, complementing the thick and cheesy mozzarella that topped my pizza. The dough was both light and crispy on the outside yet still soft on the inside – an absolute work of art!

It’s no wonder why Pizzaro’s is so popular in this area. The prices are more than reasonable, despite all of their high-quality ingredients and special cooking techniques. I was truly impressed at how quickly they were able to get my pizza ready as well!

I’m not sure if there is better pizza in The Poconos than Pizzaro’s – but I would definitely recommend giving it a try if you get the chance!

If you’re willing to go an extra 26 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Bethlehem!

#9 Antonio’s Pizza

From the moment I walked into Antonio’s Pizza, I knew it was a special place. The classic Italian decor, the aroma of fresh baked dough, and the friendly staff made me feel right at home.

The pizza itself was something else – delicious! The crust was crispy and crunchy, with just the right amount of moisture. The topping selections were plentiful and flavorful. There was something for everyone!

In addition to that fantastic pizza, Antonio’s also serves other delicious Italian fare. Their calzones were overflowing with cheese and their freshly-made pasta dishes had us licking our plates in no time.

If you’re ever in The Poconos looking for some of the best pizza around, look no further than Antonio’s Pizza! You won’t be sorry…I guarantee it!

#10 Capri Pizza

When I first walked in, the smell of fresh baked pizza hit me like a freight train and I haven’t been able to get it out of my head since. The warm, homey atmosphere makes you want to stay forever and sample their many delicious pies.

The pizzas at Capri Pizza are made with only the freshest ingredients and the perfect blend of spices that create the most flavorful pies I’ve ever tasted! Their thin-crust pizzas are extra crispy, crunchy, and full of flavor. Plus, they offer a wide selection of specialty pizzas so there’s something for everyone.

But it isn’t just the pizza that blew me away, the service was top notch—friendly, welcoming staff that made my experience even better. It’s no wonder why Capri Pizza has become one of my favorite restaurants in The Poconos!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in The Poconos, look no further than Capri Pizza. I guarantee your taste buds will thank you for it!

#11 Frank’s Pizza of Bartonsville

When I first visited Frank’s, I was amazed at the variety of pizzas available. From classic Italian-style pies to unique creations made with exotic toppings, the menu had something for everyone. Whether you’re a cheese lover or an adventurous eater, there’s a pizza here that’ll make your mouth water.

But what really impressed me was their level of commitment to quality. Every single ingredient is fresh and locally sourced, and the dough is made daily in-house. This dedication to excellence really shows in each bite – the crust has just the right amount of crunch and flavor, while all the toppings are perfectly cooked and blended together harmoniously. Plus, they offer some really interesting specialty pizza combinations that you won’t find anywhere else in the area!

All in all, I truly believe that Frank’s Pizza of Bartonsville serves some of the best pizza in The Poconos – so if you’re ever around, be sure to stop by for a slice (or two!).

#12 Kasa’s Pizza

When I arrived at Kasa’s Pizza, I was a bit skeptical. It didn’t look like your typical pizza place — but then again, it isn’t! The interior of the restaurant has an inviting, homey feel, making you feel as if you’ve somehow been transported to Italy.

But it’s the food that really matters. And when it comes to pizza, Kasa’s does not disappoint! From their signature Margherita to their spicy pepperoni and roasted vegetable slices, each bite is an explosion of flavor. Their dough is light and fluffy with just the right amount of crunch — definitely something that can’t be found everywhere.

To top off the experience, they also offer some great sides like garlic bread and salads that pair perfectly with their pizzas. To make things even better, they were willing to customize my order to make sure it’s exactly how I wanted it.

If you’re ever in The Poconos looking for great pizza, do yourself a favor and check out Kasa’s Pizza — you won’t regret it! It may just be the best pizza in The Poconos!