Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in York ME (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Maine

Best Pizza in York ME (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

79 Views

I have sampled the pizza at 11 different places around town, and I’m happy to report that there are some real gems in the bunch.

What might surprise you is that none of these pizzerias had a line out the door when I visited them – it’s almost like York ME knows all about their hidden treasures and wants to keep them all to itself!

Join me as I share my thoughtful and humorous reviews of the best pizza in York ME, so you can decide where to satisfy your craving for a great slice.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Maine

#1 YORK54 Pizza

The atmosphere was great, with cheerful staff and customers, a modern yet cozy décor, and of course the aroma of freshly-cooked pizza in the air.

The pizza itself was excellent. The crust had just the right amount of crunch – not too crispy nor too floppy – and the cheese was cheesy perfection. Toppings were also top notch; they tasted fresh and flavorful, with creative combinations that weren’t over-the-top or gimmicky.

The service was fast and friendly as well – our order was taken promptly, we received our pizzas within 15 minutes, and refills came quickly without having to ask for them. I especially appreciated the server’s knowledge of the menu items; he answered all my questions precisely and wasn’t afraid to give his opinion on what might be best.

Overall, it’s no wonder why YORK54 Pizza is considered one of the best places for pizza in York ME: delicious food, excellent service, and an inviting atmosphere! Highly recommended!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Portsmouth!

#2 Dante’s Pizza Company

I’ve never tasted a pizza as flavorful and mouthwatering as this one. It’s like eating a slice of heaven! The perfect balance between the sauce and cheese, the fresh ingredients, and the thick crust make their pizzas out of this world.

The staff at Dante’s were also some of the friendliest I’ve ever encountered. They made me feel right at home, which was great in comparison to some of the less pleasant pizza places I had been to in my travels.

All in all, Dante’s Pizza Company is certainly worth a visit if you’re looking for an excellent pizza experience. Their top-notch ingredients and staff made it one of the best pizza places I’ve ever visited. Without a doubt, it is the best pizza in York ME!

#3 Cornerstone Artisanal Pizza & Craft Beer

At first glance it seems like a typical pizza joint, but the moment you walk in and take in the friendly atmosphere you know that this is not your ordinary pizza restaurant. The staff was pleasant and accommodating, and the menu had something for everyone – from vegetarians to kids. The liquor selection was impressive too!

The pizza itself certainly lived up to my expectations as one of the best pies around! The quality ingredients used made all the difference, resulting in a delicious crust that was perfectly cooked every time. Every topping provided a unique flavor that truly made each slice special.

However, some might be disappointed with Cornerstone’s lack of delivery option. But if you’re looking for a nice spot to visit while in York ME then this is definitely it! And once you taste the hot slices there’s no way you’ll leave without having zero regrets.

All in all, I’m giving Cornerstone an A+ rating! If visiting York ME soon, be sure to check out this place – I guarantee it’ll quickly become part of your travel routine. Hands down one of the best pizzas around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 13 more pizza places in Wells!

#4 Ogunquit House of Pizza

I’m not one to turn down a culinary experience, so when I heard about Ogunquit House of Pizza, I had to try it for myself.

When I arrived, I was immediately impressed with the atmosphere. It was tourist-friendly without being too cliche and had a fun vibe. Even better than that, they have a kids menu – which is perfect for families!

Now on to the pizza – it’s out of this world! The crust is crisp and perfectly cooked every time. The toppings are fresh and flavorful, including some unique options like roasted garlic. The prices are also very reasonable – definitely value for money in my opinion!

The only downside is that they don’t deliver – but then again, why rush when you can enjoy the deliciousness right there?! In my books, it’s well worth the visit.

If you’re looking for what I consider to be the best pizza in York ME (and who isn’t?!), then look no further than Ogunquit House of Pizza. My advice? Get there now and grab yourself a slice (or two). DELICIOUS!

#5 La Pizzeria

The atmosphere at La Pizzeria was cozy and inviting. The decor was warm and inviting, with a few Italian accents here and there which really helped to set the stage for a great meal.

When I bit into my first slice of pizza I was immediately convinced that this place had some of the best pizza in York ME. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, with just the right amount of oil to keep it from getting soggy. The sauce was flavorful without being overly acidic, and the cheese melted all over the top.

I ordered a variety of toppings including pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, bell peppers, olives and sausage – which were all cooked to perfection! I couldn’t help but go back for seconds (or thirds!)

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in York ME then look no further than La Pizzeria! Whether you like traditional or specialty pizzas, they have something for everyone on their menu – sure to satisfy even the most avid food critic!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Dover!

#6 Ruby’s Wood Grill

They offer a great selection of toppings, some of those being unusual for pizza, like chicken and pineapple. The atmosphere is just as delicious. There’s even a bar where I can order my favorite beer or hard liquor to go with the fantastic pie!

The kids menu looks tasty too, which is always a plus. And when I’m done, I can stay for another round of drinks and watch sports on the big screen. To top it off, there are a few different desserts to choose from should I want something sweet afterwards.

Now here’s the downside – Ruby’s Wood Grill doesn’t deliver pizza. But that shouldn’t be too much of a problem since their location is one of the most popular tourist spots in town! So if you’re looking for the best pizza in York ME, make your way to Ruby’s Wood Grill. It really is worth it!

#7 York House of Pizza

It’s no surprise that this place has been around for nearly sixty years now; these folks know how to make great pizza and they have the recipes perfected. From their classic Margherita to a modern take on the Eggplant Parmesan, York House of Pizza has something for everyone!

The crust was cooked perfectly every time I ordered, golden brown with a slight crispiness. The sauce is sweet and flavorful and if you like extra cheese, you’ll be in pizza heaven here! My favorite combination is the pepperoni, olives and garlic; it’s like an explosion of flavor in your mouth.

The best part about eating at York House of Pizza is that the prices are very reasonable. You can easily feed a family of four on one large pizza and still have some left over for lunch the next day. Plus, they offer delivery if you don’t feel like leaving your house.

In conclusion, if you are looking for the best pizza in York ME then be sure to give York House of Pizza a try – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 25 miles, you can get to 15 more pizza places in Newburyport!

#8 Domino’s Pizza

My first visit to Domino’s Pizza was an experience I’ll never forget. From the moment I walked in, the delicious scent of fresh pizza dough filled my nostrils. The employees were friendly and eager to serve up a delicious slice of their fantastic pizza.

I sampled several of their available pizzas and by far, the highlight of the night was their yummy supreme pizza. Piled high with freshly cut vegetables, pepperoni, sausage, and an extra special sauce that clung to every bite; this pizza was truly a treat!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in York ME then look no further than Domino’s Pizza! The ingredients are top quality and their customer service is unbeatable. Highly recommend!

#9 Woodys Brick Oven Pizza

The atmosphere is always great; they have a nice, cozy spot to eat, and even serve alcohol! I usually order their large cheese pizza with pepperoni and sausage. The crust is perfectly cooked and crunchy on the outside, with a soft, chewy center. The combination of cheese, pepperoni and sausage gives it a heavenly flavor.

The only thing that could make Woodys Brick Oven Pizza better would be if they had delivery service. But I think it’s worth the trip – it’s an excellent tourist spot too!

All in all, Woodys Brick Oven Pizza is definitely my favorite pizza joint in York ME – hands down, the best pizza around!

#10 Roberto’s

I was impressed from the moment I stepped through the doors, finding a warm and welcoming atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, eager to help make sure I found exactly what I wanted.

The menu had something for everyone, with a selection of adults-only alcoholic beverages (including hard liquor!), a kid’s menu, and plenty of creative pizza topping combos. It seemed like there was something for everyone!

Speaking of topping combos, I’m glad to report that Roberto’s makes insanely good dessert pizzas! My personal favorite: banana cream with hot fudge and mini marshmallows. Delicious!

As great as Roberto’s is, there is one slight downside: they don’t deliver. So if you want to enjoy their amazing pizza creations, you’ll have to make the trip yourself. It’s worth it though – trust me!

To summarize: Roberto’s is definitely one of the best pizza places in York ME! With its great atmosphere, good service, kid-friendly options, and tasty desserts, it’s definitely worth a visit if you’re in town.

#11 The Napoli’s – Italian Kitchen & Bar

The restaurant is clean and unpretentious, but makes quite the impression when it comes to pizza. Their signature pies are hand-tossed with secret family recipes that will make any pizza-lover swoon.

The toppings are fresh, flavorful, and expertly portioned — not too much so you never miss out on a single delicious bite! The crusts are crispy yet chewy with just the right amount of char and smokey flavor.

I especially enjoyed their fun selection of specialty pizzas. The Roasted Squash Gorgonzola has layers of roasted squash, smoky gorgonzola crumbles, mozzarella, and garlic cream sauce that pair together perfectly. Not to mention the entrée salads — like the Caprese salad with roasted red peppers, mozzarella di bufala, cherry tomatoes in olive oil — which are ideal for lighter eaters or those looking for a side dish.

Overall I was very impressed by The Napoli’s – Italian Kitchen & Bar and can confidently say that they serve some of the best pizza in York ME!