Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Amarillo TX (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Texas

Best Pizza in Amarillo TX (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

76 Views

While pizza in Texas is usually thought of as being quite different from the pizza made around Rome or Naples, Amarillo still managed to surprise me. After an extensive sampling tour of the 12 best pizza places in Amarillo, I’m happy to give you my top recommendations.

But first, a bit about what makes a great pizza: it must have a crisp and perfectly charred crust, robust flavors that blend well together yet still stand out on their own, and of course plenty of cheese – not too little and not too much. Armed with these criteria, let’s get to the tasting.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Texas

#1 Jimbo Slice Pizzeria inside J’s Bar and Grill

I’d heard a lot of great things about this place, so I was eager to see what they had in store. After walking through the door, I was immediately greeted by the welcoming atmosphere and the mouth-watering aroma of fresh-baked pies. I quickly ordered their signature “Jimbo Slice,” which wasn’t easy because there were so many delicious options on the menu.

Let me tell ya, this pizza was truly incredible! The crust was slightly crunchy yet soft in all the right spots, with a nice hint of olive oil that added an amazing depth of flavor. The sauce was perfectly balanced between sweet and spicy and complemented the cheese nicely. Of course, you can’t forget about the toppings which were generous portions of fresh peppers, onions, olives and pepperoni that really put it over the top.

All in all, it is no wonder why Jimbo Slice Pizzeria inside J’s Bar and Grill has become so popular over time. It offers some of the best pizza in Amarillo TX that’s sure to satisfy any palette!

If you’re willing to go an extra 114 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Lubbock!

#2 575 Pizzeria

This amazing little pizzeria has everything I could hope for – a great atmosphere, delicious food, and ample opportunities for culinary exploration. I was particularly impressed by the fact that 575 Pizzeria serves alcohol, making it ideal for adult gatherings. For those with younger guests, there’s a kid’s menu that’s sure to make dining enjoyable for everyone. Even vegetarians have several options to choose from!

The pizza itself is what really wowed me – fresh ingredients combined with expert craftsmanship make every bite of 575 Pizzeria pizza an experience you won’t soon forget. To top off the meal, they offer scrumptious desserts that are the perfect way to end your night out.

The only downside to this restaurant is that they don’t offer delivery service, but considering all the other fantastic benefits of eating at 575 Pizzeria I can overlook this small detail. All in all, this is easily one of the best spots for enjoying some of the best pizza in Amarillo TX!

#3 Fire Slice Pizzeria

I visited Fire Slice Pizzeria and was wowed by the menu. They had so many delicious options, it was hard to choose just one! I finally decided on their signature pizza – the Fire Slice Supreme. It was out of this world! The sauce was perfectly seasoned, the cheese was melted to perfection, and the toppings were unbelievably fresh.

The ambiance at Fire Slice Pizzeria was also great. The restaurant had a cozy vibe that made me feel right at home. Plus, the staff were so friendly and attentive. They were always eager to answer any questions I had and make sure my experience was top-notch.

All in all, Fire Slice Pizzeria is one of the best pizzerias in Amarillo TX! If you’re looking for a great pizza experience that won’t break the bank, this is definitely a place to check out. Highly recommend!

#4 Palio’s Pizza and Bar

From the very first bite, I knew Palio’s was something special. The sauce was tangy and brightly flavored, with just the right amount of sweetness. The dough was crisp, but also surprisingly light and airy – a texture that can only be described as divine.

And then came the toppings! Toppings of all kinds, ranging from classic pepperoni to more creative combinations like eggplant and tomatoes. All were perfectly cooked and full of flavor.

The atmosphere at Palio’s is great too! It’s lively but still relaxed, which meant that my friends and I could spend hours chatting over good food and conversation.

If you’re in search for the best pizza in Amarillo TX, you need look no further than Palio’s Pizza and Bar! This eatery serves up delicious creations that will make your taste buds sing with joy.

#5 Pizzeria Nomad

For starters, the crust was perfectly thin and crispy. There weren’t any greasy spots, which is definitely a bonus in my book! It had the perfect balance of chewiness and crunch. On top of that, the ingredients were fresh and flavorful.

The San Marzano tomato sauce was just right – sweet yet acidic. The toppings included meats and vegetables that were cooked to perfection, leaving me wanting more with each bite. Plus, everyone knows cheese makes everything a million times better, so I was delighted to find that their mozzarella was on point.

When it comes down to it, this is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. From the delicious crust to the flavorful ingredients to the generous portions – there’s truly nothing bad about this place. If you’re ever in Amarillo TX looking for a great pie, Pizzeria Nomad should be at the top of your list!

#6 575 Pizzeria

Upon entering, I was immediately struck by the cozy and inviting atmosphere. The staff were all incredibly friendly and the waitress took great care of us throughout our meal.

As for the pizza, it was delicious! They offer a wide variety of toppings including pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers, olives, and even vegan options. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. I especially enjoyed their signature pies which had creative toppings like double-smoke bacon and roasted garlic parmesan cream sauce.

The best part is that they serve beer and wine to pair with your pizza! It’s a perfect place to bring family or friends for an enjoyable evening out.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Amarillo TX then look no further than 575 Pizzeria!

#7 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I knew that this was going to be a great experience. The atmosphere was warm and inviting with the smell of fresh-baked pizza wafting through the air. From their unique selection of crusts and toppings to their friendly staff, Papa Murphy’s really knows how to make an amazing pizza.

The best part about this restaurant is its helpful staff who are always willing to answer questions and provide advice on whatever type of pizza you’re looking for. Plus, they offer some delicious signature pizzas as well as create-your-own options that let you customize your own pizza – which is a great way to enjoy a tasty dinner at home.

The ingredients used here are top notch too, with plenty of options like fresh veggies, Italian meats, gourmet cheeses and made-from-scratch sauces. Every bite is full of flavor! Plus, if you don’t have time to take your pizza home and bake it yourself, they also offer hot-and-ready pizzas in their restaurant every day.

No matter what type of pizza you’re looking for or however much time you have available, Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza has something for everyone – it’s no wonder why I think it’s the best pizza in Amarillo TX!

#8 Big Jim’s Pizza Co.

The first thing that stood out was the warm, inviting atmosphere. The staff was friendly and accommodating. And while the décor was simple, it had a classic pizzeria feel which added to the experience.

The menu had all of the usual suspects – cheese pizza, pepperoni, veggie – and a few surprises too. My favorite was the Guacamole Supreme with extra spicy jalapenos, it really packed a punch!

The cheese pizza was my taste-testing benchmark and Big Jim’s did not disappoint. Their house-made red sauce sets them apart from competitors with its unique flavor profile and tangy aftertaste. The crust was thin but still thick enough to support generous amounts of crispy cheese and toppings.

Overall I’d give Big Jim’s Pizza Co two enthusiastic thumbs up for their fantastic food and amiable service! If you’re in the Amarillo area looking for your next pizza fix, this is definitely one to try.

If you’re willing to go an extra 218 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Midland!

#9 Pizza Planet

They offer a great variety of pies to satisfy any pizza-lover’s craving. From traditional pepperoni and cheese, to something a bit more exotic like chicken fajita pizza – they have it all. Plus, their crust is perfectly thin and crisp – perfect for folding in half and eating on the go (which I highly recommend you do!).

Their sauces are also top-notch; they have this amazing garlic oil that adds just the right amount of kick. Plus, their toppings are always fresh and delicious!

My favorite thing about Pizza Planet has to be the atmosphere. It’s a cozy place where everyone can relax and enjoy great food without worry. There’s even a wooden plank tabletop arcade game that kids love!

To sum it up, Pizza Planet makes some of the best pizza in Amarillo TX – it’s definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in town!

#10 Vince’s Italian Pizza

I was immediately impressed by the doughy, chewy crust and the creative selection of toppings. The cheese was perfectly melted, giving me a delicious experience every bite. Not to mention the garlic-infused olive oil on top – talk about flavor!

The service was great as well. The wait staff were incredibly friendly and helpful. They seemed to really care that I had a wonderful dining experience.

But the real highlight here was definitely the pizza itself. Without a doubt, it was some of the best pizza I’ve ever had! Every slice was deliciously flavorful and somehow magically formed into an eye-pleasingly delightful shape. Who knew this little gem existed in Amarillo?

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Amarillo TX, then Vince’s Italian Pizza is your go-to spot!

#11 Napoli’s

Upon entering Napoli’s, I was instantly greeted by the warm smell of freshly made pizza. The restaurant had a cozy, homey vibe that made me feel right at home.

I started off with their classic margherita pizza – it was absolutely amazing! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy and the tomato sauce was full of flavor. The cheese they use is definitely top-notch; melted to perfection and sprinkled with some fresh basil leaves for a touch of brightness.

I went on to try their unique ‘Amarillo Special’ which had a nice kick to it thanks to its spicy pepperoni, jalapenos, and hot Italian sausage. This one definitely hit all the right notes for me – a great blend of flavors that really complemented each other.

To top it all off, their service was excellent! The staff were friendly and efficient, making sure that I enjoyed every bite of my pizza experience at Napoli’s. They even gave me a few samples of some of their other dishes so that I could get a better sense for what the restaurant is about.

Overall, my experience at Napoli’s has been one of the best pizza experiences I’ve ever had! With great food, fantastic atmosphere and excellent service – this place is definitely worth checking out if you’re seeking the best pizza in Amarillo TX!

#12 Giovanni’s Pizzeria

From the moment I walked in, I was hit with an incredible aroma. I knew at that moment my taste buds were in for a treat. The staff was friendly and accommodating, making sure that all of my needs were met throughout my entire dining experience.

The highlight of course was the pizza! Oh boy! That pizza was truly something special! From the thin crust to the sweet tomato sauce and flavorful toppings, it was obvious why this place has been around for over 20 years.

I’m happy to report that Giovanni’s Pizzeria lasted me through this full review with flying colors. If you are ever passing through Amarillo TX and want to try some of the best pizza around, look no further than Giovanni’s Pizzeria!