Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Squirrel Hill (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Pennsylvania

Best Pizza in Squirrel Hill (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

80 Views

Having been to some of the top pizza destinations around the world, I decided to tackle the challenge of determining who had the best pizza here in Squirrel Hill. After tasting 12 different pizzas from different places, I am happy to share with you my findings.

Let’s get started on a delicious journey and find out which pizza places reign supreme!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania

#1 EGE Mediterranean

I’m a bit of a pizza snob and I can be quite critical at times, but EGE Mediterranean passed my tests with flying colors. The crust was delicious – perfectly thin and chewy with just the right amount of crunch. The sauce was flavorful and not too sweet or acidic. And the cheese – oh the cheese! Incredibly gooey and stringy in all the best ways.

The atmosphere of the restaurant is also delightful; it’s cozy yet spacious, warm and inviting. All of their staff members were friendly, helpful and professional. My server knew every detail about their menu items and gave great advice on what to order (I’m certainly glad I followed it!).

If you’re looking for classic Italian flavors with a Mediterranean twist then this is your spot. Not to mention, they make all their pizzas to order so it’s always fresh when it gets to you – no reheating necessary! As far as I’m concerned, EGE Mediterranean has the best pizza in Squirrel Hill – guaranteed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Pittsburgh!

#2 Sciulli’s Pizza

The atmosphere at Sciulli’s Pizza is just perfect for a night out with friends. The staff were welcoming and friendly, and the warm decor brings a cozy vibe to the restaurant.

But, let’s get to what really matters here – the pizza! Every single one of their pizzas has that classic flavor that you just can’t get anywhere else. Whether you’re hankering for a classic cheese pizza or something more experimental like a pesto and feta pizza, Sciulli’s has it all! The crust is light and fluffy yet sturdy enough to support all the toppings, while the sauce and cheese are nice and gooey.

One thing I haven’t mentioned yet that makes Sciulli’s Pizza stand out is their calzones! Everytime I’ve had them they’re always crispy on the outside and filled with delicious ingredients like pepperoni, sausage, olives, mushrooms and more!

Overall, I’d give Sciulli’s Pizza two thumbs up for making some of the best pizza in Squirrel Hill. If you’re looking for somewhere to grab a delicious slice of pie or a filling calzone, then look no further than Sciulli’s Pizza!

#3 Mercurio’s Shadyside

The atmosphere of this restaurant is what really sets it apart. As soon as you walk in, there’s a feeling of warmth. The walls are painted in bright colors and the lights create a cozy environment.

The service here is top notch. The waitstaff is very friendly and efficient, ensuring that our orders were taken quickly and accurately.

But the food – oh, the food! I tried the classic Margherita pizza with freshly-made mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce and it was delicious! The crust was thin and crispy and had just the right amount of chewiness. The toppings were generous, but not overbearing – exactly how a good pizza should be.

The real star of the show, however, was their speciality “drunken” pizza with vodka sauce and fresh basil on top. It was out of this world! The flavors blended together perfectly and it was cooked to perfection – slightly charred on the bottom for that extra bit of flavor.

Overall, Mercurio’s Shadyside offers some of the best pizza in Squirrel Hill. Not only did they nail the classic favorites, but they also have some unique specialty pizzas that will keep you coming back for more!

#4 Spak Brothers

I was immediately impressed with the cozy atmosphere and friendly staff. The decor reminded me of a classic Italian trattoria, making it all the more inviting.

The pizzas at Spak Brothers are made from scratch using only the freshest ingredients, many of which are sourced from local farmers. I had the opportunity to sample several different pies, including their signature San Marzano sauce and mozzarella. Each one was flavorful and cooked to perfection.

The homemade dough is also worth mentioning; it’s light, airy, and extremely crisp on the exterior. Plus, you can customize your pizza with an array of toppings ranging from pepperoni to artichoke hearts.

To top it off (literally), all of their pies come with a generous dusting of Parmesan cheese that melts into a delicious cheesy finish—it’s simply divine! As I took my final bite, I realized why Spak Brothers has such a loyal following here in Squirrel Hill: they make some of the best pizza around!

#5 Fazio’s Pizza

When I arrived at this lovely little pizza joint, I was served up a hot and delicious slice of pepperoni pizza that was out of this world. The crust was perfectly crunchy and the sauce tasted like it had been made from fresh tomatoes. The cheese was melted just right and the pepperoni added an extra layer of flavor that completed the dish.

I didn’t think it could get any better, but when I tried their speciality – a white pizza with spinach, mushrooms, garlic, and ricotta – my taste buds went wild! The flavors were so unique and delicious that I couldn’t stop eating until the whole pizza was gone.

The customer service here is top-notch as well. Everyone who works at Fazio’s Pizza is friendly and knowledgeable, always willing to answer questions or offer suggestions. They also have great deals on group orders if you’re feeding a large hungry crowd!

To sum it up, Fazio’s Pizza has some of the best pizza in Squirrel Hill – hands down! If you haven’t been yet, what are you waiting for?

#6 Pizza Bellino

I’ve had some amazing pizzas on my world tour, from the wood oven-baked classics in Italy to the stone-grilled gourmet pies in France. But nothing I’ve tasted can compare to the authentic Italian pies found at Pizza Bellino.

The secret weapon of this pizza joint is their robust tomato sauce – it’s thick, flavorful and made with only fresh ingredients. The mozzarella cheese is equally fantastic – buttery and creamy, with the perfect amount of saltiness. And let’s not forget about the crust – crispy yet chewy with an unmistakable crunch each time you bite into it. It’s truly a slice of heaven!

But what really sets Pizza Bellino apart is their attention to detail. Every pie they make is crafted with love and care, so you know you’re getting quality every time. And that’s why I believe it’s home to some of the best pizza in Squirrel Hill. Don’t take my word for it though – come give them a try for yourself!

#7 Aiello’s Pizza

My first impression upon entering the restaurant was that it had a very cozy and inviting vibe. The decor was simple yet comfortable, with classic Italian music playing in the background.

When it came to the pizzas, I could tell from the first bite that Aiello’s Pizza served some of the best around. The dough was perfectly cooked, with a thin crust and just the right amount of crunch at its edges. As for toppings, they managed to pull off a perfect balance of flavors while still maintaining the integrity of each ingredient.

The service at Aiello’s was also top notch! Our server was friendly and helpful, always making sure our glasses were never empty.

All in all, I’d highly recommend Aiello’s Pizza as one of the best places to get pizza in Squirrel Hill! Their unique style and flavor make them stand out from other pizza joints in town. So next time you’re feelin’ like some quality Italian indulgence, make sure to check them out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Pittsburgh!

#8 Milky Way

I’m not one to mince words when it comes to pizza, so let me tell you, this is a great spot to get your fill of cheesy, saucy goodness. The crust was perfectly crisp and the flavors of the freshly made sauces were delicious. Even better – they had some truly unique toppings like jalapenos, artichoke hearts, and sun-dried tomatoes!

The atmosphere of Milky Way made my experience even more enjoyable. It’s located in an old train depot that gives it an authentic feel. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable about their pizza recipes and gave us some great recommendations on different combinations.

To top it all off, I tried one of their signature pizzas called “The Milky Way” that came with a special blend of cheese and creamy sauce — it was simply spectacular!

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Squirrel Hill then look no further than Milky Way. I guarantee that after one bite you’ll never want to go anywhere else again!

#9 Black Lotus Pizza

I’m always a bit skeptical when it comes to trying new pizza places, but I was pleasantly surprised by the high-quality pies at Black Lotus. The crust was thin, crisp and had just the right amount of charring on it. The sauce was flavorful without being too overwhelming – not to mention they used the freshest ingredients around in their toppings.

But what really sealed the deal for me was seeing how passionate the staff were about making sure their customers get the best possible experience. Everyone from the welcoming hostess to the busy cooks behind that huge pizza oven were all focused on giving each customer an amazing experience – and that’s something money can’t buy!

To top it off, Black Lotus also boasts a great selection of soft drinks, beers and wines to compliment your meal. If you’re looking for legit pizza with some world class hospitality then you have to make Black Lotus Pizza your next stop!

#10 Pastoli’s Pizza, Pasta & Paisans

Don’t let the casual atmosphere fool you, Pastoli’s is serious about their pizza. From the classic toppings like pepperoni and sausage to unique, gourmet creations such as the Garlic Gouda and Prosciutto Pesto pizzas, there is something for everyone here.

The crust is light and airy with a perfect chewiness that will keep you coming back for more. The topping combinations are creative and flavorful, making them enjoyable even to us experienced pizza connoisseurs.

The pasta dishes are also delicious, with a wide variety of options, including penne alla vodka, cavatelli and broccoli, and fettuccine alfredo. The paisans (calzones) are especially noteworthy; the classic Italian recipe of salami, ricotta cheese and marinara sauce makes for an amazing one-of-a-kind meal.

I’d highly recommend Pastoli’s Pizza, Pasta & Paisans to any pizza fan looking for some of the best pizza in Squirrel Hill!

#11 Caprioni’s Pizza

My experience at Caprioni’s was like no other. I expected the usual Italian restaurant vibe: rich, red walls lined with oil paintings and religious iconography, traditional music playing in the background, and a mysterious old Italian man presiding over it all. Instead, I was greeted by bright colors, fun music, and a lively staff that made me feel welcome from the moment I stepped through the doors.

The pizza is where Caprioni’s truly shines. From the first bite of their homemade crust to the last delicious morsel of cheese that melted on my tongue, every element of their pizza was perfection. The ingredients are top-notch and carefully selected to create a mouthwatering combination of flavors in every slice. Not only were they cooked to absolute perfection – slightly charred on the bottom with just enough sauce and cheese to make it juicy but not overly greasy – but they also had an incredibly light texture that almost melted away while you ate it!

I’m convinced that Caprioni’s has some of the best pizza in Squirrel Hill. It truly is a special place where you can get amazing pizza with an amazing atmosphere to match. If you’re ever in town looking for great food, Caprioni’s is definitely worth a visit!

#12 Antoon’s Pizza

The atmosphere in the restaurant is wonderful. The staff is always friendly and willing to answer any questions you might have. The decor is simple but quite inviting. It’s the perfect spot to grab a slice or two with friends or family.

As for the pizza itself, it definitely lives up to its reputation! The crust is always cooked to perfection – crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The sauce has just the right mix of spices that give it a delicious, flavorful kick. And, of course, they top it off with the freshest ingredients to ensure maximum flavor and satisfaction every time!

To top it all off, Antoon’s offers great deals that will make your wallet happy too. If you’re looking for great pizza at an even better price, then this is definitely the place for you!

All in all, I’d give Antoon’s Pizza 5 stars out of 5 any day – if I could only eat pizza there every day!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Pizza Bosa

Now, let’s talk about the benefits of this joint. First off, they offer dessert. And oh boy, their chocolate lava cake is a dream come true! It’s like a molten explosion of sugary goodness in my mouth. I may have shed a tear of joy when I took my first bite. And let’s not forget about their cannoli, it’s so good that I had to resist the urge to stuff my pockets with them before leaving.

Another great thing about Pizza Bosa is that it’s a nice tourist spot. The place has a quirky and colorful atmosphere. The walls are covered in funny pizza-themed cartoons, and the staff is always cracking jokes and making you feel welcome. Plus, their outdoor seating area is perfect for people-watching and enjoying a slice of heaven.

However, there is one downside to Pizza Bosa that I feel obliged to mention. They do not accept reservations. Now, you might think this is not such a big deal, but trust me, when you’re a pizza enthusiast like me, waiting in line can feel like an eternity. I had to distract myself with pictures of pizzas on my phone to make it through the wait.

But hey, the wait was totally worth it. Pizza Bosa serves up a deep dish pizza that’s so divine it could convert even the most loyal thin-crust lovers. The crust is flaky and buttery, and the cheese is gooey beyond belief. Each bite is a symphony in your mouth, and all your worries just melt away.

All in all, Pizza Bosa is the place to be if you’re on the hunt for the best deep dish pizza in Pittsburgh. Just make sure you have a good book or some games on your phone to keep you entertained while you wait.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Spak Brothers

From the moment I walked in, I could tell that this place was the real deal. The aroma of freshly baked dough mixed with the tantalizing scent of bubbling cheese greeted me at the door. I could practically hear my taste buds doing a happy dance.

Now, let’s talk about the crust. Oh, the crust! It was so thin and crispy, it was like biting into a cloud made of pizza perfection. Each bite was a crunchy symphony of flavors that danced on my palate. I couldn’t help but wonder if Michelangelo had some sort of hand in crafting this masterpiece.

As for the toppings, they didn’t skimp on those either. I ordered a classic Margherita, and let me tell you, it was a work of art. The fresh tomatoes blended magnificently with the creamy mozzarella, and the basil added just the right touch of freshness. Each bite was like a little slice of heaven.

But it wasn’t just the pizza that impressed me. The service was top-notch, and the atmosphere was cozy and inviting. The staff was friendly and attentive, making me feel like I was part of a big, pizza-loving family.

So, if you find yourself in Pittsburgh and craving some thin crust pizza that will transport you straight to pizza paradise, do yourself a favor and head to Spak Brothers. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room

Upon arriving at Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room, I was immediately drawn in by the heavenly aroma of pizzas cooking in their wood-fired oven. As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I knew right away that I was in for a treat. And boy, was I right!

Let’s start with the pizza itself. The thin, crispy crust was perfectly charred and had just the right amount of chewiness. It was like biting into a slice of heaven. The toppings range from classics like margherita and pepperoni to more adventurous options like brie and pear. They even had a delicious vegetarian option with an assortment of fresh veggies and gooey cheese. It was so good, even the meat lovers at the table didn’t miss their usual toppings.

Now, onto the fun stuff—alcohol! Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room not only serves beer, but they also have a selection of hard liquor. This is a pizza place that knows how to keep the good times rolling! And let’s not forget about dessert. Their sweet creations are out of this world. I indulged in a warm and gooey Nutella pizza that had me singing its praises for days.

There is one downside to Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room, though—they don’t accept reservations. So if you’re planning on visiting during peak hours, be prepared to wait. But trust me, it’ll be worth it. Plus, while you wait, you can entertain yourself by gazing at the tourist spots surrounding the restaurant.

All in all, Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room is the place to go if you’re looking for the best wood-fired pizza in downtown Pittsburgh. With its incredible pizza, wide selection of drinks, and entertaining atmosphere, you can’t go wrong. Just make sure to arrive early or be prepared for a wait, but I promise you, it’s well worth it!