Having been all over the world tasting different pies, I’ve become quite the pizza connoisseur. So naturally I had to check out the best spots in Stevens Point, Wisconsin. After eating my way through twelve local pizza places, I’m now ready to share my favorite with you!
This article takes a humorous and lighthearted approach and while there may be some debate over which spot serves up the best pies, these are definitely the spots I would recommend for delicious pizza. So grab your stretchy pants and let’s get this party started!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Wisconsin
#1 Polito’s Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
- Serves alcohol
From the spotless establishment to the friendly staff, Polito’s Pizza was an all-around great experience. The aroma of their delicious pizzas hit me as soon as I walked in and my hunger was instantly piqued!
We decided on a standard cheese and pepperoni pizza, plus some garlic knots as a starter; both were exquisite. The crust was perfectly crisp yet still fluffy, the sauce had just the right amount of flavor, plus the cheeses and pepperonis added that extra kick of flavor.
The garlic knots were also perfect. Not too garlicky and not too oily, they paired perfectly with our pizza – definitely worth trying!
All in all, if you’re looking for some amazing pizza in Stevens Point then you need to check out Polito’s Pizza. I’m sure you won’t be disappointed!
If you’re willing to go an extra 30 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Wausau!
#2 Bill’s Pizza Shop
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
From the moment I walked into Bill’s Pizza Shop, I was amazed. The aroma of freshly made dough and sauce filled the air, and it truly felt like I had been transported to a magical pizza paradise. The staff was pleasant, and the decor was warm and inviting.
I ordered a plain cheese pizza, and it was served to me in no time at all – steaming hot with a perfect combination of gooey cheese and crispy crust. The flavor really blew me away! I couldn’t help but savor every bite – something that rarely happens when it comes to plain pies.
The atmosphere at Bill’s Pizza Shop is another selling point. It’s cozy yet lively, with an old-school vibe that makes you want to stay forever. Who knows – maybe one day I can finally realize my dream of living in a pizza shop!
In conclusion, Bill’s Pizza Shop is a hidden gem here in Stevens Point that offers some of the best pizza around. Whether you’re looking for a great meal or just want to hang out, head over to Bill’s Pizza Shop today – you won’t be disappointed!
#3 Arbuckles Eatery & Pub
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Great place to watch sports
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
Their New York style pizza is the bomb – loaded with gooey mozzarella and fresh, locally-sourced toppings. It’s like taking a bite of the Big Apple right here in small town Wisconsin!
But they also have some great specialty pies too like their bacon cheeseburger pizza and wild mushroom pizza. I must say that these were two of the most unexpected combinations I’ve tasted in all my travels, yet somehow Arbuckles made them both work!
The atmosphere of Arbuckles Eatery & Pub is laid back, rustic and inviting. The waitstaff are friendly and efficient, and it makes for an enjoyable experience when you want to grab a quick slice or settle in for family meal.
All in all, I can honestly say that Arbuckles Eatery & Pub has some of the best pizza this side of Stevens Point – so if you’re looking for something out of the ordinary but still delicious, make sure to check them out!
#4 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
I’m not sure if it was the bubbly, cheesy crust or the savory toppings that made me want to eat a large pizza all by myself, but whatever it was, I couldn’t get enough. As someone who’s had their fair share of pizza around the world, I can confidently say that Papa Murphy’s has mastered the perfect combination of flavor and texture.
The staff at Papa Murphy’s are also really friendly and helpful in helping customers decide what type of pizza they should get. Even better, they have a great selection of pizzas with unique ingredients like spicy sausage and avocado cream sauce! Plus, their take-and-bake feature definitely makes it easier to satisfy your late night cravings without having to wait long for delivery.
All in all, Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza is easily one of the best places to find pizza in Stevens Point. Whether you’re looking for a quick snack or a hearty meal, this place will definitely satisfy your craving for great pizza!
#5 Rocky Rococo Pizza and Pasta
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
The selection of toppings is quite diverse, ranging from classic favorites like pepperoni and sausage to more exotic selections such as jalapenos and anchovies. Despite the overwhelming variety, my favorite was a simple combination of fresh basil, mozzarella, and tomatoes. It had the perfect amount of balance between the flavors and it truly tasted like something that could have been found in one of my travels abroad.
What really set Rocky Rococo Pizza and Pasta apart, however, was their unique crust. It’s perfectly thin with just enough crunch to give each slice a satisfying crunch while still providing a flavor that doesn’t overpower the rest of the pizza.
In addition to great pizza, they’ve got some delicious pasta dishes as well as salads and sandwiches. All in all, Rocky Rococo Pizza and Pasta is definitely an establishment that can take your taste buds on an international adventure without ever having to leave Stevens Point!
If you’re willing to go an extra 60 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Oshkosh!
#6 Toppers Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
From the moment I walked in, I could tell that this restaurant had something special. It was filled with a friendly pizzeria atmosphere that felt welcoming and cheerful.
I ordered my usual pizza – a medium-sized Italian sausage with extra cheese and some green peppers – and it did not disappoint. The flavor was sublime, with just the right balance between the components of the pizza. The crust was crunchy and delicious, but not too thick or chewy. And of course, the cheese was melt-in-your-mouth perfection!
My meal also came with some garlic bread that had a crunchy outer layer and a fluffy interior. It was lightly seasoned with just enough garlic for a great flavor without overpowering the taste of the bread.
To top off an incredible experience, I enjoyed an ice cold beverage while I waited for my pizza to cook – what more could you ask for in a pizzeria?
Overall, Toppers Pizza is definitely one of the best places to get pizza in Stevens Point! With its great atmosphere and delicious food, it’s sure to exceed your expectations any time you visit.
#7 Wiscow Pizza – Plover
The first thing that struck me about Wiscow Pizza – Plover is the incredible atmosphere. When I arrived, the place was filled with chatter and laughter. The staff warmly welcomed me, and I immediately felt right at home.
Next, I had the pleasure of tasting their pizza. Each slice was packed with flavor and texture. The crust was perfectly crispy, while being light and fluffy inside. There was a generous helping of cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms and other toppings on my order; it was obvious they weren’t skimping on ingredients!
Overall, this restaurant offers a truly unique experience to its customers. From the inviting atmosphere to the scrumptious pizza, Wiscow Pizza – Plover is quite possibly the best pizza in Stevens Point. If you’re ever in town, make sure you give them a try!
#8 Pizza Ranch
- Has insanely good dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
The atmosphere couldn’t have been more inviting when I first stepped in. The wood paneling and rustic decor instantly made me feel at home. What I really appreciate is that they don’t take themselves too seriously – they even offer a full-size mechanical bull you can ride while eating pizza!
When it comes to the food, my taste buds were taken on a wild ride! I opted for their signature ranch pizza, which was heavenly. The crust was perfectly chewy and the toppings were savory and just the right amount of spicy. And with every slice, there’s an irresistible layer of cheesy goodness.
The sides are also superb – especially the potato wedges. These crunchy masterpieces come served with your choice of sauces, which gives them an extra kick!
All in all, Pizza Ranch is definitely one of my favorite places to get the best pizza in Stevens Point. Whether you want to eat in their cozy restaurant or order delivery to your door, you won’t be disappointed. Highly recommended!
#9 Fazoli’s
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
When I first walked in the door, I had my doubts. But after seeing their selection of a wide variety of freshly made pizzas, my expectations were exceeded. Plus, I got to watch as the friendly staff prepared my pizza with fresh ingredients and a signature sauce that will make any Italian feel right at home.
The pizza itself was nothing short of amazing. The crust was thin and slightly crispy on the edges, and the cheese melted beautifully into the sauce. To top it off (literally), there were plenty of toppings to choose from including salami, artichokes, spinach, mushrooms, and onions.
I washed it all down with a cold drink from their fountain machine before reluctantly leaving Fazoli’s knowing that I would be returning soon! If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Stevens Point, look no further than Fazoli’s!
If you’re willing to go an extra 63 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in Wisconsin Dells!
#10 Little Caesars Pizza
The flavor is out of this world – it’s like a five-star meal in one slice. They use the freshest ingredients around, from the savory pepperoni to the cheesy mozzarella. The crust is crunchy and delicious – it has an unmistakable homemade taste that only Little Caesars Pizza can provide.
The service is also top notch. Every time I visit, I’m greeted with a smile and exceptional customer service. They go over and beyond to make sure my experience is great.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Stevens Point, then look no further than Little Caesars Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!
#11 Papa Johns Pizza
- Offers dessert
When I entered the restaurant, it had a cozy sort of charm that immediately put me at ease. The staff were extremely friendly and welcomed me warmly. After browsing their menu, I decided to try one of their signature pizzas.
I was not disappointed! The pizza had a wonderfully cooked dough with just the right amount of crunch. The sauce was zesty and flavorful, and everything was simply delicious. What really surprised me was how generous they were with the toppings as well. Every bite was packed full of flavor and texture!
To top it all off, the whole experience was accompanied by a unique atmosphere that I can only describe as inviting yet casual. It’s clear that everyone who visits is valued and respected here.
If you’re looking for some amazing pizza in Stevens Point, Papa Johns Pizza should definitely be your first stop! It’s definitely one of the best places around for great pizza.
#12 Domino’s Pizza
The crust is the perfect balance of crunchy and chewy, with just the right amount of seasoning. The sauce is tangy and flavorful. The cheese is gooey and melty, adding a wonderful texture and flavor to each bite. And the toppings are always fresh and flavorful.
I also love the variety of options at Domino’s Pizza – from classic pepperoni to more creative options like anchovy caper bruschetta or Mediterranean veggie. No matter what your taste preference, you’re sure to find something delicious here!
And the service is always top notch – friendly staff who make sure your order is correct and delivered on time. Plus, they have some great deals that make it easy to try new things without breaking the bank!
Overall, I’d highly recommend Domino’s Pizza for the best pizza in Stevens Point.
