Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Temecula CA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in California

Best Pizza in Temecula CA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

244 Views

After tasting delicious pizza in places all over the world, I was excited to visit Temecula and test out their pizza. To find the best of the best, I sampled a total of 12 pizzas from different restaurants in the area.

I’m sure you’re wondering what I found – so let’s get into it! Each pizza was uniquely crafted with flavor combinations that were both classic and creative. I found BBQ pies, white pizzas, deep dish classics and more.

But who makes the best pizza in Temecula? Read on to find out which restaurant won my vote for the most amazing pizza in town!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of California

#1 Rosati’s Pizza

It was love at first bite. The crust was perfectly crunchy yet still chewy, and the sauce was well balanced with just the right amount of tang. The toppings were fresh and flavorful – definitely some of the best I’ve ever had.

The service was top-notch as well – friendly and efficient staff that was happy to answer my questions about the ingredients used or what to order for a large group.

My meal ended with a delicious dessert pizza that provided a pleasant combination of sweet and savory flavors. If you’re in Temecula CA, Rosati’s Pizza is a must try!

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Murrieta!

#2 The Pizza Press

When I first walked in, I was overwhelmed by all of the delicious smell and the friendly atmosphere. The staff was extremely helpful, helping to explain all the different types of pizza that they had available. They even offered samples to help me decide!

Once I chose my pizza, the staff was quick to get it in the oven so I could try it. While I waited, I watched them prepare each pizza with attention to detail – stretching and spinning the dough before topping it with their signature sauces.

Once my pizza was finished baking, it came out looking like a work of art! The crust was light yet crisp and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. It truly tasted like a slice of heaven.

I highly recommend checking out The Pizza Press if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Temecula CA! Not only will you enjoy a delicious meal but you’ll also be treated like family from the moment you walk in.

#3 Temecula Pizza Co

As soon as I stepped inside, I was hit with the delicious scent of melting cheese and freshly baked dough. They had all the classic toppings like pepperoni and sausage, plus some creative ones like artichoke and olives.

The crust was thin and crisp, just how I like it. The balance between the sauce, cheese and toppings was perfect – no skimping on any of them! There were plenty of options for those that don’t eat meat or are vegan – they even provide gluten-free crusts!

The staff were friendly and knowledgeable; they were clearly passionate about their craft. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting – an ideal place to hang out with friends while enjoying a slice (or two).

I’d highly recommend Temecula Pizza Co if you’re looking for the best pizza in Temecula CA – you won’t be disappointed!

#4 Vail Pizzeria

My experience started off with a warm welcome from the staff. They were super friendly and provided great service.

The pizza options were vast – from classic thin crust pizzas to thick-crusted Sicilian pies, there is something for everyone here. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and you could choose whatever your heart desired.

The crust was delicious – perfectly cooked and slightly crispy on the outside, yet still light enough so that it did not overpower the toppings. I ordered the Margherita pizza which was loaded with cheese and basil, and it certainly stood out in terms of both taste and presentation.

Overall, my experience at Vail Pizzeria was incredibly positive. The food was delicious, the atmosphere was inviting, and I would highly recommend this place to anyone who loves great pizza!

#5 Times Square Pizza & Bagels

From the moment I stepped in, I could tell that this was a special place. From the traditional Italian decor to the warm and inviting staff, I felt like family.

The menu at Times Square Pizza & Bagels is like no other. Their classic New York-style pies come with a variety of toppings that are sure to please everyone’s taste buds. The specialty pies have unique flavor combinations, such as the BBQ Chicken Pie, which makes it nearly impossible to choose just one slice!

I strongly believe that it’s their signature brick oven that sets them apart from your typical pizza joint. The combination of crisp crust and melted and bubbly cheese is simply divine!

If you’re looking for something a little different than pizza, you can’t go wrong with their wide selection of bagels. They have a vast assortment of fillings ranging from breakfast meats and cream cheeses to lox and tomato slices.

All in all, Times Square Pizza & Bagels is sure to make any pizza lover happy! Whether you’re in the mood for a classic NY-style pie or one of their signature brick oven creations, you won’t be disappointed by their delicious offerings.

#6 Stadium Pizza

On my first visit to this spot, I was impressed by the expansive menu full of cleverly-named pies and sides. After deliberating for a good 10 minutes, I decided on the ‘Touchdown’ pizza and garlic knots. And let me tell you: it was all worth it!

The Touchdown pizza had the perfect combination of cheesy goodness and tangy tomato sauce. The crust was crispy, yet chewy – exactly how a great pizza crust should be. My tastebuds were in heaven! As for the garlic knots? Well, they were simply divine! There’s no other way to describe them than “phenomenal”.

Let’s just say, Stadium Pizza will definitely be my go-to spot when I’m craving some of the best pizza in Temecula CA!

#7 Filippi’s Pizza Grotto Temecula

From the moment I walked in, I was immediately impressed. The atmosphere was warm and inviting and the staff were friendly and attentive.

As soon as I bit into my first slice, I knew this place was special. The pizzas here are made with the freshest ingredients and the crusts are perfectly cooked – crispy on the outside but still chewy on the inside. Even better, they offer a wide variety of topping combinations so you can get exactly what you want!

Overall, Filippi’s Pizza Grotto Temecula is an amazing pizza joint. They have perfected their craft and it shows in every single bite. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Temecula CA then look no further than Filippi’s Pizza Grotto!

#8 Spuntino Pizzeria Italia

The pizza here is delicious and the environment leaves something to be desired. The wood-fired oven emits a fantastic aroma that can be smelled from miles away and the quality of the pizzas is unbeatable.

The staff has always been welcoming and friendly, making us feel comfortable with our orders. Plus, they happily serve alcohol (including hard liquor), which is something my traveling companions always appreciate. And for those who have kids, you’ll be happy to know that there’s a dedicated kids’ menu so everyone can get their fill of delicious Italian favorites!

In addition to classic Italian pizzas, Spuntino Pizzeria Italia also has some vegetarian options as well as desserts like tiramisu or cannoli that make it well worth considering when you’re looking for great food. I never miss an opportunity to fit in one of these amazing treats when I visit!

My only criticism is that they don’t offer delivery – which could be a dealbreaker for those looking to enjoy their delicious pies at home. But if you’re able to plan ahead and make the trip out, it’s totally worth it! All in all, if you’re in Temecula CA in search of great pizza, Spuntino Pizzeria Italia should absolutely be your go-to spot for the best pizza around.

If you’re willing to go an extra 20 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Hemet!

#9 Blaze Pizza

My first impression of Blaze Pizza was that their crust was perfection! It had a delicious crunchy flavor that had just enough crispiness to keep me coming back for more. The cheese and other toppings were fresh and flavorful, giving each bite a unique and delicious taste.

The service at Blaze Pizza was excellent as well – friendly staff, prompt delivery, and great attention to detail. I even got some free samples of their house-made dipping sauces to try!

The best thing about Blaze Pizza is the unique pies they offer; classics like pepperoni are always available, but they often have special offerings like vegan options, or their signature burrata pizza with tomatoes, arugula and basil pesto. All of them were outstanding!

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Temecula CA Blaze Pizza should be your go-to spot! I guarantee you won’t be disappointed.

#10 Stadium Pizza

From the moment I stepped inside, I knew it was home. The atmosphere is cozy and friendly – with large TV screens to watch the game, and a rotating selection of local craft beers. It’s clear that the owner is passionate about pizza, as he spends time in the open kitchen chopping fresh vegetables and grating cheese for each order.

The pizza itself? Divine! The crust is light yet chewy and has a perfect balance of crunchy charring on the bottom. Best of all, they just get it right with their delightfully tangy house-made tomato sauce – you won’t believe how good it tastes! Toppings are generous, flavorful and top-notch quality.

I can honestly say that I have never had such a delicious pizza anywhere else in the world – Stadium Pizza is simply the best! If you’re ever in Temecula CA, be sure to stop by for some truly remarkable pizza.

#11 Marco’s Pizza

The first thing I noticed when I visited was the smell of delicious dough baking in the oven, and actually that is still lingering on my clothes. The crust was so light and crisp, it feels like you’re eating a cloud…but much tastier.

The toppings were plentiful and all cooked to perfection. Every bite had just the right amount of flavor, but not too overwhelming either.

I also liked how hospitable the staff was when I was there. Everyone was so friendly and welcoming, which really added to the atmosphere.

Overall, this pizza joint is definitely worth trying out for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Temecula CA! If you’re ever passing through town and in need of a slice (or two), be sure to check out Marco’s Pizza – you won’t regret it!

#12 Uncle Gino’s Pizzeria

For starters, the atmosphere of the place is amazing. It’s an old-school Italian joint that looks like it hasn’t changed since its opening—with checkered tablecloths, faded photos hanging from the walls, and a live accordion player in one corner.

The menu is full of classic Italian delicacies like calzones and lasagna, but I was here for the pizza. And boy did they deliver! There are tons of varieties to choose from, ranging from your standard pepperoni to more unique options like shrimp with pesto or goat cheese with sun dried tomatoes. But what really sets Uncle Gino’s apart is their wood-fired brick oven pizzas. The crust was delightfully crispy on the outside and pillowy soft on the inside. The flavors were spot-on and there was just enough sauce (but not too much!).

Overall, if you’re looking for some truly delicious pizza in Temecula CA then look no further than Uncle Gino’s Pizzeria! You won’t be disappointed!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Rosati’s Pizza

Now, let’s talk about their deep dish pizza. When I say deep dish, I mean DEEP. This pizza is a mountain of cheesy perfection, so thick you could use it as a pillow on a long flight. I couldn’t believe the sheer amount of toppings they managed to squeeze into each slice. The crust was crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, like a cuddly teddy bear with a crunch. I almost felt bad digging into this work of art, but one bite quickly erased any guilt.

The cheese, oh the cheese! It was like a gooey sea of melted dreams. Stretchy, stringy, and just the right amount of greasy. I had to use both hands to lift each slice, and I have big hands. The flavors of the toppings burst in my mouth like fireworks on the Fourth of July. The combination of the tangy tomato sauce, the savory pepperoni, and the perfectly sautéed mushrooms made me want to jump on a table and do a little happy dance. Don’t worry, I restrained myself, but only because I wanted to keep eating.

The service was also fantastic. The staff was friendly and accommodating, even when I asked for a side of ranch dressing for dipping (don’t judge me, it’s a personal preference). Overall, if you’re looking for a pizza experience that will leave you daydreaming about it for weeks, look no further than Rosati’s. You won’t be disappointed.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Temecula Pizza Co

As soon as I walked into the restaurant, I could smell the heavenly aroma of freshly baked dough and melted cheese. My taste buds danced with anticipation as I perused the menu, which conveniently had a nice selection of vegetarian options. As a self-proclaimed carnivore, I was skeptical at first, but their veggie-loaded pie was surprisingly satisfying! Who knew eating your greens could be so enjoyable?

But what really sealed the deal for me was the fact that Temecula Pizza Co serves alcohol. Finally, a place that understands the perfect pairing of a frosty cold brew with a mouthwatering slice of pizza. I toasted to my good fortune as I indulged in the cheesy goodness that awaited me.

And let’s not forget about dessert! They offer a delectable selection of sweet treats to satisfy any sugar craving you may have. From gooey chocolate brownies to creamy tiramisu, they have it all. I highly recommend saving room for a little something sweet after your pizza feast.

The one downside? No delivery. However, I must admit that the journey to Temecula Pizza Co is well worth it. Plus, the restaurant is situated in a nice tourist spot, so after you’ve devoured your pizza masterpiece, you can explore the surrounding area and burn off those extra calories.

All in all, Temecula Pizza Co offers a perfect combination of tasty thin crust pizza, a wide variety of vegetarian options, boozy beverages, and tempting desserts. It’s a place that even a seasoned pizza connoisseur like myself can appreciate!