Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Twin Falls ID (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Idaho

Best Pizza in Twin Falls ID (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

154 Views

Living on the road, I’ve tasted amazing pizzas all around the world. But who says the best pies need to come from far away? Twin Falls ID has plenty of its own delicious offerings for hungry pizza lovers.

In my quest for the top spots in town, I’ve sampled pies from no less than 12 pizzerias. Some were ok, some were really good… and a few absolutely blew me away.

Join me as we take a humorous and lighthearted look at the best pizzas in Twin Falls ID.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Idaho

#1 2nd South Market

I’m not sure if it’s the perfect blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese, the juicy pepperoni, or maybe the fact that every slice is just slightly crispy on the outside and gooey on the inside. Whatever it is, it’s absolutely delicious!

The atmosphere inside 2nd South Market is incredible as well. From their cozy little booths to the vibrant colors of their walls, I felt like I was getting an authentic Italian experience without leaving Twin Falls.

Plus, their staff was so friendly! They clearly love what they do and it shows in their amazing customer service. I had a great time chatting with them while I soaked up all that delicious pizza goodness!

To sum it up, if you’re ever in Twin Falls ID and you have a craving for some of the best pizza around, head over to 2nd South Market – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 105 miles, you can get to 14 more pizza places in Pocatello!

#2 Blaze Pizza

Their crust was definitely the highlight for me. It had a nice chew and was crispy on the edges, just the way I like it. Their toppings were also great – from fresh veggies to meats, they have something to please everyone. The sauce was flavorful without being too overpowering and their cheese selection was top-notch.

The service at Blaze Pizza is always friendly as well. The staff is knowledgeable and they take customization requests seriously, which I found refreshing.

One thing that stood out to me in particular was their commitment to cleanliness. When you walk in there’s not a crumb to be seen anywhere! They clearly take pride in their space and it shows.

So if you’re looking for the best pizza in Twin Falls ID, I highly recommend Blaze Pizza! Just make sure you bring your appetite because their slices are huge!

#3 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

What sets this place apart from other pizzerias is the concept: you pick up the pizza dough and ingredients, take them home, and bake them in your own oven. This way you get to make it exactly how you like it!

I tried several different variations of their pizzas on my visit, ranging from classic pepperoni to cheesy garlic veggie delight. The vegetarian options were especially delicious, with a wide variety of toppings and herbs. Plus, they have a great selection of sauces to choose from – something for everyone to enjoy!

The downside is that there’s no delivery option – but if you’re feeling adventurous then this is definitely a good choice for your pizza cravings! Of course, most people will want to just order out for more convenience. But if you want some of the best pizza in Twin Falls ID then Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza is definitely worth checking out.

#4 MOD Pizza

When I heard about MOD Pizza’s made to order pizzas – where you can choose from multiple fresh, artisan toppings and signature sauces – I knew I just had to try it.

I was not disappointed! Not only did the pizza taste amazing but MOD Pizza also offers a wide variety of delicious salads and desserts that paired perfectly with my meal.

But what really impressed me was the innovation of their ordering system. As a food critic who has spent a lot of time eating in restaurants, I know how frustrating it can be when restaurants are slow or disorganized – but there was none of that at MOD Pizza! They have an efficient automated system that lets you customize your own pizza with their incredible selection of ingredients right at the counter. You don’t even have to wait in line – the staff is so friendly and helpful that they take care of everything for you!

All in all, MOD Pizza provides some of the best pizza in Twin Falls ID and I would definitely recommend it for anyone looking for delicious, high-quality Italian food. Let’s just say that this traveling food critic will definitely be back soon!

#5 Pizza Pie Cafe Twin Falls

The first thing that struck me upon walking in to Pizza Pie Cafe Twin Falls was the vibrant atmosphere. The walls were adorned with colorful art, the menu scrawled on chalkboards, and the staff radiating energy. The place was bustling with excited customers, each one eager to get their hands on some delicious pizza.

I got a classic pepperoni pie, and it was phenomenal! The crust was perfectly crispy and chewy in all the right places. And the toppings were fresh and flavorful — no skimping on quality here! I also had a slice of their white pizza with spinach, which was equally delicious — nice garlicky flavor that really set it apart from other pies I’ve tried.

To top it all off, Pizza Pie Cafe Twin Falls has great prices for such high-quality food. It’s no wonder why it’s become so popular in town! If you’re ever craving some of the best pizza in Twin Falls ID, look no further than Pizza Pie Cafe Twin Falls.

If you’re willing to go an extra 113 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Boise!

#6 Domino’s Pizza

When I arrived at Domino’s, the staff was friendly and accommodating. The atmosphere was relaxed, and the decor modern and inviting.

As for the pizza itself – it was delicious! Freshly made with just the right amount of cheese and toppings, there was nothing like digging into a slice from Domino’s. The crust had that perfect crispiness, while still being soft enough to enjoy bite after bite.

The highlight of my visit, however, was their selection of specialty pizzas– particularly their New Yorker. Piled high with pepperoni, sausage, bacon and extra cheese, it’s perhaps one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had—not just in Twin Falls ID but anywhere!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Twin Falls ID, look no further than Domino’s Pizza – even traveling food critics like me can attest to that!

#7 Idaho Pizza Company

I’m a big fan of trying local specialty pies, and Idaho Pizza Company did not disappoint. Their “Signature Idaho Spud Pie” was an incredible surprise – topped with mashed potatoes, bacon, and cheddar cheese.

The atmosphere at Idaho Pizza Co is cozy, with a TV in one corner of the dining room playing sports or classic movies – perfect for catching up with old friends. The staff were also very friendly, welcoming us with a smile every time we visited.

The prices are very reasonable, so there’s something for everyone – even on a tight budget. And what impressed me the most was the quality of their ingredients. Everything tasted fresh and homemade; they use only the highest quality meats and cheeses.

There’s no doubt that Idaho Pizza Co makes some of the best pizza in Twin Falls ID – hands down! I highly recommend it to anyone looking to have a great meal without having to leave town!

#8 Papa Kelsey’s

My first impression of Papa Kelsey’s was that it had an old school Italian vibe, which I thought was pretty cool. The red and white checkered tablecloths, dim lighting, and classic pizza oven smack in the middle of the restaurant were reminiscent of my childhood.

The pizza itself was something else! The crust was thin and crispy, but still had a nice texture to it. And the toppings were perfectly seasoned – not too strong or too bland – just right. Plus there were plenty of different varieties to choose from.

My favorite part about Papa Kelsey’s is how welcoming the staff are. Everyone was so friendly and willing to help out any questions I had about the menu or ingredients. They even took time to chat with me about their history as a family-owned pizzeria – it was really nice to hear their story!

In my opinion, Papa Kelsey’s is the best pizza in Twin Falls ID. Whether you’re looking for a place to take your family for dinner or just need a quick slice on the go, this is definitely the spot!

#9 Domino’s Pizza

When I arrived, the service was friendly and efficient. The store was neat and clean, and the staff greeted me with a smile. After looking through their menu, I decided to go with a classic favorite–the pepperoni pizza.

The beauty of Domino’s Pizza is that they don’t skimp on quality ingredients. The crust was just right – not too thick or thin – and freshly baked. The pepperoni had great flavor, and all the other toppings were fresh as well.

My overall impression of Domino’s Pizza? It’s definitely worth the trip! Whether you’re in the mood for a traditional option like the pepperoni pizza or something more exotic like their Mediterranean Veggie pizza, you won’t be disappointed. For some of the best pizza in Twin Falls ID, I absolutely recommend Domino’s Pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 120 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Meridian!

#10 Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs

I’ve been to many pizza places, but none have hit the spot like Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs. The crust is perfectly chewy, and their mix of flavorful toppings is delicious. In fact, the sauce alone (made with a grandmother’s secret recipe) was worth the trip!

The atmosphere was also amazing. It’s not just a restaurant: it’s an experience! From the lively music to the friendly servers, I had a blast. I also enjoyed watching the pizza being made in the open kitchen as I waited for my order.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Twin Falls ID, Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs has you covered. Whether for dine-in or delivery, you won’t be disappointed!

#11 Slice

The first thing that struck me about Slice was the atmosphere. From the moment I walked in, I felt like I was in a small Italian neighborhood pizzeria. The walls were painted red and adorned with old-school posters, and the staff were all friendly and welcoming.

When it came to their pizza, Slice really delivered! The crust had just the right amount of crispiness and the sauce was flavorful and fragrant. Moreover, their toppings were always fresh and cooked to perfection. Whether we chose the classic pepperoni or something more adventurous, like wild mushrooms and goat cheese, each slice of pizza was consistently delicious!

To top it all off, they have an extensive selection of beers on tap. All in all, Slice is definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for some of the best pizza around Twin Falls ID!

#12 Little Caesars Pizza

First off, the taste of the pizza is absolutely divine. The crust is thin and crispy with just the right amount of char to give it an amazing flavor. The sauce is savory and flavorful and really shines through the cheese. As for toppings, they always have something different and delicious! Whether it’s pepperoni or veggies, they always know how to mix things up in a way that really brings out the flavor.

The atmosphere at Little Caesars Pizza is also top-notch. You can tell that they take pride in their work from the moment you walk in the door. Everything sparkles and smells like pizza heaven! Additionally, their staff are always friendly and eager to help out with whatever you need.

To top everything off, Little Caesars Pizza offers some amazing deals on their pizzas! Their prices are very affordable and they often offer specials that will make your mouth water just thinking about them. That means more money can be put towards toppings or other menu items like wings, breadsticks, or even dessert!

All in all, Little Caesars Pizza has become my go-to spot for some of the best pizza in Twin Falls ID! I highly recommend checking it out if you’re ever in the area looking for a great slice!