Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Columbus IN (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Indiana

Best Pizza in Columbus IN (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

56 Views

I’ve had the pleasure of sampling pizza from twelve places here, and this article will share what I think is the best. Now, I’m no stranger to great pizza — in fact, I’ve tried pies all over the world! So don’t think for a second that just any ol’ pizza can compete.

My standards are high; I’m looking for an awesome crust, savory toppings and delectable sauce. There’s something uniquely special about a slice of pizza, and it has to be just right or else it falls flat.

So prepare your taste buds – it’s time to find the Best Pizza in Columbus IN!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Indiana

#1 Carlos Pizza

I was so excited to try the pies here and I wasn’t let down. The restaurant has a cozy, rustic atmosphere that’s comfortable and inviting. I ordered the classic pepperoni pizza and it was perfect! The crust was thin, perfectly seasoned, with just the right amount of char. The sauce had the perfect balance of sweet, tangy and herbacious and the cheese was gooey, creamy and melted in my mouth.

The toppings were fresh and plentiful – none of that processed stuff here! The staff were friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful in guiding me through the menu. They even remembered my order from last time which made me feel like family!

Overall, Carlos Pizza is definitely a great place to go for the best pizza in Columbus IN. If you’re looking for a delicious pizza experience then look no further!

If you’re willing to go an extra 32 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Greenwood!

#2 HotBox Pizza

When I walked through the door, I was immediately greeted by a friendly host and an inviting atmosphere. The menu boasted a huge selection of all sorts of delicious pizzas, from classics like cheese and pepperoni to inventive creations like Mac and Cheese pizza.

I ended up going with their signature HotBox Special – some combination of their most popular toppings – and it certainly lived up to its name! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, the tomato sauce zingy and fresh, and the toppings flavorful and juicy. Everything melded together into a gooey cheesy delightful bite that had my taste buds in heaven.

The service was also spot on: fast delivery, friendly staff, you name it! All in all, there’s no doubt that HotBox Pizza is one of the best pizza places in Columbus IN! I highly recommend stopping by for your next pizza craving.

#3 ZwanzigZ Pizza

Right when I walked in, I was welcomed with a warm and friendly atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The decor is modern and stylish, but still maintains a cozy vibe. And the smell of pizza wafting through the air just added to the experience!

I decided to try their signature pepperoni pizza for lunch – it was amazing! The crust was light and fluffy, the cheese melted perfectly, and the sauce was just spicy enough without overpowering all my other toppings.

The staff was also extremely helpful and friendly throughout my visit. They were eager to answer any questions and make sure I got exactly what I wanted out of my meal.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Columbus IN, look no further than ZwanzigZ Pizza. With its cozy atmosphere and delicious food, you can’t go wrong!

#4 Chicago’s Pizza

I’m not sure what made their pizza so special, but it was an unforgettable experience. From the perfectly cooked, light and fluffy crust, to the flavorful sauce and mix of perfect toppings, each slice was a delightful treat. Not to mention the friendly staff who welcomed me with a smile.

The atmosphere of this restaurant was also just right. It had all the elements of classic Italian vibes, while still feeling comfortable and welcoming. The interior wall art added a touch of character to the place that made it even more charming.

Not only did I enjoy my time at Chicago’s Pizza, but I was pleased with the value for money as well! The portions were generous yet reasonably priced. With prices like these, I could visit often without breaking the bank.

All in all, Chicago’s Pizza has earned my stamp of approval as one of the best pizza places in Columbus IN! If you’re looking for a delicious and affordable meal option that won’t disappoint, look no further than this cozy little pizzeria!

#5 Noble Roman’s

The dough is perfectly cooked and tastes like it was made from scratch. The flavor is out of this world, with just the right amount of cheese and sauce. The toppings are thoughtfully selected and flavorful, making each bite an experience.

The service was also top-notch! From the moment I stepped in, I felt welcomed by the friendly staff. We had a great conversation about pizza as we waited for our order, which didn’t take long at all!

The atmosphere is cozy yet upbeat. The walls decorated with memorabilia create a unique ambiance that will make you feel like you’ve been there before–in the best way possible.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Columbus IN, Noble Roman’s is your spot! From the delicious food to the welcoming staff, it’s an experience that won’t soon be forgotten.

#6 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

I found myself pleasantly surprised by the sheer variety of pizzas available at Papa Murphy’s. The menu consists of classic pizzas like pepperoni, supreme, and meaty delite pies, as well as a great selection of signature pizzas from Hawaiian Luau to Cowboy. Also, I was delighted to find vegetarian options and even gluten-free crust available!

The crust at Papa Murphy’s is always delicious and perfectly cooked. They use premium ingredients to make sure that every pie delivers on flavor. The cheese is generous and flavorful, while their homemade sauces are packed with bold flavors.

What really sets Papa Murphy’s apart is the fact that they offer both take ‘n’ bake and traditional oven baked pizzas. Sure, having a freshly baked pizza delivered to my door is nice but there’s something special about prepping your own pizza right in your own kitchen before you bake it up in your own oven. It adds a personal touch that makes the experience special for me each time I visit.

All in all, my experience at Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza was truly remarkable. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Columbus IN then this is definitely the place you need to check out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 34 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Bloomington!

#7 Greek’s Pizzeria

The first thing I noticed upon entering the restaurant is the pleasant atmosphere and friendly smile on the staff. The decor was very traditional with a nod to Greek culture, while still staying family-friendly.

I was eager to take my first bite of their pizza and I wasn’t disappointed. The crust was cooked perfectly – crisp on the outside but chewy on the inside. It had a great flavor profile with just the right amount of herbs and spices. The cheese was fresh and of high quality, with just enough toppings to give it a fantastic flavor without overpowering the other ingredients.

My overall experience at Greek’s Pizzeria was simply delicious! While I didn’t get to sample every single item off their menu, I can confidently say that they have some of the best pizza in Columbus IN! From their quality ingredients to their attentive service, you’re guaranteed a memorable experience each time you dine here.

#8 Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders

At Mancino’s, the pies are cooked to perfection with a light golden crust, and topped with flavorful ingredients. The cheese is always melted to a gooey, stringy perfection and they have a wide selection of toppings that will tantalize your taste buds.

The grinders are also out of this world! They’re made with freshly baked bread and filled to the brim with tasty ingredients like peppers, onions, beef, and more. The grinders are always tightly wrapped in foil so that all of the flavors are held inside for maximum awesomeness.

Furthermore, their prices are reasonable and their customer service was top notch throughout our visit. Every employee we spoke to was friendly and attentive – they really seem to care about the quality of their food and making sure every customer has an enjoyable experience.

In conclusion, I’d definitely recommend Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Columbus IN. You won’t be disappointed!

#9 Marco’s Pizza

I’m sure many of you have heard the raving reviews about their pizza, and let me tell you, they are absolutely true. From the first bite, I was in love. The dough was light and airy – almost like a cloud! – with a subtle taste of oregano that made it unique and memorable. The sauce was perfectly balanced between sweet and salty and had an amazing depth of flavor. The mozzarella cheese was fresh and creamy, melting perfectly over each slice.

But if these basic ingredients weren’t enough to make this pizza one of the best in Columbus IN, then their other toppings are where Marco’s Pizza really shines. Each topping is added sparingly yet artfully to ensure an even distribution of flavor throughout the entire pizza. My favorite combination is pepperoni and mushrooms – it’s out-of-this-world delicious!

At Marco’s Pizza you can taste quality from start to finish. They offer fast delivery times as well as friendly customer service which only add to the overall dining experience. On top of all that, their prices are pretty reasonable too!

To put it simply: if you’re looking for the best pizza in Columbus IN, then Marco’s Pizza is definitely the place for you.

#10 Bucceto’s Pizza Pasta

The first thing I noticed when I stepped in the door is the friendly atmosphere, with an inviting and cheerful restaurant staff. The walls are decorated with colorful paintings and the aroma of homemade pizza wafts through the air.

One bite of their signature pizza was all it took for me to realize why this place is so popular—it’s simply delicious! The combination of fresh ingredients, crispy crust and flavorful sauce create a flavor like no other. And don’t even get me started on their topping selection; they have everything from classic pepperoni to exotic pineapple.

Not only do they offer fantastic pizzas, but their pastas are just as tasty! I especially enjoyed their Bucatini Carbonara which came with loads of bacon, cream, and egg yolks that made for a richly creamy yet light meal.

I can honestly say that Bucceto’s Pizza Pasta has earned its spot as the best pizza in Columbus IN. Their prices are also very reasonable, making this an amazing value for top-notch pizza. Don’t forget to leave room for dessert; they have homemade cannoli that will make your taste buds go wild!

#11 Marco’s Pizza

I have to admit, I was a bit smug heading into Marco’s Pizza. After eating pizza in Italy, France and other destinations that are renowned for having the best pizza recipes on the planet, I figured nothing could compare. However, my opinion did a 180 after trying their pies.

The thin crust is crispy and golden on the outside, yet soft and supple on the inside. It reminded me of some of my favorite pizzas from Naples. The sauce was perfectly spiced with oregano and basil – definitely no skimping on flavor here. The mozzarella cheese was creamy and flavorful, melting into every bite like a dream. And the toppings? Talk about freshness! Peppers were crunchy-sweet; mushrooms toasty; sausage had just enough kick to it; even their pepperoni pizzas were more than satisfactory!

In conclusion, Marco’s Pizza is hands-down the best pizza in Columbus IN! I’d highly recommend anyone looking for a delicious slice (or pie) to make their way over to this joint as soon as possible – you won’t regret it! Bon appetit!

If you’re willing to go an extra 40 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Indianapolis!

#12 Arni’s Columbus

The restaurant is warm and inviting. The staff is friendly, and the pizza is just as good.

The pizza menu provides a variety of choices to satisfy any type of pizza lover! From classic Italian-style thin crusts to thick, New York-style slices, Arni’s has something for everyone.

My personal favorite is the deep dish pepperoni pizza with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. It could easily be eaten as an entire meal in itself! Even if you don’t like pepperoni, there are plenty of other options to choose from – such as veggie or sausage pizzas.

As for the rest of the menu, it’s hard to pick out just one item as they’re all so delicious! I especially enjoyed their calzones, which are stuffed with various meats and vegetables, seasoned with herbs and spices, and baked until golden brown perfection. Delicious!

All in all, Arni’s Columbus offers some of the best pizza in Columbus IN. It’s worth a visit next time you’re in town – I know you won’t be disappointed!