Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Fort Collins CO (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Colorado

Best Pizza in Fort Collins CO (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

213 Views

I’ve visited 12 places, tasting and sampling the best of their pizzas to share my favorite finds with you. You may be surprised at some of the selections I chose as the best pizza in Fort Collins CO!

Along my travels, I’ve sampled everything from classic Neapolitan pies to creative gourmet offerings, so don’t expect a basic cheese slice here. Never one to take these decisions lightly, I came armed with a discerning palate and an open mind ready for a culinary adventure.

It’s time to dive in and find out what the best pizzas are in Fort Collins CO!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Colorado

#1 Hungry Pizza

My search started with a visit to the restaurant’s quaint brick-and-mortar location. Immediately I noticed that the staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating, which is an important factor for me when judging a pizza place.

The menu options surprised me in a very pleasant way. As soon as I saw their selection of creative toppings and unique crusts, I knew this would be no ordinary pizza experience! Any brave enough to try something truly adventurous can choose from white garlic truffle sauce and plantain chips.

The quality of the pizza was superb! Deliciously crisp dough with just enough crunch, perfectly cooked toppings and loads of flavor made every bite memorable. My favorite was the ‘H Street BBQ’ pie, topped with pepper jack cheese, pulled pork, red onions and spicy BBQ sauce–absolutely delicious!

Overall, I’d say Hungry Pizza has some of the best pizza in Fort Collins CO. With creative topping combinations, outstanding customer service and flavorful pizzas that will keep your taste buds dancing all night long, it really delivers on its promise of excellent food!

If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Loveland!

#2 Totally 80’s Pizza & Museum

The experience of eating at this place is unlike anything I’ve ever encountered. They take such pride in their flavorful 80’s-themed pizzas, from the colorful decor to the classic arcade games and cheesy pop music!

The signature pizza, the Bruiser, was my favorite. It has a crispy crust topped with pungent garlic sauce, tangy pepperoni, roasted mushrooms, and fresh bell peppers. The toppings were explosive in both flavor and texture – just perfect for my taste buds!

Another thing that captured my attention was their wide variety of craft beers on tap as well as craft cocktails like the Fruity Pebbles Margarita or an Arnold Palmer spiked with whiskey. Their selection provided a great pairing option for my meal!

My overall experience at Totally 80’s Pizza & Museum was truly memorable. From their delicious food to the fun atmosphere, this restaurant is like no other and definitely deserves its spot as one of the best pizza places in Fort Collins CO.

#3 La piadina – Italian Flatbread Sandwiches

This unique Italian-style eatery features scrumptious flatbread pizzas that are baked to perfection. The flavors and quality of each pie are beyond compare. From the classic Margherita to the savory Vimtese, there’s a taste for everyone.

The atmosphere at La piadina is one of the most inviting I’ve experienced. The bright colors and quaint decor transport you to an authentic Italian restaurant while still maintaining modern style. Plus, the staff is always super friendly, making you feel right at home.

As far as pizza goes, La piadina has some of the best pies in town. Whether you’re looking for a traditional or something more adventurous, this restaurant has what you’re craving! The crusts are crispy and delicious and the toppings are top-notch quality – it’s no wonder why this place is so popular in Fort Collins CO!

If you’re looking for a delectable slice of Italy, look no further than La piadina – Italian Flatbread Sandwiches. I guarantee your taste buds will be singing after one bite!

#4 Slyce Pizza Co.

The dough is light, fluffy and perfectly balanced between chewy and crispy. The cheese blend is just the right amount of gooey and melty. As for the toppings, I’m never let down by their selection! Everything from the classics to unique toppings like pineapples (if you’re feeling adventurous) are available.

But what really sets this pizza apart from others is its sauce. It’s not too sweet like some places, with a subtle tanginess that perfectly complements all the ingredients.

And it doesn’t hurt that the atmosphere at Slyce Pizza Co. is always lively and inviting! It’s a great spot for gathering friends or family, where everyone can settle down for delicious slices and good conversations. Plus, the staff are always friendly and helpful.

Slyce Pizza Co definitely does justice to Fort Collins’ pizza-loving crowd – if you haven’t tried it yet, it’s well worth the trip! In short: Best Pizza in Fort Collins CO? You bet!

#5 JJ’s Wood Fired Pizza

I’m not the type of person to say something unless I mean it, so when I tell you that the pizza at JJ’s is truly delicious – trust me! The wood-fired crust is light and fluffy and the toppings are always perfectly cooked. Plus, they always offer a great variety of unique options for adventurous palates.

The atmosphere at JJ’s is absolutely amazing as well. The staff are friendly and welcoming, and the decor is lively and inviting, making this spot an ideal place for grabbing a slice with friends or even having a romantic dinner for two.

When it comes down to it, there are tons of places that make delicious pizza in Fort Collins CO – but none of them can compare to the experience you get from a night spent at JJ’s Wood Fired Pizza!

#6 MOD Pizza

It’s hard to beat MOD Pizza for their tasty pies. From the first bite, you can tell that MOD Pizza takes great pride in using the freshest ingredients and highest-quality products. The mouth-watering aroma of the pizzas being cooked in their blazing-hot ovens makes it impossible to resist ordering up a pie.

The pizzas at MOD Pizza are loaded with flavor, and they always make sure to customize each one according to what your taste buds demand. The variety of toppings is so immense that you could create a different pizza experience every time! Furthermore, the prices are more than reasonable, making it a great value for those looking for an excellent pizza experience.

Coupled with their friendly staff and amazing atmosphere, MOD Pizza offers one of the best pizza experiences I’ve ever had. No matter if it’s your first time or you’re already loyal to this establishment, I guarantee you will enjoy your stay!

#7 otto PINT

I finally made it over to eat at otto PINT, and I was certainly not disappointed. When the pizza arrived at the table, I was amazed by the aroma of herbs and spices emanating from the pizza. The toppings were fresh and delicious. Every slice of pizza was melted to perfection.

The atmosphere at otto PINT was also great – they had a warm, cozy atmosphere with inviting decor that really complemented the meal. Additionally, the staff were super friendly and helpful in solving any queries we had about their menu items.

One thing that really stood out for me was how fast they prepared my meal – I barely finished my first slice before my second one came out piping hot!

Everything considered, I think Otto Pint serves some of the best pizza in Fort Collins CO, hands down!

#8 Krazy Karl’s Pizza and Sports Bar

I thought the restaurant would be gimmicky and over-the-top with its name, but I was pleasantly surprised at how quaint and welcoming it actually was. From the moment I stepped in, I had an immediate feeling of comfort and ease.

The menu featured pizzas with all sorts of unique toppings, from succulent fresh mushrooms to imported artisan meats. But what really caught my eye were the signature pizzas – each one made using perfectly balanced flavors that created a truly unforgettable taste sensation.

I ordered their signature ‘Krazy Karl’s Special’ pizza which came topped with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions and extra cheese. The charm here is not just in the ingredients used but also in their cooking technique: a flame-grilled dough and golden oven-baked layers of cheese make for an incredibly flavorful pizza experience.

I have to say–it was possibly the best pizza I’ve tasted in Fort Collins CO! Without question–I’d highly recommend Krazy Karl’s Pizza and Sports Bar for anyone looking for great tasting pizza in the area!

If you’re willing to go an extra 23 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Greeley!

#9 Panino’s Italian Restaurant

As soon as I stepped foot in the restaurant, I was immediately taken aback by the warm and inviting atmosphere. The ambiance was so inviting that I almost wanted to stay for a few more hours!

The staff were very friendly and accommodating, offering me great menu recommendations. After going through the menu, I had decided to try their signature dish – their pizza! It didn’t take long for it to be delivered to my table, and let me tell you… it blew me away! The dough was freshly made, with a nice crunchy crust. The cheese was layered perfectly on top of the pizza and its toppings – it was simply divine!

I’m not exaggerating when I say Panino’s Italian Restaurant has some of the best pizza in Fort Collins CO. If you’re ever in town, this is definitely one pizza place you should check out!

#10 Vincent Gastroteca

My experience at Vincent Gastroteca was nothing short of amazing. Not only did they have a wide variety of delicious pizzas, but the service was top-notch as well.

On my visit, I had the pleasure of tasting some of their signature dishes, including their award-winning Neapolitan-style pizza. This style is known for its thin crust and slightly charred edges – it certainly didn’t disappoint! The sauce and cheese were perfectly balanced, and the flavor was just heavenly.

But what really took this pizza to the next level was their unique toppings! From smoked salmon to roasted red peppers, every bite was truly a work of art.

If you’re ever in Fort Collins CO looking for a great pizza experience, you owe it to yourself to pay Vincent Gastroteca a visit. I can guarantee that you won’t be disappointed – it’s some of the best pizza I’ve had in all my travels!

#11 The Corner Slice

I was amazed by their selection of pizzas – they had something to please everyone. From classic combinations like pepperoni and cheese, to more daring flavors like garlic-mushroom-pesto, there’s something for any pizza craving!

The crust on the pizzas might be some of the best I’ve ever tasted – it was crunchy and flavorful, cooked perfectly. The dough was light and fluffy inside, with just the perfect amount of chewiness. It’s no wonder this place is so popular!

The toppings were fresh and tasty – nothing over-processed or greasy here. Every bite was delicious and satisfying!

The atmosphere of the restaurant itself was fun too – it had a great vibe that made me feel relaxed and comfortable. The staff were friendly and welcoming, even going out of their way to accommodate special requests from customers.

All in all, The Corner Slice is definitely one of the best pizza places I’ve been to in a long time! If you’re looking for fantastic pizza done right in Fort Collins CO, then this is where you should go!

#12 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I was welcomed by a warm and friendly staff. They took the time to explain all of their delicious options, which gave me an extra boost of confidence that this restaurant had something special waiting for me.

I was completely blown away when I finally got my pizza. After I took it home to bake it in the oven, I found out that it was made with fresh ingredients and that the crust had a wonderful lightness to it that was perfectly balanced with the flavor of tomato sauce and cheese. It turns out this is just how Papa Murphy’s makes their pizza—a secret blend of flavors that can’t be replicated elsewhere!

The crust was so crispy on top that I almost couldn’t resist eating it before popping it into the oven—but somehow I managed. When it came out piping hot, I savored every bite and discovered why Papa Murphy’s has become so popular in Fort Collins CO: they offer some of the best pizza around!

If you’re ever in Fort Collins looking for an unforgettable pizza experience, do yourself a favor and visit Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza. It will be an experience you won’t soon forget!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Beau Jo’s Fort Collins

From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a treat. The smell of freshly baked dough and bubbling cheese filled the air, and my mouth started watering before I even sat down.

As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I have high standards. But Beau Jo’s exceeded them all. Their thin crust was perfectly crisp, like biting into a deliciously crunchy cloud. The toppings were a symphony of flavors, perfectly balanced and generously portioned. I couldn’t help but do a little happy dance in my seat with each bite.

The beauty of this place is that they don’t take themselves too seriously. The atmosphere is laid-back and fun, with quirky decorations and staff that were more than happy to engage in some playful banter. I felt like I was in a comedy club that just happened to serve amazing pizza.

The menu at Beau Jo’s is extensive, catering to all types of pizza lovers. Whether you’re a vegetarian, a meat lover, or even a pineapple-on-pizza advocate (don’t worry, your secret is safe with me), there’s a pizza for you. And if you’re feeling adventurous, you can even create your own masterpiece with their wide selection of toppings.

The only downside to Beau Jo’s? Trying to decide which pizza to order. But hey, that’s a problem I’m more than willing to have. So, if you’re in Fort Collins and searching for the best thin crust pizza, look no further than Beau Jo’s. Just be prepared to fall in love, and maybe invest in some stretchy pants. Trust me, you’ll need them!