Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Lbi (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Lbi (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

221 Views

I’ve been trekking across the world in search of great pizza, and when I heard about the pizza scene in Lbi, I had to check it out for myself. So, I put together a list of 12 of the best pizza places around town.

I’m not going to lie – I was skeptical at first. Could a small beach town really host some incredible pizza? But I haven’t been disappointed yet! My taste buds have been thanking me ever since my journey began. In this article, I’ll be sharing my unique take on all the best options that Lbi has to offer.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 BLVD Pizza

The atmosphere is great for tourists, with a really cool decor and a very friendly staff. And the pizza? I’ll be honest—I haven’t had pizza this good in a long time! The crust was light and crunchy, the sauce was mouth-wateringly delicious, and the toppings were cooked to perfection.

But what really sets BLVD Pizza apart is their commitment to quality ingredients. Everything they use is fresh and of high quality, so you know you’re getting the best of the best.

That being said, there is one downside that might deter some people—they don’t offer delivery. If that’s an important factor for you, then BLVD Pizza might not be your go-to spot. But if you can make it out there yourself, it will definitely be worth it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Toms River!

#2 Libertá Pizzeria Americana

The atmosphere of the restaurant is low-key but has a cozy, inviting feeling. The staff is always friendly and make sure your experience at Libertá is enjoyable.

As for the pizza itself, it’s simply divine. The crust is thin, crunchy and light. It’s cooked to perfection with just the right amount of cheese and toppings to bring out all the amazing flavors. They also offer some unique toppings like artichoke hearts, mushrooms and jalapenos that really add an extra layer of flavor to the pizza.

Overall I can say I was truly impressed by my visit to Libertá Pizzeria Americana and I can confidently say it has some of the best pizza in Lbi!

#3 Anthony’s Restaurant-Pizzeria

After walking through the door, I was immediately impressed with the atmosphere. The entire restaurant is adorned in classic Italian decor, from the warm red walls to a giant mural of a Venetian canal scene. With music playing from an old jukebox in the corner, it’s obvious that Anthony’s takes pride in its authenticity.

And then there’s the pizza. It definitely lives up to its reputation! Every slice is fresh-made with thick crust, zesty sauce, and quality cheese and toppings galore. Whether you prefer traditional toppings like pepperoni and sausage or something more daring like goat cheese and artichokes, Anthony’s Restaurant-Pizzeria can make it happen. I had no complaints whatsoever about the taste or presentation of my meal!

Finally, what really sets this pizza joint apart is the service. From our bubbly hostess to our attentive waiter, every interaction was friendly and professional. They even threw in a complimentary dessert just because they could tell we were having a great time!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Lbi, then look no further – Anthony’s Restaurant-Pizzeria is definitely worth checking out!

#4 Naples Pizza & Restaurant

I had the opportunity to visit this restaurant on a recent trip and I was very impressed. The atmosphere is great, there’s even a kid’s menu which made my youngling happy. And the pizza? Wow, it was delicious! They have so many topping combinations, it can be hard to decide what to get.

And if you’re looking for something sweet after dinner, they offer dessert. With plenty of park spots close by too, Naples Pizza & Restaurant truly is the perfect tourist spot!

Unfortunately, they don’t deliver their amazing pizzas but that just means you’ll have to visit their place in Lbi to get your hands on some. Trust me when I say, it’ll be worth it! Overall I’d give Naples Pizza & Restaurant an A+ for its delicious pizza and excellent atmosphere.

#5 Speakeasy Pizzeria & Restaurant

From the moment you walk in, you feel as if you’ve been transported to a true Italian pizzeria. The atmosphere is inviting and cozy and the staff are very friendly and knowledgeable.

The pizza was cooked to perfection with an amazing flavor combination of cheese, sauce, and toppings! Each bite was savory and had that perfect crunchy yet chewy consistency. I especially love the house-made dough which gives it an extra special touch. The ingredients tasted like they had only just been picked from the garden that morning!

To top it off, Speakeasy Pizzeria & Restaurant offers a great selection of craft beers from local breweries. It’s the perfect way to end your meal!

All in all, Speakeasy Pizzeria & Restaurant is definitely a must-try for anyone looking for some seriously delicious pizza in Lbi! Highly recommend!

#6 Black Eyed Susans Tavern & Restaurant

From the moment I stepped through the door to this quaint beachfront restaurant, I knew I’d found something special. The atmosphere was inviting, yet cozy and inviting, and the staff was incredibly friendly.

I started off with a few slices of their signature pizza and it was amazing! The crust was thin and crispy, the sauce perfectly spiced and flavorful, and the cheese melted in my mouth. The toppings were also top notch; each bite oozed with flavor.

The real star of this meal, however, was their dessert. Baked goods like pies or cakes are usually afterthoughts at other pizza spots, but Black Eyed Susans did not disappoint. The sweet treats they served were insanely good; they went above and beyond expectations in every way possible!

One downside to this place is that they don’t offer delivery service but if you’re looking for an amazing lunch or dinner spot while visiting Lbi – look no further than Black Eyed Susans Tavern & Restaurant! In addition to having some of the best pizza around, they also offer vegetarian options as well as local craft beers (and hard liquor!). All in all it’s a great tourist spot that is definitely worth checking out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 20 miles, you can get to 14 more pizza places in Seaside Heights!

#7 California Grill & Pizza

I recently visited their restaurant and was blown away by their ingredients, which are all locally sourced and freshly prepared when you order. The dough is made in-house daily, making it incredibly light and fluffy. I tried the margherita pizza with lots of fresh basil, buffalo mozzarella cheese, juicy tomatoes, and garlic; it was amazing! All of their pizzas also come with a generous portion of olive oil and Parmesan cheese.

The atmosphere at California Grill & Pizza was also great. It’s a casual spot but has an inviting vibe that makes you feel right at home as soon as you walk in — complete with black and white photos on the wall to remind you of old Lbi charm.

I also loved the friendly waitress who served me my pizza. She gave me lots of recommendations for other menu items that I should try out next time I visit — like their calzone or stromboli.

Honestly, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Lbi, I highly suggest you visit California Grill & Pizza!

#8 Pietro’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

The first thing I noticed when I walked in the door was the smell of delicious Italian cooking. It was so inviting and inviting that I almost forgot why I was there. After taking my seat, I couldn’t help but glance at the menu and take note of all the incredible choices they had to offer.

I decided on their famous “Pietro’s Special” pizza which consisted of a tomato sauce base, pepperoni, mushrooms, olives, and green peppers. As soon as it arrived at my table, my mouth began to water as the aroma filled up the room.

The pizza was cooked to perfection, with just enough crunchy crust to keep it from becoming soggy, and each topping was perfectly balanced in flavor and texture – nothing overpowering or underwhelming here! Every bite tasted better than the last.

All in all, Pietro’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is definitely one of the best places for pizza in Lbi – I highly recommend it if you’re ever craving some excellent Italian food!

#9 Bay Village Pizza

The moment I stepped into Bay Village Pizza, my mouth starting watering. The smell of fresh dough and melted cheese filled the air – it was heavenly! It was clear that the staff here take their pizza seriously because every detail of their pies is perfectly crafted.

The atmosphere of the restaurant is friendly and inviting, with a cozy atmosphere that makes you feel like you’ve stepped back in time. Plus, the service at Bay Village Pizza is always top-notch – they always seem to know exactly what I’m craving before I even order it!

Of course, what really matters at a pizza joint is its pies. And Bay Village Pizza delivers on this front too – their pizzas are thin-crust masterpieces! Each one is loaded with just the right amount of toppings and has a perfect blend of flavors. I can honestly say that each bite of their pizza leaves me craving more!

Overall, it’s quite clear why Bay Village Pizza is known for having some of the best pizza in Lbi – they offer an inviting atmosphere and delicious pizzas crafted by professionals who have been in the business for years! If you’re ever looking for a great slice, look no further than Bay Village Pizza!

#10 Joeys’ Pizza

The pizza at Joeys’ Pizza is legendary. I had the chance to try the specialties of both their Sicilian and Neapolitan styles, and I was blown away. The dough was cooked perfectly, with a crisp crust that was flavorful and chewy, just like I love it. The toppings were also very fresh,and the sauce added just the right amount of flavor and sweetness.

The staff at Joeys’ was also warm and friendly, which really added to the overall experience. The vibe inside the restaurant was great too – it felt cozy and inviting.

All in all, my experience at Joeys’ Pizza proved once again why this place is known as one of the best places for pizza in Lbi. If you’re looking for a great place to grab some quality pizza, then look no further than Joeys’. You won’t be disappointed!

#11 Custard Hut and Pizza

The place is cozy and inviting and the staff is friendly and welcoming. When I arrived, I was delighted to see a large selection of pizzas to choose from, ranging from classic Margherita to unique offerings such as pesto pizza with artichokes and olives.

I opted for a pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and wasn’t disappointed. The crust was perfectly thin and crunchy, the sauce was flavorful and the toppings were generous and fresh. The pizza had just the right amount of cheese, making it rich but not overwhelming. Needless to say, it was one of the best pizzas I’ve had in quite some time!

To top it all off, Custard Hut offers homemade ice cream that can be served alongside your pizza! From creamy custards to decadent gelatos and even nut-based ice creams, there’s something for everyone. The flavor combinations are unique and delicious – a great way to end a meal.

Overall, I’d highly recommend Custard Hut Pizza for anyone looking for the best pizza in Lbi. They have an extensive selection of pies to choose from, plus delicious homemade ice cream that make this spot perfect for family dinners or date night outings!

If you’re willing to go an extra 23 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Toms River!

#12 Fusaros Pizza And Pasta Manahawkin

The staff at Fusaros were friendly and accommodating, but more importantly they make an amazing pizza. I tried the pepperoni and sausage, which was cooked to perfection and had just the right amount of cheese. The crust was light and fluffy, and the sauce was flavorful without being too overpowering.

The atmosphere at Fusaros is great. It’s a bright and cheerful place with an inviting feel. They offer both indoor and outdoor seating, so you can enjoy your meal in whatever way you prefer. Plus, they have a selection of draft beer on tap to pair with your pizza!

All in all, I would definitely recommend Fusaros Pizza And Pasta Manahawkin if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Lbi. I highly suggest giving it a try – you won’t be disappointed!