Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Libertyville (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Illinois

Best Pizza in Libertyville (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

203 Views

I’ve tasted pizza everywhere from Rome to Tokyo, so I feel like I have a pretty good handle on what makes a great pie. After dining at 12 different pizza places throughout Libertyville, I’m ready to tell you which one reigns supreme!

The best part? This lighthearted article isn’t just about mouthwatering reviews. Along the way, there are plenty of humorous anecdotes. So sit back, grab a slice of pizza (or two) and get ready for my take on the best pizzeria in town!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Illinois

#1 Maciano’s Pizza & Pastaria

The atmosphere is casual and inviting. The staff was friendly, efficient and attentive.

The pizza here is absolutely delicious! The crust was thin, crispy and just the right amount of crunchy. The sauce was rich and flavorful with a hint of sweetness. The toppings were fresh and plentiful.

I tried the house specialty – the Italian Sausage Pizza – it was simply amazing! It had a generous topping of sausage, bell peppers, onions, tomatoes and cheese that was cooked to perfection. I couldn’t get enough of this tasty pie!

I also sampled their pasta dishes which were also quite impressive. They offer a wide variety from spaghetti to lasagna and all tasted wonderful.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Libertyville, Maciano’s Pizza & Pastaria is definitely worth visiting. You won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Palatine!

#2 Pizzeria DeVille

The atmosphere is fantastic, the staff friendly and welcoming, and the pizza simply divine.

The crust is thin enough to get a nice crunch with each bite, but not so thin you feel like you’re eating a cracker. The sauce is savory and flavorful, and the cheese is melted just right. I especially love their specialty pies — the Primavera Pizza with artichoke hearts and zucchini slices was out of this world!

And of course, let’s not forget about dessert! They don’t skimp on the toppings here — from rich chocolates to colorful sprinkles, you can find whatever topping you desire for that unique flavor finish that brings it all together.

I highly recommend Pizzeria DeVille — I think it’s safe to say that they have some of the best pizza in Libertyville!

#3 Ganello’s Pizza Company

The atmosphere was great; the restaurant was warm and inviting. There’s plenty of seating, and the outdoor patio is perfect for enjoying a relaxing evening.

The pizza is delicious – it’s cooked to perfection with high-quality ingredients. The crust is light and fluffy and the toppings are always fresh. From traditional cheese pizzas to their signature specialty pies, Ganello’s has something for everyone.

The service is top-notch – the staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful. They’re always happy to answer questions or make suggestions about what would go well together. And they even have a loyalty program that rewards customers who come back often!

All in all, I’d highly recommend Ganello’s Pizza Company if you’re looking for the best pizza in Libertyville! Between their quality food, great atmosphere, and exceptional service, you’ll be sure to love your experience at Ganello’s Pizza Company!

#4 Morgan’s Bar & Grill

The first thing I noticed when I walked in was the cozy atmosphere. Morgan’s has a classic pub-style vibe with TVs playing sports and dim lighting that provides just enough light to see your meal. But enough about the atmosphere, let’s talk about the food.

I ordered their signature pizza – a thin crust pie topped with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions and lots of cheese. The pizza was cooked perfectly and had amazing flavor. The crust was crisp yet slightly chewy and held up well to all the toppings. And the melted cheese was pure heaven! It completely covered everything so every bite was filled with cheesy goodness.

But what really sets Morgan’s apart is their one-of-a-kind sauces they offer on the side – a tangy garlic cream sauce, smoky chipotle bbq sauce and creamy ranch dressing. All three sauces added such delicious flavor to the pizza that it almost didn’t need any other toppings.

Overall, I have to say that Morgan’s Bar & Grill is home to some of the best pizza in Libertyville! If you’re ever in town or passing through, be sure to stop by for a slice or two – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Mt Prospect!

#5 MOD Pizza

When I first visited MOD Pizza, I was immediately drawn in by the quirky decor and friendly staff. The restaurant’s vibe is perfect for a casual lunch or dinner out with friends.

The quality of the pizza was outstanding! Every topping is fresh and flavorful, and they never skimp on the cheese. The crust was cooked to perfection, neither too crunchy nor too soft – it was simply delicious!

I tried two very different pizzas during my visit: the classic Margherita pizza and the mushroom-spinach-bacon pizzas. Both pizzas were cooked perfectly, giving them an amazing flavor. Even better, you can customize your pizza however you like – no matter what you’d like on it, these guys will make it happen!

And if pizza isn’t your thing? No worries – MOD Pizza also offers salads, garlic breadsticks and more! They even have gluten-free options so everyone can get in on the fun.

All in all, MOD Pizza is definitely worth trying out if you’re looking for great pizza in Libertyville. I can tell you from personal experience that their food will be sure to hit the spot every time!

#6 The Calzone & Macaroni Co

As soon as I walked in, I was immediately struck by the cozy atmosphere of the small restaurant. The brick walls and comfy booths created an inviting environment.

I was looking forward to trying their specialty calzones, but after devouring a slice of their classic cheese pizza, I knew that would not be necessary. The crust was crispy yet light, while the sauce and cheese were perfectly balanced. It was like eating a cloud with just the right amount of flavor.

The staff at The Calzone & Macaroni Co were also delightful. They were friendly and knowledgeable about their pizzas which made my experience even more delightful. Plus, they had a great selection of craft beers on tap that really helped bring out the flavors of the pizza!

Overall, my experience at The Calzone & Macaroni Co has been one of the best pizza experiences I’ve ever had! It is definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in Libertyville in search for the best pizza around!

#7 Pizza Italia

I was incredibly impressed by the wide range of flavors and crusts available. From their classic Italian-style margherita to an exotic Thai-inspired creation, Pizza Italia really has something for everyone! The crust is perfectly crisp, the sauce is robust and flavorful, and the toppings are always fresh. It’s like a trip around the world with each slice!

The service here is also top notch – they take great care in making sure your order is right. They’ll even suggest if you’re unsure which pizza to pick!

The only downside to Pizza Italia is that they don’t offer delivery – so you’ll have to make a trip out there or ask a friend or family member to pick up your order for you. But it’s worth it – trust me! Pizza Italia definitely deserves its reputation as one of the best pizzerias in town, and I highly recommend it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in North Chicago!

#8 Lino’s Ristorante and Pizza

I’ve tried my fair share of pizzerias, but Lino’s definitely takes the cake with their fresh ingredients, delicious crusts and wide variety of delicious toppings. The first thing that stood out to me was their outstanding crust — it was just crunchy enough, with a great flavor that really complemented the cheese and sauce.

And when it comes to toppings, Lino’s really has something for everyone! From classic pepperoni to exotic creations like pineapple-jalapeno-bacon (yes please!), Lino’s offers an impressive array of delightful combinations. It seems like you could come back every day for a new experience!

Finally, the atmosphere of Lino’s is wonderfully inviting. The staff are friendly and attentive, making you feel right at home. The restaurant itself is cozy and comfortable, creating a perfect setting for enjoying your pizza in peace.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Libertyville you won’t go wrong at Lino’s Ristorante and Pizza. Fresh ingredients, great crusts and wonderful service make this place worth checking out — I know I’ll be back soon!

#9 Bill’s Pizza & Pub

The atmosphere at this place is great. Those dimly lit TVs, paired with the funky dècor and wallpaper are perfect to set the mood—it feels like a real pub! As for the service? Outstanding. The staff was friendly and accommodating. I really appreciate how Bill’s provides all of the condiments you need on every table.

Of course, what truly matters most when it comes to pizza is taste. Bill’s has perfected their recipe! All of their pizzas were perfectly cooked and full of flavor; my favorite was the “Belly Buster” which came loaded with five different meats – bacon, pepperoni, sausage, beef and more! Their pies are a bit on the greasy side (which I actually don’t mind) but none of that grease takes away from how amazing they taste.

Overall, I’m convinced that Bill’s Pizza & Pub is one of Libertyville’s hidden gems when it comes to pizza-eating experiences. You can count on me being back soon to enjoy some more of that delicious Belly Buster!

#10 Hitz Pizza and Sports Bar

I first noticed the décor of the restaurant, which was surprisingly spotless. I could tell that the staff takes great care to make sure their establishment looks inviting. The menu was extensive and they offer a variety of different pizzas.

The pizza itself lived up to the hype — it had a thin, crispy crust and the perfect combination of cheese and toppings. Even the most discerning food critic can’t help but admit that this is some of the best pizza around! The portion sizes were generous and many of my party left with boxes of leftovers, as well as smiles on their faces!

If you’re in Libertyville, you owe it to yourself to stop into Hitz Pizza and Sports Bar. Trust me — you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 21 more pizza places in Glenview!

#11 Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria

The thin-crust pies here are truly out of this world. The crust is a perfect combination of crispy and chewy and it’s baked to golden perfection. The layers of toppings are generous and flavorful, making for some seriously delicious pizzas that have won countless awards.

From the moment you step into Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria you’re welcomed with the smell of freshly baked pizza drifting in from the kitchen. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, with vibrant colors and plenty of seating for larger groups. You can also order online or through their mobile app if you don’t want to wait in line; just be sure to save room for dessert because the deep dish cookies are a must!

Overall, I highly recommend making a visit to Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria – no matter how far away you live – if you want to try some of the best pizza in Libertyville.

#12 SLYCE Coal Fired Pizza Company

The experience here is truly unlike any other. The warm, inviting atmosphere is perfect for a night out with friends or date night. The staff are always friendly and accommodating, and they make sure to provide the best service possible.

The pizzas themselves are truly something special. All are made in an authentic coal fired oven that lends a unique flavor to each pie. The crusts are thin and crispy, but still manage to stay strong enough to hold all that cheese, meats, and veggies on top! There’s a wide selection of both classic and creative pies available so there really is something for everyone here.

But the real standout for me was the house-made mozzarella cheese. It is some of the creamiest and most flavorful I’ve ever tasted! This along with their freshly-ground sauces make every bite an experience.

Overall, SLYCE Coal Fired Pizza Company has definitely earned its place as one of the best pizzerias in Libertyville! Whether you’re looking for classic pies or something more creative, this place won’t fail to satisfy your cravings. So come on down – you won’t regret it!