Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Belmar NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Belmar NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

97 Views

My journey has taken me from Italy to Chicago and everywhere in between. After trying some real specialty pizzas, I can tell you that Belmar NJ certainly doesn’t disappoint when it comes to delicious pizza.

So, get your appetite ready because I’m about to show you the twelve best pizza places in Belmar NJ. Get ready for a mouth-watering ride as I bring you an honest assessment of all the delicious choices offered.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Pizza Heaven (Authentic Neapolitan Style Wood Fired Pizza)

I was surprised to find such an amazing pizza joint tucked away in this small beach town. As soon as I stepped through the door, I knew I had made the right choice. The mouth-watering aroma of freshly cooked pizza left me drooling and the decor was downright delightful.

The staff at Pizza Heaven were friendly and accommodating, making sure that I got exactly what I wanted from my pizza. They also gave me some really helpful tips on how to get the most out of my pizza experience, which I really appreciated.

When it came to the actual pizza itself, Pizza Heaven did not disappoint! The wood fired oven produced a perfectly bubbly and crisp crust with just the right amount of charring on top. The flavor of the sauce was truly unique, offering a deep umami taste unlike anything else I’ve ever tasted before. Topping it off were plenty of fresh mozzarella and Italian sausage slices that added a nice contrasting texture and flavor to the overall pie.

All in all, I’m happy to report that Pizza Heaven (Authentic Neapolitan Style Wood Fired Pizza) serves up some of the best pizza in Belmar NJ! If you’re ever in town, make sure you stop by for an unforgettable slice!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Red Bank!

#2 Del Ponte’s Coal Fired Pizza

When I first arrived, I was immediately impressed by the cozy atmosphere. The coal-fired ovens made a wonderful smell that filled the restaurant and drew me in.

I sampled an assortment of different pizzas, from classic Margherita to Siciliana – all cooked in the pizzeria’s signature coal-fired ovens. Every pizza was cooked to perfection! The crust had a beautiful char on it and the cheese melted just right. All of their ingredients were fresh and high-quality, adding extra flavor to each pizza they make.

The staff at Del Ponte’s were also great – friendly yet professional, and really knew their stuff when it came to pizza making. It’s nice to know that they take pizza so seriously here!

In conclusion, I must say that Del Ponte’s Coal Fired Pizza is definitely one of the best places for pizza in Belmar NJ – if you’re ever in town, be sure to give them a visit. I guarantee you’ll be pleased with what you find!

#3 Federico’s Pizza & Restaurant

The atmosphere was spot on. The bustling sounds of customers and the inviting smell of cheese and sauce made my mouth water as I walked in. The staff was friendly, accommodating, and eager to please.

When it came time to order, I decided to get the ‘Signature Pizza’. Boy, am I glad I did! It arrived at my table piping hot with a great smell that could only come from the best pizza in Belmar NJ. The crust was thin and crispy but still chewy enough that the flavor really stood out, the cheese had a delicious tanginess to it, but not overwhelming. Topping it off (literally), were pepperoni’s which were cooked just right so that all their flavors melded together perfectly!

Overall, Federico’s Pizza & Restaurant is worthy of its title as having some of the best pizza in Belmar NJ! I highly recommend you check it out if you’re ever in town looking for a great slice!

#4 Pete & Elda’s Bar / Carmen’s Pizzeria

I had the pleasure of visiting Pete & Elda’s recently, and I couldn’t believe the quality of their pizza. The crust was light and crispy, with just the right amount of airiness – it was perfect! The sauce had a nice tangy flavor that balanced out the cheese. To top it off, they used generous amounts of fresh vegetables, which gave the pizza a delightful crunch.

The atmosphere at Pete & Elda’s / Carmen’s was also great. It had a cozy feel to it that made me instantly comfortable. On top of that, their servers are friendly and knowledgeable about their menu items – you don’t often find people like that in pizza places!

Overall, I’d have to say that Pete & Elda’s Bar / Carmen’s Pizzeria serves up some of the best pizza in Belmar NJ. The next time you’re in town craving some delicious pizza, definitely check them out – you won’t regret it!

#5 Vic’s Italian Restaurant

My first impression walking into the restaurant was that it had a very authentic Italian feel – complete with red-and-white checkered tablecloths and glass jars of wine. The staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming, which immediately put me at ease.

The pizza really blew me away! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, the cheese melted just right, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. I think it’s safe to say that Vic’s has some of the best pizza in Belmar NJ – if not the whole state!

To top it all off, the prices are more than reasonable for the quality you get. So if you’re ever looking for a great place to grab a slice, Vic’s is definitely worth checking out.

#6 Federici’s on 10th

I had heard about this place from some locals and decided to check it out. What I found was a cozy Italian-style restaurant, complete with white table cloths, Italian flags, and a nice atmosphere.

The menu boasted some delicious pizza options, such as their classic Margherita and the Supremo, which is topped with all kinds of yummy toppings. I went for the Supreme – really glad I did! Not only was it delicious, but they even had a kid’s menu which pleases me greatly as I travel with my family.

There were also plenty of choices when it comes to sides and desserts – cannoli, tiramisu anyone?! They even have a special “Federici’s Special Pizza” that changes each day so you can always come back for something different.

Unfortunately Federici’s does not offer delivery services – something that could definitely be improved upon. That being said, the restaurant still makes for an excellent spot for tourists and locals alike who want to enjoy some of the best pizza in Belmar NJ!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Paterson!

#7 Vinnie’s Pizza and Subs

When I arrived, the place was hopping! The aroma of sauce, cheese and all those delicious toppings filled the air. The staff was friendly and welcoming, making me feel right at home.

Their classic pepperoni pizza was an absolute delight. A perfectly thin yet crisp crust formed the base of the pie, topped with an abundance of juicy pepperonis, a generous helping of melted cheese and a just-right balance of sweet and tangy tomato sauce. It truly hit the spot!

I’m also a big fan of their specialties like Giuseppe’s Parmigiana Pizza — a decadent combination of chicken parmigiana, mozzarella cheese and basil that had me in pizza heaven. Other unique varieties include Mediterranean Veggie Delight with eggplant, mushrooms and sun-dried tomatoes as well as Meatball Bombshells with house-made meatballs cooked up nice and crispy. Yum!

If you’re looking for great quality pizza in Belmar NJ, look no further than Vinnie’s Pizza and Subs; it’s seriously one of the best places around!

#8 Bruno’s Pizza & Subs

As soon as I walked into the restaurant, I knew that this place was special. The atmosphere was inviting and everyone seemed to be enjoying themselves. The staff was friendly and helpful in making sure all of my pizza needs were met.

The pizza itself was out of this world! The crust was soft yet crunchy and the cheese melted in my mouth with every bite. Even better, the toppings were flavorful and were cooked to perfection! I’m fairly picky when it comes to pizza, but Bruno’s definitely hit all the marks for me.

Overall, Bruno’s Pizza & Subs is definitely worth a visit if you’re in Belmar NJ. The food and atmosphere are top notch and will leave you feeling satisfied (and maybe just a little bit stuffed!). It’s one of the best pizza restaurants around and definitely earns my stamp of approval!

#9 Reye’s Pizza

I must admit, I was skeptical when I first stumbled upon this little pizza joint. But the moment I stepped inside, I could smell the deliciousness! The wood-fired ovens created a rich and inviting aroma that made my mouth water.

The interior of Reye’s was cozy and inviting, with a bright yellow kitchen countertop that immediately set the tone for an enjoyable pizza experience.

The helpful staff at Reye’s Pizza welcomed me and were quick to assist in selecting the perfect pizza. After much deliberation, I decided on their classic Margherita Pizza. And boy was it heavenly! The crust was perfectly cooked with just enough crispiness. And the topping–oh my! Freshly grated mozzarella blended seamlessly with flavorful San Marzano tomatoes. Together they created a truly magical food experience!

If you’re in Belmar NJ looking for the best pizza around, make sure to check out Reye’s Pizza. You won’t be disappointed!

#10 Anthony’s Pizza

I’m serious, I wouldn’t joke about such an important matter. The pizza here is fantastic! The crust is perfectly balanced between crispy and chewy – not too thin, but not too thick. And the sauce is so flavorful. It’s made with San Marzano tomatoes and just the right amount of garlic, oregano and basil – it’s absolutely delicious.

But what really sets Anthony’s Pizza apart from the rest is their signature cheese blend. It’s a mix of whole-milk mozzarella and Provolone that adds such a rich, creamy flavor to each slice. And it melts in your mouth like butter!

Plus they have such a great selection of toppings – there are all kinds of traditional favorites plus some unique combinations that you just don’t find anywhere else.

Overall, Anthony’s Pizza is top notch. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Belmar NJ, this is definitely the spot to go!

#11 Attilios Pizza & Restaurant

From the moment I walked in, I immediately felt welcomed. Not only did they have a friendly staff, but they also had beautiful decor. The wood-fired ovens were the centerpiece of the room and gave the restaurant an inviting atmosphere that made me feel even more at home.

The pizza is some of the best I’ve ever had! It’s thin-crust and perfectly crispy – not too thick or too crunchy like some pizza places. As for toppings, it was loaded with lots of cheese and fresh ingredients like peppers, onions, sausage, and mushrooms.

I also enjoyed their other menu options. Their pasta dishes were tasty and well seasoned. Plus, their garlic knots were some of the softest and most flavorful I’ve ever tasted!

Overall, Attilios Pizza & Restaurant is a great spot to get delicious pizza while enjoying a beautiful atmosphere. It’s no wonder why it’s one of Belmar NJ’s most popular restaurants – it truly is some of the best pizza around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Asbury Park!

#12 Santino’s Pizza

I mean, it’s not the most exotic pizza I’ve tasted – but then again, I wasn’t expecting it to be. What you get at Santino’s is a classic Italian pizza experience: the crust is perfectly cooked and chewy, the sauce is so flavorful and fresh, and the toppings are always delicious.

What really set Santino’s pizza apart for me was how wonderfully cheesy it was. If you love cheese as much as I do, this place is a must-visit!

The atmosphere at Santino’s is also great – cozy tables surrounded by wood paneling give it a real ’50s era Italian pizzeria feel. Plus, they keep their prices reasonable, so it won’t break the bank to enjoy a delicious meal here.

In short – if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Belmar NJ, look no further than Santino’s Pizza!