Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Birmingham AL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Alabama

Best Pizza in Birmingham AL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

226 Views

After having sampled twelve of the area’s pizza places, I can confidently say Birmingham AL has some remarkable pies!

It wasn’t always easy to narrow down the best spots: the sheer variety of crust options and toppings available in Birmingham AL make it a hub for pizza-lovers of all preferences. This article will share my favorite places, with a bit of humor and levity thrown in for good measure.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Alabama

#1 Sanpeggio’s Pizza

I’ve tried pizza all over the world, but Sanpeggio’s always manages to impress me. Their unique blend of sauce and cheese that can’t be found anywhere else, always leaves me wanting more. The crusts are crispy, yet still doughy, just how I like them!

But my favorite part about Sanpeggio’s is definitely the fact that their pizzas have a distinct flavor that sets it apart from other pizzerias in Birmingham. Every time I go back for a visit, I find myself craving that perfect combination of ingredients that can only be found here.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Birmingham AL then look no further than Sanpeggio’s Pizza. It is truly one of a kind!

If you’re willing to go an extra 47 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Tuscaloosa!

#2 Tortugas Pizza

From the moment I stepped foot in this restaurant, it was clear that they take their pizza seriously. The staff was friendly and welcoming and the interior had a vibrant and fun atmosphere.

The menu offered an interesting array of classic pizzas, as well as some creative specialty pies. After much deliberation, I decided to try their delicious “Tortugas Special” and it did not disappoint! The crust was light and fluffy, and it had just the right amount of cheese, sauce, and toppings.

The flavors were simply exquisite! Each bite was truly a unique experience. Even better, they offer pizza by the slice for those who don’t want to commit to a pie.

All in all, Tortugas Pizza is definitely one of the best places to get pizza in Birmingham AL! From their warm hospitality to their scrumptious food choices, you won’t regret stopping in for a tasty treat!

#3 Iron City Pizza Company

I had the pleasure of trying out their signature pie which is the Iron City Special. This pizza was an amazing mixture of mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions and peppers. The combination of all these ingredients was just incredible and I could truly taste each one separately. The crust was thick and crunchy which held up well to the toppings without becoming soggy.

The atmosphere in the restaurant is casual yet stylish. It’s definitely a great place for a quick lunch or dinner with friends. The waitstaff are friendly and helpful making sure you are taken care of from start to finish.

To top it off, the price was more than reasonable especially considering how great the food was. I highly recommend Iron City Pizza Company to anyone who wants to experience some of the best pizza in Birmingham AL!

#4 Pizza Grace

I recently had the pleasure of enjoying some of their delicious pizza and delicious Italian dishes. The first thing I noticed was the warm and inviting atmosphere, which immediately put me at ease.

The pizzas were incredible! The crust was so thin and crispy, it almost melted in my mouth when I took a bite. Plus, their tomato sauce was the perfect balance of sweet and savory – definitely one of the best I’ve ever tasted!

And what about their toppings? Even there, Pizza Grace totally knocked it out of the park! From perfectly cooked sausage to crisp vegetables, every bite was absolutely heavenly.

Overall, I have to give Pizza Grace an A+ for coming up with some truly amazing pies. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Birmingham AL, this is absolutely the place to go. You won’t be disappointed!

#5 Uncle G’s Pizza at Ghost Train

The first thing that struck me about the restaurant was the atmosphere. It’s actually located inside an old abandoned train station, which is pretty cool and unique. The walls were decorated with vintage posters of iconic Birmingham trains along with a few other amusing decorations.

I had the cheese pizza, which was truly phenomenal. The crust was so thin and crispy, and the tomato sauce was sweet and flavorful. The cheese was melted perfectly giving it a creamy texture that went perfectly with the other ingredients.

But what really sets Uncle G’s Pizza apart is their toppings! From classic pepperoni to creative concoctions like buffalo chicken, they have something for everyone here. Plus, all of their ingredients are fresh; you can taste the difference in the quality of their pizza!

Overall, I’d have to say Uncle G’s Pizza at Ghost Train makes some of the best pizza in Birmingham AL! If you’re ever in town looking for a delicious slice of pie, then this is definitely a must-visit spot!

#6 Giuseppe’s Cafe

The atmosphere of the restaurant was cozy and inviting – perfect for a night out with friends. I sampled their signature thin-crust, which had an amazing flavor and a crisp texture. Piled high with herbs, fresh mozzarella cheese, and just the right amount of sauce, this pizza really hit the spot.

The staff was friendly and accommodating – they made sure we were well taken care of throughout our meal. The waiters were knowledgeable about the menu offerings, making it easy to select our meals.

Overall, my experience at Giuseppe’s Cafe was enjoyable and memorable. My only regret is that I didn’t try more of their delicious pizzas! If you’re ever near Birmingham AL and looking for some of the best pizza in town, Giuseppe’s Cafe should be your go-to spot!

#7 Ruscelli’s at Mojo Pub and Food Truck

I recently had the pleasure of trying out their signature pizza – the Mojo Special. It’s a thin-crust pizza topped with a mix of Italian herbs, garlic, mozzarella and parmesan cheeses, and fresh-baked dough. The flavor is absolutely amazing! Every bite melted in my mouth and I just couldn’t get enough.

The atmosphere at Ruscelli’s is also worth mentioning. It’s an inviting space full of bright colors, modern décor, and friendly service that made me feel right at home. What really sets this place apart from other pizzerias though is the fact that you can get your very own food truck to take away! Not only does it provide convenient takeout options but it’s also great for large groups who want to order pizza to go without having to wait in line at the restaurant.

To sum it up, Ruscelli’s has earned its spot as one of the best places for pizza in Birmingham AL and I highly recommend giving them a try if you’re ever looking for some delicious pizza!

#8 Troup’s Pizza

The first thing that struck me about Troup’s was the welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff. That, coupled with their unbeatable prices and generous portions, made for an excellent first impression.

But on to the pizza! I ordered a large pepperoni pizza, which arrived quickly and piping hot. The ingredients were fresh and delicious; the cheese melted perfectly and the crust had just the right amount of crunch. But where Troup’s really shines is in its sauces – you won’t find any watered-down sauce here! Instead, every bite is filled with bold flavors that will tantalize your taste buds.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Birmingham AL, look no further than Troup’s Pizza! Highly recommended!

If you’re willing to go an extra 84 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Montgomery!

#9 Slice Pizza & Brew

When I walked in to this cozy, Italian family-style restaurant, I was overwhelmed by the smell of freshly baked pizza and delicious Italian cuisine. The atmosphere was so inviting that I immediately knew this was going to be a memorable meal.

As soon as I took my seat at the table, I noticed that they had a great selection of handcrafted beers on tap. How could you go wrong with pairing beer and pizza?

When it came time to order, it took me a while to decide because there were so many options! In the end, I decided on the classic cheese pizza with some extra garlic, red onions and olives. When my pizza arrived at the table, it didn’t disappoint! The crust was perfectly crispy and chewy and the perfect balance of toppings made it out of this world!

The staff at Slice Pizza & Brew were top notch too. They were quick to answer any of my questions about their menu or ingredients and always had a smile on their face.

All in all, Slice Pizza & Brew is definitely one of the best places for pizza in Birmingham AL. The combination of delicious food, cold beer and great service makes it a must-visit spot for any pizza lover!

#10 Davenport’s Pizza Palace – Mtn Brook

From the first moment I stepped into Davenport’s Pizza Palace – Mtn Brook I knew I was in for a treat. The warm, inviting atmosphere was the perfect setting for an unforgettable pizza experience.

The menu offers a variety of delicious options, ranging from classic pepperoni and cheese to more creative combos like BBQ chicken and pineapple. Every pie is made with care; the dough is perfectly cooked, and the sauce is full of flavor. The topping selection also adds something special. From freshly sliced mushrooms to crunchy onions, each mix is carefully crafted to please your palate!

But what really sets Davenport’s Pizza Palace – Mtn Brook apart from other restaurants is the friendly staff. Everyone was helpful and accommodating which made our experience even better. Plus, they know just how to make their pies so that you get the best possible results every time.

If you’re looking for a unique pizza experience in Birmingham AL then Davenport’s Pizza Palace – Mtn Brook should be at the top of your list! Their pies are arguably some of the best in town, and their service will make you feel like family each time you visit. Enjoy an unrivaled slice today!

#11 Lehman’s Pizzeria

The first thing that caught my eye when I pulled up to Lehman’s was the inviting atmosphere. Not only was it clean and comfortable, but the staff were all friendly and engaging.

When I bit into a slice of their Neapolitan-style pizza, I knew why everyone raves about this place! The crust was perfectly crispy while providing a great base for their special blend of cheeses and sauces. The toppings were fresh, and the oodles of garlic gave the pizza an unmistakable kick.

I sampled other items on the menu, such as their calzones and oven-roasted wings, which were equally as delicious. I especially enjoyed their Sicilian-style pie — its thick cheese blanket must be tasted to be believed!

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Birmingham AL, Lehman’s Pizzeria should definitely be at the top of your list.

#12 Pizzeria G.M.

The atmosphere is great, with a terrific view of the city. And they serve alcohol (even hard liquor!), making it a great spot for couples who want a romantic dinner. But don’t worry, there’s also a kid’s menu for the kiddos.

But here’s what impressed me most—the pizza! Whether you’re a meat-lover or vegetarian, you’ll find something to enjoy here. And the pizza is definitely some of the best I’ve had in Alabama.

That said, Pizzeria G.M. isn’t perfect; they don’t offer delivery, which can be inconvenient if you’re expecting guests. Also, while they’re more than happy to serve dessert after your meal, it might not be the freshest option available.

All things considered though, Pizzeria G.M. is an excellent and accommodating spot to go when searching for the best pizza in Birmingham AL!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Tortugas Pizza

Walking into Tortugas Pizza was like stepping into a pizza wonderland. The scent of dough, cheese, and toppings wafted through the air, leading me to the cozy bar area. That’s right, folks, this place serves alcohol! Is there anything better than washing down a delicious slice of pizza with a cold brew? I think not.

And for all you herbivores out there, fear not! Tortugas Pizza offers some tasty vegetarian options. I mean, who knew that vegetables could taste so good when smothered in cheese and nestled on a bed of crispy crust?

But the true hero at Tortugas Pizza is their deep dish pizza. It’s like a pizza on steroids, thick and overflowing with heavenly ingredients. Each bite is a cheese pull of epic proportions. It’s so good, you’ll start to question whether it’s socially acceptable to propose to a pizza. Trust me, it’s that good.

Now, on to the downsides. Tortugas Pizza doesn’t accept reservations. So, be prepared to wait. But hey, good things come to those who wait, right? Plus, waiting just gives you more time to explore the area. And speaking of exploring, Tortugas Pizza is conveniently located in a prime tourist spot, so you can enjoy your delicious slice while people watching and soaking in the local sights.

All in all, Tortugas Pizza is a gem in the pizza world. With its boozy sidelines, vegetarian options, and outrageously mouthwatering deep dish pizza, it’s a must-visit for any pizza lover. Just be prepared to exercise some patience, because trust me, it’s worth the wait.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Tortugas Pizza

Let me start by saying that if you love a thin crust that’s crispy, yet still has a slight chewiness to it, then you have found your pizza paradise at Tortugas. Trust me, I’ve eaten pizza in Naples, New York, and even on top of the Great Wall of China, but nothing compares to the perfection of Tortugas’ thin crust.

Now, let’s talk about the benefits. Need a little liquid courage to conquer that slice? Well, you’re in luck because Tortugas serves alcohol! Nothing pairs better with a mouth-watering slice of pizza than a refreshing beer or a glass of wine. And speaking of pairs, if you’re bringing along your vegetarian friend, they’ve got options for them too. I know, I couldn’t believe it either, but they actually have some creative and flavorful vegetarian pizzas on the menu.

But wait, there’s more! Tortugas also offers some mouthwatering dessert options. Because who doesn’t want to finish off their pizza feast with a sweet treat? I highly recommend their Nutella pizza, which is basically a delicious chocolatey mess that you won’t be able to resist.

Now, onto the downsides. The only downside (yes, singular) is that Tortugas does not accept reservations. So you might have to wait a bit before sinking your teeth into that heavenly thin crust. But trust me, it’s worth the wait. Plus, you can use that time to plan out your next pizza adventure!

So, if you’re looking for the best thin crust pizza in birmingham, Tortugas Pizza is where it’s at. You won’t be disappointed, and you might just become a regular like me, Edward the pizza fanatic.