Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Boone NC (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in North Carolina

Best Pizza in Boone NC (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

115 Views

I’ve been to twelve pizza places in the area so far, and after much deliberation, I think I can confidently declare that I know the best pizza spots Boone has to offer. My process of elimination involved sampling all sorts of delicious crusts, sauces, and toppings, so you can rest assured that you’re in good hands.

Writing about food should always be taken seriously, but it’s not all work – there’s also lots of fun! Follow me on an adventure through Boone as we laugh at amusing stories and savor some delicious pies.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of North Carolina

#1 Carolina Pizza Co. Boone

I could tell from the moment I stepped inside this cozy establishment that this place was special. The doughy, freshly baked aroma of the pizza filled my senses as soon as I walked in.

The menu consists of classic Italian-inspired pizzas, with an amazing selection of toppings and mouth-watering crust. For example, I had the deluxe pepperoni pizza and it was simply divine! The crispy, golden crust paired perfectly with the fragrant cheese and spicy pepperoni for a truly unique flavor combination.

Not only were the pizzas top-notch, but the staff were some of the most hospitable people I’ve ever encountered. From their warm welcome to their willingness to help me customize my order – even making suggestions on what would pair best with my meal – they went above and beyond to ensure that my experience at Carolina Pizza Co. Boone was second to none.

To sum up: if you’re looking for the best pizza in Boone NC, look no further than Carolina Pizza Co. Boone!

If you’re willing to go an extra 36 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Hickory!

#2 Mellow Mushroom Boone

I visited the restaurant for a pizza review session, and what I found was impressive. The restaurant is in a great tourist spot, so you know they’re putting out quality food to draw people in. Plus, it’s a great place to watch sports with your friends – and even better, they serve alcohol (and hard liquor!), so you can make an evening of it.

The menu offers some vegetarian options (which I appreciated), as well as a kid’s menu, so everyone in the family can find something delicious. And if you’re looking for something sweet after your meal, there’s always dessert available!

Overall I had an excellent experience at Mellow Mushroom Boone – unfortunately their only downside is that they don’t yet offer delivery service. But if you’re looking for the best pizza in Boone NC, look no further than Mellow Mushroom Boone!

#3 Lost Province Brewing Co.

The pizza here is outstanding. From the perfect combination of crispy crust to the gooey cheese, it’s a pizza lover’s paradise. The quality of toppings is also top notch. I had the opportunity to try both their margherita and pepperoni pizzas and was impressed with how fresh those toppings were – it made for an incredibly flavorful pizza experience.

Service-wise, Lost Province Brewing Co. really knows what they’re doing. The staff is friendly and attentive, making sure that every guest feels welcome and comfortable in their establishment. The atmosphere itself is quite pleasant too – there’s lots of seating available inside, which makes it simple to grab a bite whether you’re dining solo or with a group of friends.

Overall, Lost Province Brewing Co. sets the bar for best pizza in Boone NC! Their mouth-watering pizzas and welcoming staff make this place worth visiting again and again!

#4 Hungry Howie’s Pizza

I arrived at Hungry Howie’s just in time for lunch, still famished from my last adventure. I was expecting more of the same: a generic assembly line pizza that tastes like cardboard. Boy, was I wrong!

The restaurant had an atmosphere unlike any other pizza place I visited. It felt cozy and inviting – lots of locals were enjoying their lunch with friends and family.

I decided to order the classic pepperoni and cheese pizza, expecting it to fall short of my expectations. But when it arrived, I could barely contain my delight! The crust was perfectly thin and fluffy; the sauce was savory and flavorful; and the pepperoni slices were perfectly char-grilled to perfection. Every single bite was packed with flavor!

To top it all off, they serve their pizzas with some delicious dipping sauces which added an extra layer of deliciousness to the experience. If you’re ever in Boone NC looking for the best pizza around – this is where you need to go!

If you’re willing to go an extra 38 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Johnson City!

#5 Capone’s Pizza

I had the chance to try all of the offerings on their menu and I can definitely recommend everything I tried. The pizza crust is the perfect balance of chewy and crispy, the sauce is flavorful and just a little bit sweet, and they had a great selection of toppings.

The best part, however, was how fresh everything tasted. The combination of the perfectly cooked crust, ripe ingredients, and delicious sauce made each bite as good as the last. It was like eating pizza that had just been made in front of me – absolutely delicious!

The atmosphere at Capone’s Pizza is also worth noting. The decor is charmingly old-school with cool vintage touches throughout. And the staff couldn’t be friendlier or more helpful – they really did make me feel welcome as soon as I walked in.

All in all, Capone’s Pizza is hands down one of the best pizza places I’ve ever experienced and should easily take top honors for the best pizza in Boone NC!

#6 Domino’s Pizza

The first thing that caught my eye upon entering the restaurant was the bright and cheerful atmosphere. The employees were so friendly and welcoming, it felt like I was at a family reunion!

Next was the menu. The selection of pizzas seemed endless and it was difficult for me to decide which one to try. In the end, I decided on a Hawaiian pizza. The crust was perfectly crispy and light like a cloud, while the tangy pineapple blended beautifully with gooey mozzarella cheese and ham – delicious!

I also tried some of their sides such as chicken wings and garlic breadsticks – they were heavenly! Not only was the food amazing, but they also had great alcoholic beverages available if you wanted to take your pizza experience to the next level.

Overall, Domino’s Pizza is definitely worth trying out if you’re looking for great pizza in Boone NC! The prices are very reasonable for everything you get: delicious food, excellent service, and a pleasant atmosphere. I’m happy to say that Domino’s Pizza has earned my seal of approval – this is definitely some of the best pizza in Boone NC!

#7 Little Caesars Pizza

The first thing that stands out about this restaurant is the overall atmosphere and vibe. There’s a warm feeling in the room, no matter how busy they may be. The staff are always friendly and attentive, making sure you get exactly what you asked for.

The pizzas here are truly something special – made with only the freshest ingredients, each bite is packed with flavor. I can vouch for their Deluxe Pizza as well as the Primo Meat Pizza which have the perfect combination of toppings. And don’t forget to try some of their amazing dipping sauces!

The best part about Little Caesars Pizza is that you really get bang for your buck! Prices are reasonable and they offer great deals on larger orders– perfect for a family night out or when you’re hosting a party on short notice. It won’t break the bank but will provide maximum satisfaction.

Overall, Little Caesars Pizza definitely deserves its reputation as one of the best pizza places in Boone NC – if not THE BEST! They never fail to deliver a scrumptious pizza experience every time…so much so that I’m tempted to drop by every time I’m passing through town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 54 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Kingsport!

#8 Boonie’s Chicago Style Pizza

I mean, the place is a real hole-in-the-wall joint that looks kind of sketchy from the outside, but don’t let that dissuade you – they’ve got some gourmet pizzas in there. From the classic deep dish to the signature pepperoni hotspot and ‘za supreme, there’s something for every taste.

And oh my goodness, the toppings! It seems like they use only the finest ingredients so you get this complex flavor that can’t be replicated anywhere else. I’m talking about thick mozzarella cheese and freshly cut veggies – it’s enough to make your mouth water. Plus, their prices are very reasonable, so you won’t break the bank just trying to get your Chicago style pizza fix.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Boone NC then Boonie’s Chicago Style Pizza is definitely worth checking out!

#9 Papa Johns Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant was amazing! As soon as I walked in, I was taken by the inviting and cozy environment. The staff members were really friendly and knowledgeable. They answered all my questions with a smile and created a great experience overall.

I ordered the classic pepperoni pizza, which turned out to be an excellent choice! The crust was thin and perfectly cooked. The cheese was so gooey and delicious, and the pepperoni had just the right amount of spice. Overall, this pizza was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted!

I also tried their specialty pan pizza, which was equally impressive! The crust was crisp yet light, and every bite melted in my mouth. It felt like I could taste every herb that went into it.

Overall, if you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience while in Boone NC, Papa Johns Pizza should be your first stop! Their pizzas are some of the best I’ve ever tasted – and trust me when I say that’s saying something coming from a traveling food critic who’s sampled pizza all over the world!

#10 Pizza Hut

The crust is so light and fluffy, it practically melts in your mouth. The cheese is the perfect combination of creamy and stringy – just the way I like it! And the sauce… oh, the sauce! It has that perfect blend of sweet and savory that never fails to hit the spot.

But what really sets Pizza Hut apart is their topping selection. From classic pepperoni to more gourmet offerings like portobello mushrooms and roasted peppers, they have something to please everyone’s taste buds. Plus, they offer vegan options too, so everyone can enjoy a great pizza night at Pizza Hut.

All in all, I’d highly recommend Pizza Hut for anyone looking for the best pizza in Boone NC. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, the staff is friendly and accommodating, and the food quality can’t be beat!

If you’re willing to go an extra 63 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Asheville!

#11 Bella’s Italian Restaurant of Boone

The atmosphere is quintessential Italian-style, with red and white checkered tablecloths and a warm welcome from the staff. From the moment I walked in, I felt like I was on vacation in Italy!

When it comes to the pizza itself, you can’t go wrong at Bella’s. The crust has just the right amount of crunch and chewiness. Topping options include fresh vegetables, homemade sauces, and lots of cheese. You can even get creative with your pizzas by adding unique ingredients like capers or chorizo.

As for taste, wow! This is some of the best pizza I’ve had anywhere. It’s flavorful without being too salty or heavy. And leftovers don’t turn into a soggy mess – perfection!

All-in-all, if you’re looking for great pizza in Boone NC, you won’t find any better than Bella’s Italian Restaurant. Don’t take my word for it though – come visit them yourself and see why they are hands down the best pizza in Boone NC!

#12 Casa Rustica Restaurant

The first thing that made an impression was the atmosphere. This restaurant oozes charm and pizzazz, from its cozy atmosphere to its incredibly friendly staff. I instantly felt at home when I walked in—like I was part of the family.

As for the pizza, I had a hard time choosing just one variety. They offer both classic and unique pizzas, and they all looked delicious! Ultimately, I decided to go with their signature Casa Rustica Special: pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers, and cheese. It didn’t disappoint! The pizza had a perfectly crispy crust and was loaded with toppings that exploded with flavor when combined.

Another highlight of this restaurant was the service. My waiter was prompt, knowledgeable about the menu items, and very willing to help with our orders. He also gave us recommendations on what would pair well together in terms of drinks and desserts—he definitely knew his stuff!

Overall, amazing pizza at an awesome price makes Casa Rustica Restaurant my top choice for best pizza in Boone NC!