Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Bristol CT (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Connecticut

Best Pizza in Bristol CT (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

225 Views

In my quest to find the best pizza in this Connecticut town, I sampled twelve different places to help you decide where to go for your next slice.

But why take my word for it? After all, I’ve tasted pizza from around the world, so it’s a pretty high bar! But fear not, there are some surprisingly good options in Bristol that will make your mouth water.

With a humorous and lighthearted tone, follow me as we explore the top twelve pizzerias in Bristol CT – from classic cheese slices and deep dish pies to unique toppings like clams and figs – so let’s get ready to chow down!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Connecticut

#1 Gino’s Pizza House

The first thing I noticed as I stepped through the door at Gino’s was the amazing smells coming from their wood fired pizza oven. The atmosphere was inviting and welcoming – perfect for a food critic like me.

I decided to order up a classic pepperoni pizza. After just one bite, it was clear why people flock to this place. The pizza was cooked perfectly in their wood-fired oven, making for the most delightful crust ever! The sauce had just the right amount of garlic and spices that enhanced every bite, and the cheese was perfectly melted and flavorful.

For someone who has tried a lot of pizzas around the world, I can safely say that Gino’s Pizza House is definitely serving some of the best pizza in Bristol CT. I highly recommend giving it a try if you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Southington!

#2 Uncle Sam’s Restaurant

The atmosphere at this restaurant is great. It has an inviting, family-friendly vibe and they even have a kid’s menu. Plus, the fact that they serve alcohol – and hard liquor – is a definite plus!

When it comes to the pizza itself, their pies are out of this world. The crust is always perfectly crispy and the cheese is decadent. I also appreciate that there are lots of topping options, so no matter what type of pizza you’re in the mood for, you’ll find something perfect here!

My only complaint? No delivery! But if you can manage a visit to Uncle Sam’s Restaurant, it’s definitely worth your while. Not only will you get the best pizza in Bristol CT, but it’s also a great tourist spot – with or without kids. And don’t forget to get dessert afterward…that alone is worth the trip!

#3 Chunky Tomato

Upon walking into this small pizza joint, I was immediately struck by the smell of fresh dough and tomatoes. It was clear that Chunky Tomato takes pride in their ingredients, and each pizza is made with love.

The menu at Chunky Tomato is diverse and creative. From classic Sicilian-style pies to unique combinations like macaroni and cheese pizza, they have something to suit any taste. But what really impressed me were the specialty pies — a line-up of creative recipes featuring unique toppings such as caramelized onions, guacamole, artichoke hearts and even wild mushrooms!

When it comes to taste, Chunky Tomato doesn’t disappoint! The pizzas are cooked in a blazing hot oven using only the freshest ingredients. The result is an incredibly flavorful pie with a delightfully crunchy crust. Despite all the delicious toppings, these masterpieces still manage to remain light and fluffy on the inside — an impressive feat for sure!

In short, I can definitively say that Chunky Tomato has some of the best pizza in Bristol CT — if not the best! The next time you’re hankering for a great slice of pizza (or pie!), give them a try — you won’t regret it!

#4 Pavilion Restaurant

When I stepped through the doors of Pavilion Restaurant, I was pleasantly surprised. Not only did they offer an extensive selection of meals and drinks, but they had a kid’s menu too. The atmosphere was very inviting and warm, and I felt right at home.

One thing that really impressed me were the pizza offerings – there were over 20 varieties to choose from! They use fresh ingredients for each order, so it is no surprise that their pizzas tasted exquisite. To top it all off, there is something for everyone on this menu; vegetarians can find veggie-friendly options here too.

Another great thing about Pavilion Restaurant is that they offer alcoholic beverages which makes this place great for all occasions – whether you are coming with family or with friends. And if you like sweet treats at the end of your meal, Pavilion Restaurant offers a range of desserts as well.

The only downside to Pavilion Restaurant is that they do not have delivery services; if you want to eat their delicious pizza you need to come in person or call ahead for pick-up orders. But trust me, it’s worth the visit even if you have to travel a bit further to get there.

Overall, I highly recommend Pavilion Restaurant if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Bristol CT!

#5 West End Pizza

The atmosphere was great. It’s a nice tourist spot and even had a kid’s menu, which the little ones loved. There was also a good selection of drinks at the bar, so I could have an adult beverage to accompany my meal of choice.

I decided to try their signature pizza and it did not disappoint! The crust was just crunchy enough and the sauce was full of flavor. It was also beautifully topped with all kinds of delicious veggies that made it look as good as it tasted!

I have to say that West End Pizza really delivered on their promise of having some of the best pizza in Bristol CT. The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery, but for such delicious fare, I’m more than happy to come pick it up myself!

#6 Max Pizza & Restaurant

First of all, the atmosphere is excellent. It’s a great tourist spot and a perfect place to bring family – they even have a kid’s menu. Plus, they’ve got beer and wine for the adults who want to enjoy some libations with their meal.

In terms of food options, Max Pizza & Restaurant has some vegetarian options as well as its mouth-watering pizza creations. From thin crust to deep dish, they know how to make a delicious slice. And I haven’t even mentioned their desserts yet – it’s unbelievably good!

The only downside is that there’s no delivery option, but trust me – this place is worth getting off the couch for! All in all, Max Pizza & Restaurant offers some of the best pizza in Bristol CT – can’t wait until my next visit!

#7 Stavros Pizza and Restaurant

Their pies are made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and have a perfectly cooked crispy crust. The sauce has the perfect blend of sweetness, saltiness, and spices that make it irresistible. Toppings are creative and generous – I’m partial to the pepperoni and pineapple combo they do so well!

The atmosphere of Stavros Pizza and Restaurant is what really sets it apart from other pizza places. It’s cozy with an old-world vibe and friendly staff that make dining there an incredible experience. Plus, the smell of their delicious pizzas baking in the ovens is enough to make any mouth water!

Bottom line: Stavros Pizza and Restaurant definitely deserves its place as one of the best spots for pizza in Bristol CT. Try them out – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Waterbury!

#8 Max Pizza 4

My primary criteria for a great pizza is the quality of the crust and Max Pizza 4 definitely delivers in this aspect. Their crust is light yet crunchy, with just the right amount of seasoning. Topped with savory herbs and cheese, the pizza has just enough flavor to satisfy your appetite without being overpowering.

The toppings are also impressive. From traditional choices such as pepperoni and sausage to more modern options like feta and sun-dried tomatoes, Max Pizza 4 has something to please everyone. No matter which topping you choose, it’s always delicious!

The presentation was also quite impressive. There was no skimping on ingredients, and each slice was perfectly cut and ready to devour. Yes, it looks as amazing as it tastes!

Overall, Max Pizza 4 offers some of the best pizza in Bristol CT! Between the quality ingredients, excellent toppings selection, and drool-worthy presentation; I’d give them two thumbs up (or two slices up!). If you’re looking for a great slice of pizza in Bristol CT, look no further than Max Pizza 4!

#9 PizzaPie

I stopped by PizzaPie recently to try out their famous pizza, and I was not disappointed. The restaurant is cozy and inviting, with lots of cool decorations on the walls. Plus, they serve a variety of different pizzas, so you can find something to please everyone in your group.

The pizza itself is nothing short of incredible. The crust has a perfect crunch-to-chewiness ratio, the cheese melts perfectly and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. Plus, the portion sizes are generous so you won’t walk away feeling hungry!

My favorite thing about PizzaPie though is their super friendly staff. Everyone from the cooks to the waiters are helpful and attentive – which makes for a great dining experience!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Bristol CT, then look no further than PizzaPie. You’ll get delicious pizza with generous portions and (bonus!) friendly staff – what more could you ask for?

#10 Olive Pizza

I’ve had a lot of pizza in my time, so I know good pizza when I taste it. The crust at Olive Pizza was crispy and perfectly cooked. The thin layer of tomato sauce was flavorful, yet not overpowering. Topping-wise, they used the freshest ingredients and you could really taste them.

The atmosphere at Olive Pizza is great too. It’s a cozy spot with decorations reminiscent of Italy, like vines and wooden tables. It’s the kind of place you’d want to bring your family or friends for a night out on the town!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some great pizza in Bristol CT, Olive Pizza is definitely the place to go! You won’t be disappointed by their fantastic food and friendly service. I know I’ll be back soon so that I can have more of their delicious pies!

#11 L J’s Pizza

As a food critic, I have extremely high standards. I expected the pizza to be good, but it exceeded my expectations!

The crust was golden and crispy on the bottom and the toppings were cooked to perfection with just the right ratio of cheese. The sauce was rich and flavorful. Best of all, it only took about 10 minutes from order to table!

I’ve tried many great pizzas in my travels, but this one definitely takes first place when it comes to Bristol CT. Even though L J’s Pizza is located in a small strip mall in a suburb of Bristol, don’t let that discourage you – go grab a slice or two for yourself! You won’t regret it.

#12 Bristol Pizza Restaurant

When entering the restaurant, my expectations were high and needless to say, I was not disappointed. Right away, I was treated to a warm and friendly atmosphere, with black-and-white checked tile floors and a cozy pizza oven in the corner of the room.

The menu boasts some of the most creative pizzas I’ve ever had. My favorite is their specialty “Bristol Pie,” which consists of bacon, roasted potatoes and greens. Topped with rich pesto cream sauce and mozzarella cheese, it’s simply divine! For those looking for something more classic, they have a Margherita pizza that is simple but satisfying: thin crust with tomatoes, basil and fresh mozzarella.

As if that wasn’t enough, Bristol Pizza Restaurant also makes delicious calzones stuffed with Italian sausages and ricotta cheese – yum!

I would highly recommend Bristol Pizza Restaurant to anyone looking for the best pizza in Bristol CT. From the cozy atmosphere to their inventive toppings on classic pies, it’s the perfect place for an enjoyable night out.