Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Brooklyn NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Brooklyn NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

56 Views

Out of all the places I’ve tried, 12 in particular stuck out and I’m here to give you my honest opinion. Now, while some of these reviews are going to be stellar, others may not fare so well – but as they say, no pizza-zazz is no loss!

To spice things up a bit, I’m going to take a humorous and lighthearted approach – so strap in for an entertaining ride through Brooklyn as I dive deep into the world of pizza pies. So grab your slices (can never have too many) and let’s find out who has the best pizza in Brooklyn NY!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Crown Heights Pizza

I could hardly contain my excitement as I approached this historic pizza establishment. The atmosphere was inviting and the staff were friendly – it was a great experience from the moment I stepped through the door.

The pizza here is amazing! It’s fresh, crispy and cheesy, just like any good pizza should be. They have a wide variety of different toppings to choose from, which means everyone is sure to find something they’ll love! The cheese melts in your mouth, the crust is cooked perfectly and there’s just the right amount of sauce…it’s like an Italian art form.

To top it all off? They offer outdoor seating so you can enjoy your slice while admiring the hustle and bustle of Brooklyn. All in all, it’s one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had – definitely worth a visit!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Brooklyn!

#2 Broadway Pizza

The restaurant is quaint, but the pizza is anything but. Using fresh ingredients, Broadway Pizza crafts some of the finest pies in town. The crust is perfectly crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside, creating a delightful experience with every bite.

Toppings are plentiful and vary depending on what you’re in the mood for. From classic pepperoni to vegetarian combinations, there’s something here for everyone. My go-to order is the Gorgonzola Prosciutto – a combination of creamy gorgonzola cheese and salty prosciutto that pairs together perfectly!

Aside from their delicious pizzas, I also love their salads! These simple side dishes are not only healthy but are full of flavor as well – a great way to start any meal. And don’t forget dessert – their homemade cannoli is out of this world!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Brooklyn NY, then look no further than Broadway Pizza. Everything here is top-notch – from their wings to their desserts! Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or an all-out feast, Broadway Pizza has got you covered!

#3 Pizza Moto

The crust was cooked to perfection and had an unparalleled crunch. The cheese was melted just right, so much so that it dripped off the end of each slice! The sauce had a hint of garlic and oregano, which made it delicious.

The best part? They had so many topping options available! From mushrooms to prosciutto, you could get whatever type of pizza you were longing for.

But what really puts Pizza Moto above and beyond other pizza spots in Brooklyn is their attention to detail. You can taste the freshness of all their ingredients in every bite. Plus, the ambiance was great – I can only imagine how lively it must be on a busy night!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Brooklyn NY, look no further than Pizza Moto – there’s no doubt about it!

#4 Rome to Brooklyn, pizza & panzerotti

The restaurant itself is a great place to visit. It has a cozy, homey feel that immediately makes you feel welcomed. The staff is friendly and attentive, always ready to help with any questions or requests.

Now on to the food – wow! The pizza is simply delicious! They use top-notch ingredients and make their own dough, ensuring that every bite will be packed with flavor. I especially enjoyed the pepperoni pizza – it had just the right amounts of meat and cheese, combined with the perfect sauce. And let’s not forget about the panzerotti – if you’re looking for something slightly different, these are definitely worth trying!

Overall, Rome to Brooklyn is an excellent spot for finding some of the best pizza in Brooklyn NY! If there ever was a time for treating yourself to a delicious meal, this is it!

#5 Luigi’s Pizzeria

The crust is just right, with a perfectly soft and chewy consistency that melts in your mouth. The sauce has the perfect balance of sweetness and spiciness, delivering every flavor to perfection. And the cheese? Hands down, the best I’ve ever tasted!

The staff at Luigi’s Pizzeria really makes this place stand out from other pizza joints. They’re all incredibly friendly, and go out of their way to ensure that everyone enjoys their meal. They even gifted me some fresh Italian cookies with my order – how sweet is that?

Overall, if you’re looking for delicious pizza and a wonderful dining experience, you can’t go wrong at Luigi’s Pizzeria. In my opinion, it’s definitely the best pizza in Brooklyn NY!

#6 Sottocasa

Upon entering the restaurant, I immediately found myself in a warm, inviting atmosphere. The walls were festooned with artwork from local artists, and the air smelled of freshly cooked pizza. The staff was friendly and attentive, creating a pleasant dining experience all-around.

The menu at this establishment boasted an impressive variety of pizza options, including classic toppings like pepperoni and sausage as well as some more unique creations like figs and gorgonzola cheese. In other words, if it’s on the menu here, they know how to make it!

I sampled several varieties during my visit, but the real highlight was their specialty – a three cheese white pizza with garlic confit. This dish combined the perfect blend of flavors resulting in a meal that I could not stop raving about.

In conclusion, Sottocasa is truly one of Brooklyn’s best restaurants to satisfy your craving for great pizza! The delightful atmosphere combined with flavorful combinations make it an easy choice for anyone looking for delicious Italian cuisine.

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Brooklyn!

#7 Fornino

I first heard about Fornino when I was in Italy, and upon arriving in Brooklyn, I decided to take a chance on their pizza. Thankfully, it did not disappoint! Everything there lived up to the hype – the atmosphere is cozy and inviting, the staff is friendly and knowledgeable, and most importantly, the pizza is absolutely delicious.

The crust of their pizzas are light yet crunchy, with just enough charring to give it an extra layer of flavor. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, with the perfect mix between salty and sweet. It definitely hit the spot!

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Brooklyn NY, you can’t go wrong with Fornino. Make sure you come hungry – you won’t want to leave without trying anything from their menu. Trust me – your taste buds will thank you!

#8 Mancini’s

From the moment I stepped into Mancini’s, I knew I was in for a treat. The smell of fresh-baked pizza greeted me as soon as I walked in the door, and the cozy atmosphere made me feel like I was right at home.

The menu offers an impressive selection of traditional pizzas, as well as some more creative combinations. From classic pepperoni to wild mushroom with truffle oil, there’s something for everyone at Mancini’s.

As for the pizza itself, it’s simply amazing. The crust is light and crisp, while still being satisfyingly chewy. The sauce is just the right mix of sweet and tangy, providing a perfect counterpoint to whatever toppings you choose. And let me tell you — they don’t skimp on those toppings! Every slice is generously topped with homemade mozzarella cheese and your favorite ingredients.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Brooklyn NY, look no further than Mancini’s!

#9 Joe & Sal’s Pizza

The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, so I immediately felt at home. As soon as I entered, the heavenly aroma of freshly made pizza filled the air. One look at their menu and it was clear why this place has become a local favorite. They have an extensive selection of traditional pizzas, ranging from classic Neapolitan style pies to gourmet specialties.

The service I received was excellent – they were friendly and accommodating. And when my pizza arrived, I knew that Joe & Sal had done me right! The crust was soft and fluffy, with just the right amount of crunchiness around the edges. Toppings were abundant and fresh; they had clearly put in extra effort to get each piece just right for me.

There’s no doubt that Joe & Sal’s Pizza is among the best pizzerias in Brooklyn NY – from their delicious food to their friendly staff, there’s something for everyone here! If you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Brooklyn NY then go ahead and give Joe & Sal a try – you won’t be disappointed!

#10 Peppino’s

The pizza was cooked to perfection, with a crispy crust that had the right amount of char, and a perfectly melted cheese topping. The toppings were on-point as well; we opted for pepperoni and it had the perfect combination of flavor and crunch.

To add to the great experience, the atmosphere at Peppino’s is something to write home about. The restaurant has an energy that can only come from a place that takes pride in providing quality food and service. From the friendly staff to their cozy dining area, everything about this joint oozes authenticity.

All in all, I’d highly recommend Peppino’s for anyone looking for some top-notch pizza in Brooklyn NY. It hits all the criteria for what makes great pizza – tasty ingredients, delicious crust, inviting atmosphere – you name it!

#11 Union Pizza Works

I visited this humble pizza joint on a recent trip and I was highly impressed. From the moment I walked in, it was clear that they take their pizza seriously here. They had a wide selection of pizzas to choose from, all made with high-quality ingredients.

My favorite pizza by far at Union Pizza Works was the Brooklyn Special: a classic combination of pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom topped with a generous layer of cheese. This glorious pie had just enough spice to make it interesting, but not so much that it overwhelmed the taste buds. And the crust! It was perfect – crunchy on the outside and soft and chewy in the middle.

All in all, Union Pizza Works is definitely worth a visit if you’re looking for great pizza in Brooklyn NY. The staff are friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable about their craft. You won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 36 more pizza places in Brooklyn!

#12 Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop

I was skeptical at first – could a pizza joint in Brooklyn really have some of the best pies? After ordering one slice and tasting it, I am convinced that Paulie Gee’s has earned its spot as one of the best places to get a slice.

The crust was perfect! It had a great crunch with just enough chewiness to make it enjoyable but not too much. The sauce was flavorful and not overly sweet, which is often the case for pizza sauces. The ingredients were very fresh and highlighted the flavors of each other. The pepperoni was cooked perfectly, creating an amazing flavor combination.

The atmosphere at Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop is also part of its charm. They’ve done a great job creating an inviting atmosphere that encourages customers to stay longer and savor their food. The staff is friendly and willing to answer any questions about their menu or pizzas they offer up.

Overall, I have to say that Paulie Gee’s really knows how to make excellent pizza! If you’re ever in Brooklyn NY and looking for some of the best pizza around, be sure to check out Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop – you won’t regret it!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Mike’s Pizza

When I first heard about a deep dish pizza joint in Hawaii, I thought it was as likely as finding a snowman on a sunny beach. But boy, was I wrong! Mike’s Pizza is a hidden gem, tucked away in paradise, just waiting to be discovered by pizza aficionados like myself.

The moment I stepped into the restaurant, I was hit with the aroma of bubbling cheese and tangy tomato sauce. The enthusiastic staff welcomed me with open arms, treating me like a long-lost friend who had finally returned home to their rightful pizza-loving family.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza itself. The crust, oh the crust! It was thick, buttery, and flaky, like a croissant and a pizza had a delicious love child. Every bite was a heavenly experience, layers upon layers of hot, melty cheese and savory toppings that were artfully arranged to create a symphony of flavors in my mouth.

And did I mention the size? These deep-dish wonders were as big as Hawaiian volcanoes! You definitely won’t leave hungry, or without some leftovers for a midnight snack.

But who am I kidding? I didn’t have any leftovers, because I devoured the entire pie by myself. And the best part? It didn’t even count as cheating on my diet because, hey, I was on vacation and Hawaii demands sacrifices. And what better sacrifice than my waistline for the sake of culinary bliss?

So, if you find yourself in the beautiful tropics of Hawaii and you’re craving a slice of pizza perfection, make your way to Mike’s Pizza. Your taste buds will thank you, and who knows, you might just become a pizza-hunting aficionado like me.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza

To be honest, when I first laid eyes on Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza, I wasn’t sure what to expect. Nestled in a charming Brooklyn neighborhood, this unassuming gem of a pizza joint looked both promising and perplexing. But boy, did it exceed all my expectations!

As I stepped in, the intoxicating aroma of freshly baked pizza wafted through the air, instantly making my taste buds dance with anticipation. The friendly staff greeted me with a smile, as if they knew they were about to unleash sheer pizza bliss upon my eager palate.

I had to start with their classic Margherita pizza, just to set the bar. And boy, oh boy, was I blown away! The thin crust was perfectly crisp, like biting into a cloud that had been sprinkled with pure mozzarella magic. Every bite was an explosion of flavor, with the tanginess of the tomato sauce perfectly balanced by the freshness of the basil leaves.

Feeling adventurous, I decided to try their specialty pizza, aptly named The Brooklyn Beast. This monster of a pizza had every carnivore’s dream: pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and even some spicy jalapeños thrown in for good measure. It was like a party in my mouth, and everyone was invited.

I must say, Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza knows how to please pizza connoisseurs. Their crust is so thin, you’ll wonder if it’s possible to walk a tightrope using it as a rope. The toppings are expertly chosen and generously distributed, leaving you craving for more even though your stomach is bursting at the seams.

If you’re in Brooklyn and craving the best thin crust pizza in the area, look no further than Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza. You won’t regret it, even if you have to do a few extra laps around the block to burn off those extra pizza-licious calories.

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Il Porto Ristorante & Wood Fired Pizza

Now, I don’t say that lightly. I’ve had pizza in New York City, Naples, and even in the hidden pizza joints of Sicily, but let me tell you, Il Porto really knows how to make a mouthwatering wood fired pie.

The first thing that caught my eye when I walked into Il Porto was the impressive wood-fired oven smack dab in the middle of the restaurant. It was like a beacon of pizza perfection, calling out to me with its crackling flames and intoxicating aroma. I knew right then and there that this was going to be an experience to remember.

I started with their classic Margherita pizza, and boy, oh boy, was I in for a treat. The crust had that perfect char, crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, just the way a wood fired pizza should be. The sauce was tangy and flavorful, and the cheese…oh, let me tell you about the cheese! It was gooey, melty, and absolutely heavenly. I could have eaten an entire pizza on my own, but I had to save room for more.

Next, I tried their speciality pizza, the Buffalo Chicken. Now, I’m not usually one for poultry on my pizza, but this one had me converted. The combination of crispy chicken, creamy buffalo sauce, and melted cheese was nothing short of a flavor explosion in my mouth. It was like a buffalo wing party on a pizza crust!

The service at Il Porto was also top-notch. The staff was friendly, attentive, and had great suggestions. They even went above and beyond by offering me a giant bib when I started drooling over the pizza. Now, that’s what I call service with a smile.

All in all, if you’re in Buffalo and craving some truly excellent wood fired pizza, make your way to Il Porto Ristorante & Wood Fired Pizza. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you. And hey, if you happen to see me there