Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Lafayette IN (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Indiana

Best Pizza in Lafayette IN (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

174 Views

My extensive travels (and pizza eating!) have taken me to all corners of the globe in search of the best pie. Fortunately, I can now confidently proclaim that Lafayette IN has some great places to satisfy your pizza cravings.

I’ve tasted my way through twelve different pizzerias in Lafayette IN, and let me tell you, the competition is fierce! Whether you’re a fan of thin crust, thick crust, or just a ton of cheese these places have it all. Keep reading for my definitive list of the best pizza in Lafayette IN.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Indiana

#1 Snuggs Pizza

This restaurant has just about everything I could want in a pizza joint. They have delicious pizzas with a variety of toppings, even some vegetarian options. Plus, they serve hard liquor and other alcoholic beverages, which is always a plus for me!

One downside to this place is the lack of delivery services. But it’s worth it to pop in and indulge myself in their amazing pies.

I highly recommend Snuggs Pizza if you’re looking for the best pizza experience in Lafayette IN. It checks all my boxes and I’m sure it will check yours too!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 21 more pizza places in West Lafayette!

#2 Pizza Uncommon

My first impression upon entering the restaurant was that it was very cozy and inviting. The staff was incredibly friendly, which made me feel right at home.

I decided to start with their “Pizza of the Day,” which was a sweet pepper and jalapeno pizza. The flavors combined perfectly, creating an unforgettable taste sensation! The crust was cooked to perfection, ensuring that every bite melted in my mouth.

Next, I sampled their signature pizza: a mouth-watering combination of Italian sausage, pepperoni and mushrooms. This pizza was out of this world! The flavors came together so nicely and the crust stayed crunchy on the outside yet soft on the inside. It’s safe to say that this is one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

Finally, I tried their classic pepperoni pizza. It tasted just like my childhood favorite; the perfect balance between spicy and cheesy. Even the crust held up well under all of those toppings!

In conclusion, Pizza Uncommon has some of the best pizza in Lafayette IN. They have an amazing selection of pizzas that are sure to please everyone’s taste buds! Highly recommended!!

#3 Azzip Pizza

I’m always looking for the best pizza wherever I go, so I had high expectations when I stopped into Azzip Pizza. The restaurant didn’t disappoint. First off, the atmosphere was fantastic – it felt like a real Italian pizzeria. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable – they really seemed to know their stuff!

As for the pizza itself, let me just say that it was delicious! The dough was thin yet chewy and cooked to perfection. The sauce was wonderfully flavorful, and there were plenty of topping choices to choose from. My favorite topping combination is the classic pepperoni and mushroom – the flavors all worked together perfectly! If you’re ever in Lafayette looking for a great slice of pizza, then Azzip Pizza should be your first stop! It’s definitely one of the best pizzerias around!

#4 Bruno’s Pizza and Big O’s Sports Room

I was amazed by the variety of pizza options – there were plenty of vegetarian, meat, and vegan options to choose from, along with a kid’s menu which is a huge plus.

But that’s not the only great thing about Bruno’s. Their desserts are insanely good (trust me – I’ve had them all!) and it’s also a great spot for watching sports. And if you’re looking for an extra kick, they serve up some hard liquor!

The only downside was that they don’t deliver, but when the pizza tastes this good it’s worth the walk! This place really is a must-visit on any trip to Lafayette IN.

#5 The Pickle

When I visited, I noticed they had something for everyone, whether they were a kid, vegetarian or just someone wanting dessert. But, the best part was their pizza. The crust was light and fluffy with perfect amounts of cheese and sauce.

The atmosphere here is great too as it’s a great tourist spot in the city. The staff are all friendly and you can tell that they take pride in their work.

Unfortunately there is one downside – no delivery! Which is a shame, because I would love to have this delicious pizza delivered to my door step.

But don’t let that put you off because if you’re looking for the best pizza in Lafayette IN then The Pickle should be at the top of your list!

#6 Greek’s Pizzeria

I don’t say that lightly. After all, I’m a food critic and I know my pizza.

The first thing you notice about Greek’s Pizzeria is the atmosphere. It’s cozy and welcoming. The staff is friendly and the shop has a nice rustic feel that adds to its charm.

When it comes to the pizza, Greek’s Pizzeria knows what they are doing. From the thin crust to the flavor-packed ingredients, each slice of pizza is a delight! Every bite was bursting with flavor and I found myself wanting more every time I finished one.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Lafayette IN, then look no further than Greek’s Pizzeria! Highly recommended!

#7 Arni’s Lafayette Market Square

When I arrived at Arni’s, I was pleasantly surprised to find a few nice bonuses. First of all, they serve alcohol — and not just beer, but hard liquor too! Also, the kid’s menu is great for families with young children who want pizza too. Plus there are plenty of vegetarian options which made me glad since most places don’t offer anything good for my vegan friends. And if you have room after your pizza, they even offer some delicious dessert choices as well.

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery but considering the excellent pizzas I had here, I’m willing to make the trip. The crust was perfectly cooked and the toppings were fresh and flavorful – definitely one of the best pizzas I have ever tasted!

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Lafayette IN then be sure to check out Arni’s Lafayette Market Square. You won’t regret it!

#8 HotBox Pizza

The first thing that struck me about HotBox Pizza was their huge selection of pizzas. They have so many different combinations to choose from, it’s impossible not to find something that you’ll love! Whether you’re in the mood for a classic pepperoni, a veggie loaded supreme, or something more adventurous like their Hot and Spicy Chicken pizza, there’s something here for everyone.

And once you make your selection, the pizza gods at HotBox don’t disappoint. Their crust is always cooked to perfection – never too thick or soggy – and they use only the freshest ingredients on top. The result is a delicious slice of pizza that tastes better than any I’ve had before!

But the real surprise was in their extra toppings. It turns out that HotBox Pizza has some interesting (and delicious) topping options like feta cheese and avocado – two of my absolute favorites!

All things considered, it’s easy to see why HotBox Pizza is lauded as being one of the best pizza joints in Lafayette IN. If you’re ever in town and are hankering for some good ‘za, then look no further than HotBox Pizza – it won’t disappoint!

If you’re willing to go an extra 40 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Munster!

#9 Monical’s Pizza of West Lafayette

The crust was absolutely delicious – thin and crispy on the outside yet still warm and soft inside. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the portion size was perfect for one person. I have to admit I was a bit hesitant at first because of the restaurant’s small size but after tasting their pizza, my doubts quickly faded away.

Service-wise, this local pizza joint really knows what they’re doing! Everyone from the servers to the cooks were friendly, knowledgeable about their food, and eager to please. They even went out of their way to accommodate my special requests – now that’s top-notch service!

All in all, Monical’s Pizza of West Lafayette is definitely worth trying if you find yourself in the area searching for a great slice of pizza. I’m confident that you won’t be disappointed with this delightful restaurant’s offerings!

#10 Arni’s Columbian Park

I was excited to try the pizza at Arni’s Columbian Park, especially after seeing all the positive reviews it had received. When I arrived, I was welcomed with a friendly smile and service that was absolutely top-notch.

The pizza itself was amazing! The crust was light and fluffy, and the toppings were flavorful and plentiful. I particularly enjoyed the pepperoni pizza, which featured a generous helping of spicy pepperonis on top.

For those travelling with children, Arni’s also offers a kid’s menu with fun options like macaroni and cheese or chicken nuggets. And for dessert, you can order ice cream sundaes!

The only downside is that Arni’s doesn’t offer delivery; you have to dine in or takeout. But don’t let this deter you from checking out this great place – it’s definitely worth it!

So if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Lafayette IN, look no further than Arni’s Columbian Park!

#11 Americus Pizza

The atmosphere at Americus Pizza is amazing; you can sit inside and watch sports on any of the big TVs. It’s also a great tourist spot, since it serves alcohol – including hard liquor! – so don’t forget to stop by if you’re in town.

The pizza itself was amazingly delicious. The crust was thin and crisp, the cheese melted perfectly, and the toppings were fresh. I’ll be dreaming about those slices for days!

Unfortunately, there’s one glaring downside: Americus Pizza does not offer delivery. That means if you want to enjoy their amazing creations at home, you’ll have to take out. But trust me when I say that it will be worth every minute spent in the car!

Fortunately, Americus Pizza makes up for this by offering dessert. The options they had were definitely enough to satisfy my sweet tooth after devouring all that pizza!

In conclusion, I highly recommend visiting Americus Pizza if you’re ever in Lafayette IN! With their amazing food and friendly atmosphere, it truly was an experience worthy of a world-traveling food critic like me. Go ahead and try it out – I guarantee you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Noble Roman’s Craft Pizza & Pub

As a food critic, I know the difference between great pizza and mediocre pizza. From the first bite of Noble Roman’s Craft Pizza & Pub’s zesty sauce to their perfectly-cooked crust, I knew this was a cut above the rest. Not only was the pizza remarkably fresh and delicious, but the atmosphere inside the restaurant brought me back home.

The staff at Noble Roman’s Craft Pizza & Pub clearly care about their product and take pride in using quality ingredients for their menu items. Not only did they make sure that my dinner came out in a timely manner, but they were also knowledgeable about all of their dishes. Additionally, the pricing was just right; my whole meal cost me less than I expected!

If you’re ever looking for an amazing pie in Lafayette IN, then Noble Roman’s Craft Pizza & Pub is definitely worth checking out. Hands down one of the best pizzas I have ever had!